Quantum error correction (QEC) relies on repeated parity extraction, mid-circuit measurement (MCM), reset, feed-forward, and scheduling, yet these primitives are usually assessed either in isolation or through resource-demanding experiments. We introduce a few-sample benchmark of QEC-relevant primitives based on an MCM implementation of the quantum approximate optimization algorithm (QAOA) with a fixed set of linear parameters (LR-QAOA). For a chosen code, the QAOA Hamiltonian is constructed from its check structure, such that the resulting circuit mimics the syndrome-extraction connectivity and MCM pattern while producing a direct algorithmic signal, the approximation-ratio r. The LR-QAOA depth, defined by the number of QAOA layers, plays a role analogous to the number of repeated syndrome-extraction rounds in a QEC experiment. From QPU executions, the decay of r with depth defines an effective hardware error, which we map to an equivalent two-qubit depolarizing rate λeff. We compare direct and MCM-mediated implementations across 10 QPUs from IBM, IQM, and Quantinuum, with circuits containing up to 2950 MCM operations. On Quantinuum's Helios-1 and H2-1, we run code-structured LR-QAOA benchmarks for surface-code, triangular color-code, and bivariate-bicycle qLDPC Hamiltonians up to 81, 91, and 48 data qubits, respectively, using up to 480 MCM operations. On IBM ibm_phoenix, we implement the surface-code structure and compare the LR-QAOA response with logical-memory experiments, observing a correlation between the benchmark and the logical performance across different regions of the QPU. Its construction and low resource requirements provide a practical benchmark for comparing hardware generations and QEC implementations before full logical-memory experiments are performed.
AI Summary
The paper asks whether QEC-relevant dynamic-circuit performance can be assessed without a full decoded-memory experiment. It constructs fixed-linear-ramp QAOA (LR-QAOA) circuits whose commuting cost terms follow a code’s check supports. Ancilla-mediated interactions exercise parity extraction, mid-circuit measurement (MCM), reset, feed-forward and scheduling; varying QAOA depth probes accumulated noise through the approximation ratio $r$.
Experiments span 10 IBM, IQM and Quantinuum processors, with up to 2,950 MCM operations. For one-dimensional chains, depolarizing-noise simulations calibrate an approximately exponential decay of the normalized signal, yielding an effective per-edge error $\lambda_{\mathrm{eff}}$. Direct and MCM-mediated implementations separate their aggregate hardware costs. Code-structured tests reach 81 surface-code, 91 color-code and 48 bivariate-bicycle data qubits. Quantinuum runs retain signals above the random baseline using 10–50 shots per point. A noise-model analysis predicts that distinguishing a fixed relative error-rate gap $\delta$ requires shots scaling as $1/\delta^2$, with optimal depth increasing inversely with error rate.
Validation against decoded distance-3 surface-code memories uses 11 patches of IBM Phoenix over repeated sessions. Median patch-ranking correlations reach approximately $0.83$ for the $X$-frame benchmark against $|+\rangle_L$ memory and $0.82$ for the corresponding $Z$ comparison.
The effective error is an observable-dependent depolarizing equivalent, not a physical operation error. Logical-performance validation is limited to distance 3 on one device; extension to lower logical-error rates remains untested. The benchmark omits interleaved noncommuting checks and decoding, and an observed basis-dependent decay remains unexplained.
Little sign of AI-generated textMissing comparisonUnclear writing
Error found: The effective-noise and device-ranking sections switch from per-edge to per-gate rates without stating the factor-of-two conversion needed for their stated 1D circuits.
The claimed optimal overlap of 1/e is conditional on approximately constant ideal signal amplitude and sampling variances, rather than a generally established optimum for the depth-dependent LR-QAOA benchmark.
The memory experiment's round counts are documented inconsistently, with round 1 included in Results but absent from the Methods list.
The small-relative-gap expansion incorrectly uses the device separation as its prefactor instead of the ideal-to-random signal amplitude, although the following maximum-separation formula is correct.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
Quantum error correction (QEC) relies on repeated parity extraction, mid-circuit measurement (MCM), reset, feed-forward, and scheduling, yet these primitives are usually assessed either in isolation or through resource-demanding experiments. We introduce a few-sample benchmark of QEC-relevant primitives based on an MCM implementation of the quantum approximate optimization algorithm (QAOA) with a fixed set of linear parameters (LR-QAOA). For a chosen code, the QAOA Hamiltonian is constructed from its check structure, such that the resulting circuit mimics the syndrome-extraction connectivity and MCM pattern while producing a direct algorithmic signal, the approximation-ratio r. The LR-QAOA depth, defined by the number of QAOA layers, plays a role analogous to the number of repeated syndrome-extraction rounds in a QEC experiment. From QPU executions, the decay of r with depth defines an effective hardware error, which we map to an equivalent two-qubit depolarizing rate λeff. We compare direct and MCM-mediated implementations across 10 QPUs from IBM, IQM, and Quantinuum, with circuits containing up to 2950 MCM operations. On Quantinuum's Helios-1 and H2-1, we run code-structured LR-QAOA benchmarks for surface-code, triangular color-code, and bivariate-bicycle qLDPC Hamiltonians up to 81, 91, and 48 data qubits, respectively, using up to 480 MCM operations. On IBM ibm_phoenix, we implement the surface-code structure and compare the LR-QAOA response with logical-memory experiments, observing a correlation between the benchmark and the logical performance across different regions of the QPU. Its construction and low resource requirements provide a practical benchmark for comparing hardware generations and QEC implementations before full logical-memory experiments are performed.
