arXiv:2610.07393
Benchmarking exchange-only control of a 48-spin singlet manifold
HRL Quantum Team, Microsoft Collaborators, :, Stephen Carr, Matt Abbitt, Michael Abraham, Edwin Acuna, I. Alverado, Carter Andrews, Hussein Anton, Katherine M. Beech, Aaron J. Bluestone, Jacob Z. Blumoff, Matthew G. Borselli, Brydon Boyd, Jacob T. Boyer, Peter Brewer, Steven L. Brown, Joseph D. Broz, Tyler A. Cain, John B. Carpenter, Faustin W. Carter, Brittany Carter, Matthew D. Chambers, James M. Chappell, Kevin C. Chen, Edward H. Chen, Maxwell D. Choi, Matthew N. H. Chow, Justin E. Christensen, Aaron M. Chronister, Andrew M. Clapper, Michael D. Cornelius, Gregory M. Crosswhite, Stanislav Culaclii, Erik S. Daniel, Dominic Daprano, John K. David, Charles R. Elliott, Kevin Eng, Colin P. Feeney, David J. Fialkow, Dylan H. Finestone, Bryan H. Fong, Richie Fu, Zachary A. Geiger, Bradley W. Greene, Rafael Guerra-Fuentes, Hrayr K. Gurgenian, Alex Hamill, Brooke M. Hardesty, Jim W. Harrington, Alex Hirman, Donald A. Hitko, Silas Hoffman, Dominic Holloman, Daniel R. Hulbert, Jake Hundley, Clayton A. C. Jackson, Paul C. Jerger, B. Johnson, Aaron M. Jones, Michael P. Jura, Adour V. Kabakian, Tyler Keating, Joseph Kerckhoff, Andrey A. Kiselev, Patrick W. Krantz, Thaddeus D. Ladd, Sanaaya Lakdawala, Elias Lawson-Fox, Alwina R. Liu, Dwight Luhman, Manny Macias, Theodore K. Macioce, Ryan M. Martin, Daniel S. Matic, Gavin C. Mazur, Ryan McGeehan, Olivia Means, Austin Meyer, Samuel Mumford, Tina Niknejad, Riley P. O'Neil, Andrew Pan, Winston Pouse, Eric M. Prophet, Matthew D. Reed, Marcus Rentie, Alec Roberson, Zechariah Rogers, Golam Sabbir, Spencer Sager, Christopher D. Sanborn, Jonathan Sanchez, Rachel H. Sarmiento, Christian J. Schnaible, Cole Scott, Aaron Smith, Daniel E. Smith, James Soash, Kevin C. Staley, Andrea Su, Bo Sun, Christopher M. Swank, Noah Swimmer, Charles Tahan, Bryan J. Thomas, Yessica Torres, Alan Tran, Ivan Tran, James R. van Meter, Franklin Vartanian, John Samuel Venker, Daniel Volya, Annette L. Wagner, Daniel R. Ward, Aaron J. Weinstein, Abigail L. Wessels, Thomas V. Westrick, Evan T. White, Randall M. White, Parker Williams, Catrina E. Wilson, Courtney P. Wilt, Matthew Wingert, Clifford S. YoungSciortino, Andrew Ziegler
Abstract
Exchange-only quantum computing benefits from high fidelity and straightforward control afforded by the exchange interaction. However, independently controllable qubits must be encoded into subsystems of at least three electron spins, restricting computation to only a fraction of the available spin Hilbert space. The remaining states are treated as leakage and used only transiently in gate sequences. By contrast, a quantitative, system-wide measure of exchange-only performance can exploit the full available Hilbert space, including states conventionally treated as leakage. Here, we apply this approach to arrays of up to 48 electron spins, accessing a total-spin-zero Hilbert space with dimension exceeding $2^{40}$. Measurements of out-of-time-order correlators (OTOCs) reveal rich scrambling dynamics and demonstrate access to regimes relevant to quantum computational advantage. Using generalized forms of cross-entropy and mirror randomized benchmarking, we also assess the aggregate performance of the full exchange-only system per fundamental two-body interaction: the two-spin exchange. We obtain an effective system-level error of $3 \times 10^{-4}$ per exchange, incorporating the complete experimental control sequence and all associated noise sources. This value is up to an order of magnitude lower than those reported from comparable benchmarks on other platforms at the time of writing.
AI Summary
Exchange-only processors conventionally encode qubits in small spin subsystems, leaving much of the spin Hilbert space unused. This paper asks how to characterize system-wide control when exchange instead acts throughout a single total-spin-zero manifold, without defining local encoded qubits. Experiments use up to 48 electron spins and 54 exchange axes, driven by a cryogenic CMOS controller. The accessible singlet manifold has dimension $C_{24}>2^{40}$. Singlet-pair initialization and singlet–triplet readout support random exchange sequences, their inverses, and out-of-time-order correlator (OTOC) protocols. Generalized cross-entropy benchmarking on disjoint subarrays of at most 16 spins, operated simultaneously across the device, gives an average effective fidelity loss of $2.2\times10^{-4}$ per exchange. Full-array mirror benchmarking measures all-singlet return probabilities and yields $3.20\times10^{-4}$ per exchange. Fidelity–purity comparisons indicate substantial coherent error; independently characterized microscopic noise predicts errors over an order of magnitude smaller. Random OTOCs probe information spreading across 48 spins. For a second-order OTOC on 24 spins, sequence-dependent measurements agree with noiseless simulations up to approximately 15 cycles, or 1,440 exchange pulses. An 18-spin Trotterized $J_1$–$J_2$ Heisenberg experiment resolves propagation and boundary reflections. The reported errors are effective system-level metrics, not encoded-qubit gate errors. Measurement degeneracy prevents practical full-array cross-entropy benchmarking, and readout instability limits purity estimates. The chosen Heisenberg Trotter step does not faithfully reproduce continuous Hamiltonian dynamics. No quantum-advantage claim is established: classical simulation costs and 48-spin accuracy remain insufficiently assessed. Compilation and fault tolerance for these large encodings remain unresolved.
Error found: The Random OTOC-2 section incorrectly gives 0.01 as the shot-noise floor for a singlet-return probability estimated from 10,000 binary measurements; its shot-noise standard deviation is at most 0.005 and depends on the return probability.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.