arXiv:2610.08397
Relative-Entropy Flow Across the Page Transition
Minghui Yu, Xian-Hui Ge
Abstract
We develop a computational framework for the quantum relative entropy based on the replica trick and apply it to analyze the evaporation process method of Jackiw-Teitelboim black holes. We show that the relative entropies between the exact radiation state and the Hawking saddle state and the replica wormholes saddle state quantify information-theoretic costs inherent to coarse-grained semiclassical descriptions. During evaporation, the relative entropy for the Hawking saddle increases monotonically, reflecting a progressively higher thermodynamic cost of sustaining the Hawking description. Conversely, the relative entropy associated with the replica wormholes saddle decreases, which indicates that the description of connected geometries becomes progressively more accurate. Moreover, the sign of the difference between the two quantities reverses precisely at the Page time, providing an information-theoretic diagnosis for the transition between competing gravitational saddles. Our results recast the Page transition as a flow of relative entropy costs between competing semi-classical descriptions, revealing an information-theoretic structure underlying the emergence of effective irreversibility in coarse-grained black hole evaporation.
AI Summary
The paper asks whether relative entropy can characterize the Page transition as a change in the accuracy of competing semiclassical descriptions of black-hole radiation. It studies the PSSY model—Jackiw–Teitelboim gravity with an end-of-the-world brane carrying $k$ flavors—and introduces Hawking-saddle and replica-wormhole reference states for the same radiation state $\rho$. A generalized replica construction evaluates mixed moments $\operatorname{Tr}(\rho^n\sigma^m)$, followed by analytic continuation to Petz–Rényi and quantum relative entropies. The reported expressions are $D(\rho\Vert\sigma_{\mathrm{Haw}})=\log k-S(\rho)$ and $D(\rho\Vert\sigma_{\mathrm{WH}})=S_{\mathrm{BH}}-S(\rho)$. Their difference is therefore $\log k-S_{\mathrm{BH}}$, changing sign at the saddle-crossing Page point. In the microcanonical ensemble, with $t=k/e^{S_0}$, the Hawking quantity equals $t/2$ before $t=1$ and $\log t+1/(2t)$ afterward; the wormhole quantity equals $-\log t+t/2$ before the transition and $1/(2t)$ afterward. Canonical-ensemble behavior is evaluated using an approximate radiation spectrum, numerical integration, and early- and late-stage expansions. The interpretation is that the Hawking description becomes increasingly costly while the wormhole description becomes more accurate, without loss of microscopic unitarity. The construction assumes normalized saddle reference states and support inclusion ensuring finite relative entropy, and uses large-$k$ planar and semiclassical approximations. The paper explicitly distinguishes this state-level mismatch from Crooks trajectory entropy production: no microscopic forward–reverse gravitational protocol is constructed, and data processing alone does not establish the reported temporal monotonicity.
Central claim may not hold: Appendix B uses an inconsistent mixed-moment factorization and an incorrect matrix-power expansion to derive the wormhole relative entropy, leaving the opposite relative-entropy flows and their crossing unestablished. The saddle-resolved reference density operators are not explicitly constructed, and their positivity, normalization, support, and requisite mixed moments are not established by the listed saddle contributions. The abstract's thermodynamic-cost interpretation exceeds the state-level analogy established in the body, which provides no operational thermodynamic-cost formula. Appendix D's black-hole entropy approximation evaluates to approximately 5.10743 at the stated canonical parameters, rather than the reported 20.285.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 11 pages, many figures