Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2610.04534

Beyond ideal cavities: quantifying the impact of cavity dissipation on light-matter strong coupling

Giovanna Bruno, Enrico Busani, Lorenzo Gialli, Rosario Roberto Riso, Enrico Ronca

physics.chem-phquant-phSubmitted Oct 3, 2026• Announced Oct 6, 2026• 2 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Cavity Quantum Electrodynamics (Cavity-QED) offers a powerful framework for controlling light-matter interactions, yet first-principles approaches commonly assume ideal, lossless cavity fields. Here, we introduce a minimal extension to the Pauli-Fierz Hamiltonian that accounts for cavity dissipation through the experimentally accessible cavity quality factor Q. The electromagnetic field is described as a damped harmonic oscillator within the very weak damping approximation. In this framework, cavity losses only enter the light-matter interaction and dipole self-energy terms, without introducing additional photonic degrees of freedom. A time-dependent unitary transformation yields a real-valued Hermitian Hamiltonian that can be incorporated into existing ab-initio QED methods without additional computational cost or changes in scaling. We combined the approach to the QED-CCSD method and investigated the effects of cavity dissipation on the optical spectrum of a p-nitroaniline molecule under strong light-matter coupling. We found that, for realistic quality factors, cavity dissipation can reduce the Rabi splitting by more than 20% compared to the ideal-cavity limit, even though the system remains in the strong-coupling regime. Convergence towards the ideal-cavity limit then requires substantially higher quality factors than those needed to establish strong coupling. These results demonstrate that cavity dissipation can significantly affect polaritonic energetics and highlight the importance of incorporating experimentally realistic cavity losses into quantitative ab-initio Cavity-QED simulations to accurately guide experimental protocols.

AI Summary

The paper asks how finite cavity lifetimes affect polaritonic energies in ab-initio strong-coupling calculations, even when Rabi splitting remains observable. It proposes a phenomenological extension of the Pauli–Fierz Hamiltonian parameterized by the cavity quality factor $Q$, with decay rate $\kappa=\omega/Q$. The construction treats the field as a weakly damped harmonic oscillator, neglects the damping-induced frequency shift, and expands its vector potential to first order in time. Pointwise unitary transformations and averaging over a chosen interval $\tau$ yield a real, Hermitian effective Hamiltonian. Losses rescale the light–matter interaction and dipole self-energy prefactors by $1-\omega\tau/(4Q)$ and $1-\omega\tau/(2Q)$, respectively, without adding reservoir modes or changing computational scaling. QED-CCSD calculations for a single p-nitroaniline molecule give a minimum polaritonic splitting of $1.250$ eV in the ideal-cavity limit and $0.979$ eV for $Q=60$ and $\tau=5.01$ fs, a $21.68\%$ reduction. The minimum-gap cavity frequency red-shifts by approximately $0.08$ eV. At fixed frequency $5.66$ eV and $\tau=2.33$ fs, the splitting differs from the ideal value by less than $1\%$ at $Q=640$ and by less than $5$ meV above approximately $Q=1500$. The formulation is restricted to very weak damping and a leading-order temporal expansion; the averaging interval is chosen no longer than the cavity energy lifetime. It neglects mirror-induced dispersion. The demonstration uses single-mode, long-wavelength and Born–Oppenheimer approximations, and a single-emitter coupling explicitly acknowledged to be experimentally unrealizable.

Little sign of AI-generated textStrong assumptionsPossible errorMissing comparisonOverclaims

Central claim may not hold: The effective Hamiltonian and reported quality-factor convergence thresholds depend on a separately selected averaging interval τ whose connection to the measured optical spectrum is not established. The reported large corrections use the first-order temporal expansion outside its controlled regime, including intervals reaching a full cavity energy lifetime. The eigenvalues of the proposed time-averaged Hermitian Hamiltonian are interpreted as loss-modified polaritonic spectral energies without establishing their relation to an open-system response spectrum.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
18 pages, 4 figure

Related papers

Dissipation in the broadband and ultrastrong coupling regimes of cavity quantum electrodynamics: an ab initio quantized quasinormal mode approach

