Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2610.10980

A Flash-Based Relativistic Collapse Model for Quantum Fields

Nicolò Piccione

quant-phSubmitted Oct 7, 2026• Announced Oct 9, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Spontaneous collapse models provide a possible, testable solution to the quantum measurement problem, but constructing a relativistic version applicable to quantum field theory remains an important open challenge. Challenges in constructing relativistic collapse models include avoiding superluminal signaling and foliation dependence, controlling energy production, and ensuring vacuum stability. Here, we present a relativistic collapse framework that addresses these problems at the cost of introducing a new space of physical states, whose complete characterization is left open. A modified, history-dependent Aharonov--Albert prescription describes instantaneous nonlocal state updates on arbitrary spacelike foliations while preserving foliation independence. To ensure vacuum stability, we modify the standard unitary evolution through a prescription that we name dynamical vacuum subtraction. The resulting dynamical map is linear and trace-preserving but not positive on the full set of standard density operators. We establish no-signaling by proving microscopic parameter independence, and identify conditions under which standard nonrelativistic collapse dynamics are recovered. Finally, we apply our framework to a free massive scalar field, obtaining finite particle-number and energy-increase rates at leading order in the long-time regime, together with further promising evidence for the consistency of the framework.

AI Summary

The paper addresses relativistic spontaneous-collapse dynamics for quantum fields, seeking vacuum stability, foliation independence, no superluminal signaling, and finite excitation rates. It constructs a flash ontology from Poisson-distributed spacetime points carrying auxiliary qubits. Each qubit couples to a local scalar field operator within the point’s past light cone; its eventual binary outcome determines whether a flash occurs. Vacuum stability is imposed through “dynamical vacuum subtraction,” replacing unitary evolution by $\widetilde{\mathcal U}A=\mathcal UA+\operatorname{Tr}(A)(\Omega-\mathcal U\Omega)$. This preserves linearity, trace, composition, and the vacuum, but not positivity on conventional density operators. Physical states are instead defined by nonnegative probabilities for every finite flash/no-flash history. A history-dependent collapse prescription refers to a fixed initial Cauchy surface while retaining independence from the interpolating foliation. A causal-support argument establishes microscopic parameter independence under spacelike-separated external potentials, assuming the initial state is admissible with and without the perturbation. In a weak-coupling, infinite-point-density limit, the framework yields formal colored-noise reduced dynamics and joint flash intensities. For a free massive scalar field coupled through $:\!\varphi^2\!:/2$, Bogoliubov calculations give finite, nonnegative leading-order long-time particle-number and energy-increase rates for suitable smearing profiles and particle-number-diagonal positive states. The leading one-point flash intensity is also nonnegative for this class; vacuum–even-particle coherences can make it negative. Conditions for recovering nonrelativistic collapse dynamics are derived. The central unresolved issue is whether a sufficiently rich nonvacuum state space satisfies all history-positivity constraints. Higher-order positivity, interacting-field applications, and curved-spacetime extensions remain open.

No sign of AI-generated textStrong assumptions

Central claim may not hold: The framework has not been shown to admit a sufficiently rich non-vacuum physical state space with non-negative probabilities for every finite flash/no-flash history, so its resolution of the relativistic-collapse consistency problems remains conditional.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
21 pages plus appendices, 3 figures

Related papers

Relativistic dynamical collapse model

Philip Pearle

A model is discussed where all operators are constructed from a quantum scalar field whose energy spectrum takes on all real values. The Schr\"odinger picture wave function depends upon space and time coordinates for each particle, as well as an inexorably increasing evolution parameter $s$ which labels a foliation of spacelike hypersurfaces. The model is constructed to be manifestly Lorentz invariant in the interaction picture. Free particle states and interactions are discussed in this framework. Then, the formalism of the continuous spontaneous localization (CSL) theory of dynamical collapse is applied. The collapse-generating operator is chosen to be the particle number space-time density. Unlike previous relativistically invariant models, the vacuum state is not excited. The collapse dynamics depends upon two parameters, a parameter $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Lambda}}$ which represents the collapse rate/volume and a scale factor $\ensuremath{\ell}$. A common example of collapse dynamics, involving a clump of matter in a superposition of two locations, is analyzed. The collapse rate is shown to be identical to that of nonrelativistic CSL when the GRW-CSL choice of $\ensuremath{\ell}=a=1{0}^{\ensuremath{-}5}\text{ }\text{ }\mathrm{cm}$, is made, along with $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Lambda}}=\ensuremath{\lambda}/{a}^{3}$ (GRW-CSL choice $\ensuremath{\lambda}=1{0}^{\ensuremath{-}16}{s}^{\ensuremath{-}1}$). The collapse rate is also satisfactory with the choice $\ensuremath{\ell}$ as the size of the Universe, with $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Lambda}}=\ensuremath{\lambda}/\ensuremath{\ell}{a}^{2}$. Because the collapse narrows wave functions in space and time, it increases a particle's momentum and energy, altering its mass. It is shown that, with $\ensuremath{\ell}=a$, the change of mass of a nucleon is unacceptably large but, when $\ensuremath{\ell}$ is the size of the Universe, the change of mass over the age of the Universe is acceptably small.

