Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2610.10004

Causal confusion in quantum systems: distinguishing direct cause and common cause

Krisztina Tolotti, Riley Blank-Matthews, Arthur J. Parzygnat

quant-phSubmitted Oct 7, 2026• Announced Oct 8, 2026• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The joint expectation values of quantum observables measured by two parties typically depend on the causal structure of the measurement protocol. The two causal structures we investigate here are the direct-cause scenario, in which a single quantum state is measured twice in series with a general quantum channel between measurements, and the common-cause scenario, in which a shared bipartite quantum state is measured in parallel. Through a variety of examples of qubit channels with tunable parameters, we identify the full set of input states where the direct-cause joint expectation values of Pauli observables coincide with those obtained from a common cause, a situation that we call causal confusion. More generally, for arbitrary finite-dimensional quantum systems and light-touch observables, we prove that a channel exhibits causal confusion for some input state if and only if it is a positive-partial-transpose (PPT) channel, thereby endowing PPT channels with a new operational meaning in terms of causal confusion. Using this result, we characterize the set of qubit channels for which there exists an input state leading to causal confusion as the set of entanglement-breaking channels.

AI Summary

The paper asks when two-time quantum correlations from sequential measurements on an input state $\rho$, with an intervening channel $\mathcal E$, can also arise from local measurements on a shared bipartite state. It calls equality of the joint expectation-value tables “causal confusion.” The temporal protocol uses Lüders measurements; the general results concern light-touch observables satisfying $A^2=\lambda I$, including Pauli observables. Using the established Jordan-product state-over-time representation, compatibility becomes positivity of $\mathcal E\star\rho=\tfrac12\{\rho\otimes I,J(\mathcal E)\}$, where $J$ is the partially transposed Choi matrix. The central necessity result shows that positivity for a full-rank input implies that $\mathcal E$ is PPT, by inverting the anticommutator through a positivity-preserving integral solving a Sylvester equation. Conversely, every PPT channel gives compatibility for the maximally mixed input. The paper states an unrestricted existence-if-and-only-if-PPT corollary, although its necessity proof assumes full rank. For qubit channels, PPT is equivalent to entanglement breaking. Explicit calculations characterize compatible inputs for several channel families. For qubit depolarization $\mathcal E(\rho)=(1-\lambda)\rho+\lambda I/2$, compatibility holds exactly when $2/3\le\lambda\le4/3$ and the Bloch radius obeys $\|\mathbf r\|\le\sqrt{(2-\lambda)(3\lambda-2)}/\lambda$. Examples show that entanglement-breaking channels need not give compatibility for every input, and compatible bipartite states can be entangled. Additional results concern Bayesian inverses. The scope excludes general instruments and broader causal structures. General input-state criteria, quantitative distinguishability measures, and practical protocols exploiting the distinction remain open.

No sign of AI-generated textAI use disclosedPossible errorOverclaims
polish a few sentences once the manuscript was written.

Central claim may not hold: The abstract's arbitrary-input-state claim exceeds Theorem 'PPTEQSOTstate', whose necessity proof explicitly requires a full-rank input state. Corollary 'causalconfusioniffPPT' incorrectly drops the full-rank hypothesis: the qutrit channel E(A)=PAP+QAQ, with P=|0><0| and Q=I−P, exhibits causal confusion at rho=P but is not PPT.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
32 pages, 17 figures; comments welcome!

