Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2610.08241

Multi-time advantage for certifying quantum coherence

Karol Sajnok, Fabio Costa

quant-phSubmitted Oct 6, 2026• Announced Oct 7, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Non-classical dynamics in open quantum systems can be hidden in temporal correlations that are invisible to standard state- and channel-based tests. We define coherence for multi-time quantum processes and show that access to intermediate times can reveal coherence absent from all corresponding pairwise channels. Incoherent processes are fixed points of dephasing on all input and output spaces, and their coherence is quantified by relative entropy. As a proof of principle, we use an Ising model in which all three pairwise channels are incoherent while the full three-time process remains coherent. We observe this multi-time coherence on a superconducting quantum processor using a coherence witness and full process tomography.

AI Summary

Can intermediate-time interventions reveal coherence when every pairwise dynamical channel is incoherent? This paper defines basis-dependent coherence of a multi-time process operator $W$ by its failure to remain invariant under dephasing of every input and output leg. It quantifies this using $\mathcal C_{\rm rel}(W)=S(\mathcal D(\omega))-S(\omega)$, where $\omega=W/\operatorname{tr}W$, and develops linear coherence witnesses. The framework includes convexity and monotonicity under dephasing-covariant superprocesses. An exactly solvable Ising model couples one system qubit to two persistent environmental qubits. At observation times $0,\tau,2\tau$, with $\tau=\pi/(8g)$, all three pairwise channels are completely dephasing, yet the three-time process has coherence $\tfrac12\ln2$. Resetting the memory between intervals eliminates this coherence. A four-Pauli witness has ideal expectation $-1/2$. The effect requires only classical memory and is related explicitly to spin echo, rather than requiring quantum environmental memory. Appendices give a quantum-memory example and a single-memory construction whose coherence is at least $(N-1)\ln2$ over $N$ intervals. Ancilla-assisted measurements on an IBM superconducting processor yield witness magnitude $0.3486\pm0.0146$ and tomographic process coherence $0.2689$, versus ideal $0.3466$; reconstructed pairwise-channel coherences remain below $0.022$. The experimental channels therefore retain residual coherence rather than exhibiting exact separation. The notion differs from classicality under fixed-basis sequential probes. Pairwise channels in non-Markovian settings depend on the specified earlier closure, and tomographic entropy estimates use eigenvalue clipping without reported uncertainties.

Little sign of AI-generated textAI use disclosedIncrementalUnclear novelty
The Qiskit implementation was developed with assistance from ChatGPT (5.6 Sol) and verified by the authors.

Error found: The claimed monotonicity under dephasing-covariant deterministic superprocesses is false: incoherent input replacement can increase normalized-Choi coherence from (ln 2)/2 to ln 2. The single-environment appendix displays the wrong process matrix for its stated interaction times and later cites it at different times, although its reported coherence values remain correct.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
7+5 pages, 4+3 figures, 1 table

Related papers

Observation of Genuine Multi-Time Quantum Memory

Konstantin Beyer, Valentin Link, Surihan Sean Borjigin +5 more

Memory effects in open quantum systems do not by themselves imply quantum memory, since non-Markovian dynamics can often be reproduced by classical-memory models. Known criteria certify the presence of quantum memory in the environment by comparing the evolution of the system at two different times. We show that quantum memory can remain hidden from all such pairwise tests and become detectable only when three or more times are considered jointly. We derive an analytical three-time witness and use it to certify quantum memory in a minimal qubit example in which every pair of times has a classical-memory explanation, thus establishing a strict hierarchy of quantum memory effects. Genuine multi-time quantum memory does not rely on fine-tuned time-dependent Hamiltonians or gate-based evolution. We experimentally demonstrate the hierarchy of quantum memory in a time-continuous realization on a superconducting-qubit platform with time-independent couplings.

