Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2610.06526

Classical Simulation of Lossy Gaussian Boson Sampling beyond Square-Root Regime

Youngrong Lim

quant-phSubmitted Oct 5, 2026• Announced Oct 6, 2026• 2 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Photon loss makes Gaussian boson sampling easier to simulate classically. A standard approach replaces the lossy input by classical light, and it stays accurate while the mean number of surviving photons grows no faster than the square root of the number $N$ of squeezed inputs at fixed squeezing and accuracy. We prove that this scale is a limit of replacement by classical light. For explicit interferometers, no state with a nonnegative Glauber--Sudarshan $P$ representation, Gaussian or not and however correlated, keeps the error in the photon count distribution small beyond this scale. We then surpass this limit by approximating the detection instead of the input. The sampler evolves the state exactly between detections and, after each detection, replaces the conditional state by a Gaussian with the same covariance. For every interferometer its total variation error is $O(Nη^3)$ at polynomial expected cost, where $η$ is the photon survival probability. The mean surviving photon number can therefore grow as $N^{2/3}$ at fixed accuracy. A separate pair construction reaches $N^{3/4}$ when every input mode is equally squeezed.

AI Summary

The paper asks whether classical simulation of lossy Gaussian boson sampling can exceed the regime of $O(\sqrt N)$ surviving photons at fixed squeezing and accuracy. It separates limitations of classical-light replacement from limitations of classical computation. For an explicit interferometer family built from independent two-mode squeezed pairs, every state with a nonnegative Glauber–Sudarshan $P$ representation—including non-Gaussian, arbitrarily correlated states—has photon-count total variation error at least $1-e^{-c_rN\eta^2}$. A bounded count-probability witness and an affinity bound establish this worst-case barrier. The family itself is efficiently simulable, so this is not a computational hardness result. A different sampler retains the exact Gaussian input and no-click evolution, but replaces each photon-subtracted conditional state by a Gaussian with matching covariance. For every interferometer, including output collisions and additional vacuum modes, its error is $O_r(N\eta^3)$ at polynomial expected arithmetic cost, permitting $O(N^{2/3})$ surviving photons. A covariance-potential drift argument controls accumulated reset errors and rare trajectories. When all modes are equally squeezed ($M=N$), a separate pair-generation/amplification construction achieves error $O_r(\sqrt N\,\eta^2)$ under stated small-loss conditions, permitting $O(N^{3/4})$ surviving photons. These guarantees concern loss decreasing with system size, not fixed nonzero transmission; the general bound is trivial at the cited experimental parameters. Small-system simulations favor a combined displacement-noise/reset variant over classical Gaussian replacement, but no uniform error bound is proved for that variant. Typical-interferometer classical-light barriers and the ultimate efficient-simulation threshold remain open.

No sign of AI-generated textAI use disclosed
GPT-6 and Fable-5.1 were used under the author's direction to assist with exploring and refining mathematical arguments, checking calculations, numerical simulations, and revising the manuscript.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
6+12 pages, 2 figures

Related papers

Boson sampling is fragile to loss

Youngrong Lim

Boson sampling experiments aim to demonstrate quantum computational advantage with increasing numbers of interfering photons. A central question is whether their computational hardness survives under photon loss. We show that even an arbitrarily small nonzero uniform loss rate permits efficient classical sampling in the average case when the rate remains fixed as the system grows. We exploit how loss suppresses correlations involving many photons to approximate the full output distribution using low correlation orders. The resulting samplers run in time polynomial in system size and inverse total variation error, with the error averaged over Haar random interferometers. The results apply to Fock state boson sampling with single-photon states in distinct input modes and arbitrary additional vacuum inputs, and to Gaussian boson sampling with equal squeezing of bounded strength in every input mode. Classical sampling is efficient even when the mean detected photon number grows linearly with system size, showing that large photon counts alone do not ensure computational hardness.

quant-pharXiv:2611.01434•Nov 3, 2026•1 citation

Polynomial-Time Classical Simulation of BosonSampling under Any Constant-Fraction Photon Loss

