Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2610.06818

The complete phase diagram of detailed-balanced Gibbs samplers for the mean-field Heisenberg model

Levente Raikovich, József Mák, Csaba Czabán, András Gilyén

quant-phSubmitted Oct 5, 2026• Announced Oct 6, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We study the spectral gap of recently discovered families of KMS-detailed-balanced Gibbs-sampler Lindbladians for the mean-field Heisenberg model on $n$ spins. We show that the spectral gaps of these natural families of Lindbladians admit the same phase diagram: the gap is constant above the critical temperature (i.e., in the disordered phase), scales as $1/\sqrt{n}$ at the critical temperature, and as $1/n$ below the critical temperature (i.e., in the ordered phase). Our result builds on and extends the recent work of Basso et al.~(2026) which characterized this phase diagram for the GNS-detailed-balanced Davies generator, but only partially resolved the gap scaling at the critical temperature.

AI Summary

The paper studies whether different detailed-balanced quantum Gibbs samplers exhibit the same relaxation scaling across the thermal transition of the mean-field Heisenberg ferromagnet, $H_n=-n^{-1}\sum_\alpha(S^\alpha_{\mathrm{tot}})^2$. It considers single-site Pauli jumps in Davies generators, coherent-reweighting Lindbladians, and Gaussian operator-Fourier-transform (OFT) Lindbladians. For fixed inverse temperature $\beta>0$, admissible normalized KMS filters, and fixed OFT width $\sigma>0$, all three constructions have spectral gap $\Theta(1)$ for $\beta<2$, $\Theta(n^{-1/2})$ at $\beta=2$, and $\Theta(n^{-1})$ for $\beta>2$. This extends the previously established Davies phase diagram to implementable KMS samplers and closes the previous critical-point bounds $\Omega(n^{-1})\leq\mathrm{gap}\leq O(n^{-1/2})$. Under additional filter-limit assumptions, the zero-temperature gap is $\Theta(n^{-1})$ and worst-case trace-distance mixing time is $\Theta(n\log(1/\varepsilon))$. The proof decomposes operator space using collective $\mathrm{SU}(2)$ rotations and site permutations. Coherent and Davies Dirichlet forms are comparable on observables commuting with the Hamiltonian; complementary sectors are controlled through the interchange process and collective Casimir. At criticality, scalar-chain estimates and the spin moment $\mathbb E[s^2]=\Theta(n^{3/2})$ control the remaining modes. A mixture representation transfers coherent-form bounds to OFT samplers. The analysis relies on this model’s symmetries and these jump families. Asymptotics hold with temperature, filter, and width fixed, rather than uniformly near criticality. The general theorem excludes $\beta=0$ because the OFT construction is ill-behaved there. Gaps use summed, not per-site-normalized, generators.

Little sign of AI-generated text

Error found: The main theorem's universal β=∞ extension requires additional filter assumptions: an explicitly admitted oscillatory KMS filter yields Davies generators with no zero-temperature limit, while the zero-temperature proof assumes that the filter converges at negative infinity.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
45 pages

Related papers

Spectral Gap of the Davies Generator for the Mean-Field Heisenberg Model

Joao Basso, Thiago Bergamaschi, Lin Lin +2 more

The mean-field Heisenberg ferromagnet is a quantum spin model on the complete graph with isotropic spin-1/2 interactions. This non-commuting Hamiltonian is permutation and $\mathsf{SU}(2)$ invariant, and its Gibbs states undergo an $\mathsf{SU}(2)$ symmetry breaking phase transition at inverse temperature $β=2$. We consider the associated Davies generator, a canonical model of open-system thermalization, and prove tight asymptotic estimates for its spectral gap at all noncritical temperatures. For fixed $β<2$, the gap as a function of number of qubits $n$ is $Θ(1)$, while for fixed $β>2$ the gap is $Θ(n^{-1})$. The matching upper bound of the spectral gap is witnessed by the total magnetization order parameter, suggesting that the low-temperature ($β>2$) slowdown is associated with broken continuous symmetry. Two key ingredients in our approach are a comparison argument, which introduces auxiliary generators to bound dissipation on nontrivial representations of the symmetry groups $\mathsf{SU}(2)$ and $\mathsf{S}_n$, and a decomposition of the space of observables into spherical tensor operators to reveal a form of monotonicity.

quant-pharXiv:2607.21798•Jul 27, 2026•6 citations

Spectral Analysis Beyond the Spectral Gap: Rapid Mixing of Quantum Gibbs Samplers in One Dimension

