arXiv:2610.07352
Classical chaotic signatures in Krylov space
Gastón F. Scialchi, Augusto J. Roncaglia, Diego A. Wisniacki
Abstract
In recent years, Krylov space approaches have emerged as a useful framework for characterizing dynamical chaos in a wide variety of physical systems. However, the connection between Krylov dynamics and the established structures of classical chaos remains largely unexplored. Classical chaos is characterized by exponential stretching and mixing. For quantum maps with a classical limit, we show that these two signatures are encoded in different structures within Krylov space: stretching is encoded in the geometry of the Krylov operators as determined by the Lyapunov exponent, while mixing manifests itself as an exponential decay of the Arnoldi sequences in agreement with the Ruelle-Pollicott resonances.
AI Summary
The paper asks how classical stretching and mixing appear in operator Krylov space for quantum maps with a classical limit. It studies quantized area-preserving maps on the torus, constructing Krylov bases from smooth, traceless observables using a Hilbert–Schmidt inner product. The main example is a perturbed Arnold cat map, with additional numerical tests for Harper and standard maps. Stretching is measured through the root-mean-square chord length $r_n$ of the $n$th Krylov operator. Numerically, $r_n$ grows exponentially at the classical Lyapunov rate before saturating. For the unperturbed cat map, an analytical argument using exact Weyl-translation dynamics and the approximation that successive Krylov operators follow unitary evolution gives $r_n\sim e^{\Lambda n}$ for $\Lambda^{-1}\lesssim n\lesssim\tau_E$, where $\Lambda=\ln[(3+\sqrt5)/2]$ and $\tau_E=\ln N/\Lambda$. Mixing is associated numerically with exponentially decaying Arnoldi coefficients: $|a_n|\sim|\lambda_1|^{2n}$, $1-b_{n+1}\sim|\lambda_1|^{2n}$, and $|c_n|\sim|\lambda_1|^n$, where $\lambda_1$ is the leading nontrivial Ruelle–Pollicott resonance. Calculations at $N=2048$ compare cat-map resonances $|\lambda_1|=0.526,0.698,0.822$ across three perturbations. These rates characterize approach to the previously proposed maximally ergodic Krylov regime. The resonance correspondence is numerical rather than generally derived; oscillatory modes can modulate the decay, and the discussion notes that coefficient and correlation decay rates need not coincide generally. Removing the invariant-density component matters: retaining it produces algebraic coefficient tails, captured by a solvable phenomenological model, that obscure the resonance-dependent behavior.
Central claim may not hold: The proposed resonance-controlled coefficient decay is supported for selected numerical examples but is not a general consequence of classical mixing, since smooth observables of an exponentially mixing cat map can have algebraically decaying Verblunsky coefficients. The claimed analytical stretching derivation assumes an uncontrolled replacement of orthogonalized Krylov operators by evolved initial operators. The printed standard-map Floquet operator generates a different classical map from the one stated, leaving that example's quantum–classical comparison unverified. The uniform chord-radius correction is incorrect: the specified even-N lattice gives r_unif^2=1/6+1/(3N^2). The supplemental Hessenberg formula and its expression for c_n contain an extra factor b_{n+1}, contradicting the stated Szegő recurrence.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 4+1.5 pages, 2 figures + 6 page appendix with 4 figures