arXiv:2611.17268•Nov 12, 2026•0 citations

Coherence-generating power of quantum dephasing processes

Georgios Styliaris, Lorenzo Campos Venuti, Paolo Zanardi

We provide a quantification of the capability of various quantum dephasing processes to generate coherence out of incoherent states. The measures defined, admitting computable expressions for any finite Hilbert-space dimension, are based on probabilistic averages and arise naturally from the viewpoint of coherence as a resource. We investigate how the capability of a dephasing process (e.g., a nonselective orthogonal measurement) to generate coherence depends on the relevant bases of the Hilbert space over which coherence is quantified and the dephasing process occurs, respectively. We extend our analysis to include those Lindblad time evolutions which, in the infinite-time limit, dephase the system under consideration and calculate their coherence-generating power as a function of time. We further identify specific families of such time evolutions that, although dephasing, have optimal (over all quantum processes) coherence-generating power for some intermediate time. Finally, we investigate the coherence-generating capability of random dephasing channels.

arXiv:1711.02291•Physical Review A•Mar 7, 2018•29 citations

What can unitary sequences tell us about multi-time physics?

Gregory A. L. White, Felix A. Pollock, Lloyd C. L. Hollenberg +2 more

Multi-time quantum processes are endowed with the same richness as multipartite states, including temporal entanglement and exotic causal structures. However, experimentally probing these rich phenomena leans heavily on fast and clean mid-circuit measurements, which are rarely available. We show here how surprisingly accessible these phenomena are in nascent quantum processors even when faced with substantially limited control. We work within the limitation where only unitary control is allowed, followed by a terminating measurement. Within this setting, we first develop a witness for genuine multi-time entanglement, and then methods to bound (from top and bottom) multi-time entanglement, non-Markovianity, purity, entropy, and other correlative measures. Our tools are designed to be implemented on quantum information processors, which we proceed to demonstrate. Finally, we discuss the limitations of these methods by testing them across random multi-time processes. Conceptually, this broadens our understanding of the extent to which temporal correlations may be determined with only deterministic control. Our techniques are pertinent to generic quantum stochastic dynamical processes, with a scope ranging across condensed matter physics, quantum biology, and in-depth diagnostics of NISQ-era quantum devices.

arXiv:2107.13934•Quantum•Apr 8, 2025•34 citations

Multi-time quantum process tomography on a superconducting qubit

Christina Giarmatzi, Tyler Jones, Alexei Gilchrist +3 more

Current quantum technologies are at the cusp of becoming useful, but still face formidable obstacles such as noise. Noise severely limits the ability to scale quantum devices to the point that they would offer an advantage over classical devices. To understand the sources of noise it is necessary to fully characterise the quantum processes occurring across many time steps; only this would reveal any time-correlated noise called non-Markovian. Previous efforts have attempted such a characterisation but obtained only a limited reconstruction of such multi-time processes. In this work, we fully characterise a multi-time quantum process on superconducting hardware using in-house and cloud-based quantum processors. We achieve this by employing sequential measure-and-prepare operations combined with post-processing. Employing a recently developed formalism for multi-time processes, we detect general multi-time correlated noise. We also detect quantum correlated noise which demonstrates that part of the noise originates from quantum sources, such as physically nearby qubits on the chip.

arXiv:2308.00750•Quantum•Dec 18, 2025•12 citations

Quantifying quantum non-Markovianity based on quantum coherence via skew information

Lian-He Shao, Yu-Ran Zhang, Yu Luo +2 more

Abstract Based on the nonincreasing property of quantum coherence via skew information under incoherent completely positive and trace-preserving maps, we propose a non-Markovianity measure for open quantum processes. As applications, by applying the proposed measure to some typical noisy channels, we find that it is equivalent to the three previous measures of non-Markovianity for phase damping and amplitude damping channels, i.e. the measures based on the quantum trace distance, dynamical divisibility, and quantum mutual information. For the random unitary channel, it is equivalent to the non-Markovianity measure based on l 1 norm of coherence for a class of output states and it is incompletely equivalent to the measure based on dynamical divisibility. We also use the modified Tsallis relative entropy of coherence to detect the non-Markovianity of dynamics of quantum open systems, the results show that the modified Tsallis relative entropy of coherence are more comfortable than the original Tsallis relative entropy of coherence for small .

