arXiv:2610.09322
Cross-Validation of Open-Source Quantum Network Simulators
Joaquin Chung, Michal Hajdušek, Naphan Benchasattabuse, Robert J. Hayek, Alexander Kolar, Ansh Singal, Kento Samuel Soon, Kentaro Teramoto, Allen Zang, Caitao Zhan, Raj Kettimuthu, Rodney Van Meter
Abstract
We present a comparative analysis of two open-source quantum network simulators, QuISP and SeQUeNCe, focusing on cross-validation of basic networking tasks to ensure consistency and accuracy in simulation outputs. Although both simulators are designed to study quantum network management policies and their dynamics under complex noise models, their differing underlying assumptions can lead to variations in simulation results. We highlight the discrepancies in how the two simulators handle connections, internal network node processing time, and classical communication, resulting in significant quantitative and qualitative differences in the time required to perform basic network tasks such as entanglement generation, purification, and swapping. We simulate common scenarios between the simulators to compare both the latency of resource distribution and the fidelity of the distributed resources. Our findings indicate that while the simulators differ in the time required to complete network tasks---a constant factor difference attributable to their respective connection models---they agree on the fidelity of the distributed resources under identical error parameters. This work demonstrates a crucial first step towards enhancing the reliability and reproducibility of quantum network simulations, as well as leading to full protocol development. Furthermore, our benchmarking methodology establishes a foundational set of tasks for the cross-validation of simulators to study future quantum networks.
AI Summary
Quantum-network simulators can produce different predictions for nominally similar configurations because their control protocols, timing assumptions, and noise conventions differ. This paper cross-validates the open-source simulators QuISP and SeQUeNCe, separating implementation consistency from differences in the networks they model. Four analytically tractable benchmarks test symmetric and asymmetric meet-in-the-middle entanglement generation, two-link entanglement swapping, and one round of BBPSSW purification without twirling. Generation tests request 1,000 Bell pairs over a 20 km link with 1–16 memories per node; swapping and purification use 40 km end-to-end separations. Closed-form timing and fidelity models, including stochastic waiting times for purification, are compared against simulation outputs. Gate-error and coherence-time conventions are explicitly translated between simulators. For symmetric generation, SeQUeNCe predicts completion times 4.16–4.33 times longer than QuISP, primarily because it repeats a three-way handshake for each generation attempt whereas QuISP amortizes connection setup. Moving the Bell-state analyzer away from the midpoint increases QuISP’s predicted generation time but leaves SeQUeNCe’s unchanged. Fidelity predictions agree for purification with perfect memories and generally agree for swapping with long-lived memories. Finite coherence times expose discrepancies associated with different waiting times and protocol schedules; QuISP generally predicts higher purification fidelity and throughput. Both simulators match their respective analytical models, and the comparison led to bug fixes. The study is limited to basic first-generation repeater scenarios. Larger networks, competing requests, other link architectures and repeater generations, and a fuller analysis of interacting communication and error-model differences remain future work.
Central claim may not hold: The abstract claims fidelity agreement under identical error parameters, whereas the results report finite-coherence-time fidelity differences in both swapping and purification, making agreement conditional rather than general. The reported symmetric-link completion-time ratio of 4.16–4.33 contradicts the stated timing equations, which predict a SeQUeNCe/QuISP ratio strictly below 4 for the specified parameters. The analytical purification output-fidelity expression omits decoherence during post-circuit result communication, despite the appendix defining the final resource as the state after that communication.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 18 pages, 9 figures, journal, 1 appendix