arXiv:2610.10040
Can we make sense out of negative kinetic energy?
Alessio Maiezza, Fabrizio Nesti
Abstract
Many Quantum Field Theory models, either designed to improve the ultraviolet behavior via higher derivative terms or aimed at providing unified descriptions of Gravity, inevitably introduce negative-energy 'ghosts' states. These states raise fundamental questions regarding the stability of the theory. In this study, we investigate the time evolution of simplified quantum mechanical models consisting of two coupled normal and ghost subsystems. Although the full spectrum of these models is unbounded from below and, therefore, lacks a true ground state, we focus the time evolution of a 'would-be ground state': a zero-energy eigenstate of the decoupled system. By analyzing its metastability under interactions, we gain insights into the dynamics of ghost-like states. Contrary to the standard paradigm, our results demonstrate that, across a broad range of couplings, the would-be ground state does not decay and remains dynamically stable over long times. This provides evidence towards resolving the stability problems of Hamiltonians that are unbounded from below. We also discuss the connections with the corresponding classical and semiclassical dynamics.
AI Summary
Does coupling positive- and negative-energy degrees of freedom necessarily destabilize a quantum state? This paper studies $H=H_1-H_2+V$ for two harmonic oscillators with $\omega_1=1$, $\omega_2=\sqrt{2}$, starting from the product oscillator vacuum. The interactions are $V=(\lambda/2)x^2y^2e^{-(x^2+y^2)}$ and $V=(\lambda/2)x^2y^2$. The observable is the survival probability $P(t)=|\langle0,0|e^{-iHt}|0,0\rangle|^2$, supplemented by subsystem energies and probability currents. Formal perturbation expansions and cutoff-dependent numerical diagonalization are used, with spatial discretization and, for the quartic interaction, truncation in the oscillator basis. At weak coupling, the initial state predominantly overlaps one interacting eigenstate, and the computed survival probability exhibits persistent oscillations rather than complete decay within numerically reliable times. For the quartic interaction, an empirical envelope is $P(t)\gtrsim10^{-0.085\lambda^2-0.9\lambda^3}$ for $\lambda<0.15$. For the bounded interaction, survival remains approximately above $50\%$ for $\lambda\leq30$. Subsystem energies likewise oscillate without observed runaway in the weak-coupling regime. Excited initial states show stronger depletion; increasing the ghost frequency suppresses it. Classical simulations identify bounded-motion regions and runaway trajectories with qualitative parallels to the quantum results. The conclusions concern finite-time metastability, not proven asymptotic stability. Reliable simulation times shorten substantially at stronger coupling, and spectral counting does not rigorously establish the interacting spectral type. The two numerical regulators yield different survival curves despite apparent convergence within each scheme; this is interpreted as UV sensitivity, with predictive implications left unresolved. Extension to field-theoretic vacuum stability remains open.
Central claim may not hold: The abstract's broad nondecay claim and the conclusion's survival at any later time exceed numerical evidence that establishes only finite-time persistence, most reliably at weak coupling. The two numerical regulators yield different survival probabilities beyond their estimated cutoff errors, leaving the claimed regulator-independent physical dynamics unresolved. Growing eigenvalue density in finite truncations does not establish the claimed dense point spectrum of the interacting infinite-dimensional Hamiltonian. For the specified quartic interaction and initial oscillator vacuum, the exact short-time survival coefficient is lambda^2/16, whereas the paper reports approximately 14 lambda^2. The printed finite-difference stencil already approximates minus one-half of the second derivative, so applying the subsequent kinetic prefactor yields the wrong kinetic operator as written, although the implemented operator is unknown.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 33 pages, 22 figure