arXiv:1412.6723•Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•May 15, 2015•85 citations

Toward relativistic generalization of collapse models

Anirudh Gundhi, Lajos Diósi, Matteo Carlesso

Spontaneous collapse models provide a possible, testable solution to the quantum measurement problem. While experiments are providing increasingly stronger bounds on their parameters, a full-fledged relativistic extension is still missing. Previous attempts have encountered different obstacles, such as violation of microcausality, infinite energy rate, and particle production from vacuum. Here, we propose a generalization of the collapse master equation that is characterized by a local field collapse operator and a non-Markovian noise with a Lorentz invariant correlation. Our construction is able to overcome previously encountered problems and has the desirable properties in the nonrelativistic limit. A specific choice of the noise correlation function is also introduced and discussed.

arXiv:2507.06954•Physical Review A•Jun 22, 2026•3 citations

Non-Markovian Poissonian Spontaneous Collapse Models

Nicolò Piccione

Spontaneous collapse models provide a possible solution to the measurement problem by modifying standard quantum dynamics. The modification consists of adding non-linear and stochastic terms inducing wavefunction collapse in space. Non-Markovian versions of these models are motivated by physical reasons, phenomenological consistency, and potential for relativistic extensions. Here, we investigate a non-Markovian version of the Poissonian Spontaneous Localization (PSL) model, i.e., a model characterized by instantaneous and localized collapse events. We assume that our model is characterized by a typical time scale $τ_C$ so that, given an initial state $ρ_0$ of standard quantum matter at time $t=0$, we derive an effective long-time ($t\gg τ_C$) statistical dynamics in terms of a CPTP map $Φ_t$. We then show how $Φ_t$ can be made equal to that obtained by non-Markovian CSL models. Moreover, given $Φ_t$, we obtain the associated time-convolutionless master equation by means of a supercumulant expansion. Finally, we characterize the collapse events process (for events with $t \gg τ_C$) given an initial quantum state $ρ_0$ at $t=0$.

quant-pharXiv:2607.08955•Jul 13, 2026•1 citation

Relativistic collapse model with tachyonic features

Philip Pearle

A finite relativistic model for free particles, which describes the collapse of the state vector, is presented. The interaction of particles with a classical fluctuating field $w(x)$ causes collapse, as in the (so far) physically satisfactory nonrelativistic continuous spontaneous localization (CSL) model. In previous relativistic models, where $w(x)$ has a white-noise spectrum, collapse is accompanied by spontaneous creation of particles with all energies out of the vacuum [amounting to infinite energy/(sec-volume)]. In this paper we explore one way of eliminating such vacuum excitation. We present a formalism which allows an arbitrary spectrum for $w(x).$ We point out, in lowest order of perturbation theory, that it is timelike components of this spectrum which are responsible for vacuum excitation but (appropriate, it seems, to a fundamentally nonlocal phenomenon) it is spacelike components which are responsible for collapse. We restrict the spectrum of $w(x)$ to that of a tachyon of mass $\ensuremath{\mu}=\ensuremath{\Elzxh}/ac\ensuremath{\approx}1 \mathrm{eV},$ where $a\ensuremath{\approx}{10}^{\ensuremath{-}5} \mathrm{cm}\mathrm{}$ is the Ghirardi-Rimini-Weber (GRW) collapse model scale parameter used in CSL. However, in higher orders than the first, there is still vacuum excitation due to the energy-momentum supplied by particle propagators. We opt to explore a simple means of eliminating this vacuum excitation: by removing the time-ordering operation from the state vector evolution so that particle propagators are on the mass shell. The result is a finite theory: there is no vacuum excitation (and no need for renormalization) as each vertex describes a finite physical process, the spontaneous emission or absorption of a real tachyon by a particle (pair creation or annihilation is not permitted by energy-momentum conservation). This process may be thought of as analogous to the GRW ``hitting'' description of collapse. The cost of no time ordering is that at each vertex a mass M particle's wave function can spread by as much as $\ensuremath{\approx}cT(\ensuremath{\mu}/M)$ in time T. This has the result that, beginning at perturbation order $2M/\ensuremath{\mu},$ there is a nonvanishing probability for the particle to be found outside its light cone: for electrons and nucleons, the probability of this spacelike transport is negligibly small. Apart from this effect, the density matrix of particles in one region evolves independently of particles in another spacelike separated region. We thus obtain a finite, reasonably sensible, relativistic collapse model for free particles.