Chris Gustin, Juanjuan Ren, Sebastian Franke +1 more

Phenomenological approaches to photon loss have long been the workhorse of cavity-QED, but prove inadequate in the presence of sufficiently broadband light-matter interactions. We present a rigorous and ab initio derivation of a quantum master equation for a quantized optical cavity mode coupled to a dipole, using a quasinormal mode (QNM) quantization procedure for plasmonic and dielectric open-system cavity-QED, which is valid in broadband light-matter interaction regimes, including ultrastrong coupling (USC). The theory supports general three-dimensional resonators with arbitrary dispersion and loss, and thus can be applied to a wide range of realistic open cavities. Our ab initio and gauge-invariant approach fully recovers a recent result for the spectral density of a quantized cavity with a single dipole and reveals important departures from previous heuristic assumptions about system-reservoir coupling. We identify a new criterion for what we term the "broadband dissipative" regime of cavity-QED, where phenomenological models require corrections in accordance with the intrinsic and spatially-dependent complex phase of the QNM, and also shed light on fundamental limits to single-mode models in extreme coupling regimes. Using experimentally motivated plasmonic and dielectric cavity examples, we show validity ranges of our QNM master equation and spectral USC calculations, and discuss prospects for near-term experimental observation of the broadband dissipative effects.

arXiv:2507.21408•Light Science & Applications•Aug 26, 2026•6 citations

New Hamiltonian formalisms for cavity quantum electrodynamics

Taylor, Michael Anthony David, Pengfei Huo

Coupling matter to the quantized electromagnetic field inside an optical cavity creates a set of new photon-matter hybrid states, the polariton states. These polariton states have delocalized excitations between the matter and photonic degrees of freedom, which have been shown to facilitate new chemical reactivities in molecular systems and to modify material properties in condensed matter systems. Theoretical investigations play a crucial role in understanding new principles in this emerging field and have suggested interesting mechanisms enabled by cavity quantum electrodynamics (QED). In recent years, experimental capabilities have gone to coupling strengths that cannot be described by the Jaynes-Cummings Hamiltonian, revitalizing theoretical research into new Hamiltonian formalisms for cavity QED. Developing exact unitary transformations of the Hamiltonian that reduce the computational cost of simulations and provide novel physical insights is an exciting new research direction with the potential of having great impact in the field. The problem now arises: how to properly truncate an infinite basis Hamiltonian to form a computable eigenproblem? Due to the gauge freedom of QED, there are many equivalent gauges in which to represent the full-space QED Hamiltonian. The gauge ambiguity arises upon truncation of the exact Hamiltonian under different gauges, giving non-equivalent results. In this thesis, we resolve this ambiguity by redefining the gauge transformation in the truncated basis for both matter truncation and photonic mode truncation. We then perform a case study of molecular cavity QED using the new Polarized Fock State Hamiltonian formalism. We provide a simple and intuitive theory to explain how coupling a molecule to an optical cavity can modify ground-state chemical reactivity by exploiting intrinsic quantum behaviors of light-matter interactions. Going beyond existing formalisms, we then develop a new theoretical framework for describing light-matter interactions in cavity quantum electrodynamics (QED), optimized for efficient convergence at arbitrarily strong coupling strengths and is naturally applicable to low-dimensional materials. The Reciprocal Asymptotically Decoupled (RAD)Hamiltonian allows for a fast convergence of the polariton eigenspectrum with a much smaller matter and photon basis and also allows one to go beyond the commonly used long-wavelength approximation, which ensures the conservation of momentum between light and matter.

•Jan 1, 2025•0 citations

Light-induced nonadiabatic dissipative quantum dynamics of the Na2 molecule

Patrick Barron, Krisztián Szabó, Gábor J. Halász +2 more

Strong light-matter coupling between molecules and optical or plasmonic cavity modes has emerged as a promising platform for advancing photonics, materials science, and chemistry. However, optical cavities and plasmonic resonators in particular are inherently lossy systems characterized by finite photon lifetimes. Accurate theoretical descriptions of molecular dynamics under strong coupling therefore require a proper treatment of cavity losses. In this work, we compare three theoretical approaches for modeling dissipative molecule-cavity dynamics within a realistic parameter regime: the Lindblad master equation, the stochastic Schrödinger equation, and the non-Hermitian Schrödinger equation. As an example, we consider the two lowest energy state of Na2 molecule coupled to a cavity mode and analyze the time evolution of the excited-state population and the mean photon number. Our results demonstrate that the stochastic Schrödinger equation provides an accurate and computationally efficient alternative to the Lindblad master equation, while the non-Hermitian Schrödinger approach is found to be applicable only within a limited range of conditions. Furthermore, we show that inclusion of molecular rotation leads to rotational-vibrational-photonic coupling and gives rise to pronounced nonadiabatic dynamics through light-induced conical intersections. These findings highlight the importance of both dissipation and rotational degrees of freedom for a realistic description of molecular dynamics in strongly coupled molecule-cavity systems.

