arXiv:2610.10004
Causal confusion in quantum systems: distinguishing direct cause and common cause
Krisztina Tolotti, Riley Blank-Matthews, Arthur J. Parzygnat
Abstract
The joint expectation values of quantum observables measured by two parties typically depend on the causal structure of the measurement protocol. The two causal structures we investigate here are the direct-cause scenario, in which a single quantum state is measured twice in series with a general quantum channel between measurements, and the common-cause scenario, in which a shared bipartite quantum state is measured in parallel. Through a variety of examples of qubit channels with tunable parameters, we identify the full set of input states where the direct-cause joint expectation values of Pauli observables coincide with those obtained from a common cause, a situation that we call causal confusion. More generally, for arbitrary finite-dimensional quantum systems and light-touch observables, we prove that a channel exhibits causal confusion for some input state if and only if it is a positive-partial-transpose (PPT) channel, thereby endowing PPT channels with a new operational meaning in terms of causal confusion. Using this result, we characterize the set of qubit channels for which there exists an input state leading to causal confusion as the set of entanglement-breaking channels.
AI Summary
The paper asks when two-time quantum correlations from sequential measurements on an input state $\rho$, with an intervening channel $\mathcal E$, can also arise from local measurements on a shared bipartite state. It calls equality of the joint expectation-value tables “causal confusion.” The temporal protocol uses Lüders measurements; the general results concern light-touch observables satisfying $A^2=\lambda I$, including Pauli observables. Using the established Jordan-product state-over-time representation, compatibility becomes positivity of $\mathcal E\star\rho=\tfrac12\{\rho\otimes I,J(\mathcal E)\}$, where $J$ is the partially transposed Choi matrix. The central necessity result shows that positivity for a full-rank input implies that $\mathcal E$ is PPT, by inverting the anticommutator through a positivity-preserving integral solving a Sylvester equation. Conversely, every PPT channel gives compatibility for the maximally mixed input. The paper states an unrestricted existence-if-and-only-if-PPT corollary, although its necessity proof assumes full rank. For qubit channels, PPT is equivalent to entanglement breaking. Explicit calculations characterize compatible inputs for several channel families. For qubit depolarization $\mathcal E(\rho)=(1-\lambda)\rho+\lambda I/2$, compatibility holds exactly when $2/3\le\lambda\le4/3$ and the Bloch radius obeys $\|\mathbf r\|\le\sqrt{(2-\lambda)(3\lambda-2)}/\lambda$. Examples show that entanglement-breaking channels need not give compatibility for every input, and compatible bipartite states can be entangled. Additional results concern Bayesian inverses. The scope excludes general instruments and broader causal structures. General input-state criteria, quantitative distinguishability measures, and practical protocols exploiting the distinction remain open.
polish a few sentences once the manuscript was written.
Central claim may not hold: The abstract's arbitrary-input-state claim exceeds Theorem 'PPTEQSOTstate', whose necessity proof explicitly requires a full-rank input state. Corollary 'causalconfusioniffPPT' incorrectly drops the full-rank hypothesis: the qutrit channel E(A)=PAP+QAQ, with P=|0><0| and Q=I−P, exhibits causal confusion at rho=P but is not PPT.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 32 pages, 17 figures; comments welcome!