arXiv:quant-ph/9902046•Physical Review A•Jan 1, 1999•90 citations

Demystifying Relativistic Quantum Collapse

R. Muciño, E. Okon, D. Sudarsky +1 more

Non-relativistic objective collapse theories have been remarkably successful in addressing the conceptual problems of standard quantum mechanics. Despite substantial efforts, the project of extending them to the relativistic domain remains burdened by significant conceptual objections and technical challenges, often taken to cast doubt on the viability of the program as a whole. On the conceptual side, relativistic collapse theories have been claimed to face challenges involving tension between instantaneous collapse and relativity, frame-dependence of property values and probabilities, the possibility of superluminal signaling and the failure of narratability. On the technical side, persistent infinities, difficulties in constructing fully covariant frameworks and the apparent need for non-standard fields have hindered the development of workable models. In this paper, we offer a systematic rebuttal of the conceptual objections and provide a structured account of the remaining technical challenges. We conclude that relativistic collapse theories do provide a promising route toward a fully relativistic quantum framework that overcomes the conceptual limitations of standard quantum theory.

quant-pharXiv:2608.26474•Aug 28, 2026•1 citation

Lorentz Invariant Master Equation for Quantum Systems

Pranav Vaidhyanathan, Gerard J. Milburn

Irreversibility implies a preferred flow of time, yet special relativity denies the existence of a preferred clock. This tension has long obstructed the formulation of a relativistic master equation: standard Markovian approximations either break Lorentz covariance, trigger catastrophic vacuum heating, or depend arbitrarily on the observer's foliation. In this work, we derive a Lorentz-invariant description of irreversibility for quantum fields. We take an approach that explicitly models the measurements required to observe irreversible dynamics. Instead of evolving the system along an abstract geometric time parameter, we anchor the dynamics to a physical, relational scalar clock field. Using a relational Tomonaga-Schwinger framework, we derive a local, non-Markovian master equation that is manifestly covariant and completely positive. We show that the finite resolution of the physical clock acts as a covariant regulator, preventing the vacuum instability that plagues white-noise models. This framework demonstrates that a consistent relativistic theory of decay exists, provided the reference frame is treated as a dynamical quantum resource rather than a gauge choice. In a gravitating context, the resulting dynamics is described by a hybrid classical-quantum (CQ) evolution that remains completely positive and trace preserving (CPTP).