The paper asks whether QEC-relevant dynamic-circuit performance can be assessed without a full decoded-memory experiment. It constructs fixed-linear-ramp QAOA (LR-QAOA) circuits whose commuting cost terms follow a code’s check supports. Ancilla-mediated interactions exercise parity extraction, mid-circuit measurement (MCM), reset, feed-forward and scheduling; varying QAOA depth probes accumulated noise through the approximation ratio r.
Experiments span 10 IBM, IQM and Quantinuum processors, with up to 2,950 MCM operations. For one-dimensional chains, depolarizing-noise simulations calibrate an approximately exponential decay of the normalized signal, yielding an effective per-edge error λeff. Direct and MCM-mediated implementations separate their aggregate hardware costs. Code-structured tests reach 81 surface-code, 91 color-code and 48 bivariate-bicycle data qubits. Quantinuum runs retain signals above the random baseline using 10–50 shots per point. A noise-model analysis predicts that distinguishing a fixed relative error-rate gap δ requires shots scaling as 1/δ2, with optimal depth increasing inversely with error rate.
Validation against decoded distance-3 surface-code memories uses 11 patches of IBM Phoenix over repeated sessions. Median patch-ranking correlations reach approximately 0.83 for the X-frame benchmark against ∣+⟩L memory and 0.82 for the corresponding Z comparison.
The effective error is an observable-dependent depolarizing equivalent, not a physical operation error. Logical-performance validation is limited to distance 3 on one device; extension to lower logical-error rates remains untested. The benchmark omits interleaved noncommuting checks and decoding, and an observed basis-dependent decay remains unexplained.
Scaling up quantum algorithms to tackle high-impact problems in science and industry requires quantum error correction and fault tolerance. While progress has been made in experimentally realizing error-corrected primitives, the end-to-end execution of logical quantum algorithms using only fault-tolerant (FT) components has remained out of reach. We demonstrate the FT and error-corrected execution of two quantum algorithms, the Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (QAOA) and the Harrow-Hassidim-Lloyd (HHL) algorithm applied to the Poisson equation, on Quantinuum H2 and Helios trapped-ion quantum processors using the [[7,1,3]] Steane code. For QAOA circuits on 5 and 6 logical qubits, we show performance improvements from increasing the number of QAOA layers and the number of T gates used to approximate logical rotations, despite increased physical circuit complexity. We further show that QAOA circuits with up to 8 logical qubits and 9 logical T gates perform similarly to unencoded circuits. For the largest QAOA circuits we run, with 12 logical (97 physical) qubits and 2132 physical two-qubit gates, we still observe better-than-random performance. Finally, we show that adding active QEC cycles and increasing the repeat-until-success limit of state preparation subroutines can improve the performance of a quantum algorithm, thereby demonstrating critical capabilities of scalable FT quantum computation. Our results are enabled by an FT logical T gate implementation with an infidelity of ∼2.6(4)×10−3 and dynamic circuits with measurement-dependent feedback. Our work demonstrates near-break-even performance of complex, error-corrected algorithmic quantum circuits using only FT components.
Quantum computers have now surpassed classical simulation limits, yet noise continues to limit their practical utility. As the field shifts from proof-of-principle demonstrations to early deployments, there is no standard method for meaningfully and scalably comparing heterogeneous quantum hardware. Existing benchmarks typically focus on gate-level fidelity or constant-depth circuits, offering limited insight into algorithmic performance at depth. Here we introduce a benchmarking protocol based on the linear ramp quantum approximate optimization algorithm (LR-QAOA), a fixed-parameter, deterministic variant of QAOA. LR-QAOA quantifies a QPU's ability to preserve a coherent signal as circuit depth increases, identifying when performance becomes statistically indistinguishable from random sampling. We apply this protocol to 24 quantum processors from six vendors, testing problems with up to 156 qubits and 10,000 layers across 1D-chains, native layouts, and fully connected topologies. This constitutes the most extensive cross-platform quantum benchmarking effort to date, with circuits reaching a million two-qubit gates. LR-QAOA offers a scalable, unified benchmark across platforms and architectures, making it a tool for tracking performance in quantum computing.