arXiv:2001.01261•Laser Physics Letters•Dec 20, 2019•2 citations

Nonlocal advantage of quantum coherence in a dephasing channel with memory*

Ming‐Liang Hu, Yuhan Zhang, Heng Fan

We investigate nonlocal advantage of quantum coherence (NAQC) in a correlated dephasing channel modeled by the multimode bosonic reservoir. We obtain analytically the dephasing and memory factors of this channel for the reservoir having a Lorentzian spectral density, and analyze how they affect the NAQC defined by the l 1 norm and relative entropy. It is shown that the memory effects of this channel on NAQC are state-dependent, and they suppress noticeably the rapid decay of NAQC for the family of input Bell-like states with one excitation. For the given transmission time of each qubit, we also obtain the regions of the dephasing and memory factors during which there is NAQC in the output states.

Chinese Physics B•Dec 1, 2020•54 citations
Non-classical dynamics in open quantum systems can be hidden in temporal correlations that are invisible to standard state- and channel-based tests. We define coherence for multi-time quantum processes and show that access to intermediate times can reveal coherence absent from all corresponding pairwise channels. Incoherent processes are fixed points of dephasing on all input and output spaces, and their coherence is quantified by relative entropy. As a proof of principle, we use an Ising model in which all three pairwise channels are incoherent while the full three-time process remains coherent. We observe this multi-time coherence on a superconducting quantum processor using a coherence witness and full process tomography.
Can intermediate-time interventions reveal coherence when every pairwise dynamical channel is incoherent? This paper defines basis-dependent coherence of a multi-time process operator WWW by its failure to remain invariant under dephasing of every input and output leg. It quantifies this using Crel(W)=S(D(ω))−S(ω)\mathcal C_{\rm rel}(W)=S(\mathcal D(\omega))-S(\omega)Crel​(W)=S(D(ω))−S(ω), where ω=W/tr⁡W\omega=W/\operatorname{tr}Wω=W/trW, and develops linear coherence witnesses. The framework includes convexity and monotonicity under dephasing-covariant superprocesses.
An exactly solvable Ising model couples one system qubit to two persistent environmental qubits. At observation times 0,τ,2τ0,\tau,2\tau0,τ,2τ, with τ=π/(8g)\tau=\pi/(8g)τ=π/(8g), all three pairwise channels are completely dephasing, yet the three-time process has coherence 12ln⁡2\tfrac12\ln221​ln2. Resetting the memory between intervals eliminates this coherence. A four-Pauli witness has ideal expectation −1/2-1/2−1/2. The effect requires only classical memory and is related explicitly to spin echo, rather than requiring quantum environmental memory. Appendices give a quantum-memory example and a single-memory construction whose coherence is at least (N−1)ln⁡2(N-1)\ln2(N−1)ln2 over NNN intervals.
Ancilla-assisted measurements on an IBM superconducting processor yield witness magnitude 0.3486±0.01460.3486\pm0.01460.3486±0.0146 and tomographic process coherence 0.26890.26890.2689, versus ideal 0.34660.34660.3466; reconstructed pairwise-channel coherences remain below 0.0220.0220.022. The experimental channels therefore retain residual coherence rather than exhibiting exact separation. The notion differs from classicality under fixed-basis sequential probes. Pairwise channels in non-Markovian settings depend on the specified earlier closure, and tomographic entropy estimates use eigenvalue clipping without reported uncertainties.
Memory effects in open quantum systems do not by themselves imply quantum memory, since non-Markovian dynamics can often be reproduced by classical-memory models. Known criteria certify the presence of quantum memory in the environment by comparing the evolution of the system at two different times. We show that quantum memory can remain hidden from all such pairwise tests and become detectable only when three or more times are considered jointly. We derive an analytical three-time witness and use it to certify quantum memory in a minimal qubit example in which every pair of times has a classical-memory explanation, thus establishing a strict hierarchy of quantum memory effects. Genuine multi-time quantum memory does not rely on fine-tuned time-dependent Hamiltonians or gate-based evolution. We experimentally demonstrate the hierarchy of quantum memory in a time-continuous realization on a superconducting-qubit platform with time-independent couplings.
