Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2610.04807

Active lattice percolation: an apparently new universality class of percolation transitions

Vernon M. Hughes, David A. Huse

cond-mat.stat-mechquant-phSubmitted Oct 3, 2026• Announced Oct 6, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We investigate a class of dynamic percolation models on a lattice, in which connections are added and removed by a set of local stochastic rules. In particular, the removal of any connection that can result in one connected cluster becoming two (or more) separate clusters is strictly forbidden. These models include and are inspired by a model for local quantum error correction for a toric code studied by Chirame, et al., PRX Quantum 6, 030363 (2025), who identified a phase transition with first-order characteristics, such as bistability and a discontinuous order parameter. We show numerically that this transition is a hybrid percolation transition (HPT), having characteristics of a continuous percolation transition such as diverging critical clusters while at the same transition having discontinuities like a first-order transition. We then modify this model to be fully isotropic, showing that the HPT remains. In both of these models, the steady state on one side of the HPT is an absorbing state; by turning on additional isotropic local stochastic moves, we remove the absorbing state and strongly suppress or remove the first-order transition, leaving an apparently continuous percolation transition. Curiously, the numerically-observed percolation critical exponents do not change significantly between the models with hybrid transitions and the model with an apparently continuous transition. These exponents are significantly different from known percolation transitions, indicating that this may be a new universality class.

AI Summary

The paper asks whether the discontinuous transition in a local toric-code error-correction model also exhibits percolation criticality, and which dynamical ingredients control it. It studies classical bond dynamics on a honeycomb lattice: stochastic updates add, remove, or reroute occupied bonds, but cannot split a connected cluster into separate clusters. Monte Carlo simulations examine the original anisotropic, Toom-inspired model, an isotropic variant, and a variant with additional connectivity-preserving moves that eliminate the absorbing state. Cluster measurements typically use $L=750$, 100 trials, and times up to $t=2000$, supplemented by size- and time-convergence checks. In the original model, the density jumps from approximately $0.2$ to the fully occupied absorbing state, while cluster statistics indicate a diverging length scale. Estimated exponents are $\tau=2.26(10)$, $d_f=1.59(8)$, $z=1.91(6)$, and $\nu=0.67(2)$, supporting a hybrid percolation transition. The isotropic model retains this behavior; its absorption time scales as $T\sim(\gamma_c-\gamma)^{-1.31(5)}$, consistent with the independently estimated $\nu z$ rather than nucleation-driven activation. Removing the absorbing state strongly suppresses the density jump while yielding broadly similar critical exponents. The results suggest a universality class distinct from ordinary percolation, but do not establish it analytically. The nonabsorbing transition could remain weakly first-order. Finite-time and off-critical effects limit exponent estimates, particularly the isotropic fractal dimension, $d_f=1.8(2)$; whether all variants share one universality class remains unresolved. Only three variants are explored, and the necessity of forbidding cluster fragmentation is untested.

No sign of AI-generated text

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
15 pages, 15 figures

Related papers

Nontrivial critical crossover between directed percolation models: Effect of infinitely many absorbing states

Su‐Chan Park, Hyunggyu Park

At nonequilibrium phase transitions into absorbing (trapped) states, it is well known that the directed percolation (DP) critical scaling is shared by two classes of models with a single (S) absorbing state and with infinitely many (IM) absorbing states. We study the crossover behavior in one dimension, arising from a considerable reduction of the number of absorbing states (typically from the IM-type to the S -type DP models) by following two different (excitatory or inhibitory) routes which make the auxiliary field density abruptly jump at the crossover. Along the excitatory route, the system becomes overly activated even for an infinitesimal perturbation and its crossover becomes discontinuous. Along the inhibitory route, we find a continuous crossover with universal crossover exponent phi approximately=1.78(6), which is argued to be equal to nu||, the relaxation time exponent of the DP universality class on a general footing. This conjecture is also confirmed in the case of the directed Ising (parity-conserving) class. Finally, we discuss the effect of diffusion on the IM-type models and suggest an argument why diffusive models with some hybrid-type reactions should belong to the DP class.

