We construct large families of mixed-state topological orders in (3+1)D, including intrinsically mixed-state topological orders. We realize these theories by relating the data parameterizing braided fusion 2-categories to the strong higher-form symmetries and their anomalies that characterize mixed-state topological order. We focus here on bosonic theories, which include theories which admit an emergent fermion in the spectrum of line operators. Our general framework is exemplified on the lattice, where we present concrete models and identify how the data of braided fusion 2-categories are physically encoded. We then formalize this data and show that every braided fusion 2-category arises from a general construction (decoherence followed by strong and weak gauging) as the category of topological operators of a (3+1)D mixed state, with intrinsically mixed-state topological orders distinguished by the presence of strong higher-form symmetries whose anomalies cannot be realized in any (3+1)D gapped ground state. Notably, we show that (3+1)D admits a new mechanism with no (2+1)D counterpart: intrinsically mixed-state order whose topological operators braid non-degenerately, but which carries a gravitational anomaly.
AI Summary
The paper asks which operator algebras can occur in bosonic $(3+1)$D mixed-state topological orders, including orders with emergent fermions, and how decoherence permits structures excluded from gapped pure-state ground states. It adopts the ansatz that strong topological operators form a braided fusion 2-category and gives a construction intended to realize every such category: incoherently proliferate excitations of an Abelian gauge theory, then gauge a non-anomalous strong 0-form symmetry and a possibly anomalous weak quotient symmetry.
The categorical parametrization uses a finite Abelian group $E$ and a loop-anomaly class $\beta\in H^5(B^2E;\mathbb C^\times)$, replaced by twisted supercohomological data when emergent fermions occur, together with crossed extensions and braided symmetry actions. The correspondence is established through higher-categorical extension theory and (de-)equivariantization, with explicit lattice noise channels for representative cases. A new example retains a fermionic particle and fermionic loop with nontrivial mutual braiding. Its operator category is non-degenerate but carries the gravitational anomaly $\pi\int w_2w_3$, providing a proposed mechanism for intrinsically mixed order distinct from anomalous transparent operators.
This is not a classification of phases under two-way finite-depth local channels: the operator-category ansatz is unproved, and categorical distinctions are not shown to imply phase distinctions. The gravitationally anomalous example relies on the expected obstruction to a strictly three-dimensional gapped-ground-state realization. General lattice realizations remain open; intrinsically fermionic theories requiring spin structure, chiral mixed-state phases, and multi-loop braiding are outside the treatment.
No sign of AI-generated textStrong assumptionsOverclaims
Central claim may not hold: The universal mixed-state realization claim exceeds the physical construction established in the paper, because existence of the requisite seed symmetry actions and general gauging implementations is assumed rather than demonstrated.
Theorem equiv is false as written: setting the symmetry group to the trivial group would incorrectly require every braided fusion 2-category to be nondegenerate.
In the emergent-fermion derivation, the stated fiber sequence and homotopy table imply a nontrivial fundamental group for trivial E, contradicting the triviality assertion used to reduce crossed-extension data to tau and varpi.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
We construct large families of mixed-state topological orders in (3+1)D, including intrinsically mixed-state topological orders. We realize these theories by relating the data parameterizing braided fusion 2-categories to the strong higher-form symmetries and their anomalies that characterize mixed-state topological order. We focus here on bosonic theories, which include theories which admit an emergent fermion in the spectrum of line operators. Our general framework is exemplified on the lattice, where we present concrete models and identify how the data of braided fusion 2-categories are physically encoded. We then formalize this data and show that every braided fusion 2-category arises from a general construction (decoherence followed by strong and weak gauging) as the category of topological operators of a (3+1)D mixed state, with intrinsically mixed-state topological orders distinguished by the presence of strong higher-form symmetries whose anomalies cannot be realized in any (3+1)D gapped ground state. Notably, we show that (3+1)D admits a new mechanism with no (2+1)D counterpart: intrinsically mixed-state order whose topological operators braid non-degenerately, but which carries a gravitational anomaly.
The paper asks which operator algebras can occur in bosonic (3+1)D mixed-state topological orders, including orders with emergent fermions, and how decoherence permits structures excluded from gapped pure-state ground states. It adopts the ansatz that strong topological operators form a braided fusion 2-category and gives a construction intended to realize every such category: incoherently proliferate excitations of an Abelian gauge theory, then gauge a non-anomalous strong 0-form symmetry and a possibly anomalous weak quotient symmetry.
