Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2610.07986

Divisibility of Non-Invertible Quantum Dynamics in the Heisenberg Picture

Federico Settimo, Dariusz Chruściński

quant-phSubmitted Oct 6, 2026• Announced Oct 7, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We study divisibility of finite-dimensional quantum dynamics in the Heisenberg picture when the dynamical maps need not be invertible. Heisenberg divisible dynamics determines unique reduced propagators on the accessible operator systems, and Heisenberg CP-divisibility is shown to be equivalent to an operator-norm monotonicity. Although each reduced propagator admits a unital completely positive extension, independently chosen extensions need not satisfy a composition law. Generalized inverses restore this law algebraically, but do not, in general, preserve complete positivity. We characterize the resulting obstruction and give a sufficient construction based on unital completely positive projections onto the accessible operator systems. It is shown that for qubit dynamics Heisenberg CP-divisibility always guarantees a completely positive generalized-inverse propagator. Finally, we analyze time-local generators at singular times and identify the associated gauge freedom on dynamically inaccessible directions.

AI Summary

The paper studies finite-dimensional quantum dynamics when dynamical maps become noninvertible, focusing on Heisenberg left divisibility, $\Lambda_t^*=W_{t,s}^*\Lambda_s^*$. This differs from the adjoint of standard Schrödinger divisibility because taking adjoints reverses composition order. Linear Heisenberg divisibility is equivalent to $\ker\Lambda_s^*\subseteq\ker\Lambda_t^*$ and defines unique reduced propagators on the accessible operator systems $\mathcal S_s=\operatorname{Im}\Lambda_s^*$. The main characterization states that Heisenberg CP-divisibility is equivalent to $\|(\operatorname{id}_d\otimes\Lambda_t^*)(X)\|_\infty\leq\|(\operatorname{id}_d\otimes\Lambda_s^*)(X)\|_\infty$ for every Hermitian $X$, where $d$ is the system dimension. The proof combines norm–positivity relations with Arveson’s extension theorem, which supplies unital completely positive extensions of the reduced maps. Independently selected extensions need not compose. Generalized-inverse propagators $\Lambda_t^*(\Lambda_s^*)^-$ satisfy composition algebraically but can fail complete positivity. UCP projections onto the accessible systems provide a sufficient construction satisfying both requirements. For norm-continuous CP-divisible qubit dynamics starting at the identity, accessible dimensions are restricted to $1,2,4$; all admit such projections. A continuous, locally absolutely continuous qutrit counterexample shows that CP-divisibility alone does not guarantee CP generalized-inverse propagators. The paper also gives examples separating Schrödinger and Heisenberg divisibility, phase-covariant qubit criteria, and algebraic conditions and gauge freedom for time-local generators at singular times. It leaves open a higher-dimensional characterization of UCP-complemented accessible systems, necessary and sufficient conditions for global UCP cocycles without these projections, and connections to operational and genuinely multitime notions of Markovianity.

Little sign of AI-generated textUnclear writing

Error found: The abstract overstates the qubit generalized-inverse result by omitting hypotheses imposed in the body; a discontinuous CP-divisible qubit evolution can reach a constant rank-three map for which no completely positive generalized-inverse propagator exists. In the dephasing-generator example, the displayed rate identity must be κ(t)=−dot f(t)/(2f(t))=1/(1−t), rather than κ(t)=dot f(t)/f(t)=1/(1−t).

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
19 + 3 pages

Related papers

Construction of propagators for divisible dynamical maps

Ujan Chakraborty, Dariusz Chruściński

Abstract Divisible dynamical maps play an important role in characterizing Markovianity on the level of quantum evolution. Divisible maps provide an important generalization of Markovian semigroups. Usually one analyzes either completely positive or just positive divisibility meaning that the corresponding propagators are defined in terms of completely positive or positive maps, respectively. For maps which are invertible at any moment of time the very existence of propagator is already guaranteed and hence the only issue is (complete) positivity and trace-preservation. However, for maps which are not invertible the problem is much more involved since even the existence of a propagator is not guaranteed. In this paper we propose a simple method to construct propagators of dynamical maps using the concept of generalized inverse. We analyze both time-continuous and time-discrete maps. Since the generalized inverse is not uniquely defined the same applies for the corresponding propagator. In simple examples of qubit evolution we analyze it turns out that the additional requirement of complete positivity possibly makes the propagator unique.