We provide a quantification of the capability of various quantum dephasing processes to generate coherence out of incoherent states. The measures defined, admitting computable expressions for any finite Hilbert-space dimension, are based on probabilistic averages and arise naturally from the viewpoint of coherence as a resource. We investigate how the capability of a dephasing process (e.g., a nonselective orthogonal measurement) to generate coherence depends on the relevant bases of the Hilbert space over which coherence is quantified and the dephasing process occurs, respectively. We extend our analysis to include those Lindblad time evolutions which, in the infinite-time limit, dephase the system under consideration and calculate their coherence-generating power as a function of time. We further identify specific families of such time evolutions that, although dephasing, have optimal (over all quantum processes) coherence-generating power for some intermediate time. Finally, we investigate the coherence-generating capability of random dephasing channels.
Multi-time quantum processes are endowed with the same richness as multipartite states, including temporal entanglement and exotic causal structures. However, experimentally probing these rich phenomena leans heavily on fast and clean mid-circuit measurements, which are rarely available. We show here how surprisingly accessible these phenomena are in nascent quantum processors even when faced with substantially limited control. We work within the limitation where only unitary control is allowed, followed by a terminating measurement. Within this setting, we first develop a witness for genuine multi-time entanglement, and then methods to bound (from top and bottom) multi-time entanglement, non-Markovianity, purity, entropy, and other correlative measures. Our tools are designed to be implemented on quantum information processors, which we proceed to demonstrate. Finally, we discuss the limitations of these methods by testing them across random multi-time processes. Conceptually, this broadens our understanding of the extent to which temporal correlations may be determined with only deterministic control. Our techniques are pertinent to generic quantum stochastic dynamical processes, with a scope ranging across condensed matter physics, quantum biology, and in-depth diagnostics of NISQ-era quantum devices.
Current quantum technologies are at the cusp of becoming useful, but still face formidable obstacles such as noise. Noise severely limits the ability to scale quantum devices to the point that they would offer an advantage over classical devices. To understand the sources of noise it is necessary to fully characterise the quantum processes occurring across many time steps; only this would reveal any time-correlated noise called non-Markovian. Previous efforts have attempted such a characterisation but obtained only a limited reconstruction of such multi-time processes. In this work, we fully characterise a multi-time quantum process on superconducting hardware using in-house and cloud-based quantum processors. We achieve this by employing sequential measure-and-prepare operations combined with post-processing. Employing a recently developed formalism for multi-time processes, we detect general multi-time correlated noise. We also detect quantum correlated noise which demonstrates that part of the noise originates from quantum sources, such as physically nearby qubits on the chip.
Abstract Based on the nonincreasing property of quantum coherence via skew information under incoherent completely positive and trace-preserving maps, we propose a non-Markovianity measure for open quantum processes. As applications, by applying the proposed measure to some typical noisy channels, we find that it is equivalent to the three previous measures of non-Markovianity for phase damping and amplitude damping channels, i.e. the measures based on the quantum trace distance, dynamical divisibility, and quantum mutual information. For the random unitary channel, it is equivalent to the non-Markovianity measure based on l 1 norm of coherence for a class of output states and it is incompletely equivalent to the measure based on dynamical divisibility. We also use the modified Tsallis relative entropy of coherence to detect the non-Markovianity of dynamics of quantum open systems, the results show that the modified Tsallis relative entropy of coherence are more comfortable than the original Tsallis relative entropy of coherence for small .
We investigate nonlocal advantage of quantum coherence (NAQC) in a correlated dephasing channel modeled by the multimode bosonic reservoir. We obtain analytically the dephasing and memory factors of this channel for the reservoir having a Lorentzian spectral density, and analyze how they affect the NAQC defined by the l 1 norm and relative entropy. It is shown that the memory effects of this channel on NAQC are state-dependent, and they suppress noticeably the rapid decay of NAQC for the family of input Bell-like states with one excitation. For the given transmission time of each qubit, we also obtain the regions of the dephasing and memory factors during which there is NAQC in the output states.