arXiv:2610.03610
Decohering Kitaev's Sixteenfold Way: A Holographic Approach
Shuyu Zhang, Linhao Li, Zhen Bi, Tzu-Chieh Wei, Zijian Song
Abstract
We study anyon decoherence in 2D topological order, with the fermion decoherence in Kitaev's sixteenfold way as explicit examples. The sixteenfold way includes chiral topological phases, which are believed to admit no commuting projector Hamiltonian, making it challenging to study their decoherence directly. We further conjecture the density matrix produced by this decoherence induced phase transition can be obtained by a three-step procedure: first lift the topological order to its Walker-Wang model, followed by a transition to another Walker-Wang model, and finally trace over the bulk degrees of freedom. This establishes a connection between the decoherence of a topological order and a pure state phase transition in its 3D counterpart. Many examples are given. In particular, we show that decohering the fermion in each of the sixteen states always yields an intrinsically mixed-state topological order, a consequence of the fact the corresponding 3D bulk always transits into the 3D fermionic toric code (fTC). Our result suggests a systematic method for studying anyon decoherence in chiral topological orders at the level of commuting projector Hamiltonians.
AI Summary
The paper asks how to study anyon decoherence in two-dimensional topological orders, particularly chiral phases without strictly 2D commuting-projector realizations. It proposes a holographic construction: lift a unitary modular tensor category $\mathcal C$ to its 3D Walker–Wang model, project edge labels onto the subcategory $\mathcal D$ that braids trivially with a fusion-closed set $S$, and trace out the bulk. The conjecture is that the resulting boundary state realizes maximal decoherence of $S$. A boundary buffer must be retained to support the symmetry operators. The correspondence is established explicitly for bosonic and fermionic decoherence of the 2D toric code. Projections of its Raussendorf–Bravyi–Harrington bulk yield, respectively, the 3D toric code and fermionic toric code; their boundary reductions reproduce the known strong-to-weak symmetry-breaking and intrinsically mixed-state topological states. Across all 16 theories in Kitaev’s sixteenfold way, restricting to $\{1,f\}$ yields the same fermionic-toric-code bulk endpoint and hence the same intrinsically mixed-state boundary order. These restrictions are demonstrated using lattice Hamiltonians, topological actions, or string-net wavefunctions. A double-semion example instead retains an anti-semion sector. The general decoherence correspondence remains conjectural. For chiral boundary reductions, equivalence to pure reference states is inferred from strong symmetries, without constructing quasilocal channels in both directions. The analysis concerns maximal-decoherence endpoints, not finite-noise thresholds; relations between bulk and boundary critical behavior remain unresolved. Projections onto label sets not closed under fusion are also left open.
Central claim may not hold: The unconditional abstract claim about fermion decoherence throughout the sixteenfold way is established only conditional on the conjectured identification between two-dimensional decoherence and projection followed by partial trace of a Walker–Wang state. For chiral inputs, the paper explicitly leaves conjectural even the phase equivalence between the initial reduced Walker–Wang boundary state and a pure ground state of the intended two-dimensional topological order.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 31 pages, 6 figures, 1 table