Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2610.08397

Relative-Entropy Flow Across the Page Transition

Minghui Yu, Xian-Hui Ge

hep-thgr-qcquant-phSubmitted Oct 6, 2026• Announced Oct 7, 2026
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We develop a computational framework for the quantum relative entropy based on the replica trick and apply it to analyze the evaporation process method of Jackiw-Teitelboim black holes. We show that the relative entropies between the exact radiation state and the Hawking saddle state and the replica wormholes saddle state quantify information-theoretic costs inherent to coarse-grained semiclassical descriptions. During evaporation, the relative entropy for the Hawking saddle increases monotonically, reflecting a progressively higher thermodynamic cost of sustaining the Hawking description. Conversely, the relative entropy associated with the replica wormholes saddle decreases, which indicates that the description of connected geometries becomes progressively more accurate. Moreover, the sign of the difference between the two quantities reverses precisely at the Page time, providing an information-theoretic diagnosis for the transition between competing gravitational saddles. Our results recast the Page transition as a flow of relative entropy costs between competing semi-classical descriptions, revealing an information-theoretic structure underlying the emergence of effective irreversibility in coarse-grained black hole evaporation.

AI Summary

The paper asks whether relative entropy can characterize the Page transition as a change in the accuracy of competing semiclassical descriptions of black-hole radiation. It studies the PSSY model—Jackiw–Teitelboim gravity with an end-of-the-world brane carrying $k$ flavors—and introduces Hawking-saddle and replica-wormhole reference states for the same radiation state $\rho$. A generalized replica construction evaluates mixed moments $\operatorname{Tr}(\rho^n\sigma^m)$, followed by analytic continuation to Petz–Rényi and quantum relative entropies. The reported expressions are $D(\rho\Vert\sigma_{\mathrm{Haw}})=\log k-S(\rho)$ and $D(\rho\Vert\sigma_{\mathrm{WH}})=S_{\mathrm{BH}}-S(\rho)$. Their difference is therefore $\log k-S_{\mathrm{BH}}$, changing sign at the saddle-crossing Page point. In the microcanonical ensemble, with $t=k/e^{S_0}$, the Hawking quantity equals $t/2$ before $t=1$ and $\log t+1/(2t)$ afterward; the wormhole quantity equals $-\log t+t/2$ before the transition and $1/(2t)$ afterward. Canonical-ensemble behavior is evaluated using an approximate radiation spectrum, numerical integration, and early- and late-stage expansions. The interpretation is that the Hawking description becomes increasingly costly while the wormhole description becomes more accurate, without loss of microscopic unitarity. The construction assumes normalized saddle reference states and support inclusion ensuring finite relative entropy, and uses large-$k$ planar and semiclassical approximations. The paper explicitly distinguishes this state-level mismatch from Crooks trajectory entropy production: no microscopic forward–reverse gravitational protocol is constructed, and data processing alone does not establish the reported temporal monotonicity.

Likely largely AI-generatedPossible errorStrong assumptionsOverclaimsUnclear novelty

Central claim may not hold: Appendix B uses an inconsistent mixed-moment factorization and an incorrect matrix-power expansion to derive the wormhole relative entropy, leaving the opposite relative-entropy flows and their crossing unestablished. The saddle-resolved reference density operators are not explicitly constructed, and their positivity, normalization, support, and requisite mixed moments are not established by the listed saddle contributions. The abstract's thermodynamic-cost interpretation exceeds the state-level analogy established in the body, which provides no operational thermodynamic-cost formula. Appendix D's black-hole entropy approximation evaluates to approximately 5.10743 at the stated canonical parameters, rather than the reported 20.285.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
11 pages, many figures