quant-pharXiv:2606.15292•Jun 16, 2026

Multiple interacting photonic modes in strongly coupled organic microcavities

Felipe Herrera, William L. Barnes

Room-temperature cavity quantum electrodynamics with molecular materials in optical cavities offers exciting prospects for controlling electronic, nuclear and photonic degrees of freedom for applications in physics, chemistry and materials science. However, achieving strong coupling with molecular ensembles typically requires high molecular densities and substantial electromagnetic-field confinement. These conditions usually involve a significant degree of molecular disorder and a highly structured photonic density of states. It remains unclear to what extent these additional complexities modify the usual physical picture of strong coupling developed for atoms and inorganic semiconductors. Using a microscopic quantum description of molecular ensembles in realistic multimode optical resonators, we show that the emergence of vacuum Rabi splitting in linear spectroscopy is a necessary but not sufficient metric of coherent admixing between light and matter. In low-finesse multi-mode situations, we find that molecular dipoles can be partially hybridized with photonic dissipation channels associated with off-resonant cavity modes. These vacuum-induced dissipative processes ultimately limit the extent of light-matter coherence that the system can sustain.This article is part of the theme issue 'The quantum theory of light'.

arXiv:2407.04904•Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society A Mathematical Physical and Engineering Sciences•Dec 24, 2024•9 citations

Relevance of the Quadratic Diamagnetic and Self-Polarization Terms in Cavity Quantum Electrodynamics

Christian Schäfer, Michael Ruggenthaler, Vasil Rokaj +1 more

Experiments at the interface of quantum optics and chemistry have revealed that strong coupling between light and matter can substantially modify the chemical and physical properties of molecules and solids. While the theoretical description of such situations is usually based on nonrelativistic quantum electrodynamics, which contains quadratic light-matter coupling terms, it is commonplace to disregard these terms and restrict the treatment to purely bilinear couplings. In this work, we clarify the physical origin and the substantial impact of the most common quadratic terms, the diamagnetic and self-polarization terms, and highlight why neglecting them can lead to rather unphysical results. Specifically, we demonstrate their relevance by showing that neglecting these terms leads to the loss of gauge invariance, basis set dependence, disintegration (loss of bound states) of any system in the basis set limit, unphysical radiation of the ground state, and an artificial dependence on the static dipole. Besides providing important guidance for modeling of strongly coupled light-matter systems, the presented results also indicate conditions under which those effects might become accessible.

arXiv:1911.08427•ACS Photonics•Feb 26, 2020•202 citations

Cavity Quantum Electrodynamics at Arbitrary Light-Matter Coupling Strengths

Yuto Ashida, Ataç İmamoğlu, Eugene Demler

Quantum light-matter systems at strong coupling are notoriously challenging to analyze due to the need to include states with many excitations in every coupled mode. We propose a nonperturbative approach to analyze light-matter correlations at all interaction strengths. The key element of our approach is a unitary transformation that achieves asymptotic decoupling of light and matter degrees of freedom in the limit where light-matter interaction becomes the dominant energy scale. In the transformed frame, truncation of the matter or photon Hilbert space is increasingly well justified at larger coupling, enabling one to systematically derive low-energy effective models, such as tight-binding Hamiltonians. We demonstrate the versatility of our approach by applying it to concrete models relevant to electrons in crystal potential and electric dipoles interacting with a cavity mode. A generalization to the case of spatially varying electromagnetic modes is also discussed.