arXiv:0706.2973•Physical Review E•Nov 21, 2007•17 citations

Protected percolation: a new universality class pertaining to quantum critical systems

Sean Fayfar

We describe a new universality class - dubbed protected percolation - that we show to be relevant to quantum critical systems. Percolation theory describes phase transitions where long-range order is lost when parts of a system become disconnected from other parts; in the vicinity of the transition, critical behavior is observed, captured by universal power laws. Protected percolation has the added restriction that only sites from the system spanning connection can be removed. We developed a new technique to simulate protected percolation, and we used it to determine the critical exponents of this new universality class in 2, 3, and 4 dimensions. We relate the exponents analytically to those of standard percolation. The Harris criterion predicts whether a phase transition is stable against impurities. We prove that protected percolation violates this criterion in 3 dimensions and higher, implying that impurities result in the loss of universal behavior in systems governed by protected percolation. We investigated the change in critical exponents for various types of impurities, focusing on the case for three dimensions where protected percolation models quantum critical systems. We detail how our simulations can be used for direct comparison to experimental results on such quantum critical systems.

•Dec 1, 2021•0 citations

Active–absorbing-state phase transition beyond directed percolation: A class of exactly solvable models

Urna Basu, P. K. Mohanty

We introduce and solve a model of hardcore particles on a one-dimensional periodic lattice which undergoes an active-absorbing-state phase transition at finite density. In this model, an occupied site is defined to be active if its left neighbor is occupied and the right neighbor is vacant. Particles from such active sites hop stochastically to their right. We show that both the density of active sites and the survival probability vanish as the particle density is decreased below half. The critical exponents and spatial correlations of the model are calculated exactly using the matrix product ansatz. Exact analytical study of several variations of the model reveals that these nonequilibrium phase transitions belong to a new universality class different from the generic active-absorbing-state phase transition, namely, directed percolation.

arXiv:0812.3241•Physical Review E•Apr 27, 2009•58 citations

Critical behavior of the pair contact process

Iwan Jensen

I study a nonequilibrium lattice model, the pair contact process, in which pairs of particles annihilate with probability p or else create a particle at a vacant nearest neighbor. The model exhibits a continuous phase transition from an active state, with an ongoing production of particles, to an absorbing state without pairs. The model has infinitely many absorbing states. Computer simulations in 1D yielded critical exponents consistent with directed percolation, for the first time placing a model with infinitely many absorbing states firmly in the directed-percolation universality class.

Physical Review Letters•Mar 8, 1993•168 citations

Microscopic study of topological phase transitions: Percolation point of view

Keisuke Kataoka, Ikuo Ichinose

We investigate microscopic mechanisms underlying decoherence-induced transitions between topologically ordered states. As a first case study, we analyze the color code using topological entanglement negativity (TEN) and a disorder parameter associated with 1-form symmetry. We interpret these quantities as first- and zeroth-dimensional simplicial homological objects, respectively, and show that the transition can be understood in terms of decoherence percolation. To resolve its local structure, we introduce quasi-local TEN (QLTEN), which visualizes the spatial distribution of local topological properties and the growth of decohered regions. We further introduce explosive percolation (EP), corresponding here to biased decoherence that suppresses the formation of large decohered clusters. As a second case study, we consider the toric code on a triangular lattice under external-field-type decoherence. Numerical results show that QLTEN faithfully captures the emergence of Higgs regions and the survival of logical qubits. Although global TEN, QLTEN clusters, and string operators are strongly correlated in both models, the color code and toric code respond differently to EP patterns. This difference indicates that a universal microscopic description of decoherence-induced topological phase transitions remains challenging even for closely related systems.

quant-pharXiv:2607.26707•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Jul 30, 2026•1 citation

Universality classes of second-order dynamical phase transitions

Daniel ben‐Avraham

The long-time asymptotic properties of numerous dynamical lattice models are described by rich phase diagrams. A suggestive pattern is observed about the universality class of second-order phase transitions in such systems: if the transition occurs from (or into) a single absorbing state (where the order parameter is then zero) then it belongs to the same universality class as directed percolation and Reggeon field theory (RFT). This has been conjectured to be always true for one-component systems by Grassberger and also by Janssen. Grinstein, Lai, and Browne have argued for a possible generalization of this rule to multicomponent systems. I present an example of a one-component lattice model where the second-order transition about a single absorbing state is not in the RFT universality class, thus violating even the weaker conjecture of Grassberger and Janssen.