Byeongseon Go, Hyunseok Jeong

Understanding how photon loss changes the classical complexity of BosonSampling is central to assessing the robustness of near-term photonic quantum advantage. In this work, we present a polynomial-time classical simulation algorithm for lossy BosonSampling that applies whenever a constant fraction of the input photons survives. We consider the standard fixed-loss model, where $N$ input photons propagate through an $M$-mode interferometer and exactly $N-n$ photons are lost uniformly at random, leaving $n$ surviving photons at the output. For any constant surviving fraction $n/N\in(0,1)$, the algorithm samples from a distribution within total variation distance $\varepsilon$ of the fixed-loss BosonSampling distribution with probability at least $1-δ$ over Haar-random interferometers, in time $\operatorname{poly}(M,N,\varepsilon^{-1},δ^{-1})$. We further extend the fixed-loss analysis to the uniform-transmission-loss model and obtain analogous polynomial-time simulability for any fixed transmission rate $η\in(0,1)$. These results substantially extend the known provably simulable regime of $n=O(\sqrt{\varepsilon N})$ surviving photons or $η=O(\sqrt{\varepsilon/N})$ transmission rate, and demonstrate that even the experimentally relevant linear-survival regime can admit efficient classical simulation under the conditions considered here.

quant-pharXiv:2610.27065•Oct 21, 2026•2 citations

Simulating lossy Gaussian boson sampling with matrix-product operators

Minzhao Liu, Changhun Oh, Junyu Liu +2 more

Gaussian boson sampling, a computational model that is widely believed to admit quantum supremacy, has already been experimentally demonstrated and is claimed to surpass the classical simulation capabilities of even the most powerful supercomputers today. However, whether the current approach limited by photon loss and noise in such experiments prescribes a scalable path to quantum advantage is an open question. To understand the effect of photon loss on the scalability of Gaussian boson sampling, we analytically derive the asymptotic operator entanglement entropy scaling, which relates to the simulation complexity. As a result, we observe that efficient tensor network simulations are likely possible under the ${N}_{\text{out}}\ensuremath{\propto}\sqrt{N}$ scaling of the number of surviving photons ${N}_{\text{out}}$ in the number of input photons $N$. We numerically verify this result using a tensor network algorithm with $\mathrm{U}(1)$ symmetry, and we overcome previous challenges due to the large local Hilbert-space dimensions in Gaussian boson sampling with hardware acceleration. Additionally, we observe that increasing the photon number through larger squeezing does not increase the entanglement entropy significantly. Finally, we numerically find the bond dimension necessary for fixed accuracy simulations, providing more direct evidence for the complexity of tensor networks.

arXiv:2301.12814•Physical Review A•Nov 13, 2023•30 citations

Proof of the hiding conjecture for Gaussian boson sampling with an arbitrary number of squeezed input modes

Laura Shou, Alexey V. Gorshkov, Victor Galitski +1 more

Gaussian boson sampling (GBS) is a sampling task proposed to demonstrate quantum advantage. We consider Gaussian boson sampling on $M$ optical modes, with $K$ equally squeezed input modes and $N$ observed photon counts. We complete the proof of the hiding conjecture for Gaussian boson sampling with an arbitrary number of squeezers $K$, which is a part of the argument for classical hardness of GBS. In particular, we show that for any $K$ and $N=o(\sqrt{K})$, the symmetric product $MK^{-1/2}U_{NK}U_{NK}^T$, for $U_{NK}$ the top left $N\times K$ submatrix of an $M\times M$ Haar random unitary $U$, is close in total variation distance to both an $N\times N$ symmetric complex Gaussian matrix $\mathbf G$ with independent entries, and the symmetric product $GG^T/\sqrt{K}$ for $G$ an $N\times K$ matrix of iid standard complex Gaussians. We show however that the density-based instance generating method of [Aaronson and Arkhipov, Theory Comput. 9, 143 (2013), Lemma 5.8] used to efficiently implement a hiding procedure fails for Gaussian boson sampling with $K=cM$ if $c<1/2$. Instead we use approximate instance generating to implement the hiding for the usual classical hardness reduction.

quant-pharXiv:2608.19314•Aug 21, 2026•3 citations

Polynomial-time classical simulation of boson and fermion sampling under thermal loss

