Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2610.03672

Ordering-Aware Theory of Trotter Error

Zhenning Liu, Zhi-Yuan Wei, Michael Foss-Feig, Alexey V. Gorshkov, Andrew M. Childs

quant-phSubmitted Oct 2, 2026• Announced Oct 5, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Product formulas are a basic tool for simulating quantum many-body dynamics, but a fundamental degree of freedom in their application---the ordering of Hamiltonian terms---has remained largely unexplored. Here we systematically study such ordering effects, quantifying their impact on simulation accuracy and exploiting them to design more accurate product-formula simulations. We develop an efficiently computable, ordering-sensitive bound on the finite-step-size Trotter error for geometrically local Hamiltonians for arbitrarily high-order product formulas. For translation-invariant one-dimensional chains, our bounds are close to exact second-, fourth-, and sixth-order Trotter errors in small-system tests, while on large-scale systems they improve on previous higher-order analytical bounds by orders of magnitude. We further use the local structure of the error bounds and estimates to optimize ordering efficiently, reducing the long-chain problem to a minimum-mean-weight-cycle problem on a weighted de Bruijn graph. For random translation-invariant chains, sequential (staircase-like) orderings consistently outperform standard brickwall circuits; when circuit depth is restricted, the optimizer instead favors wave-like parallel-sequential orderings, which preserve much of the accuracy advantage over brickwall circuits. These results establish ordering as a useful degree of freedom for both understanding and improving product-formula simulation.

AI Summary

The paper asks how Hamiltonian-term ordering affects product-formula error and how to choose an ordering efficiently. Its main setting is one-dimensional nearest-neighbor chains, with ordering optimization specialized to translation-invariant Hamiltonians and Suzuki formulas. It constructs ordering-sensitive, finite-step spectral-norm error bounds for arbitrary-order product formulas. Exact and product-formula evolutions are compared through increments obtained by adding local terms. Each increment is evaluated exactly within a finite window; omitted contributions are bounded using boundary commutators. Grouping $q$ increments and enlarging the window to $L=p+q+v$ terms retains additional cancellations, at classical cost $2^{O(p+q+v)}$ per window. For 500 random translation-invariant ten-qubit Hamiltonians at step size $0.1$, the $q=2$ fourth-order bound averages approximately $1.4$ times the exact error and correctly selects between sequential and brickwall orderings in $495/500$ cases. Comparisons extending to 256 qubits show orders-of-magnitude reductions over previous bounds, although exact errors are unavailable at those sizes. Ordering optimization encodes neighboring-term precedence as a binary string and maps local error costs to weighted de Bruijn graphs. Minimum-mean-cycle optimization finds asymptotically bound-minimizing periodic patterns. In exhaustive eight-qubit tests, unrestricted selections have actual errors averaging 3.5% and 4.2% above optimum at fourth and sixth order; depth-three constraints usually select wave-like patterns. The optimization minimizes a bound or predictor, not the actual error. Sequential superiority is empirical and Hamiltonian-dependent. Bounds require recomputation at each step size; larger windows cost exponentially more. Higher-dimensional ordering optimization and cancellation between simulation steps remain unresolved.

Little sign of AI-generated textAI use disclosed
AI also assisted with later-stage numerical verification presented in \cref{sec:numerics} (based on code written by the authors), literature searches, and the writing and editing of the manuscript.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
24 pages, 11 figures

