arXiv:2610.08749
No-Disturbance-without-Uncertainty generates the Quantum set in the simplest Bell scenario
Ravishankar Ramanathan
Abstract
Characterizing the set of quantum nonlocal correlations through information-theoretic constraints is a central problem in quantum foundations. We show that the convex hull of no-signalling behaviors in a bipartite Bell experiment satisfying a common-overlap no-disturbance-without-uncertainty condition is exactly the finite-dimensional quantum set whenever one party has two binary measurements and the other has an arbitrary finite number of settings, each with an arbitrary finite number of outcomes. In the simplest binary input-output Bell scenario, this characterizes the full eight-dimensional set of quantum behaviors, including the local marginals. The proof constructs a quantum realization directly from the conditional probabilities and no-signalling. The characterization also reduces optimization of any linear Bell expression in these scenarios to maximization over a one-parameter family of second-order cone programs. The results establish a connection between local uncertainty-disturbance constraints and quantum nonlocality, mediated by no-signalling and shared classical randomness.
AI Summary
The paper asks whether a local uncertainty–disturbance constraint, combined with no-signalling and shared classical randomness, characterizes quantum Bell correlations including nonzero marginals. It studies a common-overlap version of no-disturbance-without-uncertainty (NDWU): the conditional averages $(v_0,v_1)$ of two binary measurements must satisfy $v_0^2+v_1^2+c^2-2cv_0v_1\leq1$, with one preparation-independent parameter $c\in[-1,1]$ shared across all remotely prepared conditional states. In the $(2,2;2,2)$ scenario, the convex hull of no-signalling behaviors satisfying this criterion on either party alone, or on both parties, equals the full eight-dimensional finite-dimensional quantum set. The result extends whenever one party has two binary measurements and the other has arbitrarily many finite settings and outcomes. Every quantum behavior in the simplest scenario is also shown to be a mixture of at most eight pure-two-qubit, projective-measurement behaviors. The constructive sufficiency proof maps conditional probabilities to positive qubit operators; no-signalling makes their sum preparation-independent, allowing a quantum realization through purification and suitable POVMs. The reverse inclusion uses projective dilation and Jordan’s lemma. Optimizing any linear Bell functional reduces to a scalar maximization over a one-parameter family of second-order cone programs. Convexification is essential: the unconvexified criterion excludes some local behaviors and is not preserved by shared randomization. Its operational motivation assumes repeatable measurements with outcome-dependent, preparation-independent post-measurement states. When both parties have more outcomes, binary coarse-graining yields only necessary outer constraints; an intrinsic extension remains open.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 6+11 pages