Related papers

The black hole information puzzle and the quantum de Finetti theorem

Renato Renner, Jinzhao Wang

The black hole information puzzle arises from a discrepancy between conclusions drawn from general relativity and quantum theory about the nature of the radiation emitted by a black hole. According to Hawking's original argument, the radiation is thermal and its entropy thus increases monotonically as the black hole evaporates. Conversely, due to the reversibility of time evolution according to quantum theory, the radiation entropy should start to decrease after a certain time, as predicted by the Page curve. This decrease has been confirmed by new calculations based on the replica trick, which also exhibit its geometrical origin: spacetime wormholes that form between the replicas. Here we analyse the discrepancy between these and Hawking's original conclusions from a quantum information theory viewpoint, using in particular the quantum de Finetti theorem. The theorem implies the existence of extra information, $W$, which is neither part of the black hole nor the radiation, but plays the role of a reference. The entropy obtained via the replica trick can then be identified to be the entropy $S(R|W)$ of the radiation conditioned on the reference $W$, whereas Hawking's original result corresponds to the non-conditional entropy $S(R)$. The entropy $S(R|W)$, which mathematically is an ensemble average, gains an operational meaning in an experiment with $N$ independently prepared black holes: For large $N$, it equals the normalised entropy of their joint radiation, $S(R_1 \cdots R_N)/N$. The discrepancy between this entropy and $S(R)$ implies that the black holes are correlated. The replica wormholes may thus be interpreted as the geometrical representation of this correlation. Our results also suggest a many-black-hole extension of the widely used random unitary model, which we support with non-trivial checks.

arXiv:2110.14653•Oct 27, 2021•25 citations

Replica wormholes and the black hole interior

Geoff Penington, Stephen H. Shenker, Douglas Stanford +1 more

A bstract Recent work has shown how to obtain the Page curve of an evaporating black hole from holographic computations of entanglement entropy. We show how these computations can be justified using the replica trick, from geometries with a spacetime wormhole connecting the different replicas. In a simple model, we study the Page transition in detail by summing replica geometries with different topologies. We compute related quantities in less detail in more complicated models, including JT gravity coupled to conformal matter and the SYK model. Separately, we give a direct gravitational argument for entanglement wedge reconstruction using an explicit formula known as the Petz map; again, a spacetime wormhole plays an important role. We discuss an interpretation of the wormhole geometries as part of some ensemble average implicit in the gravity description.

arXiv:1911.11977•Journal of High Energy Physics•Mar 1, 2022•1,135 citations

An algebraic description of the Page transition

Haocheng Zhong

A bstract In this work, we develop an algebraic description of the Page transition, a key feature in black hole evaporation where the entropy of Hawking radiation follows a unitary Page curve instead of monotonically increasing. By applying concepts from approximate quantum error correction with complementary recovery, we characterize the Page transition as a phase transition in channel recovery. We then generalize the description to infinite-dimensional settings using algebraic relative entropy, which remains valid even in type III factors. For type I/II factors, explicit probes based on relative entropy differences are derived, serving as indicators for the transition at the Page time.

arXiv:2601.11363•Journal of High Energy Physics•Apr 20, 2026•0 citations

Large and small corrections to the JLMS Formula from replica wormholes

Jonah Kudler-Flam, Pratik Rath

Abstract The JLMS formula relates the bulk and boundary relative entropies and is fundamental to the holographic dictionary, providing justification for entanglement wedge reconstruction. We revisit the replica trick for relative entropy and find corrections to the JLMS formula in a variety of scenarios, even after accounting for effects of quantum extremality. We analyze the problem in the PSSY model, a model of Jackiw-Teitelboim gravity coupled to end-of-the-world branes. We find non-perturbative (in G) corrections that are always present, arising from subdominant replica wormhole gravitational saddles that indicate the approximate error-correcting nature of AdS/CFT. Near entanglement phase transitions, these saddles can get enhanced to large corrections. We find O (G−1/2) corrections arising from area fluctuations and O (G−1) corrections from incompressible bulk quantum states. Lastly, we find our most surprising result, an infinite violation of the JLMS formula after the Page time arising from a rank deficiency in the bulk entanglement spectrum. We discuss similar calculations in tensor networks and comment on the implications for bulk reconstruction.

arXiv:2203.11954•Journal of High Energy Physics•Aug 19, 2022•6 citations

Information Recovery from Non-Factorized States

Iker Ibarrola Echeverría

We present a minimal, fully unitary toy model of black hole evaporation in which information recovery emerges from non-factorized global states and observer-dependent access. The model reproduces a Page-like entropy curve for Hawking radiation without invoking fundamental information loss, horizon microstructure, or spacetime geometry at the microscopic level. The result supports the interpretation that the black hole information paradox arises from regime-dependent coarse-graining rather than from a breakdown of quantum unitarity.