Related papers

Practical Estimation of Trotter Error for Hamiltonian Simulation

William Maxwell, Pablo A. M. Casares, Robert A. Lang +7 more

Trotter product formulas are a leading approach for Hamiltonian simulation on quantum computers, yet their practical performance has remained difficult to assess due to the challenge of accurately estimating the Trotter error. In this work, we develop new theoretical results, algorithms, and software tools that advance the state-of-the-art in Trotter error estimation by orders of magnitude in both scale and accuracy. On the theoretical side, we prove that in the asymptotic limit the error of a product formula depends on the diagonal elements of the Baker-Campbell-Hausdorff (BCH) error operator in the eigenbasis of the Hamiltonian, rather than its full spectral norm -- yielding an improved scaling for Hamiltonian simulation using product formulas. On the algorithmic side, we introduce a compact representation of the BCH expansion that reduces the number of commutators from $\mathcal{O}(n^3)$ to $\mathcal{O}(n)$ for second-order, and from $\mathcal{O}(n^5)$ to $\mathcal{O}(n^2)$ for fourth-order formulas on $n$ fragments, complemented by an importance sampling scheme to further reduce the computational cost. We provide implementations of these techniques in software and demonstrate their power on two applications: (i) X-ray absorption spectroscopy of an electronic Hamiltonian (Li$_4$Mn$_2$O) at up to 56 qubits using tensor networks; and (ii) vibronic dynamics of naphthalene at over 100 qubits using ML-MCTDH, where we find that naive analytical bounds overestimate the required number of Trotter steps by nearly five orders of magnitude. Our framework enables, for the first time, the accurate estimation of Trotter error at practically relevant system sizes, providing a foundation for fair algorithmic comparisons and rational design of product formulas.

quant-pharXiv:2606.30738•Jul 1, 2026•7 citations

Entanglement-Dependent Error Bounds for Hamiltonian Simulation

Prateek P. Kulkarni

We establish tight connections between entanglement entropy and the approximation error in Trotter-Suzuki product formulas for Hamiltonian simulation. Product formulas remain the workhorse of quantum simulation on near-term devices, yet standard error analyses yield worst-case bounds that can vastly overestimate the resources required for structured problems. For systems governed by geometrically local Hamiltonians with maximum entanglement entropy $S_\text{max}$ across all bipartitions, we prove that the first-order Trotter error scales as $\mathcal{O}(t^2 S_\text{max} \operatorname{polylog}(n)/r)$ rather than the worst-case $\mathcal{O}(t^2 n/r)$, where $n$ is the system size and $r$ is the number of Trotter steps. This yields improvements of $\tildeΩ(n^2)$ for one-dimensional area-law systems and $\tildeΩ(n^{3/2})$ for two-dimensional systems. We extend these bounds to higher-order Suzuki formulas, where the improvement factor involves $2^{pS^*/2}$ for the $p$-th order formula. We further establish a separation result demonstrating that volume-law entangled systems fundamentally require $\tildeΩ(n)$ more Trotter steps than area-law systems to achieve the same precision. This separation is tight up to logarithmic factors. Our analysis combines Lieb-Robinson bounds for locality, tensor network representations for entanglement structure, and novel commutator-entropy inequalities that bound the expectation value of nested commutators by the Schmidt rank of the state. These results have immediate applications to quantum chemistry, condensed matter simulation, and resource estimation for fault-tolerant quantum computing.

quant-pharXiv:2602.00555•Feb 3, 2026•1 citation

Trotter error compensation with polylogarithmic precision and nested-commutator scaling without ancillas

Xinzhao Wang, Shuo Zhou, Ziruo Wang +5 more

Product formulas are among the most practical approaches to Hamiltonian simulation, requiring no ancillary qubits and exhibiting error bounds governed by nested commutators rather than only by Hamiltonian norms. Their circuit size, however, scales polynomially with the inverse precision. We develop a high-order nested-commutator compensation (HNCC) algorithm that preserves the main advantages of product formulas while achieving polylogarithmic precision dependence in the circuit size and the standard $\mathcal{O}(\varepsilon^{-2})$ sampling cost. HNCC uses a truncated Baker--Campbell--Hausdorff expansion to represent high-order Trotter errors by products of nested commutators and compensates these errors at the channel level through randomly sampled Pauli-rotation channels, avoiding Hadamard tests and ancillary qubits. For a fixed $K$-th order product formula applied to a $k$-local Hamiltonian on $N$ qubits with $Γ$ Pauli terms and local interaction strength $g_0$, HNCC estimates $\operatorname{tr}[Oe^{-i tH}ρe^{i tH}]$ to additive precision $\varepsilon\|O\|$ using $\mathcal{O}(\varepsilon^{-2})$ repetitions. Its maximum gate count per circuit is $\mathcal{O}\bigl( kN^{\frac{1}{2K+1}} Γ^{1-\frac{1}{2K+1}} \max\{Γ,N\log(1/\varepsilon)\}^{\frac{1}{2K+1}} (kg_0t\log(1/\varepsilon))^{1+\frac{1}{2K+1}} \bigr)$. Finite-size resource estimates for the periodic Heisenberg chain indicate that HNCC has the lowest estimated $T$-gate count per circuit among the product-formula-based methods considered.

