arXiv:2610.08710
Entanglement Sudden Death: Eberly's Work and the Limits of Local Dynamics
Abhaya S. Hegde, Songbo Xie
Abstract
Entanglement sudden death (ESD), explored through a series of works by Yu and Eberly, supports the notion of entanglement vanishing abruptly and completely at a finite time, even when the underlying open-system dynamics remain smooth. In this article, we revisit the development of ESD from bipartite origins to genuine multipartite entanglement. We first illustrate the canonical mechanism of ESD with two independently damped qubits, for which the concurrence vanishes at a finite time while populations and coherences remain nonzero. We next present our results on multipartite entanglement for generalized GHZ states under depolarization. Global and independent local depolarizing dynamics can be chosen to produce identical reduced evolution for every individual qubit, yet they yield different genuine-multipartite-entanglement sudden death times, whose ordering can reverse with the initial state. For N-qubit GHZ states, this distinction becomes asymptotically stronger since the ESD time scales as 1/N under independent local depolarization, whereas under global depolarization it approaches a finite value in the thermodynamic limit. Echoing a central lesson of Prof. Eberly's work, we report the lifetime of multipartite entanglement is not fixed by the local dynamics, but rather depends on the evolution of the joint quantum state.
AI Summary
This memorial/review article revisits entanglement sudden death (ESD) and compares genuine multipartite entanglement lifetimes under noise processes with identical single-qubit reduced dynamics. It reviews ESD’s development and illustrates the standard two-qubit amplitude-damping mechanism: for $(|00\rangle+2|11\rangle)/\sqrt5$, concurrence vanishes at $t_*=\ln2/\gamma$ although populations and joint coherence remain nonzero. The new analysis considers generalized GHZ states $\cos\theta|0\rangle^{\otimes N}+\sin\theta|1\rangle^{\otimes N}$ under global white-noise mixing and independent single-qubit depolarization, both with $p=e^{-\gamma t}$. Exact concurrence formulas for $X$ states give the genuine-entanglement thresholds. For three qubits, global depolarization yields $\gamma t_*^{\rm glob}=\ln[1+4\sin(2\theta)/3]$. For the maximally entangled GHZ state, the global and independent-local lifetimes are approximately $0.847/\gamma$ and $0.335/\gamma$, respectively. Their ordering reverses for sufficiently weak initial entanglement, with small-angle scalings $\gamma t_*^{\rm glob}\sim4\sin(2\theta)/3$ and $\gamma t_*^{\rm loc}\sim[\sqrt2\sin(2\theta)/3]^{2/3}$. For maximally entangled $N$-qubit GHZ states, the global lifetime approaches $\ln2/\gamma$, whereas the local lifetime scales as $2\ln\varphi/(\gamma N)$, where $\varphi=(1+\sqrt5)/2$. These follow from explicit concurrence thresholds and a large-$N$ expansion. Thus identical one-qubit dynamics need not determine multipartite entanglement lifetimes or their size scaling. The calculations concern GHZ-family states and specified depolarizing channels; arbitrary-angle local thresholds generally remain implicit. The paper distinguishes loss of genuine multipartite entanglement from loss of all entanglement, and notes that vanishing bipartition negativity alone does not establish separability.
Error found: The exact three-qubit lifetime crossover occurs at sin(2θ) ≈ 0.0783, rather than the stated 3/32, although the qualitative reversal remains valid. Section IV.A incorrectly leaves biseparability unresolved after negativity vanishes, despite having already established it through the earlier vanishing of the exact genuine multipartite concurrence. The final paragraph of Section IV incorrectly writes the global limiting lifetime as ln(2/γ) instead of (ln 2)/γ.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- Submitted to Focus Collection Celebrating the Life and Science of Joseph H. Eberly. 10 pages, 2 figures