Armando Angrisani, Hela Mhiri

Sampling experiments are a leading approach to demonstrating quantum computational advantage, yet their robustness to experimental noise is not completely understood. We develop a common framework for classical simulation of boson and fermion sampling under thermal loss, including pure loss. For Fock-state boson sampling, Gaussian boson sampling with fixed uniform squeezing, and fermion sampling with magic inputs, we obtain polynomial-time sampling at inverse-polynomial total variation error, for any fixed nonzero overall loss rate, and with high probability over Haar-random interferometers. A milder flatness assumption on the ideal output distribution suffices for quasipolynomial-time simulation without Haar randomness. With constant thermal loss per layer, the same flatness assumption gives polynomial-time simulation at logarithmic depth. Our bounds for Fock-state boson sampling cover both dilute and saturated regimes and become stronger near full input filling: when only a bounded number of input modes are empty, the noisy output for Haar-random interferometers converges, as the number of modes grows, to a distribution independent of the interferometer.

arXiv:2611.08444•Nov 5, 2026•0 citations

Optimizing photon-number distributions of Gaussian states in the presence of loss: Towards minimizing the impact of loss in Gaussian boson sampling

Hendrik Ellenberg, René Sondenheimer

We analyze the impact of photon loss on the photon-number statistics of Gaussian states. Specifically, we propose and carefully evaluate several methods to mitigate deviations in the photon-number distributions of lossy (displaced) squeezed vacuum states from those of their lossless counterparts. These methods rely on appropriately redefining the parameters of Gaussian states when the loss budget is known in order to recover, as closely as possible, the desired photon-number distribution associated with each target state. While it is intrinsically hard to directly optimize the photon-number distribution of high-dimensional, correlated multimode Gaussian states, the proposed methods are instead based on optimizing specific key properties such as fidelity, phase-space functions, low-order moments of the underlying photon-number statistics, or overlap with the vacuum state. In particular, our results show that optimizing the fidelity between a pure Gaussian target state and a modified Gaussian state that has passed through a loss channel does typically not result in closeness of the corresponding photon-number distributions. Furthermore, we show that correcting for the vacuum overlap minimizes the deviation in the photon-number distribution for large parameter ranges which we explicitly prove for single-mode squeezed vacuum and provide numerical evidence for general (displaced) squeezed vacuum states. As photon loss is a key limitation for Gaussian boson sampling, our results provide insights into the feasibility and limitations of such photonic quantum simulations in lossy environments and offer guidelines for mitigating these imperfections.