quant-pharXiv:2607.11856•Jul 14, 2026•1 citation

First-Order Trotter Error from a Second-Order Perspective

David Layden

Simulating quantum dynamics beyond the reach of classical computers is one of the main envisioned applications of quantum computers. The most promising quantum algorithms to this end in the near term are the simplest, which use the Trotter formula and its higher-order variants to approximate the dynamics of interest. The approximation error of these algorithms is often poorly understood, even in the most basic and topical cases where the target Hamiltonian decomposes into two realizable terms: H=H_{1}+H_{2}. Recent studies have reported anomalously low approximation error with unexpected scaling in such cases, which they attribute to quantum interference between the errors from different steps of the algorithm. Here, we provide a simpler picture of these effects by relating the Trotter formula to its second-order variant for such H=H_{1}+H_{2} cases. Our method generalizes state-of-the-art error bounds without the technical caveats of prior studies, and elucidates how each part of the total error arises from the underlying quantum circuit. We compare our bound to the true error numerically, and find a close match over many orders of magnitude in the simulation parameters. Our findings further reduce the required circuit depth for the least experimentally demanding quantum simulation algorithms, and illustrate a useful method for bounding simulation error more broadly.

arXiv:2107.08032•Physical Review Letters•May 23, 2022•48 citations

Beyond Commutativity: Redesigning Trotter Decomposition via Local Symmetry

Naoki Negishi, Bo Yang

The product formula, commonly known as Trotter decomposition, is a central tool for digital quantum simulation, whose performance depends critically on how the Hamiltonian is partitioned into tractable blocks. Standard decompositions typically rely on direct commutativity among Hamiltonian terms in a chosen operator representation, which can lead to large residual errors and deep circuits for complex, practically relevant many-body quantum systems. We address this fundamental bottleneck by introducing a new decomposition principle that goes beyond commutativity, grouping Hamiltonian terms into local three-site clusters according to the underlying SU(2) symmetry of the local dynamics. We show that three-site generators fall into at most four SU(2)-symmetry classes, each admitting an effective two-qubit SU(4) representation with exact and efficient implementations. By reducing the number of clusters, this decomposition principle substantially suppresses commutator-induced errors and circuit overhead while preserving underlying physical structures that commutativity-based decompositions may violate. We demonstrate the proposed method on several physically relevant spin-lattice models, where the reduced cluster structure can even realise the second-order product formula without doubling the circuit depth, as would be required by conventional decompositions. Numerical simulations of a Kagome Heisenberg model with triangular spin-chirality interactions show that the proposed method reduces both state infidelity and average spin-chirality bias by more than three orders of magnitude compared with conventional decompositions, while using substantially fewer gates. These results establish local symmetry as a flexible and practical design principle for product-formula simulation, opening a route to more accurate and hardware-efficient simulations of broader classes of many-body systems.

quant-pharXiv:2605.16016•May 18, 2026•4 citations

Randomized product formulas beyond optimal deterministic scaling

Leeseok Kim, Luis Pedro García-Pintos

Product formulas, also known as Trotter formulas, are among the most widely used and practical methods for simulating quantum systems on quantum computers. Here we introduce two new classes of randomized product formulas for simulating Hamiltonians with separated energy scales, $H=A+αB$, where $α$ is small. In the standard access model, where one can implement exponentials of $A$ and $B$ separately, our randomized formulas achieve $\mathcal O(α^2)$ error scaling at the cost of only doubling the gate depth of the corresponding deterministic formula. We further prove an $Ω(α)$ lower bound for deterministic product formulas. In a stronger access model, allowing exponentials of $A+αB_\ell$ for $B = \sum_{\ell}B_\ell$, our randomized formula, based on Trotter Heuristic Resource Improved Formulas for Time-dynamics (THRIFT)~[J. L. Bosse et al., Nat. Commun. 16, 2673 (2025)], achieves $\mathcal O(α^3)$ error scaling with only constant-factor expected gate overhead. We also establish an $Ω(α^2)$ lower bound for deterministic product formulas in this access model. Numerical simulations confirm gate-count reductions for simulating physically motivated systems.