arXiv:2004.09264•New Journal of Physics•Dec 16, 2020•10 citations

Divisibility and Information Flow Notions of Quantum Markovianity for Noninvertible Dynamical Maps

Dariusz Chruściński, ́Angel Rivas, Erling Størmer

We analyze the relation between completely positive (CP) divisibility and the lack of information backflow for an arbitrary-not necessarily invertible-dynamical map. It is well known that CP divisibility always implies a lack of information backflow. Moreover, these two notions are equivalent for invertible maps. In this Letter, it is shown that for a map which is not invertible the lack of information backflow always implies the existence of a completely positive propagator which, however, needs not be trace preserving. Interestingly, for a wide class of image nonincreasing dynamical maps, this propagator becomes trace preserving as well, and hence, the lack of information backflow implies CP divisibility. This result sheds new light into the structure of the time-local generators giving rise to CP-divisible evolutions. We show that if the map is not invertible then positivity of dissipation/decoherence rates is no longer necessary for CP divisibility.

arXiv:1710.06771•Physical Review Letters•Aug 24, 2018•79 citations

Divisibility of Dynamical Maps: Schrödinger Versus Heisenberg Picture

Federico Settimo, Andrea Smirne, Kimmo Luoma +3 more

Divisibility of dynamical maps is a central notion in the study of quantum non-Markovianity, providing a natural framework to characterize memory effects via time-local master equations. In this work, we generalize the notion of divisibility of quantum dynamical maps from the Schrödinger to the Heisenberg picture. While the two pictures are equivalent at the level of physical predictions, we show that the divisibility properties of the corresponding dual maps are, in general, not equivalent. This inequivalence originates from the distinction between left and right generators of time-local master equations, which interchange roles under duality. We demonstrate that Schrödinger and Heisenberg divisibility are distinct concepts by constructing explicit dynamics divisible only in one picture. Furthermore, we introduce a quantifier for the violation of Heisenberg P-divisibility, analogous to the trace-distance-based measure of non-Markovianity, and provide it with an operational interpretation in terms of the guessing probability between effects. Our results show that Heisenberg divisibility is an independent witness of memory effects and highlight the need to consider both pictures when characterizing non-Markovian quantum dynamics.

arXiv:2506.08103•PRX Quantum•Jan 5, 2026•7 citations

Map-Dependent Quantum Characteristic Functions and CP-Divisibility in Non-Markovian Quantum Dynamics

Koichi Nakagawa

We introduce map-dependent quantum characteristic functions constructed from the normalized Choi operator of quantum dynamical maps. We prove a Bochner--Choi positivity theorem establishing that the positive-type condition of the associated Gram matrix is equivalent to complete positivity of the underlying quantum channel. Applying the construction to intermediate dynamical maps, we obtain a characterization of CP-divisibility in terms of positivity of two-time characteristic functions. Numerical examples for amplitude damping and pure dephasing models demonstrate that negativity of the Gram matrix coincides with the breakdown of CP-divisibility and the emergence of information backflow. The proposed framework provides a new bridge between characteristic-function methods in quantum statistics and structural properties of quantum dynamical maps.

quant-pharXiv:2604.17185•Apr 21, 2026•0 citations

Divisibility of qubit channels and dynamical maps

David Davalos, Mário Ziman, Carlos Pineda

The concept of divisibility of dynamical maps is used to introduce an analogous concept for quantum channels by analyzing the simulability of channels by means of dynamical maps. In particular, this is addressed for Lindblad divisible, completely positive divisible and positive divisible dynamical maps. The corresponding L-divisible, CP-divisible and P-divisible subsets of channels are characterized (exploiting the results by Wolf et al. \cite{cirac}) and visualized for the case of qubit channels. We discuss the general inclusions among divisibility sets and show several equivalences for qubit channels. To this end we study the conditions of L-divisibility for finite dimensional channels, especially the cases with negative eigenvalues, extending and completing the results of Ref.~\cite{Wolf2008}. Furthermore we show that transitions between every two of the defined divisibility sets are allowed. We explore particular examples of dynamical maps to compare these concepts. Finally, we show that every divisible but not infinitesimal divisible qubit channel (in positive maps) is entanglement breaking, and open the question if something similar occurs for higher dimensions.