Related papers

Efficient Distinction between Quantum Direct and Common Causes and its Experimental Verification

Feixiang Xu, Jiayi Lin, Ben Wang +4 more

Identifying the causal structures between two statistically correlated events has been widely investigated in many fields of science. While some of the well-studied classical methods are carefully generalized to quantum version of causal inference for certain cases, an effective and efficient way to detect the more general quantum causal structures is still lacking. Here, we introduce a quantity named `Causal Determinant' to efficiently identify the quantum causal structures between two quantum systems and experimentally verify the validity of the method. According to the causal determinant, the quantum direct cause imposed by an arbitrary unitary operator can be perfectly discriminated with the quantum common cause, in which the two quantum systems share a joint quantum state. In addition, the causal determinant has the capability to discriminate between more general causal structures and predict the range of their parameters. The ability to detect more general quantum causal structures of our method can shed new light on the field of quantum causal inference.

arXiv:2203.02752•Mar 5, 2022•0 citations

Bipartite quantum states admitting a causal explanation

Min-Jeong Song, Arthur J. Parzygnat

The statistics of local measurements of joint quantum systems can sometimes be used to distinguish the spatiotemporal structure in which they were measured. We first prove that every bipartite separable density matrix is temporally compatible with direct causal influence for arbitrary finite-dimensional quantum systems and measurements of a tomographically complete class of observables, which includes all Pauli observables in the case of multi-qubit systems. Equivalently, if a bipartite density matrix is not temporally compatible with direct causal influence, then it must be entangled. We also provide an operational meaning for the two temporal evolutions consistent with such correlations in terms of generalized dephasing channels and pretty good measurements. The two temporal evolutions are Bayesian inverses of each other, which is different from them being Petz recovery maps of each other. Finally, we prove necessary and sufficient conditions for an arbitrary bipartite quantum state to be temporally compatible, thereby providing a temporal analogue of the positive partial transpose criterion valid for quantum systems of any dimension.

arXiv:2507.14278•AVS Quantum Science•Dec 1, 2025•12 citations

Elimination of quantum causal confusion in the presence of dual states

James Fullwood, Weixiang Ye

There is a rich class of bipartite quantum correlations between qubits which are consistent both with measurements performed in parallel and measurements performed in sequence. This phenomenon has recently been termed \emph{quantum causal confusion}, which is made mathematically precise by the notion of a dual state---a bipartite density operator whose associated correlations are causally ambiguous. A natural question is then whether or not the spatial and temporal scenarios associated with a dual state are fundamentally indistinguishable from a causal perspective. Here we show that as long as the reduced density operator of a dual state is oblique---meaning that all coefficients in its Pauli expansion are non-zero---then the underlying joint probabilities giving rise to such causally ambiguous correlations will differ in the spatial and temporal scenarios. Specifically, the temporal joint probabilities will inherently violate the no-signalling condition, thus eliminating quantum causal confusion. Moreover, as oblique states form an open dense subset of the Bloch ball, the elimination of quantum causal confusion is the norm rather than an exception.

arXiv:2611.07449•Nov 5, 2026•0 citations

Two-qubit causal structures and the geometry of positive qubit-maps

Jonas M. Kübler, Daniel Braun

We study quantum causal inference in a setup proposed by Ried et al (2015 Nat. Phys. 11 414) in which a common cause scenario can be mixed with a cause–effect scenario, and for which it was found that quantum mechanics can bring an advantage in distinguishing the two scenarios: whereas in classical statistics, interventions such as randomized trials are needed, a quantum observational scheme can be enough to detect the causal structure if the common cause results from a maximally entangled state. We analyze this setup in terms of the geometry of unital positive but not completely positive qubit-maps, arising from the mixture of qubit channels and steering maps. We find the range of mixing parameters that can generate given correlations, and prove a quantum advantage in a more general setup, allowing arbitrary unital channels and initial states with fully mixed reduced states. This is achieved by establishing new bounds on signed singular values of sums of matrices. Based on the geometry, we quantify and identify the origin of the quantum advantage depending on the observed correlations, and discuss how additional constraints can lead to a unique solution of the problem.