quant-pharXiv:2608.07720•Aug 11, 2026•1 citation
Product formulas are a basic tool for simulating quantum many-body dynamics, but a fundamental degree of freedom in their application---the ordering of Hamiltonian terms---has remained largely unexplored. Here we systematically study such ordering effects, quantifying their impact on simulation accuracy and exploiting them to design more accurate product-formula simulations. We develop an efficiently computable, ordering-sensitive bound on the finite-step-size Trotter error for geometrically local Hamiltonians for arbitrarily high-order product formulas. For translation-invariant one-dimensional chains, our bounds are close to exact second-, fourth-, and sixth-order Trotter errors in small-system tests, while on large-scale systems they improve on previous higher-order analytical bounds by orders of magnitude. We further use the local structure of the error bounds and estimates to optimize ordering efficiently, reducing the long-chain problem to a minimum-mean-weight-cycle problem on a weighted de Bruijn graph. For random translation-invariant chains, sequential (staircase-like) orderings consistently outperform standard brickwall circuits; when circuit depth is restricted, the optimizer instead favors wave-like parallel-sequential orderings, which preserve much of the accuracy advantage over brickwall circuits. These results establish ordering as a useful degree of freedom for both understanding and improving product-formula simulation.
The paper asks how Hamiltonian-term ordering affects product-formula error and how to choose an ordering efficiently. Its main setting is one-dimensional nearest-neighbor chains, with ordering optimization specialized to translation-invariant Hamiltonians and Suzuki formulas.
It constructs ordering-sensitive, finite-step spectral-norm error bounds for arbitrary-order product formulas. Exact and product-formula evolutions are compared through increments obtained by adding local terms. Each increment is evaluated exactly within a finite window; omitted contributions are bounded using boundary commutators. Grouping qqq increments and enlarging the window to L=p+q+vL=p+q+vL=p+q+v terms retains additional cancellations, at classical cost 2O(p+q+v)2^{O(p+q+v)}2O(p+q+v) per window.
For 500 random translation-invariant ten-qubit Hamiltonians at step size 0.10.10.1, the q=2q=2q=2 fourth-order bound averages approximately 1.41.41.4 times the exact error and correctly selects between sequential and brickwall orderings in 495/500495/500495/500 cases. Comparisons extending to 256 qubits show orders-of-magnitude reductions over previous bounds, although exact errors are unavailable at those sizes.
Ordering optimization encodes neighboring-term precedence as a binary string and maps local error costs to weighted de Bruijn graphs. Minimum-mean-cycle optimization finds asymptotically bound-minimizing periodic patterns. In exhaustive eight-qubit tests, unrestricted selections have actual errors averaging 3.5% and 4.2% above optimum at fourth and sixth order; depth-three constraints usually select wave-like patterns.
The optimization minimizes a bound or predictor, not the actual error. Sequential superiority is empirical and Hamiltonian-dependent. Bounds require recomputation at each step size; larger windows cost exponentially more. Higher-dimensional ordering optimization and cancellation between simulation steps remain unresolved.
Trotter product formulas are a leading approach for Hamiltonian simulation on quantum computers, yet their practical performance has remained difficult to assess due to the challenge of accurately estimating the Trotter error. In this work, we develop new theoretical results, algorithms, and software tools that advance the state-of-the-art in Trotter error estimation by orders of magnitude in both scale and accuracy. On the theoretical side, we prove that in the asymptotic limit the error of a product formula depends on the diagonal elements of the Baker-Campbell-Hausdorff (BCH) error operator in the eigenbasis of the Hamiltonian, rather than its full spectral norm -- yielding an improved scaling for Hamiltonian simulation using product formulas. On the algorithmic side, we introduce a compact representation of the BCH expansion that reduces the number of commutators from O(n3)\mathcal{O}(n^3)O(n3) to O(n)\mathcal{O}(n)O(n) for second-order, and