•Jan 30, 2026•0 citations

On quantum information before the Page time

Jonah Kudler-Flam, Yuya Kusuki

Abstract While recent progress in the black hole information problem has shown that the entropy of Hawking radiation follows a unitary Page curve, the quantum state of Hawking radiation prior the Page time is still treated as purely thermal, containing no information about the microstructure of the black hole. We demonstrate that there is significant quantum information regarding the quantum state of the black hole in the Hawking radiation prior to the Page time. By computing of the quantum fidelity in a 2D boundary conformal field theory (BCFT) model of black hole evaporation, we demonstrate that an observer outside of an evaporating black hole may distinguish different black holes via measurements of the Hawking radiation at any time during the evaporation process, albeit with an exponentially large number of measurements. Furthermore, our results are universal, applicable to general BCFTs including those with large central charge and rational BCFTs. The techniques we develop for computing the fidelity are more generally applicable to excited states in CFT. As such, we are able to characterize more general aspects of thermalization in 2D conformal field theory.

arXiv:2212.06839•Journal of High Energy Physics•May 9, 2023•5 citations
We develop a computational framework for the quantum relative entropy based on the replica trick and apply it to analyze the evaporation process method of Jackiw-Teitelboim black holes. We show that the relative entropies between the exact radiation state and the Hawking saddle state and the replica wormholes saddle state quantify information-theoretic costs inherent to coarse-grained semiclassical descriptions. During evaporation, the relative entropy for the Hawking saddle increases monotonically, reflecting a progressively higher thermodynamic cost of sustaining the Hawking description. Conversely, the relative entropy associated with the replica wormholes saddle decreases, which indicates that the description of connected geometries becomes progressively more accurate. Moreover, the sign of the difference between the two quantities reverses precisely at the Page time, providing an information-theoretic diagnosis for the transition between competing gravitational saddles. Our results recast the Page transition as a flow of relative entropy costs between competing semi-classical descriptions, revealing an information-theoretic structure underlying the emergence of effective irreversibility in coarse-grained black hole evaporation.
The paper asks whether relative entropy can characterize the Page transition as a change in the accuracy of competing semiclassical descriptions of black-hole radiation. It studies the PSSY model—Jackiw–Teitelboim gravity with an end-of-the-world brane carrying kkk flavors—and introduces Hawking-saddle and replica-wormhole reference states for the same radiation state ρ\rhoρ.
A generalized replica construction evaluates mixed moments Tr⁡(ρnσm)\operatorname{Tr}(\rho^n\sigma^m)Tr(ρnσm), followed by analytic continuation to Petz–Rényi and quantum relative entropies. The reported expressions are D(ρ∥σHaw)=log⁡k−S(ρ)D(\rho\Vert\sigma_{\mathrm{Haw}})=\log k-S(\rho)D(ρ∥σHaw​)=logk−S(ρ) and D(ρ∥σWH)=SBH−S(ρ)D(\rho\Vert\sigma_{\mathrm{WH}})=S_{\mathrm{BH}}-S(\rho)D(ρ∥σWH​)=SBH​−S(ρ). Their difference is therefore log⁡k−SBH\log k-S_{\mathrm{BH}}logk−SBH​, changing sign at the saddle-crossing Page point. In the microcanonical ensemble, with t=k/eS0t=k/e^{S_0}t=k/eS0​, the Hawking quantity equals t/2t/2t/2 before t=1t=1t=1 and log⁡t+1/(2t)\log t+1/(2t)logt+1/(2t) afterward; the wormhole quantity equals −log⁡t+t/2-\log t+t/2−logt+t/2 before the transition and 1/(2t)1/(2t)1/(2t) afterward. Canonical-ensemble behavior is evaluated using an approximate radiation spectrum, numerical integration, and early- and late-stage expansions.
The interpretation is that the Hawking description becomes increasingly costly while the wormhole description becomes more accurate, without loss of microscopic unitarity. The construction assumes normalized saddle reference states and support inclusion ensuring finite relative entropy, and uses large-kkk planar and semiclassical approximations. The paper explicitly distinguishes this state-level mismatch from Crooks trajectory entropy production: no microscopic forward–reverse gravitational protocol is constructed, and data processing alone does not establish the reported temporal monotonicity.
The black hole information puzzle arises from a discrepancy between conclusions drawn from general relativity and quantum theory about the nature of the radiation emitted by a black hole. According to Hawking's original argument, the radiation is thermal and its entropy thus increases monotonically as the black hole evaporates. Conversely, due to the reversibility of time evolution according to quantum theory, the radiation entropy should start to decrease after a certain time, as predicted by the Page curve. This decrease has been confirmed by new calculations based on the replica trick, which also exhibit its geometrical origin: spacetime wormholes that form between the replicas. Here we analyse the discrepancy between these and Hawking's original conclusions from a quantum information theory viewpoint, using in particular the quantum de Finetti theorem. The theorem implies the