arXiv:1803.00369•New Journal of Physics•Jul 26, 2018•9 citations

Quantum tests of causal structures and non-orthogonal states

Megan Agnew

This thesis details two experimental tests that can be applied to particular quantum states to reveal important information. We begin by discussing the relevant background in quantum information. We introduce qubits and qudits as basic quantum states, and we discuss the evolution and measurement of quantum states. We then discuss quantum state tomography as a means by which to obtain complete information about a state, followed by a discussion of state discrimination as a means by which to determine the state given the promise that it is drawn from some known set. We then discuss relevant experimental techniques in quantum optics, including measurement, generation of entanglement, and generation of single photons from entanglement. \n \nThe first experiment we discuss deals with the causal structure of a system, which is the description of the origin of correlations between two or more states. The causal structure can be direct-cause, meaning that one state causes the other; common-cause, meaning that both states are caused by another; or hybrid-cause, which is a combination of the two. We perform the first implementation of a new type of tomography to determine the causal structure; this is called causal tomography and functions regardless of whether two qubits are related by a common state, a process, or some combination thereof. We implement a process on two entangled photons so that we can select the exact causal structure that results, which ranges continuously between direct-cause and common-cause structures. Using causal tomography, we recover causal structures that closely match expected results and demonstrate that quantum mechanics provides an advantage in causal inference. \n \nThe second experiment we discuss deals with the unambiguous discrimination of multiple quantum states. For the first time, we apply the principles of unambiguous state discrimination to high-dimensional systems. Given a state chosen randomly out of d possible states encoded in d dimensions, we implement a procedure for determining which state was chosen; this procedure in theory functions without error. We encode and detect the states in the orbital angular momentum degree of freedom up to dimension d=14. Although no experiment can provide perfectly error-free measurement due to inevitable imperfections, we obtain an error rate below the theoretical error rate of minimum-error state discrimination for dimensions up to d=12. At the time of submission of this thesis, this work has been accepted for publication in Physical Review Letters.

•Jun 13, 2014•0 citations

Quantum causal inference in the presence of hidden common causes: An entropic approach

Mohammad Ali Javidian, Vaneet Aggarwal, Zubin Jacob

Quantum causality is an emerging field of study which has the potential to greatly advance our understanding of quantum systems. In this paper, we put forth a theoretical framework for merging quantum information science and causal inference by exploiting entropic principles. For this purpose, we leverage the tradeoff between the entropy of hidden cause and the conditional mutual information of observed variables to develop a scalable algorithmic approach for inferring causality in the presence of latent confounders (common causes) in quantum systems. As an application, we consider a system of three entangled qubits and transmit the second and third qubits over separate noisy quantum channels. In this model, we validate that the first qubit is a latent confounder and the common cause of the second and third qubits. In contrast, when two entangled qubits are prepared and one of them is sent over a noisy channel, there is no common confounder. We also demonstrate that the proposed approach outperforms the results of classical causal inference for the Tubingen database when the variables are classical by exploiting quantum dependence between variables through density matrices rather than joint probability distributions. Thus, the proposed approach unifies classical and quantum causal inference in a principled way.