Hongrui Chen, Zhiyan Ding

We prove rapid mixing of a quantum Gibbs sampler for general one-dimensional non-commuting local spin systems at every fixed positive temperature. In particular, for a system of $n$ sites, we show that the Kubo--Martin--Schwinger (KMS) detailed-balanced Gibbs sampler of~\cite{CKG2023} converges from any initial state to trace-norm error $ε$ in time $O(\log^4(n)+\log(1/ε))$. This improves the previous $O(n+\log(1/ε))$ bound and establishes rapid mixing beyond high-temperature and weak-interaction regimes. Our proof explains why the slowest decay rate, captured by the spectral gap, can substantially underestimate the speed of equilibration. The key insight is that a state far from equilibrium must have a substantial component outside the span of low-weight Pauli operators, where stronger dissipation estimates apply. This yields two stages of relaxation: a double-exponential convergence from a bad initial state, followed by exponential convergence near equilibrium. We turn this mechanism into a framework for proving rapid mixing through spectral analysis beyond the gap. Our decay estimate is equivalent to exponential convergence in sandwiched Rényi-2 divergence. Together with the spectral gap, it also implies a modified logarithmic Sobolev inequality with rate $Ω(\log^{-4}(n))$.

quant-pharXiv:2610.05848•Oct 6, 2026•6 citations

Fast Mixing of Quantum Spin Chains at All Temperatures

Thiago Bergamaschi, Chi-Fang Chen

It is shown that every one-dimensional Hamiltonian with short-range interactions admits a quantum Gibbs sampler [CKG23] with a system-size independent spectral gap at all finite temperatures. Consequently, their Gibbs states can be prepared in polylogarithmic depth, and satisfy exponential clustering of correlations, generalizing [Ara69].

arXiv:2510.08533•ACM Symposium on Theory of Computing (STOC)•Jun 9, 2026•42 citations

From Heat to Homology: Spectral Gap Transfer for Exact Quantum Gibbs Sampling at All Temperatures

Caesnan M. G. Leditto, Kuo-Chin Chen, Min-Hsiu Hsieh

Preparing Gibbs states through dissipative dynamics requires controlling convergence for the chosen Hamiltonian $H$ and coupling operators. However, efficient implementation requires convergence guarantees from the spectral gap of the generator of the dynamics, which remains a crucial challenge. Recent results address the challenge by restricting the dynamics with structural assumptions about the Hamiltonian and its interactions. For the Chen-Kastoryano-Gilyen (CKG) construction and arbitrary finite-dimensional Hamiltonians, we prove an explicit comparison that converts a spectral gap estimate for the infinite-temperature generator into a lower bound on the spectral gap of the CKG quantum Gibbs sampler at every finite positive inverse temperature $β$. It allows a single spectral gap estimate at infinite temperature to certify convergence across Hamiltonians and temperatures. Such an estimate is often known from a classical spectral gap estimate, such as the classical random walk spectral gap. For Hodge Laplacians of simplicial complexes as Hamiltonians, we construct coupling operators whose generator at infinite temperature has the same spectral gap as a classical simplicial down-up walk. A positive spectral gap of the walk and bounded spectral width $W=λ_{\max}(H)-λ_{\min}(H)$ give a generator spectral gap independent of the number of simplices at every fixed temperature. We then establish conditions under which the sampler approximately prepares zero-energy (harmonic) states in polynomial evolution time. This provides a conditional convergence guarantee for the state preparation in the thermal approach to quantum topological data analysis.

quant-pharXiv:2610.02859•Oct 5, 2026•0 citations

Phase diagram of spin-1 quantum Ising-Heisenberg models

Carla Buzano

The phase diagram at T = 0 of a family of spin-1 quantum Ising-Heisenberg models is studied using a mean-field approximation. The model Hamiltonian is characterized by single ion anisotropy terms D μ , (μ = x, y, z ) and by two positive parameters η x , η y measuring the degree of anisotropy of the interaction. They allow to describe a variety of models: among them the spin-1 Ising-Blume-Capel model (η x = η y = 0), and the isotropic Heisenberg model (η x = η y = 1). Both dipolar and quadrupolar order parameters are used to derive the phase diagram in the parameter space (η x , η y , D μ ). The resulting phase diagram is rather complex as it exhibits first and second order critical transitions as well as multicritical points.

Physica Scripta•Apr 1, 1988•3 citations

A rapidly mixing quantum Swendsen–Wang sampler and a locality lower bound for Gibbs sampling

Soo-Jong Rey

I study the mixing time of quantum Gibbs samplers (Davies / Chen– Kastoryano–Gilyén generators) at low temperature. I prove a locality lower bound: any local, KMS–detailed-balanced sampler whose target has an order- parameter bottleneck has an Arrhenius-small spectral gap, by a quantum Cheeger argument, and hence mixing time eΩ(β∆F). The bound is a quantum Cheeger argument and holds for every KMS–detailed-balanced sampler. The coherence cannot lift an order-parameter bottleneck, thereby the obstruction survives quantization. It is not, however, intrinsic to the target. I give a 3-local, detailed-balanced Lindbladian on an enlarged spin+bond register whose spin marginal realizes the Fortuin–Kasteleyn cluster update and which, for commuting ferromagnets, has an inverse-polynomial gap at every temperature and prepares σ in poly(n)log(1/ε) gates. This gives an unconditional separation from the local-reversible class in which locality (not coherence) is the operative resource. As a conjecture, I isolate the genuinely quantum question about cluster updates for noncommuting targets, where no nonnegative bond representation exists and the cluster must be grown coherently.

