arXiv:2610.07986
Divisibility of Non-Invertible Quantum Dynamics in the Heisenberg Picture
Federico Settimo, Dariusz Chruściński
Abstract
We study divisibility of finite-dimensional quantum dynamics in the Heisenberg picture when the dynamical maps need not be invertible. Heisenberg divisible dynamics determines unique reduced propagators on the accessible operator systems, and Heisenberg CP-divisibility is shown to be equivalent to an operator-norm monotonicity. Although each reduced propagator admits a unital completely positive extension, independently chosen extensions need not satisfy a composition law. Generalized inverses restore this law algebraically, but do not, in general, preserve complete positivity. We characterize the resulting obstruction and give a sufficient construction based on unital completely positive projections onto the accessible operator systems. It is shown that for qubit dynamics Heisenberg CP-divisibility always guarantees a completely positive generalized-inverse propagator. Finally, we analyze time-local generators at singular times and identify the associated gauge freedom on dynamically inaccessible directions.
AI Summary
The paper studies finite-dimensional quantum dynamics when dynamical maps become noninvertible, focusing on Heisenberg left divisibility, $\Lambda_t^*=W_{t,s}^*\Lambda_s^*$. This differs from the adjoint of standard Schrödinger divisibility because taking adjoints reverses composition order. Linear Heisenberg divisibility is equivalent to $\ker\Lambda_s^*\subseteq\ker\Lambda_t^*$ and defines unique reduced propagators on the accessible operator systems $\mathcal S_s=\operatorname{Im}\Lambda_s^*$. The main characterization states that Heisenberg CP-divisibility is equivalent to $\|(\operatorname{id}_d\otimes\Lambda_t^*)(X)\|_\infty\leq\|(\operatorname{id}_d\otimes\Lambda_s^*)(X)\|_\infty$ for every Hermitian $X$, where $d$ is the system dimension. The proof combines norm–positivity relations with Arveson’s extension theorem, which supplies unital completely positive extensions of the reduced maps. Independently selected extensions need not compose. Generalized-inverse propagators $\Lambda_t^*(\Lambda_s^*)^-$ satisfy composition algebraically but can fail complete positivity. UCP projections onto the accessible systems provide a sufficient construction satisfying both requirements. For norm-continuous CP-divisible qubit dynamics starting at the identity, accessible dimensions are restricted to $1,2,4$; all admit such projections. A continuous, locally absolutely continuous qutrit counterexample shows that CP-divisibility alone does not guarantee CP generalized-inverse propagators. The paper also gives examples separating Schrödinger and Heisenberg divisibility, phase-covariant qubit criteria, and algebraic conditions and gauge freedom for time-local generators at singular times. It leaves open a higher-dimensional characterization of UCP-complemented accessible systems, necessary and sufficient conditions for global UCP cocycles without these projections, and connections to operational and genuinely multitime notions of Markovianity.
Error found: The abstract overstates the qubit generalized-inverse result by omitting hypotheses imposed in the body; a discontinuous CP-divisible qubit evolution can reach a constant rank-three map for which no completely positive generalized-inverse propagator exists. In the dephasing-generator example, the displayed rate identity must be κ(t)=−dot f(t)/(2f(t))=1/(1−t), rather than κ(t)=dot f(t)/f(t)=1/(1−t).
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 19 + 3 pages