arXiv:2010.03583•Physical Review Letters•Apr 13, 2021•106 citations
Cavity Quantum Electrodynamics (Cavity-QED) offers a powerful framework for controlling light-matter interactions, yet first-principles approaches commonly assume ideal, lossless cavity fields. Here, we introduce a minimal extension to the Pauli-Fierz Hamiltonian that accounts for cavity dissipation through the experimentally accessible cavity quality factor Q. The electromagnetic field is described as a damped harmonic oscillator within the very weak damping approximation. In this framework, cavity losses only enter the light-matter interaction and dipole self-energy terms, without introducing additional photonic degrees of freedom. A time-dependent unitary transformation yields a real-valued Hermitian Hamiltonian that can be incorporated into existing ab-initio QED methods without additional computational cost or changes in scaling. We combined the approach to the QED-CCSD method and investigated the effects of cavity dissipation on the optical spectrum of a p-nitroaniline molecule under strong light-matter coupling. We found that, for realistic quality factors, cavity dissipation can reduce the Rabi splitting by more than 20% compared to the ideal-cavity limit, even though the system remains in the strong-coupling regime. Convergence towards the ideal-cavity limit then requires substantially higher quality factors than those needed to establish strong coupling. These results demonstrate that cavity dissipation can significantly affect polaritonic energetics and highlight the importance of incorporating experimentally realistic cavity losses into quantitative ab-initio Cavity-QED simulations to accurately guide experimental protocols.
The paper asks how finite cavity lifetimes affect polaritonic energies in ab-initio strong-coupling calculations, even when Rabi splitting remains observable. It proposes a phenomenological extension of the Pauli–Fierz Hamiltonian parameterized by the cavity quality factor QQQ, with decay rate κ=ω/Q\kappa=\omega/Qκ=ω/Q.
The construction treats the field as a weakly damped harmonic oscillator, neglects the damping-induced frequency shift, and expands its vector potential to first order in time. Pointwise unitary transformations and averaging over a chosen interval τ\tauτ yield a real, Hermitian effective Hamiltonian. Losses rescale the light–matter interaction and dipole self-energy prefactors by 1−ωτ/(4Q)1-\omega\tau/(4Q)1−ωτ/(4Q) and 1−ωτ/(2Q)1-\omega\tau/(2Q)1−ωτ/(2Q), respectively, without adding reservoir modes or changing computational scaling.
QED-CCSD calculations for a single p-nitroaniline molecule give a minimum polaritonic splitting of 1.2501.2501.250 eV in the ideal-cavity limit and 0.9790.9790.979 eV for Q=60Q=60Q=60 and τ=5.01\tau=5.01τ=5.01 fs, a 21.68%21.68\%21.68% reduction. The minimum-gap cavity frequency red-shifts by approximately 0.080.080.08 eV. At fixed frequency 5.665.665.66 eV and τ=2.33\tau=2.33τ=2.33 fs, the splitting differs from the ideal value by less than 1%1\%1% at Q=640Q=640Q=640 and by less than 555 meV above approximately Q=1500Q=1500Q=1500.
The formulation is restricted to very weak damping and a leading-order temporal expansion; the averaging interval is chosen no longer than the cavity energy lifetime. It neglects mirror-induced dispersion. The demonstration uses single-mode, long-wavelength and Born–Oppenheimer approximations, and a single-emitter coupling explicitly acknowledged to be experimentally unrealizable.
Phenomenological approaches to photon loss have long been the workhorse of cavity-QED, but prove inadequate in the presence of sufficiently broadband light-matter interactions. We present a rigorous and ab initio derivation of a quantum master equation for a quantized optical cavity mode coupled to a dipole, using a quasinormal mode (QNM) quantization procedure for plasmonic and dielectric open-system cavity-QED, which is valid in broadband light-matter interaction regimes, including ultrastrong coupling (USC). The theory supports general three-dimensional resonators with arbitrary dispersion and loss, and thus can be applied to a wide range of realistic open cavities. Our ab initio and gauge-invariant approach fully recovers a recent result for the spectral density of a quantized cavity with a single dipole and reveals important departures from previous heuristic assumptions about system-reservoir coupling. We identify a new criterion for what we term the "broadband dissipative" regime of cavity-QED, where phenomenological models require corrections in accordance with the intrinsic and spatially-dependent complex phase of the QNM, and also shed light on fundamental limits to single-mode models in extreme coupling regimes. Using experimentally motivated plasmonic and dielectric cavity examples, we show validity ranges of our QNM master equation and spectral USC calculations, and discuss prospects for near-term experimental observation of the broadband dissipative effects.
Coupling matter to the quantized electromagnetic field inside an optical cavity creates a set of new photon-matter hybrid states, the polariton states. These polariton states have delocalized excitations between the matter and photonic degrees of freedom, which have been shown to facilitate new chemical reactivities in molecular systems and to modify material properties in condensed matter systems. Theoretical investigations play a crucial role in understanding new principles in this emerging field and have suggested interesting mechanisms enabled by cavity quantum electrodynamics (QED). In recent years, experimental capabilities have gone to coupling strengths that cannot be described by the Jaynes-Cummings Hamiltonian, revitalizing theoretical research into new Hamiltonian formalisms for cavity QED. Developing exact unitary transformations of the Hamiltonian that reduce the computational cost of simulations and provide novel physical insights is an exciting new research direction with the potential of having great impact in the field. The problem now arises: how to properly truncate an infinite basis Hamiltonian to form a computable eigenproblem? Due to the gauge freedom of QED, there are many equivalent gauges in which to represent the full-space QED Hamiltonian. The