quant-pharXiv:2512.19346•Dec 23, 2025•0 citations
Spontaneous collapse models provide a possible, testable solution to the quantum measurement problem, but constructing a relativistic version applicable to quantum field theory remains an important open challenge. Challenges in constructing relativistic collapse models include avoiding superluminal signaling and foliation dependence, controlling energy production, and ensuring vacuum stability. Here, we present a relativistic collapse framework that addresses these problems at the cost of introducing a new space of physical states, whose complete characterization is left open. A modified, history-dependent Aharonov--Albert prescription describes instantaneous nonlocal state updates on arbitrary spacelike foliations while preserving foliation independence. To ensure vacuum stability, we modify the standard unitary evolution through a prescription that we name dynamical vacuum subtraction. The resulting dynamical map is linear and trace-preserving but not positive on the full set of standard density operators. We establish no-signaling by proving microscopic parameter independence, and identify conditions under which standard nonrelativistic collapse dynamics are recovered. Finally, we apply our framework to a free massive scalar field, obtaining finite particle-number and energy-increase rates at leading order in the long-time regime, together with further promising evidence for the consistency of the framework.
The paper addresses relativistic spontaneous-collapse dynamics for quantum fields, seeking vacuum stability, foliation independence, no superluminal signaling, and finite excitation rates. It constructs a flash ontology from Poisson-distributed spacetime points carrying auxiliary qubits. Each qubit couples to a local scalar field operator within the point’s past light cone; its eventual binary outcome determines whether a flash occurs.
Vacuum stability is imposed through “dynamical vacuum subtraction,” replacing unitary evolution by U~A=UA+Tr⁡(A)(Ω−UΩ)\widetilde{\mathcal U}A=\mathcal UA+\operatorname{Tr}(A)(\Omega-\mathcal U\Omega)UA=UA+Tr(A)(Ω−UΩ). This preserves linearity, trace, composition, and the vacuum, but not positivity on conventional density operators. Physical states are instead defined by nonnegative probabilities for every finite flash/no-flash history. A history-dependent collapse prescription refers to a fixed initial Cauchy surface while retaining independence from the interpolating foliation. A causal-support argument establishes microscopic parameter independence under spacelike-separated external potentials, assuming the initial state is admissible with and without the perturbation.
In a weak-coupling, infinite-point-density limit, the framework yields formal colored-noise reduced dynamics and joint flash intensities. For a free massive scalar field coupled through : ⁣φ2 ⁣:/2:\!\varphi^2\!:/2:φ2:/2, Bogoliubov calculations give finite, nonnegative leading-order long-time particle-number and energy-increase rates for suitable smearing profiles and particle-number-diagonal positive states. The leading one-point flash intensity is also nonnegative for this class; vacuum–even-particle coherences can make it negative. Conditions for recovering nonrelativistic collapse dynamics are derived.
The central unresolved issue is whether a sufficiently rich nonvacuum state space satisfies all history-positivity constraints. Higher-order positivity, interacting-field applications, and curved-spacetime extensions remain open.
A model is discussed where all operators are constructed from a quantum scalar field whose energy spectrum takes on all real values. The Schr\"odinger picture wave function depends upon space and time coordinates for each particle, as well as an inexorably increasing evolution parameter sss which labels a foliation of spacelike hypersurfaces. The model is constructed to be manifestly Lorentz invariant in the interaction picture. Free particle states and interactions are discussed in this framework. Then, the formalism of the continuous spontaneous localization (CSL) theory of dynamical collapse is applied. The collapse-generating operator is chosen to be the particle number space-time density. Unlike previous relativistically invariant models, the vacuum state is not excited. The collapse dynamics depends upon two parameters, a parameter $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Lambda}}$ which represents the collapse rate/volume and a scale factor $\ensuremath{\ell}$. A common example of collapse dynamics, involving a clump of matter in a superposition of two locations, is analyzed. The collapse rate is shown to be identical to that of nonrelativistic CSL when the GRW-CSL choice of $\ensuremath{\ell}=a=1{0}^{\ensuremath{-}5}\text{ }\text{ }\mathrm{cm}$, is made, along with $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Lambda}}=\ensuremath{\lambda}/{a}^{3}$ (GRW-CSL choice $\ensuremath{\lambda}=1{0}^{\ensuremath{-}16}{s}^{\ensuremath{-}1}$). The collapse rate is also satisfactory with the choice $\ensuremath{\ell}$ as the size of the Universe, with $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Lambda}}=\ensuremath{\lambda}/\ensuremath{\ell}{a}^{2}$. Because the collapse narrows wave functions in space and time, it increases a particle's momentum and energy, altering its mass. It is shown that, with $\ensuremath{\ell}=a$, the change of mass of a nucleon is unacceptably large but, when $\ensuremath{\ell}$ is the size of the Universe, the change of mass over the age of the Universe is acceptably small.
Spontaneous collapse models provide a possible, testable solution to the quantum measurement problem. While experiments are providing increasingly stronger bounds on their parameters, a full-fledged relativistic extension is still missing. Previous attempts have encountered different obstacles, such as violation of microcausality, infinite energy rate, and particle production from vacuum. Here, we propose a generalization of the collapse master equation that is characterized by a local field collapse operator and a non-Markovian noise with a Lorentz invariant correlation. Our construction is able to overcome previously encountered problems and has the desirable properties in the nonrelativistic limit. A specific choice of the noise correlation function is also introduced and discussed.