from O(n5)\mathcal{O}(n^5)O(n5) to O(n2)\mathcal{O}(n^2)O(n2) for fourth-order formulas on nnn fragments, complemented by an importance sampling scheme to further reduce the computational cost. We provide implementations of these techniques in software and demonstrate their power on two applications: (i) X-ray absorption spectroscopy of an electronic Hamiltonian (Li4_44​Mn2_22​O) at up to 56 qubits using tensor networks; and (ii) vibronic dynamics of naphthalene at over 100 qubits using ML-MCTDH, where we find that naive analytical bounds overestimate the required number of Trotter steps by nearly five orders of magnitude. Our framework enables, for the first time, the accurate estimation of Trotter error at practically relevant system sizes, providing a foundation for fair algorithmic comparisons and rational design of product formulas.
We establish tight connections between entanglement entropy and the approximation error in Trotter-Suzuki product formulas for Hamiltonian simulation. Product formulas remain the workhorse of quantum simulation on near-term devices, yet standard error analyses yield worst-case bounds that can vastly overestimate the resources required for structured problems. For systems governed by geometrically local Hamiltonians with maximum entanglement entropy SmaxS_\text{max}Smax​ across all bipartitions, we prove that the first-order Trotter error scales as O(t2Smaxpolylog⁡(n)/r)\mathcal{O}(t^2 S_\text{max} \operatorname{polylog}(n)/r)O(t2Smax​polylog(n)/r) rather than the worst-case O(t2n/r)\mathcal{O}(t^2 n/r)O(t2n/r), where nnn is the system size and rrr is the number of Trotter steps. This yields improvements of Ω~(n2)\tildeΩ(n^2)Ω~(n2) for one-dimensional area-law systems and Ω~(n3/2)\tildeΩ(n^{3/2})Ω~(n3/2) for two-dimensional systems. We extend these bounds to higher-order Suzuki formulas, where the improvement factor involves 2pS∗/22^{pS^*/2}2pS∗/2 for the ppp-th order formula. We further establish a separation result demonstrating that volume-law entangled systems fundamentally require Ω~(n)\tildeΩ(n)Ω~(n) more Trotter steps than area-law systems to achieve the same precision. This separation is tight up to logarithmic factors. Our analysis combines Lieb-Robinson bounds for locality, tensor network representations for entanglement structure, and novel commutator-entropy inequalities that bound the expectation value of nested commutators by the Schmidt rank of the state. These results have immediate applications to quantum chemistry, condensed matter simulation, and resource estimation for fault-tolerant quantum computing.
Product formulas are among the most practical approaches to Hamiltonian simulation, requiring no ancillary qubits and exhibiting error bounds governed by nested commutators rather than only by Hamiltonian norms. Their circuit size, however, scales polynomially with the inverse precision. We develop a high-order nested-commutator compensation (HNCC) algorithm that preserves the main advantages of product formulas while achieving polylogarithmic precision dependence in the circuit size and the standard O(ε−2)\mathcal{O}(\varepsilon^{-2})O(ε−2) sampling cost. HNCC uses a truncated Baker--Campbell--Hausdorff expansion to represent high-order Trotter errors by products of nested commutators and compensates these errors at the channel level through randomly sampled Pauli-rotation channels, avoiding Hadamard tests and ancillary qubits. For a fixed KKK-th order product formula applied to a kkk-local Hamiltonian on NNN qubits with ΓΓΓ Pauli terms and local interaction strength g0g_0g0​, HNCC estimates tr⁡[Oe−itHρeitH]\operatorname{tr}[Oe^{-i tH}ρe^{i tH}]tr[Oe−itHρeitH] to additive precision ε∥O∥\varepsilon\|O\|ε∥O∥ using O(ε−2)\mathcal{O}(\varepsilon^{-2})O(ε−2) repetitions. Its maximum gate count per circuit is O(kN12K+1Γ1−12K+1max⁡{Γ,Nlog⁡(1/ε)}12K+1(kg0tlog⁡(1/ε))1+12K+1)\mathcal{O}\bigl( kN^{\frac{1}{2K+1}} Γ^{1-\frac{1}{2K+1}} \max\{Γ,N\log(1/\varepsilon)\}^{\frac{1}{2K+1}} (kg_0t\log(1/\varepsilon))^{1+\frac{1}{2K+1}} \bigr)O(kN2K+11​Γ1−2K+11​max{Γ,Nlog(1/ε)}2K+11​(kg0​tlog(1/ε))1+2K+11​). Finite-size resource estimates for the periodic Heisenberg chain indicate that HNCC has the lowest estimated TTT-gate count per circuit among the product-formula-based methods considered.
