arXiv:2610.05667
Constraints on the Origin of Universal $1/f^2$ Photon-Count Spectra at Baseband
Malvin Carl Teich, Steven B. Lowen
Abstract
A series of 11.6-d-duration photon-counting experiments, employing a broad variety of light sources with different statistical properties and optical spectra, were carried out over a 1.5-yr period. All of the photon-count spectra at baseband followed a common $1/f^2$ form over the frequency range $1 \times 10^{-6} \leqslant f \leqslant 5 \times 10^{-4}$ Hz, corresponding to a timescale range $33$ min $ \leqslant T_f \leqslant 11.6$ d, where $T_f \equiv 1/f$. The lower and upper timescale limits were established by the photodetector noise floor and the duration of the individual experiments, respectively. Unlike ordinary Brownian motion, all of the measured photon-count sample paths exhibited irregular long-timescale fluctuations, with durations ranging from hours to days. It has been established that the photon-count spectra cannot plausibly be ascribed to fluctuations of the current, voltage, or temperature of the source or the detector, nor to technical sources of noise associated with the optical system or local environment. Although the physical origin of the photon-count fluctuations remains unresolved, several heterodox hypotheses are set forth. From a statistical point-of-view, the photon counts appear to follow a doubly stochastic Poisson process with a slowly varying random intensity. Analogous experiments that rely on ionizing radiation and direct-conversion solid-state radiation detectors are proposed.
AI Summary
The paper investigates the origin of approximately $1/f^2$ photon-count spectra at very low frequencies, reviewing previously reported measurements and examining possible explanations. Experiments conducted over 1.5 years used LEDs, superluminescent diodes, laser diodes, incandescent sources, and tritium-driven phosphor luminescence, with SPAD and PMT detection. Most records lasted 11.6 days, with counts collected in 5-s windows at roughly $2\times10^5\,\mathrm{s}^{-1}$. Across these sources, normalized periodograms follow approximately $1/f^2$ over $10^{-6}$–$5\times10^{-4}\,\mathrm{Hz}$, corresponding to 33 minutes–11.6 days. Wavelet variances show corresponding quadratic scaling. Simultaneous split-beam measurements exhibit correlated slow fluctuations in different detectors; shuffling count order removes the spectral structure while preserving count histograms. These observations motivate a Cox-process description: conditionally Poisson counts driven by a slowly fluctuating random intensity, yielding excess count variance and an intensity spectrum above the white shot-noise floor. Comparisons with electrical and temperature records, dark-count measurements, detector technologies, and operating conditions are used to argue against conventional source, detector, optical, and environmental explanations. Betaluminescence establishes that an applied electrical drive is unnecessary. Several technical-noise exclusions rely on consistency across configurations rather than direct quantitative bounds. The physical mechanism remains unresolved. Integrated forcing, mean-reverting diffusion, and intermittent diffusion are discussed as phenomenological possibilities, without identifying a driver. The accessible band is limited by record duration and noise, leaving a possible low-frequency rollover untested. Proposed simultaneous independent-source and direct ionizing-radiation measurements would help distinguish source-specific fluctuations from a common external influence.
Central claim may not hold: Betaluminescence without electrical drive rules out electrical fluctuations as a necessary common cause, not as a cause of the fluctuations measured in electrically driven sources. The paper excludes thermal contributions without supplying temperature-to-count transfer functions or quantitative bounds on the resulting photon-count noise. Recurring 1/f² slopes across different configurations do not establish the paper's broad exclusions of optical, environmental, mechanical, and source-package noise. Tritium's stated half-life predicts a 0.1785% intensity decrease over 11.6 days whose contribution to the betaluminescence periodogram is not quantitatively addressed, although its dominance is not established.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 19 pages, 12 figures, 1 animated video in Ancillary Directory