existence of extra information, WWW, which is neither part of the black hole nor the radiation, but plays the role of a reference. The entropy obtained via the replica trick can then be identified to be the entropy S(R∣W)S(R|W)S(R∣W) of the radiation conditioned on the reference WWW, whereas Hawking's original result corresponds to the non-conditional entropy S(R)S(R)S(R). The entropy S(R∣W)S(R|W)S(R∣W), which mathematically is an ensemble average, gains an operational meaning in an experiment with NNN independently prepared black holes: For large NNN, it equals the normalised entropy of their joint radiation, S(R1⋯RN)/NS(R_1 \cdots R_N)/NS(R1​⋯RN​)/N. The discrepancy between this entropy and S(R)S(R)S(R) implies that the black holes are correlated. The replica wormholes may thus be interpreted as the geometrical representation of this correlation. Our results also suggest a many-black-hole extension of the widely used random unitary model, which we support with non-trivial checks.
A bstract Recent work has shown how to obtain the Page curve of an evaporating black hole from holographic computations of entanglement entropy. We show how these computations can be justified using the replica trick, from geometries with a spacetime wormhole connecting the different replicas. In a simple model, we study the Page transition in detail by summing replica geometries with different topologies. We compute related quantities in less detail in more complicated models, including JT gravity coupled to conformal matter and the SYK model. Separately, we give a direct gravitational argument for entanglement wedge reconstruction using an explicit formula known as the Petz map; again, a spacetime wormhole plays an important role. We discuss an interpretation of the wormhole geometries as part of some ensemble average implicit in the gravity description.
A bstract In this work, we develop an algebraic description of the Page transition, a key feature in black hole evaporation where the entropy of Hawking radiation follows a unitary Page curve instead of monotonically increasing. By applying concepts from approximate quantum error correction with complementary recovery, we characterize the Page transition as a phase transition in channel recovery. We then generalize the description to infinite-dimensional settings using algebraic relative entropy, which remains valid even in type III factors. For type I/II factors, explicit probes based on relative entropy differences are derived, serving as indicators for the transition at the Page time.
Abstract The JLMS formula relates the bulk and boundary relative entropies and is fundamental to the holographic dictionary, providing justification for entanglement wedge reconstruction. We revisit the replica trick for relative entropy and find corrections to the JLMS formula in a variety of scenarios, even after accounting for effects of quantum extremality. We analyze the problem in the PSSY model, a model of Jackiw-Teitelboim gravity coupled to end-of-the-world branes. We find non-perturbative (in G) corrections that are always present, arising from subdominant replica wormhole gravitational saddles that indicate the approximate error-correcting nature of AdS/CFT. Near entanglement phase transitions, these saddles can get enhanced to large corrections. We find O (G−1/2) corrections arising from area fluctuations and O (G−1) corrections from incompressible bulk quantum states. Lastly, we find our most surprising result, an infinite violation of the JLMS formula after the Page time arising from a rank deficiency in the bulk entanglement spectrum. We discuss similar calculations in tensor networks and comment on the implications for bulk reconstruction.
We present a minimal, fully unitary toy model of black hole evaporation in which information recovery emerges from non-factorized global states and observer-dependent access. The model reproduces a Page-like entropy curve for Hawking radiation without invoking fundamental information loss, horizon microstructure, or spacetime geometry at the microscopic level. The result supports the interpretation that the black hole information paradox arises from regime-dependent coarse-graining rather than from a breakdown of quantum unitarity.
Abstract While recent progress in the black hole information problem has shown that the entropy of Hawking radiation follows a unitary Page curve, the quantum state of Hawking radiation prior the Page time is still treated as purely thermal, containing no information about the microstructure of the black hole. We demonstrate that there is significant quantum information regarding the quantum state of the black hole in the Hawking radiation prior to the Page time. By computing of the quantum fidelity in a 2D boundary conformal field theory (BCFT) model of black hole evaporation, we demonstrate that an observer outside of an evaporating black hole may distinguish different black holes via measurements of the Hawking radiation at any time during the evaporation process, albeit with an exponentially large number of measurements. Furthermore, our results are universal, applicable to general BCFTs including those with large central charge and rational BCFTs. The techniques we develop for computing the fidelity are more generally applicable to excited states in CFT. As such, we are able to characterize more general aspects of thermalization in 2D conformal field theory.