quant-pharXiv:2603.20401•Physical Review A•Mar 24, 2026•0 citations
Photon loss makes Gaussian boson sampling easier to simulate classically. A standard approach replaces the lossy input by classical light, and it stays accurate while the mean number of surviving photons grows no faster than the square root of the number NNN of squeezed inputs at fixed squeezing and accuracy. We prove that this scale is a limit of replacement by classical light. For explicit interferometers, no state with a nonnegative Glauber--Sudarshan PPP representation, Gaussian or not and however correlated, keeps the error in the photon count distribution small beyond this scale. We then surpass this limit by approximating the detection instead of the input. The sampler evolves the state exactly between detections and, after each detection, replaces the conditional state by a Gaussian with the same covariance. For every interferometer its total variation error is O(Nη3)O(Nη^3)O(Nη3) at polynomial expected cost, where ηηη is the photon survival probability. The mean surviving photon number can therefore grow as N2/3N^{2/3}N2/3 at fixed accuracy. A separate pair construction reaches N3/4N^{3/4}N3/4 when every input mode is equally squeezed.
The paper asks whether classical simulation of lossy Gaussian boson sampling can exceed the regime of O(N)O(\sqrt N)O(N​) surviving photons at fixed squeezing and accuracy. It separates limitations of classical-light replacement from limitations of classical computation.
For an explicit interferometer family built from independent two-mode squeezed pairs, every state with a nonnegative Glauber–Sudarshan PPP representation—including non-Gaussian, arbitrarily correlated states—has photon-count total variation error at least 1−e−crNη21-e^{-c_rN\eta^2}1−e−cr​Nη2. A bounded count-probability witness and an affinity bound establish this worst-case barrier. The family itself is efficiently simulable, so this is not a computational hardness result.
A different sampler retains the exact Gaussian input and no-click evolution, but replaces each photon-subtracted conditional state by a Gaussian with matching covariance. For every interferometer, including output collisions and additional vacuum modes, its error is Or(Nη3)O_r(N\eta^3)Or​(Nη3) at polynomial expected arithmetic cost, permitting O(N2/3)O(N^{2/3})O(N2/3) surviving photons. A covariance-potential drift argument controls accumulated reset errors and rare trajectories. When all modes are equally squeezed (M=NM=NM=N), a separate pair-generation/amplification construction achieves error Or(N η2)O_r(\sqrt N\,\eta^2)Or​(N​η2) under stated small-loss conditions, permitting O(N3/4)O(N^{3/4})O(N3/4) surviving photons.
These guarantees concern loss decreasing with system size, not fixed nonzero transmission; the general bound is trivial at the cited experimental parameters. Small-system simulations favor a combined displacement-noise/reset variant over classical Gaussian replacement, but no uniform error bound is proved for that variant. Typical-interferometer classical-light barriers and the ultimate efficient-simulation threshold remain open.
Boson sampling experiments aim to demonstrate quantum computational advantage with increasing numbers of interfering photons. A central question is whether their computational hardness survives under photon loss. We show that even an arbitrarily small nonzero uniform loss rate permits efficient classical sampling in the average case when the rate remains fixed as the system grows. We exploit how loss suppresses correlations involving many photons to approximate the full output distribution using low correlation orders. The resulting samplers run in time polynomial in system size and inverse total variation error, with the error averaged over Haar random interferometers. The results apply to Fock state boson sampling with single-photon states in distinct input modes and arbitrary additional vacuum inputs, and to Gaussian boson sampling with equal squeezing of bounded strength in every input mode. Classical sampling is efficient even when the mean detected photon number grows linearly with system size, showing that large photon counts alone do not ensure computational hardness.
Understanding how photon loss changes the classical complexity of BosonSampling is central to assessing the robustness of near-term photonic quantum advantage. In this work, we present a polynomial-time classical simulation algorithm for lossy BosonSampling that applies whenever a constant fraction of the input photons survives. We consider the standard fixed-loss model, where NNN input photons propagate through an MMM-mode interferometer and exactly N−nN-nN−n photons are lost uniformly at random, leaving nnn surviving photons at the output. For any constant surviving fraction n/N∈(0,1)n/N\in(0,1)n/N∈(0,1), the algorithm samples from a distribution within total variation distance ε\varepsilonε of the fixed-loss BosonSampling distribution with probability at least 1−δ1-δ1−δ over Haar-random interferometers, in time poly⁡(M,N,ε−1,δ−1)\operatorname{poly}(M,N,\varepsilon^{-1},δ^{-1})poly(M,N,ε−1,δ−1). We further extend the fixed-loss analysis to the uniform-transmission-loss model and obtain analogous polynomial-time simulability for any fixed transmission rate η∈(0,1)η\in(0,1)η∈(0,1). These results substantially extend the known provably simulable regime of n=O(εN)n=O(\sqrt{\varepsilon N})n=O(εN​) surviving photons or η=O(ε/N)η=O(\sqrt{\varepsilon/N})η=O(ε/N​) transmission rate, and demonstrate that even the experimentally relevant linear-survival regime can admit efficient classical simulation under the conditions considered here.