Simulating quantum dynamics beyond the reach of classical computers is one of the main envisioned applications of quantum computers. The most promising quantum algorithms to this end in the near term are the simplest, which use the Trotter formula and its higher-order variants to approximate the dynamics of interest. The approximation error of these algorithms is often poorly understood, even in the most basic and topical cases where the target Hamiltonian decomposes into two realizable terms: H=H_{1}+H_{2}. Recent studies have reported anomalously low approximation error with unexpected scaling in such cases, which they attribute to quantum interference between the errors from different steps of the algorithm. Here, we provide a simpler picture of these effects by relating the Trotter formula to its second-order variant for such H=H_{1}+H_{2} cases. Our method generalizes state-of-the-art error bounds without the technical caveats of prior studies, and elucidates how each part of the total error arises from the underlying quantum circuit. We compare our bound to the true error numerically, and find a close match over many orders of magnitude in the simulation parameters. Our findings further reduce the required circuit depth for the least experimentally demanding quantum simulation algorithms, and illustrate a useful method for bounding simulation error more broadly.
The product formula, commonly known as Trotter decomposition, is a central tool for digital quantum simulation, whose performance depends critically on how the Hamiltonian is partitioned into tractable blocks. Standard decompositions typically rely on direct commutativity among Hamiltonian terms in a chosen operator representation, which can lead to large residual errors and deep circuits for complex, practically relevant many-body quantum systems. We address this fundamental bottleneck by introducing a new decomposition principle that goes beyond commutativity, grouping Hamiltonian terms into local three-site clusters according to the underlying SU(2) symmetry of the local dynamics. We show that three-site generators fall into at most four SU(2)-symmetry classes, each admitting an effective two-qubit SU(4) representation with exact and efficient implementations. By reducing the number of clusters, this decomposition principle substantially suppresses commutator-induced errors and circuit overhead while preserving underlying physical structures that commutativity-based decompositions may violate. We demonstrate the proposed method on several physically relevant spin-lattice models, where the reduced cluster structure can even realise the second-order product formula without doubling the circuit depth, as would be required by conventional decompositions. Numerical simulations of a Kagome Heisenberg model with triangular spin-chirality interactions show that the proposed method reduces both state infidelity and average spin-chirality bias by more than three orders of magnitude compared with conventional decompositions, while using substantially fewer gates. These results establish local symmetry as a flexible and practical design principle for product-formula simulation, opening a route to more accurate and hardware-efficient simulations of broader classes of many-body systems.
Product formulas, also known as Trotter formulas, are among the most widely used and practical methods for simulating quantum systems on quantum computers. Here we introduce two new classes of randomized product formulas for simulating Hamiltonians with separated energy scales, H=A+αBH=A+αBH=A+αB, where ααα is small. In the standard access model, where one can implement exponentials of AAA and BBB separately, our randomized formulas achieve O(α2)\mathcal O(α^2)O(α2) error scaling at the cost of only doubling the gate depth of the corresponding deterministic formula. We further prove an Ω(α)Ω(α)Ω(α) lower bound for deterministic product formulas. In a stronger access model, allowing exponentials of A+αBℓA+αB_\ellA+αBℓ​ for B=∑ℓBℓB = \sum_{\ell}B_\ellB=∑ℓ​Bℓ​, our randomized formula, based on Trotter Heuristic Resource Improved Formulas for Time-dynamics (THRIFT)~[J. L. Bosse et al., Nat. Commun. 16, 2673 (2025)], achieves O(α3)\mathcal O(α^3)O(α3) error scaling with only constant-factor expected gate overhead. We also establish an Ω(α2)Ω(α^2)Ω(α2) lower bound for deterministic product formulas in this access model. Numerical simulations confirm gate-count reductions for simulating physically motivated systems.