arXiv:2610.10143
Inequivalent Quantum Resources from Multipartite State Discrimination
Srijani Das, Tuhin Paul, Manasi Patra, Atanu Bhunia, Ramij Rahaman
Abstract
Any two orthogonal quantum states can be perfectly distinguished via local operations and classical communication (LOCC), yet whether all orthogonal multipartite pairs incur an identical operational cost remains an open question. Here, we address the resource consumption required for local state discrimination across multipartite pair of states. We demonstrate that distinct pairs of orthogonal multipartite maximally entangled states require unequal amounts of quantum resources to achieve local distinguishability. Extending our framework beyond individual pairs, we analyze larger sets of both locally distinguishable and indistinguishable multipartite orthogonal states, revealing a nontrivial hierarchy in their entanglement consumption. These results show that the resource cost of LOCC discrimination is state-dependent, providing insight into the fine-grained structure of multipartite nonlocality.
AI Summary
The paper studies the entanglement cost of LOCC discrimination when an unknown multipartite state must remain intact, rather than merely be identified. It focuses on orthogonal states in an $n$-qubit GHZ basis and nonmaximally entangled variants, distinguishing phase-opposite states with identical computational supports from states with disjoint supports, termed zero and nonzero relative Hamming distance. For two GHZ states with nonzero relative distance, it gives a nondestructive protocol consuming one shared Bell pair: local controlled-NOT gates transfer a two-party computational parity to the ancilla, whose measurement identifies the state. A reduction to two Bell states across a bipartition supplies the claimed one-ebit lower bound. For phase-opposite pairs, separability of the equiprobable mixture is used to rule out net entanglement extraction under LOCC; the paper contrasts Bell-pair assistance with an auxiliary $n$-party GHZ state for preserving these pairs. For larger ensembles, computational-basis measurements distinguish any set containing at most one state per complementary-support pair. Conversely, any ensemble of more than two states containing a phase-opposite pair is shown LOCC-indistinguishable by reduction to three Bell states. The paper claims nondestructive discrimination of $k$ pairwise-nonzero-distance GHZ states using $\lceil\log_2 k\rceil$ Bell pairs, through recursive parity partitioning, and also discusses two-copy discrimination and nonmaximal extensions. The scope is GHZ-basis families rather than general multipartite states. Resource preservation is exact and discrimination deterministic. Although the conclusion calls the Bell ancilla a catalyst, the explicit parity protocol measures and consumes it; the target state, not the ancilla, is preserved.
Central claim may not hold: The abstract omits the nondestructive-discrimination restriction needed for its pairwise resource distinction, since ordinary discrimination of every orthogonal pure-state pair requires no auxiliary entanglement. The zero-distance no-net-extraction theorem does not establish the claimed optimal auxiliary-resource classification, and categorical prohibitions on assisted preservation are contradicted by a nondestructive protocol consuming an auxiliary GHZ state. The larger-ensemble resource bounds rely on a false balanced-parity premise: eight configurations comprising the empty set and seven singletons require at least four queries in the displayed protocol, rather than the advertised three. The claimed genuine Bell-state catalyst is actually consumed by computational-basis measurements, making the displayed protocol resource-assisted rather than catalytic. Equation GHZ_Hr2 incorrectly claims that local Z operations change GHZ computational-support configurations, although such a change requires X operations.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 7 Pages, 1 Figure