Gaussian boson sampling, a computational model that is widely believed to admit quantum supremacy, has already been experimentally demonstrated and is claimed to surpass the classical simulation capabilities of even the most powerful supercomputers today. However, whether the current approach limited by photon loss and noise in such experiments prescribes a scalable path to quantum advantage is an open question. To understand the effect of photon loss on the scalability of Gaussian boson sampling, we analytically derive the asymptotic operator entanglement entropy scaling, which relates to the simulation complexity. As a result, we observe that efficient tensor network simulations are likely possible under the ${N}_{\text{out}}\ensuremath{\propto}\sqrt{N}$ scaling of the number of surviving photons Nout{N}_{\text{out}}Nout​ in the number of input photons NNN. We numerically verify this result using a tensor network algorithm with U(1)\mathrm{U}(1)U(1) symmetry, and we overcome previous challenges due to the large local Hilbert-space dimensions in Gaussian boson sampling with hardware acceleration. Additionally, we observe that increasing the photon number through larger squeezing does not increase the entanglement entropy significantly. Finally, we numerically find the bond dimension necessary for fixed accuracy simulations, providing more direct evidence for the complexity of tensor networks.
Gaussian boson sampling (GBS) is a sampling task proposed to demonstrate quantum advantage. We consider Gaussian boson sampling on MMM optical modes, with KKK equally squeezed input modes and NNN observed photon counts. We complete the proof of the hiding conjecture for Gaussian boson sampling with an arbitrary number of squeezers KKK, which is a part of the argument for classical hardness of GBS. In particular, we show that for any KKK and N=o(K)N=o(\sqrt{K})N=o(K​), the symmetric product MK−1/2UNKUNKTMK^{-1/2}U_{NK}U_{NK}^TMK−1/2UNK​UNKT​, for UNKU_{NK}UNK​ the top left N×KN\times KN×K submatrix of an M×MM\times MM×M Haar random unitary UUU, is close in total variation distance to both an N×NN\times NN×N symmetric complex Gaussian matrix G\mathbf GG with independent entries, and the symmetric product GGT/KGG^T/\sqrt{K}GGT/K​ for GGG an N×KN\times KN×K matrix of iid standard complex Gaussians. We show however that the density-based instance generating method of [Aaronson and Arkhipov, Theory Comput. 9, 143 (2013), Lemma 5.8] used to efficiently implement a hiding procedure fails for Gaussian boson sampling with K=cMK=cMK=cM if c<1/2c<1/2c<1/2. Instead we use approximate instance generating to implement the hiding for the usual classical hardness reduction.
Sampling experiments are a leading approach to demonstrating quantum computational advantage, yet their robustness to experimental noise is not completely understood. We develop a common framework for classical simulation of boson and fermion sampling under thermal loss, including pure loss. For Fock-state boson sampling, Gaussian boson sampling with fixed uniform squeezing, and fermion sampling with magic inputs, we obtain polynomial-time sampling at inverse-polynomial total variation error, for any fixed nonzero overall loss rate, and with high probability over Haar-random interferometers. A milder flatness assumption on the ideal output distribution suffices for quasipolynomial-time simulation without Haar randomness. With constant thermal loss per layer, the same flatness assumption gives polynomial-time simulation at logarithmic depth. Our bounds for Fock-state boson sampling cover both dilute and saturated regimes and become stronger near full input filling: when only a bounded number of input modes are empty, the noisy output for Haar-random interferometers converges, as the number of modes grows, to a distribution independent of the interferometer.
We analyze the impact of photon loss on the photon-number statistics of Gaussian states. Specifically, we propose and carefully evaluate several methods to mitigate deviations in the photon-number distributions of lossy (displaced) squeezed vacuum states from those of their lossless counterparts. These methods rely on appropriately redefining the parameters of Gaussian states when the loss budget is known in order to recover, as closely as possible, the desired photon-number distribution associated with each target state. While it is intrinsically hard to directly optimize the photon-number distribution of high-dimensional, correlated multimode Gaussian states, the proposed methods are instead based on optimizing specific key properties such as fidelity, phase-space functions, low-order moments of the underlying photon-number statistics, or overlap with the vacuum state. In particular, our results show that optimizing the fidelity between a pure Gaussian target state and a modified Gaussian state that has passed through a loss channel does typically not result in closeness of the corresponding photon-number distributions. Furthermore, we show that correcting for the vacuum overlap minimizes the deviation in the photon-number distribution for large parameter ranges which we explicitly prove for single-mode squeezed vacuum and provide numerical evidence for general (displaced) squeezed vacuum states. As photon loss is a key limitation for Gaussian boson sampling, our results provide insights into the feasibility and limitations of such photonic quantum simulations in lossy environments and offer guidelines for mitigating these imperfections.