arXiv:1812.11437•Quantum•May 20, 2019•39 citations

Divisibility of quantum dynamical maps and collision models

Sergey N. Filippov, Jyrki Piilo, Sabrina Maniscalco +1 more

The divisibility of dynamical maps is visualized by trajectories in the parameter space and analyzed within the framework of collision models. We introduce ultimate completely positive (CP) divisible processes, which lose CP divisibility under infinitesimal perturbations, and characterize Pauli dynamical semigroups exhibiting such a property. We construct collision models with factorized environment particles, which realize additivity and multiplicativity of generators of CP divisible maps. A mixture of dynamical maps is obtained with the help of correlated environment. The mixture of ultimate CP divisible processes is shown to result in a class of eternal CP indivisible evolutions. We explicitly find collision models leading to weakly and essentially non-Markovian Pauli dynamical maps.

arXiv:1708.04994•Physical Review A•Sep 14, 2017•86 citations
We study divisibility of finite-dimensional quantum dynamics in the Heisenberg picture when the dynamical maps need not be invertible. Heisenberg divisible dynamics determines unique reduced propagators on the accessible operator systems, and Heisenberg CP-divisibility is shown to be equivalent to an operator-norm monotonicity. Although each reduced propagator admits a unital completely positive extension, independently chosen extensions need not satisfy a composition law. Generalized inverses restore this law algebraically, but do not, in general, preserve complete positivity. We characterize the resulting obstruction and give a sufficient construction based on unital completely positive projections onto the accessible operator systems. It is shown that for qubit dynamics Heisenberg CP-divisibility always guarantees a completely positive generalized-inverse propagator. Finally, we analyze time-local generators at singular times and identify the associated gauge freedom on dynamically inaccessible directions.
The paper studies finite-dimensional quantum dynamics when dynamical maps become noninvertible, focusing on Heisenberg left divisibility, Λt∗=Wt,s∗Λs∗\Lambda_t^*=W_{t,s}^*\Lambda_s^*Λt∗​=Wt,s∗​Λs∗​. This differs from the adjoint of standard Schrödinger divisibility because taking adjoints reverses composition order.
Linear Heisenberg divisibility is equivalent to ker⁡Λs∗⊆ker⁡Λt∗\ker\Lambda_s^*\subseteq\ker\Lambda_t^*kerΛs∗​⊆kerΛt∗​ and defines unique reduced propagators on the accessible operator systems Ss=Im⁡Λs∗\mathcal S_s=\operatorname{Im}\Lambda_s^*Ss​=ImΛs∗​. The main characterization states that Heisenberg CP-divisibility is equivalent to ∥(id⁡d⊗Λt∗)(X)∥∞≤∥(id⁡d⊗Λs∗)(X)∥∞\|(\operatorname{id}_d\otimes\Lambda_t^*)(X)\|_\infty\leq\|(\operatorname{id}_d\otimes\Lambda_s^*)(X)\|_\infty∥(idd​⊗Λt∗​)(X)∥∞​≤∥(idd​⊗Λs∗​)(X)∥∞​ for every Hermitian XXX, where ddd is the system dimension. The proof combines norm–positivity relations with Arveson’s extension theorem, which supplies unital completely positive extensions of the reduced maps.
Independently selected extensions need not compose. Generalized-inverse propagators Λt∗(Λs∗)−\Lambda_t^*(\Lambda_s^*)^-Λt∗​(Λs∗​)− satisfy composition algebraically but can fail complete positivity. UCP projections onto the accessible systems provide a sufficient construction satisfying both requirements. For norm-continuous CP-divisible qubit dynamics starting at the identity, accessible dimensions are restricted to 1,2,41,2,41,2,4; all admit such projections. A continuous, locally absolutely continuous qutrit counterexample shows that CP-divisibility alone does not guarantee CP generalized-inverse propagators.
The paper also gives examples separating Schrödinger and Heisenberg divisibility, phase-covariant qubit criteria, and algebraic conditions and gauge freedom for time-local generators at singular times. It leaves open a higher-dimensional characterization of UCP-complemented accessible systems, necessary and sufficient conditions for global UCP cocycles without these projections, and connections to operational and genuinely multitime notions of Markovianity.
Abstract Divisible dynamical maps play an important role in characterizing Markovianity on the level of quantum evolution. Divisible maps provide an important generalization of Markovian semigroups. Usually one analyzes either completely positive or just positive divisibility meaning that the corresponding propagators are defined in terms of completely positive or positive maps, respectively. For maps which are invertible at any moment of time the very existence of propagator is already guaranteed and hence the only issue is (complete) positivity and trace-preservation. However, for maps which are not invertible the problem is much more involved since even the existence of a propagator is not guaranteed. In this paper we propose a simple method to construct propagators of dynamical maps using the concept of generalized inverse. We analyze both time-continuous and time-discrete maps. Since the generalized inverse is not uniquely defined the same applies for the corresponding propagator. In simple examples of qubit evolution we analyze it turns out that the additional requirement of complete positivity possibly makes the propagator unique.