Physical review. E, Statistical physics, plasmas, fluids, and related interdisciplinary topics•Jan 1, 1993•6 citations
We investigate a class of dynamic percolation models on a lattice, in which connections are added and removed by a set of local stochastic rules. In particular, the removal of any connection that can result in one connected cluster becoming two (or more) separate clusters is strictly forbidden. These models include and are inspired by a model for local quantum error correction for a toric code studied by Chirame, et al., PRX Quantum 6, 030363 (2025), who identified a phase transition with first-order characteristics, such as bistability and a discontinuous order parameter. We show numerically that this transition is a hybrid percolation transition (HPT), having characteristics of a continuous percolation transition such as diverging critical clusters while at the same transition having discontinuities like a first-order transition. We then modify this model to be fully isotropic, showing that the HPT remains. In both of these models, the steady state on one side of the HPT is an absorbing state; by turning on additional isotropic local stochastic moves, we remove the absorbing state and strongly suppress or remove the first-order transition, leaving an apparently continuous percolation transition. Curiously, the numerically-observed percolation critical exponents do not change significantly between the models with hybrid transitions and the model with an apparently continuous transition. These exponents are significantly different from known percolation transitions, indicating that this may be a new universality class.
The paper asks whether the discontinuous transition in a local toric-code error-correction model also exhibits percolation criticality, and which dynamical ingredients control it. It studies classical bond dynamics on a honeycomb lattice: stochastic updates add, remove, or reroute occupied bonds, but cannot split a connected cluster into separate clusters.
Monte Carlo simulations examine the original anisotropic, Toom-inspired model, an isotropic variant, and a variant with additional connectivity-preserving moves that eliminate the absorbing state. Cluster measurements typically use L=750L=750L=750, 100 trials, and times up to t=2000t=2000t=2000, supplemented by size- and time-convergence checks. In the original model, the density jumps from approximately 0.20.20.2 to the fully occupied absorbing state, while cluster statistics indicate a diverging length scale. Estimated exponents are τ=2.26(10)\tau=2.26(10)τ=2.26(10), df=1.59(8)d_f=1.59(8)df​=1.59(8), z=1.91(6)z=1.91(6)z=1.91(6), and ν=0.67(2)\nu=0.67(2)ν=0.67(2), supporting a hybrid percolation transition. The isotropic model retains this behavior; its absorption time scales as T∼(γc−γ)−1.31(5)T\sim(\gamma_c-\gamma)^{-1.31(5)}T∼(γc​−γ)−1.31(5), consistent with the independently estimated νz\nu zνz rather than nucleation-driven activation.
Removing the absorbing state strongly suppresses the density jump while yielding broadly similar critical exponents. The results suggest a universality class distinct from ordinary percolation, but do not establish it analytically. The nonabsorbing transition could remain weakly first-order. Finite-time and off-critical effects limit exponent estimates, particularly the isotropic fractal dimension, df=1.8(2)d_f=1.8(2)df​=1.8(2); whether all variants share one universality class remains unresolved. Only three variants are explored, and the necessity of forbidding cluster fragmentation is untested.
At nonequilibrium phase transitions into absorbing (trapped) states, it is well known that the directed percolation (DP) critical scaling is shared by two classes of models with a single (S) absorbing state and with infinitely many (IM) absorbing states. We study the crossover behavior in one dimension, arising from a considerable reduction of the number of absorbing states (typically from the IM-type to the S -type DP models) by following two different (excitatory or inhibitory) routes which make the auxiliary field density abruptly jump at the crossover. Along the excitatory route, the system becomes overly activated even for an infinitesimal perturbation and its crossover becomes discontinuous. Along the inhibitory route, we find a continuous crossover with universal crossover exponent phi approximately=1.78(6), which is argued to be equal to nu||, the relaxation time exponent of the DP universality class on a general footing. This conjecture is also confirmed in the case of the directed Ising (parity-conserving) class. Finally, we discuss the effect of diffusion on the IM-type models and suggest an argument why diffusive models with some hybrid-type reactions should belong to the DP class.