•Jul 23, 2026•0 citations
We study the spectral gap of recently discovered families of KMS-detailed-balanced Gibbs-sampler Lindbladians for the mean-field Heisenberg model on nnn spins. We show that the spectral gaps of these natural families of Lindbladians admit the same phase diagram: the gap is constant above the critical temperature (i.e., in the disordered phase), scales as 1/n1/\sqrt{n}1/n​ at the critical temperature, and as 1/n1/n1/n below the critical temperature (i.e., in the ordered phase). Our result builds on and extends the recent work of Basso et al.~(2026) which characterized this phase diagram for the GNS-detailed-balanced Davies generator, but only partially resolved the gap scaling at the critical temperature.
The paper studies whether different detailed-balanced quantum Gibbs samplers exhibit the same relaxation scaling across the thermal transition of the mean-field Heisenberg ferromagnet, Hn=−n−1∑α(Stotα)2H_n=-n^{-1}\sum_\alpha(S^\alpha_{\mathrm{tot}})^2Hn​=−n−1∑α​(Stotα​)2. It considers single-site Pauli jumps in Davies generators, coherent-reweighting Lindbladians, and Gaussian operator-Fourier-transform (OFT) Lindbladians.
For fixed inverse temperature β>0\beta>0β>0, admissible normalized KMS filters, and fixed OFT width σ>0\sigma>0σ>0, all three constructions have spectral gap Θ(1)\Theta(1)Θ(1) for β<2\beta<2β<2, Θ(n−1/2)\Theta(n^{-1/2})Θ(n−1/2) at β=2\beta=2β=2, and Θ(n−1)\Theta(n^{-1})Θ(n−1) for β>2\beta>2β>2. This extends the previously established Davies phase diagram to implementable KMS samplers and closes the previous critical-point bounds Ω(n−1)≤gap≤O(n−1/2)\Omega(n^{-1})\leq\mathrm{gap}\leq O(n^{-1/2})Ω(n−1)≤gap≤O(n−1/2). Under additional filter-limit assumptions, the zero-temperature gap is Θ(n−1)\Theta(n^{-1})Θ(n−1) and worst-case trace-distance mixing time is Θ(nlog⁡(1/ε))\Theta(n\log(1/\varepsilon))Θ(nlog(1/ε)).
The proof decomposes operator space using collective SU(2)\mathrm{SU}(2)SU(2) rotations and site permutations. Coherent and Davies Dirichlet forms are comparable on observables commuting with the Hamiltonian; complementary sectors are controlled through the interchange process and collective Casimir. At criticality, scalar-chain estimates and the spin moment E[s2]=Θ(n3/2)\mathbb E[s^2]=\Theta(n^{3/2})E[s2]=Θ(n3/2) control the remaining modes. A mixture representation transfers coherent-form bounds to OFT samplers.
The analysis relies on this model’s symmetries and these jump families. Asymptotics hold with temperature, filter, and width fixed, rather than uniformly near criticality. The general theorem excludes β=0\beta=0β=0 because the OFT construction is ill-behaved there. Gaps use summed, not per-site-normalized, generators.
The mean-field Heisenberg ferromagnet is a quantum spin model on the complete graph with isotropic spin-1/2 interactions. This non-commuting Hamiltonian is permutation and SU(2)\mathsf{SU}(2)SU(2) invariant, and its Gibbs states undergo an SU(2)\mathsf{SU}(2)SU(2) symmetry breaking phase transition at inverse temperature β=2β=2β=2. We consider the associated Davies generator, a canonical model of open-system thermalization, and prove tight asymptotic estimates for its spectral gap at all noncritical temperatures. For fixed β<2β<2β<2, the gap as a function of number of qubits nnn is Θ(1)Θ(1)Θ(1), while for fixed β>2β>2β>2 the gap is Θ(n−1)Θ(n^{-1})Θ(n−1). The matching upper bound of the spectral gap is witnessed by the total magnetization order parameter, suggesting that the low-temperature (β>2β>2β>2) slowdown is associated with broken continuous symmetry. Two key ingredients in our approach are a comparison argument, which introduces auxiliary generators to bound dissipation on nontrivial representations of the symmetry groups SU(2)\mathsf{SU}(2)SU(2) and Sn\mathsf{S}_nSn​, and a decomposition of the space of observables into spherical tensor operators to reveal a form of monotonicity.
