arXiv:2610.10073
Tradeoff between Wigner negativity and decoherence time for cubic Gaussian states
Matthieu Arnhem, Valerio Crescimanna, Giuseppe Patera, Stephan De Bièvre
Abstract
Wigner negativity has been shown to be a resource in quantum computing, raising the question of how to efficiently produce states with a large Wigner negativity. Cubic Gaussian states, obtained when a cubic gate is applied to a Gaussian state, have been proposed as candidates for this purpose. We show that cubic Gaussian states with a large Wigner negativity $\mathcal N$ necessarily have a short decoherence time $τ$ that is bounded above by $\mathcal N^{-2}$. In other words, a large Wigner negativity comes at a cost: the decoherence time $τ$ of cubic Gaussian states decreases at least quadratically in the negativity $\mathcal N$. Maximizing $τ$ at fixed Wigner negativity $\mathcal N$, we show that this upper bound is reached by optimal cubic Gaussian states. They have the property that for large negativity, the optimal squeezing scales as $\ln\mathcal N$ and the optimal cubicity as $\mathcal N^{-1}$. Optimal cubic Gaussian states with large negativity can therefore be constructed with small cubicity, provided sufficient squeezing is applied. However, their decoherence time decreases with growing negativity. In addition, we show that their preparation is extremely sensitive to thermal noise. Finally, we compare, for each integer $n$, the optimal cubic Gaussian state with the $n$th Fock state that has the same negativity: despite their pronounced differences in photon number distribution and Wigner function, we show that they have similar, be it slightly larger, decoherence times and entanglement generating potential through a beam splitter.
AI Summary
The paper asks how much decoherence sensitivity is unavoidable when generating Wigner negativity by applying a cubic phase gate $\Gamma_\gamma=e^{-i\gamma\hat q^3}$ to a single-mode Gaussian state. It studies the full displaced, squeezed, thermal input family, using the quadrature coherence scale (QCS) as a decoherence-rate measure for coupling to a thermal bath, with $\tau\simeq\mathcal C^{-2}$. An Airy-function expression for the Wigner function reduces its integrated absolute value, $\mathcal N$ (normalized to 1 for Wigner-positive states), to a function of one parameter, $\lambda=6\gamma(\sigma_{qq}/\det V)^{3/2}$. Analytical bounds and numerical integration give large-$\lambda$ growth $\mathcal N\sim0.745\sqrt\lambda$. Explicit QCS formulas allow optimization at fixed negativity: for $\lambda\geq1/\sqrt2$, an optimal state is a cubic momentum-squeezed vacuum with $\mathcal C_{\mathrm{opt}}^2=\sqrt{1+2\lambda^2}$ and $r_{\mathrm{opt}}=\tfrac14\ln(1+2\lambda^2)$. Consequently, the longest decoherence time scales as $\mathcal N^{-2}$, while optimal squeezing grows as $\ln\mathcal N$ and cubicity decreases as $\mathcal N^{-1}$. Further calculations characterize thermal-input sensitivity and broad, super-Poissonian photon statistics. Comparisons at equal negativity find similar photon costs and somewhat longer coherence times than Fock states; numerical beam-splitter simulations also compare entanglement generation. The negativity asymptotic coefficient is numerical rather than rigorously established. The decoherence conclusion uses the QCS–thermal-bath relation, not a channel-independent lifetime. Photon-distribution calculations require large cutoffs, and experimental optimization depends on accessible squeezing and cubicity. Extending the negativity–QCS tradeoff to arbitrary states remains a conjecture.
Error found: The decoherence-time conclusion is conditional on the thermal-bath Lindblad interpretation of the approximate relation τ ≃ C⁻², rather than an established noise-model-independent bound. Attainment of the inverse-quadratic lifetime scaling relies on a numerically supported negativity asymptotic that the paper does not prove analytically. The unrestricted inequality C² ≥ (√2/c²)N² is contradicted by the paper's own tabulated optimal states and should not be asserted outside its asymptotic regime. The claimed thermal half-loss threshold comes from an unjustified finite-noise extrapolation: asymptotically, a thermal input of mean photon number 0.5 retains about 59.5% of the negative volume, not 50%. The low-negativity optimization gives C²_opt = 2^(3/4)√λ rather than the stated constant √2.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 32 pages, 9 figures