arXiv:2610.06272
Two-Sided Bounds on Ground State Properties in Lattice Gauge Theories
Eloïc Vallée, Ariel Kelman, Julius Mildenberger, Jordi Tura, Patrick Emonts
Abstract
Gauge theories describe fundamental interactions in the standard model of particle physics and build effective theories in condensed matter physics. Being notoriously hard to simulate, these theories are commonly regularized as lattice gauge theories which can be evaluated with high precision through Monte Carlo algorithms or variational methods. However, Monte Carlo algorithms are not applicable in all regimes due to the sign problem; while variational methods, quantum and classical alike, only give upper-bounds on the ground-state energy. Their precision crucially depends on the chosen ansatz. Here, we present a framework based on a hierarchy of semidefinite programs to yield increasingly good lower-bounds on the ground-state energy and propagate these bounds to extended observables like Wilson loops and mesonic strings. We demonstrate the numerical capabilities by applying the algorithm to a (1+1)-dimensional $\mathbb{Z}_2$ theory with dynamic fermionic matter and its pure-gauge version in (2+1)-dimensions. In both cases, we obtain certified intervals for the ground-state energy. For a one-dimensional system with 129 sites, the certified interval has a relative spread of $0.04\%$. For a two-dimensional system with 97 sites (corresponding to a $7 \times 8$ lattice), the relative spread is $2.08\%$. Beyond energy estimates, the proposed method provides rigorous bounds on both short- and long-range observables such as Wilson loops over multiple plaquettes and the magnitude of the mesonic string. The method can be both used as a computational microscope into many-body physics and a way to certify results of quantum simulators.
AI Summary
Variational calculations of lattice-gauge-theory ground states provide energy upper bounds but generally do not certify their accuracy or that of other observables. This paper combines matrix-product-state (MPS) variational estimates with semidefinite-programming (SDP) relaxations to bracket ground-state energies and bound observable expectation values over an energy-constrained feasible set. The construction uses Pauli moment matrices from an NPA-type hierarchy, evaluated up to level three with restricted spatial range. Gauss-law constraints select the gauge sector, while gauge symmetry block-diagonalizes the moment matrix. Energy bounds become constraints in subsequent SDPs minimizing or maximizing gauge-invariant observables. Additional, empirically chosen monomials allow extended strings and loops to enter the relaxation without including all operators of comparable weight. Demonstrations cover a $(1+1)$-dimensional $\mathbb{Z}_2$ theory with dynamical fermionic matter and a $(2+1)$-dimensional pure-gauge $\mathbb{Z}_2$ theory. Reported energy intervals have relative spreads of $0.04\%$ for a 129-site 1D system and $2.08\%$ for a 97-spin system on a $7\times8$ lattice. Observable calculations include local matter occupations and electric fields, mesonic strings of lengths up to eight, and an eight-body Wilson loop enclosing four plaquettes. Finite hierarchy levels and spatial cutoffs limit tightness, and the 2D MPS upper bounds are not fully converged. Mesonic-string modulus estimates additionally use finite phase sampling and smoothness assumptions, so they lack the unconditional certification of the energy and Hermitian-observable bounds. Higher-dimensional dynamical fermions, compact Lie groups, and non-Abelian theories remain extensions.
Error found: The reported finite-phase mesonic-string calculation does not certify enclosing magnitude bounds, because its sampled feasible polygon is an inner approximation and no quantitative angular-error correction is provided. The main-text prescription for minimizing the mesonic-string magnitude omits radial nonnegativity and instead computes minus the largest feasible modulus, although the appendix supplies the missing constraint.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 14 pages, 10 figures