We prove rapid mixing of a quantum Gibbs sampler for general one-dimensional non-commuting local spin systems at every fixed positive temperature. In particular, for a system of nnn sites, we show that the Kubo--Martin--Schwinger (KMS) detailed-balanced Gibbs sampler of~\cite{CKG2023} converges from any initial state to trace-norm error εεε in time O(log⁡4(n)+log⁡(1/ε))O(\log^4(n)+\log(1/ε))O(log4(n)+log(1/ε)). This improves the previous O(n+log⁡(1/ε))O(n+\log(1/ε))O(n+log(1/ε)) bound and establishes rapid mixing beyond high-temperature and weak-interaction regimes. Our proof explains why the slowest decay rate, captured by the spectral gap, can substantially underestimate the speed of equilibration. The key insight is that a state far from equilibrium must have a substantial component outside the span of low-weight Pauli operators, where stronger dissipation estimates apply. This yields two stages of relaxation: a double-exponential convergence from a bad initial state, followed by exponential convergence near equilibrium. We turn this mechanism into a framework for proving rapid mixing through spectral analysis beyond the gap. Our decay estimate is equivalent to exponential convergence in sandwiched Rényi-2 divergence. Together with the spectral gap, it also implies a modified logarithmic Sobolev inequality with rate Ω(log⁡−4(n))Ω(\log^{-4}(n))Ω(log−4(n)).
Preparing Gibbs states through dissipative dynamics requires controlling convergence for the chosen Hamiltonian HHH and coupling operators. However, efficient implementation requires convergence guarantees from the spectral gap of the generator of the dynamics, which remains a crucial challenge. Recent results address the challenge by restricting the dynamics with structural assumptions about the Hamiltonian and its interactions. For the Chen-Kastoryano-Gilyen (CKG) construction and arbitrary finite-dimensional Hamiltonians, we prove an explicit comparison that converts a spectral gap estimate for the infinite-temperature generator into a lower bound on the spectral gap of the CKG quantum Gibbs sampler at every finite positive inverse temperature βββ. It allows a single spectral gap estimate at infinite temperature to certify convergence across Hamiltonians and temperatures. Such an estimate is often known from a classical spectral gap estimate, such as the classical random walk spectral gap. For Hodge Laplacians of simplicial complexes as Hamiltonians, we construct coupling operators whose generator at infinite temperature has the same spectral gap as a classical simplicial down-up walk. A positive spectral gap of the walk and bounded spectral width W=λmax⁡(H)−λmin⁡(H)W=λ_{\max}(H)-λ_{\min}(H)W=λmax​(H)−λmin​(H) give a generator spectral gap independent of the number of simplices at every fixed temperature. We then establish conditions under which the sampler approximately prepares zero-energy (harmonic) states in polynomial evolution time. This provides a conditional convergence guarantee for the state preparation in the thermal approach to quantum topological data analysis.
The phase diagram at T = 0 of a family of spin-1 quantum Ising-Heisenberg models is studied using a mean-field approximation. The model Hamiltonian is characterized by single ion anisotropy terms D μ , (μ = x, y, z ) and by two positive parameters η x , η y measuring the degree of anisotropy of the interaction. They allow to describe a variety of models: among them the spin-1 Ising-Blume-Capel model (η x = η y = 0), and the isotropic Heisenberg model (η x = η y = 1). Both dipolar and quadrupolar order parameters are used to derive the phase diagram in the parameter space (η x , η y , D μ ). The resulting phase diagram is rather complex as it exhibits first and second order critical transitions as well as multicritical points.
I study the mixing time of quantum Gibbs samplers (Davies / Chen– Kastoryano–Gilyén generators) at low temperature. I prove a locality lower bound: any local, KMS–detailed-balanced sampler whose target has an order- parameter bottleneck has an Arrhenius-small spectral gap, by a quantum Cheeger argument, and hence mixing time eΩ(β∆F). The bound is a quantum Cheeger argument and holds for every KMS–detailed-balanced sampler. The coherence cannot lift an order-parameter bottleneck, thereby the obstruction survives quantization. It is not, however, intrinsic to the target. I give a 3-local, detailed-balanced Lindbladian on an enlarged spin+bond register whose spin marginal realizes the Fortuin–Kasteleyn cluster update and which, for commuting ferromagnets, has an inverse-polynomial gap at every temperature and prepares σ in poly(n)log(1/ε) gates. This gives an unconditional separation from the local-reversible class in which locality (not coherence) is the operative resource. As a conjecture, I isolate the genuinely quantum question about cluster updates for noncommuting targets, where no nonnegative bond representation exists and the cluster must be grown coherently.