The categorical parametrization uses a finite Abelian group E and a loop-anomaly class β∈H5(B2E;C×), replaced by twisted supercohomological data when emergent fermions occur, together with crossed extensions and braided symmetry actions. The correspondence is established through higher-categorical extension theory and (de-)equivariantization, with explicit lattice noise channels for representative cases. A new example retains a fermionic particle and fermionic loop with nontrivial mutual braiding. Its operator category is non-degenerate but carries the gravitational anomaly π∫w2w3, providing a proposed mechanism for intrinsically mixed order distinct from anomalous transparent operators.
This is not a classification of phases under two-way finite-depth local channels: the operator-category ansatz is unproved, and categorical distinctions are not shown to imply phase distinctions. The gravitationally anomalous example relies on the expected obstruction to a strictly three-dimensional gapped-ground-state realization. General lattice realizations remain open; intrinsically fermionic theories requiring spin structure, chiral mixed-state phases, and multi-loop braiding are outside the treatment.
Gravitational anomalies can be realized on the boundary of topologically ordered states in one higher dimension and are described by topological orders in one higher dimension. In this paper, we try to develop a general theory for both topological order and gravitational anomaly in any dimensions. (1) We introduce the notion of BF category to describe the braiding and fusion properties of topological excitations that can be point-like, string-like, etc. A subset of BF categories -- closed BF categories -- classify topological orders in any dimensions, while generic BF categories classify (potentially) anomalous topological orders that can appear at a boundary of a gapped quantum liquid in one higher dimension. (2) We introduce topological path integral based on tensor network to realize those topological orders. (3) Bosonic topological orders have an important topological invariant: the vector bundles of the degenerate ground states over the moduli spaces of closed spaces with different metrics. They may fully characterize topological orders. (4) We conjecture that a topological order has a gappable boundary iff the above mentioned vector bundles are flat. (5) We find a holographic phenomenon that every topological order with a gappable boundary can be uniquely determined by the knowledge of the boundary. As a consequence, BF categories in different dimensions form a (monoid) cochain complex, that reveals the structure and relation of topological orders and gravitational anomalies in different dimensions. We also studied the simplest kind of bosonic topological orders that have no non-trivial topological excitations. We find that this kind of topological orders form a Z class in 2+1D (with gapless edge), a Z2 class in 4+1D (with gappable boundary), and a Z⊕Z class in 6+1D (with gapless boundary).
The classification and characterization of topological phases of matter is well understood for ground states of gapped Hamiltonians that are well isolated from the environment. However, decoherence due to interactions with the environment is inevitable—thus motivating the investigation of topological orders in the context of mixed states. Here, we take a step toward classifying mixed-state topological orders in two spatial dimensions by considering their (emergent) generalized symmetries. We argue that their 1-form symmetries and the associated anyon theories lead to a partial classification under two-way connectivity by quasilocal quantum channels. This allows us to establish mixed-state topological orders that are intrinsically mixed, i.e., that have no ground-state counterpart. We provide a wide range of examples based on topological subsystem codes, decohering G -graded string-net models, and “classically gauging” symmetry-enriched topological orders. One of our main examples is an Ising string-net model under the influence of dephasing noise. We study the resulting space of locally indistinguishable states and compute the modular transformations within a particular coherent space. Based on our examples, we identify two possible effects of quasilocal quantum channels on anyon theories: (1) anyons can be incoherently proliferated—thus reducing to a commutant of the proliferated anyons, or (2) the system can be “classically gauged,” resulting in the symmetrization of anyons and an extension by transparent bosons. Given these two mechanisms, we conjecture that mixed-state topological orders are classified by premodular anyon theories, i.e., those for which the braiding relations may be degenerate.
