arXiv:2610.06692
Climbing the Fusion Tree: Center Ordering and Decoding Hierarchy in Non-Abelian Mixed States
Pablo Sala, Vlad Temkin, Cenke Xu, Daniel Podolsky, Ehud Altman
Abstract
We develop an operational approach to strong-to-weak spontaneous symmetry breaking (sw-SSB) of a non-Abelian symmetry group G. We formulate it as the decoding task of distinguishing two strongly symmetric states that differ by a pair of inserted irreps, after both are corrupted by strongly symmetric decoherence. For finite G, this task is dual to distinguishing logical states of the quantum double D(G) under pure-charge noise. We derive a hierarchy of statistical mechanics models describing optimal decoding from the fusion outcomes measured on successively larger nested regions. As for maximum-likelihood decoders of Abelian codes the measured irreps act as quenched disorder obeying a Nishimori-like condition. Strikingly, because local irreps do not determine how they fuse globally, the strong $G\times G$ symmetry is realized only nonlocally, and irreps trivially charged under Z(G) (the center of G) can hide inside noise-generated ones. As a result, the strong symmetry spontaneously breaks down to Z(G), times the weak symmetry. The only transition at nonzero error rate is then an ordering of the center, whose threshold cannot decrease as the hierarchy is ascended. This conclusion holds at any finite level of the hierarchy for non-nilpotent groups. We confirm these predictions with tensor-network calculations for $S_3$ and SU(2). At the first level, the $S_3$ model, whose center is trivial, shows no transition, and the fidelity correlations of all irreps provably decay to non-zero values. The SU(2) model exhibits a $Z_2$ transition consistent with the Nishimori-Ising universality class, where the fidelity correlations of spin-$1/2$ irreps become long-range. The threshold rises from the first to the second level of the hierarchy by $16\%$. Our results provide a systematic framework for studying non-Abelian sw-SSB and for constructing decoders for non Abelian topological codes.
AI Summary
The paper asks how non-Abelian fusion ambiguity affects strong-to-weak spontaneous symmetry breaking (sw-SSB), operationally defined through distinguishability of noisy symmetric states differing by distant irrep-pair insertions. It studies commuting, strongly symmetric channels that inject conjugate-irrep singlets. For finite $G$, the construction is dual to pure-charge noise in quantum-double $D(G)$ codes. Syndrome probabilities are expressed as partition functions of disordered statistical-mechanics models, with a Nishimori-like disorder distribution. Measuring local irreps, then fusion outcomes on increasingly large nested regions, defines a hierarchy of measurement-restricted optimal decoders. Data processing guarantees nondecreasing thresholds, each lower-bounding the intrinsic quantum-fidelity threshold. A hiding mechanism—an inserted irrep can fuse with a noise-generated irrep without changing its measured label—gives positive long-distance classical-fidelity bounds. For $S_3$ and $\mathrm{SU}(2)$, fixed-depth measurements leave only center ordering available at nonzero noise: $S_3$ has no finite-noise transition, while half-integer-spin insertions detect the $\mathbb Z_2$ center of $\mathrm{SU}(2)$. Tensor-network contractions confirm these predictions. For spin-$1/2$ pair noise, the $\mathrm{SU}(2)$ center threshold increases from $p_c^{(1)}=0.1736(4)$ to $p_c^{(2)}=0.2024(6)$, approximately $16\%$, with scaling consistent with Nishimori-Ising universality. An exact calculation on one-dimensional open chains finds exponentially decaying intrinsic correlators at finite noise. The hierarchy need not attain the intrinsic threshold, even with complete fusion-tree measurements. Whether intrinsic $\mathrm{SU}(2)$ sw-SSB has a finite threshold remains open. Adaptive clustering, higher-level contraction costs, and extension to faulty measurements are also unresolved; the analysis restricts noise to the specified commuting-channel family.
Central claim may not hold: The unconditional center-only conclusion fails for allowed noise channels: S3 with only sign-irrep noise reduces to Abelian Z2 decoding and has a nonzero threshold although its center is trivial. For the specified spin-1/2-only SU(2) noise on the square lattice, a spin-5 probe has syndrome support disjoint from the unprobed state, contradicting the claim of long-range fidelity for all integer-spin probes. The hiding argument establishes a necessary central-character condition but does not establish that every center-trivial probe can hide in an irrep accessible under the chosen noise. The topological-memory section incorrectly infers finite intrinsic quantum fidelity from a lower bound on measurement-dependent classical fidelity, despite the inequality relating them running in the opposite direction.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 24 + 15 pages, 10 figures