arXiv:2610.08146
Operational quasiprobability formulation of non-signaling in time for macrorealism violations
Stefano Gherardini, Paolo Solinas
Abstract
In this paper, we introduce the concept of quasi non-signaling in time (QNSIT), which extends non-signaling in time (NSIT) to quasiprobability distributions. QNSIT requires that the marginals of the quasiprobability distribution under consideration at intermediate times remain unperturbed by the measurement back-action induced by a sequence of quantum measurements. Associated with QNSIT, we propose a quasiprobabilistic characterization of macrorealism, ${\rm MR}_{\rm qp}$, which requires that both the QNSIT conditions are satisfied and the quasiprobability distribution constructed from the measurement outcomes is positive. We prove that ${\rm MR}_{\rm qp}$ implies NSIT, whereas the converse does not hold because of hidden superposition paths generated or preserved by the system dynamics. We also prove that, for a two-level system, the ${\rm MR}_{\rm qp}$ and NSIT conditions coincide. ${\rm MR}_{\rm qp}$ therefore provides a more sensitive tool for testing macrorealism and can be implemented experimentally through a quantum non-demolition measurement scheme.
AI Summary
The paper asks whether non-signaling in time (NSIT), which tests consistency of sequential-measurement probabilities under omission of intermediate measurements, can miss quantum interference detectable through quasiprobabilities. It introduces quasi non-signaling in time (QNSIT) and a corresponding macrorealism criterion, $\mathrm{MR}_{\mathrm{qp}}$, requiring QNSIT, quasiprobability positivity, and induction. For three measurement times, the construction retains separate forward and backward history indices, giving complex path coefficients whose grouped contributions define a real quasiprobability distribution. QNSIT marginalization relations follow from projector completeness and hold automatically for this construction. Assuming the encoded observable spectra distinguish different unordered path-index groups, classical and interference contributions occupy distinct support points; positivity is then equivalent to vanishing of the grouped interference contributions. The main result is $\mathrm{MR}_{\mathrm{qp}}\Rightarrow\mathrm{MR}_{\mathrm{str}}$, where strong macrorealism is characterized by three NSIT conditions and induction. The converse fails: an explicit three-level example satisfies all three NSIT conditions while retaining nonzero, oppositely signed interference weights that cancel in ordinary marginals. For two-level systems, the two criteria coincide. These results follow from decomposing the quasiprobability marginal identities into diagonal and interference terms. An ancilla-based quantum non-demolition coupling and interferometric reconstruction of the characteristic function provide a proposed implementation; no experiment is reported. The analysis treats unitary dynamics and assumes induction and spectrally separated path encodings. Stated extensions include general completely positive, trace-preserving dynamics, sequential weak measurements, and comparisons with augmented Leggett–Garg inequalities and temporal Kirkwood–Dirac approaches.
Central claim may not hold: The abstract's implication from quasiprobability positivity to NSIT requires the body's spectral-separation assumption; without it, a positive qubit quasiprobability can coexist with an NSIT violation. The identification of quasiprobability positivity with absence of coherent superpositions is false: an initially coherent qubit with identity dynamics has a positive quasiprobability even with separated spectra.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 7 pages, 1 figure. Comments and feedback are welcome