arXiv:2104.13227•Physical Review A•Dec 19, 2022•2 citations
The joint expectation values of quantum observables measured by two parties typically depend on the causal structure of the measurement protocol. The two causal structures we investigate here are the direct-cause scenario, in which a single quantum state is measured twice in series with a general quantum channel between measurements, and the common-cause scenario, in which a shared bipartite quantum state is measured in parallel. Through a variety of examples of qubit channels with tunable parameters, we identify the full set of input states where the direct-cause joint expectation values of Pauli observables coincide with those obtained from a common cause, a situation that we call causal confusion. More generally, for arbitrary finite-dimensional quantum systems and light-touch observables, we prove that a channel exhibits causal confusion for some input state if and only if it is a positive-partial-transpose (PPT) channel, thereby endowing PPT channels with a new operational meaning in terms of causal confusion. Using this result, we characterize the set of qubit channels for which there exists an input state leading to causal confusion as the set of entanglement-breaking channels.
The paper asks when two-time quantum correlations from sequential measurements on an input state ρ\rhoρ, with an intervening channel E\mathcal EE, can also arise from local measurements on a shared bipartite state. It calls equality of the joint expectation-value tables “causal confusion.” The temporal protocol uses Lüders measurements; the general results concern light-touch observables satisfying A2=λIA^2=\lambda IA2=λI, including Pauli observables.
Using the established Jordan-product state-over-time representation, compatibility becomes positivity of E⋆ρ=12{ρ⊗I,J(E)}\mathcal E\star\rho=\tfrac12\{\rho\otimes I,J(\mathcal E)\}E⋆ρ=21​{ρ⊗I,J(E)}, where JJJ is the partially transposed Choi matrix. The central necessity result shows that positivity for a full-rank input implies that E\mathcal EE is PPT, by inverting the anticommutator through a positivity-preserving integral solving a Sylvester equation. Conversely, every PPT channel gives compatibility for the maximally mixed input. The paper states an unrestricted existence-if-and-only-if-PPT corollary, although its necessity proof assumes full rank. For qubit channels, PPT is equivalent to entanglement breaking.
Explicit calculations characterize compatible inputs for several channel families. For qubit depolarization E(ρ)=(1−λ)ρ+λI/2\mathcal E(\rho)=(1-\lambda)\rho+\lambda I/2E(ρ)=(1−λ)ρ+λI/2, compatibility holds exactly when 2/3≤λ≤4/32/3\le\lambda\le4/32/3≤λ≤4/3 and the Bloch radius obeys ∥r∥≤(2−λ)(3λ−2)/λ\|\mathbf r\|\le\sqrt{(2-\lambda)(3\lambda-2)}/\lambda∥r∥≤(2−λ)(3λ−2)​/λ. Examples show that entanglement-breaking channels need not give compatibility for every input, and compatible bipartite states can be entangled. Additional results concern Bayesian inverses.
The scope excludes general instruments and broader causal structures. General input-state criteria, quantitative distinguishability measures, and practical protocols exploiting the distinction remain open.
Identifying the causal structures between two statistically correlated events has been widely investigated in many fields of science. While some of the well-studied classical methods are carefully generalized to quantum version of causal inference for certain cases, an effective and efficient way to detect the more general quantum causal structures is still lacking. Here, we introduce a quantity named `Causal Determinant' to efficiently identify the quantum causal structures between two quantum systems and experimentally verify the validity of the method. According to the causal determinant, the quantum direct cause imposed by an arbitrary unitary operator can be perfectly discriminated with the quantum common cause, in which the two quantum systems share a joint quantum state. In addition, the causal determinant has the capability to discriminate between more general causal structures and predict the range of their parameters. The ability to detect more general quantum causal structures of our method can shed new light on the field of quantum causal inference.
The statistics of local measurements of joint quantum systems can sometimes be used to distinguish the spatiotemporal structure in which they were measured. We first prove that every bipartite separable density matrix is temporally compatible with direct causal influence for arbitrary finite-dimensional quantum systems and measurements of a tomographically complete class of observables, which includes all Pauli observables in the case of multi-qubit systems. Equivalently, if a bipartite density matrix is not temporally compatible with direct causal influence, then it must be entangled. We also provide an operational meaning for the two temporal evolutions consistent with such correlations in terms of generalized dephasing channels and pretty good measurements. The two temporal evolutions are Bayesian inverses of each other, which is different from them being Petz recovery maps of each other. Finally, we prove necessary and sufficient conditions for an arbitrary bipartite quantum state to be temporally compatible, thereby providing a temporal analogue of the positive partial transpose criterion valid for quantum systems of any dimension.