gauge ambiguity arises upon truncation of the exact Hamiltonian under different gauges, giving non-equivalent results. In this thesis, we resolve this ambiguity by redefining the gauge transformation in the truncated basis for both matter truncation and photonic mode truncation. We then perform a case study of molecular cavity QED using the new Polarized Fock State Hamiltonian formalism. We provide a simple and intuitive theory to explain how coupling a molecule to an optical cavity can modify ground-state chemical reactivity by exploiting intrinsic quantum behaviors of light-matter interactions. Going beyond existing formalisms, we then develop a new theoretical framework for describing light-matter interactions in cavity quantum electrodynamics (QED), optimized for efficient convergence at arbitrarily strong coupling strengths and is naturally applicable to low-dimensional materials. The Reciprocal Asymptotically Decoupled (RAD)Hamiltonian allows for a fast convergence of the polariton eigenspectrum with a much smaller matter and photon basis and also allows one to go beyond the commonly used long-wavelength approximation, which ensures the conservation of momentum between light and matter.
Strong light-matter coupling between molecules and optical or plasmonic cavity modes has emerged as a promising platform for advancing photonics, materials science, and chemistry. However, optical cavities and plasmonic resonators in particular are inherently lossy systems characterized by finite photon lifetimes. Accurate theoretical descriptions of molecular dynamics under strong coupling therefore require a proper treatment of cavity losses. In this work, we compare three theoretical approaches for modeling dissipative molecule-cavity dynamics within a realistic parameter regime: the Lindblad master equation, the stochastic Schrödinger equation, and the non-Hermitian Schrödinger equation. As an example, we consider the two lowest energy state of Na2 molecule coupled to a cavity mode and analyze the time evolution of the excited-state population and the mean photon number. Our results demonstrate that the stochastic Schrödinger equation provides an accurate and computationally efficient alternative to the Lindblad master equation, while the non-Hermitian Schrödinger approach is found to be applicable only within a limited range of conditions. Furthermore, we show that inclusion of molecular rotation leads to rotational-vibrational-photonic coupling and gives rise to pronounced nonadiabatic dynamics through light-induced conical intersections. These findings highlight the importance of both dissipation and rotational degrees of freedom for a realistic description of molecular dynamics in strongly coupled molecule-cavity systems.
Room-temperature cavity quantum electrodynamics with molecular materials in optical cavities offers exciting prospects for controlling electronic, nuclear and photonic degrees of freedom for applications in physics, chemistry and materials science. However, achieving strong coupling with molecular ensembles typically requires high molecular densities and substantial electromagnetic-field confinement. These conditions usually involve a significant degree of molecular disorder and a highly structured photonic density of states. It remains unclear to what extent these additional complexities modify the usual physical picture of strong coupling developed for atoms and inorganic semiconductors. Using a microscopic quantum description of molecular ensembles in realistic multimode optical resonators, we show that the emergence of vacuum Rabi splitting in linear spectroscopy is a necessary but not sufficient metric of coherent admixing between light and matter. In low-finesse multi-mode situations, we find that molecular dipoles can be partially hybridized with photonic dissipation channels associated with off-resonant cavity modes. These vacuum-induced dissipative processes ultimately limit the extent of light-matter coherence that the system can sustain.This article is part of the theme issue 'The quantum theory of light'.
Experiments at the interface of quantum optics and chemistry have revealed that strong coupling between light and matter can substantially modify the chemical and physical properties of molecules and solids. While the theoretical description of such situations is usually based on nonrelativistic quantum electrodynamics, which contains quadratic light-matter coupling terms, it is commonplace to disregard these terms and restrict the treatment to purely bilinear couplings. In this work, we clarify the physical origin and the substantial impact of the most common quadratic terms, the diamagnetic and self-polarization terms, and highlight why neglecting them can lead to rather unphysical results. Specifically, we demonstrate their relevance by showing that neglecting these terms leads to the loss of gauge invariance, basis set dependence, disintegration (loss of bound states) of any system in the basis set limit, unphysical radiation of the ground state, and an artificial dependence on the static dipole. Besides providing important guidance for modeling of strongly coupled light-matter systems, the presented results also indicate conditions under which those effects might become accessible.
Quantum light-matter systems at strong coupling are notoriously challenging to analyze due to the need to include states with many excitations in every coupled mode. We propose a nonperturbative approach to analyze light-matter correlations at all interaction strengths. The key element of our approach is a unitary transformation that achieves asymptotic decoupling of light and matter degrees of freedom in the limit where light-matter interaction becomes the dominant energy scale. In the transformed frame, truncation of the matter or photon Hilbert space is increasingly well justified at larger coupling, enabling one to systematically derive low-energy effective models, such as tight-binding Hamiltonians. We demonstrate the versatility of our approach by applying it to concrete models relevant to electrons in crystal potential and electric dipoles interacting with a cavity mode. A generalization to the case of spatially varying electromagnetic modes is also discussed.