Quantum error correction enables scalable fault-tolerant quantum computation by suppressing logical errors exponentially with code distance once physical error rates fall below a critical threshold. Here we demonstrate below-threshold operation of triangular color codes with distances d=3,5, and 7 on Quantinuum's Helios trapped-ion quantum processor. Leveraging both circuit- and hardware- level leakage reduction schemes, we achieve logical error rates as low as 5−2+4×10−6, and demonstrate error suppression by over an order of magnitude, Λ=12−2+3, with each successive increase in code distance. Moreover, we demonstrate below threshold scaling of error rates for Clifford two-qubit randomized benchmarking circuits when encoded in d=3,5 color codes, achieving logical error rate of 7−3+3×10−5 per logical two-qubit Clifford at distance 5 with a suppression factor of Λ=9−3+8. We compare logical performance for existing near-optimal algorithmic decoders, and both convolutional neural network and transformer-based neural network decoders capable of real-time decoding an order of magnitude faster than the syndrome extraction rate. These results approach the logical error rates required for megaquop-scale quantum computation and indicate that scaled trapped-ion processors could reach application-relevant performance with substantially smaller code blocks than indicated by previous results in other qubit modalities.
Quantum error correction can suppress logical errors exponentially with code distance when physical noise is below threshold. Realizing this on hardware requires tight coordination among quantum gates, mid-circuit measurements, and qubit coherence. Device variation, noise asymmetry, and correlations across space and time complicate the translation of these capabilities into logical error suppression. Here, we study rotated surface-code memory on an IBM Nighthawk r2 processor. Performance varies across tested processor placements, which we attribute to differences in qubit quality. We optimize the code by combining short readout, fused measurement and reset, and an XX echo on data qubits during ancilla readout. Compared with standard readout without reset or echo, the optimized syndrome extraction circuit reduces the median per-round logical error rate by factors of 3.8 in the X basis and 1.4 in the Z basis. In memory experiments of up to 150 rounds, the distance advantage weakens, alongside long-lived correlations that may reflect a persistent error component. Under our optimization recipe, increasing the protected distance from 3 to 6 while holding the other distance fixed reduces the per-round logical error rate from 0.53% to 0.24% in Z memory and from 0.52% to 0.22% in X memory. The corresponding error-suppression factors under maximum-likelihood decoding are 1.68 and 1.85. These results connect circuit compilation and optimization to surface-code memory performance and limitations, and motivate QPU and QEC circuit codesign for fault-tolerant quantum computing primitives on current cloud hardware.
Quantum error correction (QEC) is beginning to enable logical operations that outperform their unencoded physical counterparts, but useful fault-tolerant computation will require more than low-error quantum memory. An effective architecture must orchestrate efficient logical encoding, low-overhead logical operations, and access to the non-Clifford resources required for universal computation. Here, we introduce and experimentally validate such an architecture based on the [[20,2,6]]C4-Helix code, designed for the early fault-tolerant regime. Using Quantinuum Helios, a 98-qubit trapped-ion quantum processor, we experimentally demonstrate the principal components of this architecture: we perform repeated quantum error correction with an error of 4.6−2.6+6.2×10−5 per logical qubit per QEC cycle. We benchmark the complete Clifford group on the two logical qubits of a single codeblock under active error correction, obtaining an error of 2.8−1.6+1.0×10−4 per two-qubit logical Clifford. We further demonstrate a fault-tolerant chain-map interface between C4-Helix and a distance-5 surface code, preparing a heterogeneous three-logical-qubit GHZ state with a fidelity lower bound of 99.925−0.245+0.068%. In each case, the encoded implementation outperforms its corresponding unencoded physical baseline without relying on postselection. Circuit-level simulations indicate that improvements in physical fidelity bring the same architecture into the 10−6-10−8 logical-error regime targeted for early fault-tolerant computation. Together, these results establish C4-Helix as a hardware-validated fault-tolerant architecture rather than a bare quantum memory.
Quantum processors have crossed the one-hundred-qubit mark, but noise continues to limit circuit performance, while full quantum error correction remains too costly for routine use. Error suppression and mitigation therefore play an important role in extracting value from current hardware, yet independent comparisons of commercial solutions on identical workloads and devices remain scarce. We benchmark IBM Qiskit Runtime, Q-CTRL Performance Management, and Qedma QESEM on IBM Pittsburgh, a 156-qubit IBM Quantum Heron r3 processor. For Sampler workloads, we run Bernstein-Vazirani, quantum phase estimation, GHZ-state preparation, and randomized mirror circuits with up to 100 measured qubits, comparing raw execution, IBM measurement twirling, and Q-CTRL. For Estimator workloads, we measure chain-averaged magnetization and correlation observables of an eight-layer transverse-field Ising circuit at 25, 50, and 75 qubits against an exact matrix-product-state reference, comparing IBM raw execution, IBM TREX plus twirling, Q-CTRL, and QESEM. Q-CTRL produced the best results on the three structured Sampler workloads while keeping reported QPU times within the same order as the IBM configurations. Across six Ising observable and system-size cases, aggregate mean absolute error was 0.0883 for IBM raw execution, 0.0807 for IBM TREX plus twirling, 0.0285 for Q-CTRL, and 0.0188 for QESEM. Relative to raw execution, Q-CTRL and QESEM reduced aggregate error by factors of 3.10 and 4.70, respectively, while QESEM used 7.5 to 11.1 times the reported QPU time of Q-CTRL. These results show that managed error suppression and mitigation can substantially improve current hardware performance, but with distinct accuracy and execution-time tradeoffs.