arXiv:2610.03979
Foundational puzzles on quantum universality: From Wigner's friend to black holes
Laurens Walleghem
Abstract
Despite its remarkable empirical success and predictive power, quantum theory is riddled with mysteries. One such conceptual puzzle is the measurement problem: why do quantum systems in superposition collapse to a single-valued outcome upon being measured? The scenario of Wigner's friend illustrates this tension, with recent extensions deriving strong no-go results for the nature of reality. Another fundamental puzzle arises at the interface of quantum theory and general relativity---the black hole information paradox. This thesis further explores these two foundational paradoxes. Part I of this thesis focuses on extensions of the Wigner's friend scenario. We introduce several novel extended Wigner's friend arguments, and establish connections with notions of nonclassicality, i.e. the study of quantum phenomena that evade classical explanation. Key results are a refined version of the Frauchiger--Renner paradox, new extended Wigner's friend scenarios based on contextuality, and an argument against the absoluteness of free choices based on the Pusey--Barrett--Rudolph theorem. The latter result complements the Local Friendliness no-go theorem, which challenged the absoluteness of experimentally obtained measurement outcomes. In Part II of this thesis, we turn to black hole puzzles and the interplay of quantum theory and gravity. We present a paradox that unifies extended Wigner's friend arguments with black hole puzzles, strengthening the cloning and firewall paradoxes. After discussing subtleties in these paradoxes, we next present an analysis combining elements of quantum theory with gravity, analyzing the detector response near a superposed black hole using elements of quantum reference frames.
AI Summary
This thesis examines whether universal quantum dynamics can be reconciled with observer-independent events, and connects extended Wigner’s-friend arguments with black-hole information puzzles. It also studies a particle detector near a quantum-superposed black hole. The supplied text is the introduction and contribution overview; detailed assumptions, proofs and calculations are not included. Part I reports a refinement of the Frauchiger–Renner paradox that produces a contradiction in every protocol run, rather than conditionally, while weakening the consistency requirement used to combine agents’ predictions. It proposes a corresponding “Relativity of Observed Events” principle. Further constructions connect extended Wigner’s-friend scenarios to Kochen–Specker and generalized contextuality. A Pusey–Barrett–Rudolph-based argument retains the locality assumption of Local Friendliness but places the relevant absoluteness assumption on free choices rather than measurement outcomes. Part II combines extended Wigner’s-friend reasoning with cloning and firewall scenarios. Under their black-hole assumptions, the resulting arguments claim an incompatibility at the level of observers’ operational quantum predictions, rather than only cloning or entanglement monogamy. The thesis explicitly questions those assumptions, highlighting quantum backreaction, gauge invariance and observer-dependent descriptions. A separate calculation uses quantum-reference-frame methods to formulate an Unruh–DeWitt interaction near a position-superposed BTZ black hole. It reports no detector-response peaks analogous to those previously found for mass superpositions, and derives analytical spectra identifying the latter peaks with spectral singularities. This is a limited model calculation without a full quantum-gravity theory; the comparison is presented as supporting, not establishing, a mass-quantization interpretation.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 332 pages, PhD thesis, University of York, UK (2026)