There is a rich class of bipartite quantum correlations between qubits which are consistent both with measurements performed in parallel and measurements performed in sequence. This phenomenon has recently been termed \emph{quantum causal confusion}, which is made mathematically precise by the notion of a dual state---a bipartite density operator whose associated correlations are causally ambiguous. A natural question is then whether or not the spatial and temporal scenarios associated with a dual state are fundamentally indistinguishable from a causal perspective. Here we show that as long as the reduced density operator of a dual state is oblique---meaning that all coefficients in its Pauli expansion are non-zero---then the underlying joint probabilities giving rise to such causally ambiguous correlations will differ in the spatial and temporal scenarios. Specifically, the temporal joint probabilities will inherently violate the no-signalling condition, thus eliminating quantum causal confusion. Moreover, as oblique states form an open dense subset of the Bloch ball, the elimination of quantum causal confusion is the norm rather than an exception.
We study quantum causal inference in a setup proposed by Ried et al (2015 Nat. Phys. 11 414) in which a common cause scenario can be mixed with a cause–effect scenario, and for which it was found that quantum mechanics can bring an advantage in distinguishing the two scenarios: whereas in classical statistics, interventions such as randomized trials are needed, a quantum observational scheme can be enough to detect the causal structure if the common cause results from a maximally entangled state. We analyze this setup in terms of the geometry of unital positive but not completely positive qubit-maps, arising from the mixture of qubit channels and steering maps. We find the range of mixing parameters that can generate given correlations, and prove a quantum advantage in a more general setup, allowing arbitrary unital channels and initial states with fully mixed reduced states. This is achieved by establishing new bounds on signed singular values of sums of matrices. Based on the geometry, we quantify and identify the origin of the quantum advantage depending on the observed correlations, and discuss how additional constraints can lead to a unique solution of the problem.
This thesis details two experimental tests that can be applied to particular quantum states to reveal important information. We begin by discussing the relevant background in quantum information. We introduce qubits and qudits as basic quantum states, and we discuss the evolution and measurement of quantum states. We then discuss quantum state tomography as a means by which to obtain complete information about a state, followed by a discussion of state discrimination as a means by which to determine the state given the promise that it is drawn from some known set. We then discuss relevant experimental techniques in quantum optics, including measurement, generation of entanglement, and generation of single photons from entanglement. \n \nThe first experiment we discuss deals with the causal structure of a system, which is the description of the origin of correlations between two or more states. The causal structure can be direct-cause, meaning that one state causes the other; common-cause, meaning that both states are caused by another; or hybrid-cause, which is a combination of the two. We perform the first implementation of a new type of tomography to determine the causal structure; this is called causal tomography and functions regardless of whether two qubits are related by a common state, a process, or some combination thereof. We implement a process on two entangled photons so that we can select the exact causal structure that results, which ranges continuously between direct-cause and common-cause structures. Using causal tomography, we recover causal structures that closely match expected results and demonstrate that quantum mechanics provides an advantage in causal inference. \n \nThe second experiment we discuss deals with the unambiguous discrimination of multiple quantum states. For the first time, we apply the principles of unambiguous state discrimination to high-dimensional systems. Given a state chosen randomly out of d possible states encoded in d dimensions, we implement a procedure for determining which state was chosen; this procedure in theory functions without error. We encode and detect the states in the orbital angular momentum degree of freedom up to dimension d=14. Although no experiment can provide perfectly error-free measurement due to inevitable imperfections, we obtain an error rate below the theoretical error rate of minimum-error state discrimination for dimensions up to d=12. At the time of submission of this thesis, this work has been accepted for publication in Physical Review Letters.
Quantum causality is an emerging field of study which has the potential to greatly advance our understanding of quantum systems. In this paper, we put forth a theoretical framework for merging quantum information science and causal inference by exploiting entropic principles. For this purpose, we leverage the tradeoff between the entropy of hidden cause and the conditional mutual information of observed variables to develop a scalable algorithmic approach for inferring causality in the presence of latent confounders (common causes) in quantum systems. As an application, we consider a system of three entangled qubits and transmit the second and third qubits over separate noisy quantum channels. In this model, we validate that the first qubit is a latent confounder and the common cause of the second and third qubits. In contrast, when two entangled qubits are prepared and one of them is sent over a noisy channel, there is no common confounder. We also demonstrate that the proposed approach outperforms the results of classical causal inference for the Tubingen database when the variables are classical by exploiting quantum dependence between variables through density matrices rather than joint probability distributions. Thus, the proposed approach unifies classical and quantum causal inference in a principled way.