Spontaneous collapse models provide a possible solution to the measurement problem by modifying standard quantum dynamics. The modification consists of adding non-linear and stochastic terms inducing wavefunction collapse in space. Non-Markovian versions of these models are motivated by physical reasons, phenomenological consistency, and potential for relativistic extensions. Here, we investigate a non-Markovian version of the Poissonian Spontaneous Localization (PSL) model, i.e., a model characterized by instantaneous and localized collapse events. We assume that our model is characterized by a typical time scale τCτ_CτC​ so that, given an initial state ρ0ρ_0ρ0​ of standard quantum matter at time t=0t=0t=0, we derive an effective long-time (t≫τCt\gg τ_Ct≫τC​) statistical dynamics in terms of a CPTP map ΦtΦ_tΦt​. We then show how ΦtΦ_tΦt​ can be made equal to that obtained by non-Markovian CSL models. Moreover, given ΦtΦ_tΦt​, we obtain the associated time-convolutionless master equation by means of a supercumulant expansion. Finally, we characterize the collapse events process (for events with t≫τCt \gg τ_Ct≫τC​) given an initial quantum state ρ0ρ_0ρ0​ at t=0t=0t=0.
A finite relativistic model for free particles, which describes the collapse of the state vector, is presented. The interaction of particles with a classical fluctuating field w(x)w(x)w(x) causes collapse, as in the (so far) physically satisfactory nonrelativistic continuous spontaneous localization (CSL) model. In previous relativistic models, where w(x)w(x)w(x) has a white-noise spectrum, collapse is accompanied by spontaneous creation of particles with all energies out of the vacuum [amounting to infinite energy/(sec-volume)]. In this paper we explore one way of eliminating such vacuum excitation. We present a formalism which allows an arbitrary spectrum for w(x).w(x).w(x). We point out, in lowest order of perturbation theory, that it is timelike components of this spectrum which are responsible for vacuum excitation but (appropriate, it seems, to a fundamentally nonlocal phenomenon) it is spacelike components which are responsible for collapse. We restrict the spectrum of w(x)w(x)w(x) to that of a tachyon of mass $\ensuremath{\mu}=\ensuremath{\Elzxh}/ac\ensuremath{\approx}1 \mathrm{eV},$ where $a\ensuremath{\approx}{10}^{\ensuremath{-}5} \mathrm{cm}\mathrm{}$ is the Ghirardi-Rimini-Weber (GRW) collapse model scale parameter used in CSL. However, in higher orders than the first, there is still vacuum excitation due to the energy-momentum supplied by particle propagators. We opt to explore a simple means of eliminating this vacuum excitation: by removing the time-ordering operation from the state vector evolution so that particle propagators are on the mass shell. The result is a finite theory: there is no vacuum excitation (and no need for renormalization) as each vertex describes a finite physical process, the spontaneous emission or absorption of a real tachyon by a particle (pair creation or annihilation is not permitted by energy-momentum conservation). This process may be thought of as analogous to the GRW ``hitting'' description of collapse. The cost of no time ordering is that at each vertex a mass M particle's wave function can spread by as much as $\ensuremath{\approx}cT(\ensuremath{\mu}/M)$ in time T. This has the result that, beginning at perturbation order $2M/\ensuremath{\mu},$ there is a nonvanishing probability for the particle to be found outside its light cone: for electrons and nucleons, the probability of this spacelike transport is negligibly small. Apart from this effect, the density matrix of particles in one region evolves independently of particles in another spacelike separated region. We thus obtain a finite, reasonably sensible, relativistic collapse model for free particles.
Non-relativistic objective collapse theories have been remarkably successful in addressing the conceptual problems of standard quantum mechanics. Despite substantial efforts, the project of extending them to the relativistic domain remains burdened by significant conceptual objections and technical challenges, often taken to cast doubt on the viability of the program as a whole. On the conceptual side, relativistic collapse theories have been claimed to face challenges involving tension between instantaneous collapse and relativity, frame-dependence of property values and probabilities, the possibility of superluminal signaling and the failure of narratability. On the technical side, persistent infinities, difficulties in constructing fully covariant frameworks and the apparent need for non-standard fields have hindered the development of workable models. In this paper, we offer a systematic rebuttal of the conceptual objections and provide a structured account of the remaining technical challenges. We conclude that relativistic collapse theories do provide a promising route toward a fully relativistic quantum framework that overcomes the conceptual limitations of standard quantum theory.
Irreversibility implies a preferred flow of time, yet special relativity denies the existence of a preferred clock. This tension has long obstructed the formulation of a relativistic master equation: standard Markovian approximations either break Lorentz covariance, trigger catastrophic vacuum heating, or depend arbitrarily on the observer's foliation. In this work, we derive a Lorentz-invariant description of irreversibility for quantum fields. We take an approach that explicitly models the measurements required to observe irreversible dynamics. Instead of evolving the system along an abstract geometric time parameter, we anchor the dynamics to a physical, relational scalar clock field. Using a relational Tomonaga-Schwinger framework, we derive a local, non-Markovian master equation that is manifestly covariant and completely positive. We show that the finite resolution of the physical clock acts as a covariant regulator, preventing the vacuum instability that plagues white-noise models. This framework demonstrates that a consistent relativistic theory of decay exists, provided the reference frame is treated as a dynamical quantum resource rather than a gauge choice. In a gravitating context, the resulting dynamics is described by a hybrid classical-quantum (CQ) evolution that remains completely positive and trace preserving (CPTP).