We describe a new universality class - dubbed protected percolation - that we show to be relevant to quantum critical systems. Percolation theory describes phase transitions where long-range order is lost when parts of a system become disconnected from other parts; in the vicinity of the transition, critical behavior is observed, captured by universal power laws. Protected percolation has the added restriction that only sites from the system spanning connection can be removed. We developed a new technique to simulate protected percolation, and we used it to determine the critical exponents of this new universality class in 2, 3, and 4 dimensions. We relate the exponents analytically to those of standard percolation. The Harris criterion predicts whether a phase transition is stable against impurities. We prove that protected percolation violates this criterion in 3 dimensions and higher, implying that impurities result in the loss of universal behavior in systems governed by protected percolation. We investigated the change in critical exponents for various types of impurities, focusing on the case for three dimensions where protected percolation models quantum critical systems. We detail how our simulations can be used for direct comparison to experimental results on such quantum critical systems.
We introduce and solve a model of hardcore particles on a one-dimensional periodic lattice which undergoes an active-absorbing-state phase transition at finite density. In this model, an occupied site is defined to be active if its left neighbor is occupied and the right neighbor is vacant. Particles from such active sites hop stochastically to their right. We show that both the density of active sites and the survival probability vanish as the particle density is decreased below half. The critical exponents and spatial correlations of the model are calculated exactly using the matrix product ansatz. Exact analytical study of several variations of the model reveals that these nonequilibrium phase transitions belong to a new universality class different from the generic active-absorbing-state phase transition, namely, directed percolation.
I study a nonequilibrium lattice model, the pair contact process, in which pairs of particles annihilate with probability p or else create a particle at a vacant nearest neighbor. The model exhibits a continuous phase transition from an active state, with an ongoing production of particles, to an absorbing state without pairs. The model has infinitely many absorbing states. Computer simulations in 1D yielded critical exponents consistent with directed percolation, for the first time placing a model with infinitely many absorbing states firmly in the directed-percolation universality class.
We investigate microscopic mechanisms underlying decoherence-induced transitions between topologically ordered states. As a first case study, we analyze the color code using topological entanglement negativity (TEN) and a disorder parameter associated with 1-form symmetry. We interpret these quantities as first- and zeroth-dimensional simplicial homological objects, respectively, and show that the transition can be understood in terms of decoherence percolation. To resolve its local structure, we introduce quasi-local TEN (QLTEN), which visualizes the spatial distribution of local topological properties and the growth of decohered regions. We further introduce explosive percolation (EP), corresponding here to biased decoherence that suppresses the formation of large decohered clusters. As a second case study, we consider the toric code on a triangular lattice under external-field-type decoherence. Numerical results show that QLTEN faithfully captures the emergence of Higgs regions and the survival of logical qubits. Although global TEN, QLTEN clusters, and string operators are strongly correlated in both models, the color code and toric code respond differently to EP patterns. This difference indicates that a universal microscopic description of decoherence-induced topological phase transitions remains challenging even for closely related systems.
The long-time asymptotic properties of numerous dynamical lattice models are described by rich phase diagrams. A suggestive pattern is observed about the universality class of second-order phase transitions in such systems: if the transition occurs from (or into) a single absorbing state (where the order parameter is then zero) then it belongs to the same universality class as directed percolation and Reggeon field theory (RFT). This has been conjectured to be always true for one-component systems by Grassberger and also by Janssen. Grinstein, Lai, and Browne have argued for a possible generalization of this rule to multicomponent systems. I present an example of a one-component lattice model where the second-order transition about a single absorbing state is not in the RFT universality class, thus violating even the weaker conjecture of Grassberger and Janssen.