Gapped phases in 2+1 dimensional quantum field theories with fusion 2-categorical symmetries were recently classified and characterized using the Symmetry Topological Field Theory (SymTFT) approach [L. Bhardwaj et al., SciPost Phys. 19, 056 (2025); L. Bhardwaj et al., arXiv: 2502.20440]. In this paper, we provide a systematic lattice model construction for all such gapped phases. Specifically, we consider “all-boson type” fusion 2-category symmetries, all of which are obtainable from 0-form symmetry groups G G (possibly with an ’t Hooft anomaly) via generalized gauging—that is, by stacking with an H H -symmetric TFT and gauging a subgroup H H . The continuum classification directly informs the lattice data, such as the generalized gauging that determines the symmetry category, and the data that specifies the gapped phase. We construct commuting projector Hamiltonians and ground states applicable to any non-chiral gapped phase with such symmetries. We also describe the ground states in terms of tensor networks. In light of the length of the paper, we include a self-contained summary section presenting the main results and examples.
Quasiparticle excitations in 3+1 dimensions can be either bosons or fermions. In this work, we introduce the notion of fermionic loop excitations in (3+1)-dimensional (3+1d) topological phases. Specifically, we construct a new many-body lattice invariant of gapped Hamiltonians, the loop self-statistics $\ensuremath{\mu}=\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}1$, that distinguishes two bosonic topological orders that both superficially resemble 3+1dZ2 gauge theory coupled to fermionic charged matter. The first has fermionic charges and bosonic Z2 gauge flux loops (FcBl) and is just the ordinary fermionic toric code. The second has fermionic charges and fermionic loops (FcFl) and, as we argue, can only exist at the boundary of a nontrivial (4+1)-dimensional (4+1d) invertible phase, stable without any symmetries, i.e., it possesses a gravitational anomaly. We substantiate these claims by constructing an explicit exactly solvable 4+1d model using a method that bootstraps a boundary theory into a bulk Hamiltonian, analogous to that of Walker and Wang, and computing the loop self-statistics in the fermionic Z2 gauge theory hosted at its boundary. We also show that the FcFl phase has the same gravitational anomaly as all-fermion quantum electrodynamics. Our results are in agreement with the recent classification of nondegenerate braided fusion 2-categories by Johnson-Freyd, and with the cobordism prediction of a nontrivial Z2-classified 4+1d invertible phase with action $S=\frac{1}{2}\ensuremath{\int}{w}_{2}{w}_{3}$.
A bosonic non-invertible Symmetry Protected Topological (NISPT) phase in (1+1)-dim is referred to as intrinsic if it cannot be mapped, under discrete gauging, to a gapped phase with any invertible symmetry, that is, if it is protected by a non-group-theoretical fusion category symmetry. We construct the intrinsic NISPT phases by performing discrete gauging in a partial SSB phase with a fusion category symmetry that has a certain mixed anomaly. Sometimes, the anomaly of that symmetry category can be alternatively understood as a self-anomaly of a proper categorical sub-symmetry; when this is the case, the same gauging provides an anomaly resolution of this anomalous categorical sub-symmetry. This allows us to construct intrinsic gapless SPT (igSPT) phases, where the anomalous faithfully acting symmetry is non-invertible; and we refer to such igSPT phases as igNISPT phases. We provide two concrete lattice models realizing an intrinsic NISPT phase and an igNISPT phase, respectively. We also generalize the construction of intrinsic NISPT phases to (3+1)-dim.
We investigate the gauging of higher-form finite Abelian symmetries and their sub-groups in quantum spin models in spatial dimensions d=2 d = 2 and 3. Doing so, we naturally uncover gauged models with dual higher-group symmetries and potential mixed ‘t Hooft anomalies. We demonstrate that the mixed anomalies manifest as the symmetry fractionalization of higher-form symmetries participating in the mixed anomaly. Gauging is realized as an isomorphism or duality between the bond algebras that generate the space of quantum spin models with the dual generalized symmetry structures. We explore the mapping of gapped phases under such gauging related dualities for 0-form and 1-form symmetries in spatial dimension d=2 d = 2 and 3. In d=2 d = 2 , these include several non-trivial dualities between short-range entangled gapped phases with 0-form symmetries and 0-form symmetry enriched Higgs and (twisted) deconfined phases of the gauged theory with possible symmetry fractionalizations. Such dualities also imply strong constraints on several unconventional, i.e., deconfined or topological transitions. In d=3 d = 3 , among others, we find, dualities between topological orders via gauging of 1-form symmetries. Hamiltonians self-dual under gauging of 1-form symmetries host emergent non-invertible symmetries, realizing higher-categorical generalizations of the Tambara-Yamagami fusion category.