We analyze the relation between completely positive (CP) divisibility and the lack of information backflow for an arbitrary-not necessarily invertible-dynamical map. It is well known that CP divisibility always implies a lack of information backflow. Moreover, these two notions are equivalent for invertible maps. In this Letter, it is shown that for a map which is not invertible the lack of information backflow always implies the existence of a completely positive propagator which, however, needs not be trace preserving. Interestingly, for a wide class of image nonincreasing dynamical maps, this propagator becomes trace preserving as well, and hence, the lack of information backflow implies CP divisibility. This result sheds new light into the structure of the time-local generators giving rise to CP-divisible evolutions. We show that if the map is not invertible then positivity of dissipation/decoherence rates is no longer necessary for CP divisibility.
Divisibility of dynamical maps is a central notion in the study of quantum non-Markovianity, providing a natural framework to characterize memory effects via time-local master equations. In this work, we generalize the notion of divisibility of quantum dynamical maps from the Schrödinger to the Heisenberg picture. While the two pictures are equivalent at the level of physical predictions, we show that the divisibility properties of the corresponding dual maps are, in general, not equivalent. This inequivalence originates from the distinction between left and right generators of time-local master equations, which interchange roles under duality. We demonstrate that Schrödinger and Heisenberg divisibility are distinct concepts by constructing explicit dynamics divisible only in one picture. Furthermore, we introduce a quantifier for the violation of Heisenberg P-divisibility, analogous to the trace-distance-based measure of non-Markovianity, and provide it with an operational interpretation in terms of the guessing probability between effects. Our results show that Heisenberg divisibility is an independent witness of memory effects and highlight the need to consider both pictures when characterizing non-Markovian quantum dynamics.
We introduce map-dependent quantum characteristic functions constructed from the normalized Choi operator of quantum dynamical maps. We prove a Bochner--Choi positivity theorem establishing that the positive-type condition of the associated Gram matrix is equivalent to complete positivity of the underlying quantum channel. Applying the construction to intermediate dynamical maps, we obtain a characterization of CP-divisibility in terms of positivity of two-time characteristic functions. Numerical examples for amplitude damping and pure dephasing models demonstrate that negativity of the Gram matrix coincides with the breakdown of CP-divisibility and the emergence of information backflow. The proposed framework provides a new bridge between characteristic-function methods in quantum statistics and structural properties of quantum dynamical maps.
The concept of divisibility of dynamical maps is used to introduce an analogous concept for quantum channels by analyzing the simulability of channels by means of dynamical maps. In particular, this is addressed for Lindblad divisible, completely positive divisible and positive divisible dynamical maps. The corresponding L-divisible, CP-divisible and P-divisible subsets of channels are characterized (exploiting the results by Wolf et al. \cite{cirac}) and visualized for the case of qubit channels. We discuss the general inclusions among divisibility sets and show several equivalences for qubit channels. To this end we study the conditions of L-divisibility for finite dimensional channels, especially the cases with negative eigenvalues, extending and completing the results of Ref.~\cite{Wolf2008}. Furthermore we show that transitions between every two of the defined divisibility sets are allowed. We explore particular examples of dynamical maps to compare these concepts. Finally, we show that every divisible but not infinitesimal divisible qubit channel (in positive maps) is entanglement breaking, and open the question if something similar occurs for higher dimensions.
The divisibility of dynamical maps is visualized by trajectories in the parameter space and analyzed within the framework of collision models. We introduce ultimate completely positive (CP) divisible processes, which lose CP divisibility under infinitesimal perturbations, and characterize Pauli dynamical semigroups exhibiting such a property. We construct collision models with factorized environment particles, which realize additivity and multiplicativity of generators of CP divisible maps. A mixture of dynamical maps is obtained with the help of correlated environment. The mixture of ultimate CP divisible processes is shown to result in a class of eternal CP indivisible evolutions. We explicitly find collision models leading to weakly and essentially non-Markovian Pauli dynamical maps.