arXiv:2610.04817
Competing pathways in polaritonic chemistry and general harmonic environments
Jonas Vinther, Leonardo A. Cunha, Johannes Flick
Abstract
Recent experiments suggest that strong light-matter coupling between molecules and cavity modes can significantly modify chemical reaction rates and yields. Despite multiple proposed mechanisms, a clear microscopic understanding of how vibrational strong coupling alters reaction kinetics remains incomplete. Here, we employ a general quantum-dynamical framework for analyzing competing reaction pathways in polaritonic chemistry by considering reaction coordinates with multiple relevant transition frequencies and general harmonic environments. We extend on a tensor-network formulation of the hierarchical equations of motion (HEOM) method to compute probability currents between vibrational states, leveraging a concise formulation for effective spectral densities and a controlled compression of Markovian bath modes into system-level jump operators. This allows us to decompose the resulting state-to-state probability currents, revealing how cavity-induced changes in individual transitions propagate through multistep reaction networks. We find that these local modifications can alter kinetic bottlenecks and selectively redistribute reaction flux between competing pathways, changing branching ratios under irreversible conditions without substantially affecting the equilibrium yield in the reversible regime. Finally, for coupled reaction-coordinate, spectator-mode, and cavity environments, we find structured, asymmetric rate profiles arising from interference between hybridized decay channels. Together, these results provide a mechanistic framework for understanding pathway-specific chemical reactivity under vibrational strong coupling.
AI Summary
How do frequency-selective cavity effects on vibrational transitions propagate through competing chemical reaction pathways? This paper studies that question using a single anharmonic reaction coordinate in piecewise-parabolic double- and triple-well potentials, coupled to harmonic solvent, cavity and optional spectator-mode environments. The calculations combine tensor-network HEOM dynamics with a matrix-inversion expression for effective harmonic-environment spectral densities. State-to-state probability currents are resolved into Hamiltonian, solvent and cavity contributions to identify kinetic bottlenecks. A compression scheme replaces approximately Markovian auxiliary modes with system-level Lindblad jumps: in one benchmark, reducing 19 explicit modes to two changes the extracted reaction rate by $0.102\%$, while retaining one gives a $1.215\%$ deviation. Cavity resonance accelerates selected transitions, but its effect on overall kinetics depends on whether those transitions limit the reaction. In the triple-well example, resonance with one product well increases its formation rate by approximately $2.6\times$ and reduces the competing rate to $0.86\times$ its baseline. The inferred irreversible branching ratio consequently shifts from roughly $1:3$ to $1:1$; the simulated reversible system instead shows negligible cavity-induced equilibrium redistribution. Cavity–spectator hybridization produces geometry-dependent asymmetric rate profiles, interpreted through interfering decay channels and compared with broadened golden-rule predictions. The demonstrated regimes remain perturbative and use simplified single-coordinate models, without resolving collective experimental behavior. Golden-rule agreement requires fitted broadening and rescaling. The compression implementation introduces an additional approximation outside the original universal-Lindblad error bound; stronger coupling and more realistic environments remain future directions.
Error found: The abstract's irreversible branching-ratio finding is supported by applying an irreversible rate formula to a reversible triple-well simulation, without demonstrating that the required irreversible modification preserves the forward rates or their cavity response.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 15 pages, 9 figures. Supplemental: 25 pages, 8 figures, 3 tables