arXiv:2610.03438
An exact semidefinite characterization of the stoquasticity cone of permutationally invariant Bell operators
Jan Li, Owidiusz Makuta, Evert van Nieuwenburg, Jordi Tura
Abstract
Bell correlations have been detected in atomic ensembles ranging from hundreds to hundreds of thousands of particles, witnessed by the permutationally invariant (PI) Bell operators. For all the operators realized so far, the maximally violating state can be brought, in a suitable basis, into a nonnegative-amplitude form. In that basis, the Bell operator is stoquastic. The coefficients parametrising these operators that at the same time lead to stoquasticity form a convex cone, the so-called stoquasticity cone. Its characterization had remained open beyond two-body operators, as for many-body operators the number of inequalities grows with the system size $n$. In this work we show that, in the thermodynamic limit, the stoquasticity cone admits an exact semidefinite characterization, valid at any operator order. The key observation is that, along each off-diagonal, the matrix elements are the values of a single univariate polynomial. Being univariate, this condition is equivalent to a linear matrix inequality, with no relaxation hierarchy. Therefore, deciding stoquasticity becomes a single semidefinite feasibility problem. As its lowest-degree instances, this description recovers the known three-hyperplane characterization for two-body operators and yields, for three-body operators, a curved boundary.
AI Summary
The paper asks which coefficients make a fixed-setting, $K$-body permutationally invariant qubit Bell operator stoquastic in the Dicke basis of its symmetric spin block. At finite particle number $n$, this cone is defined by $O(Kn)$ linear inequalities; the goal is a description whose size depends on $K$ rather than $n$. The main structural result factors each $d$th off-diagonal matrix element into a positive ladder-operator prefactor and a polynomial in the row index of degree at most $K-d$, with coefficients linear in the Bell coefficients. Requiring its continuous interpolation to be nonpositive on $[0,1]$ gives an inner approximation at finite $n$. Applying the Markov–Lukács theorem yields an exact sum-of-squares/semidefinite representation of this continuous condition, without a relaxation hierarchy. Membership requires one SDP with positive-semidefinite blocks of size at most $\lceil K/2\rceil$. The construction recovers the exact three-inequality finite-$n$ description for two-body operators. For three-body operators, an interior quadratic maximum produces a conic boundary and an SDP formulation with one auxiliary scalar. Its quadratic form differs from its leading-order limit by an explicitly bounded $O(1/n)$ correction. The characterization concerns only the symmetric block, which need not contain the global optimum. With coefficients held fixed, lower-body contributions disappear in the strict limit; parity makes the limiting cones polyhedral through $K=4$, including flattening the three-body curved boundary. Size-dependent coefficient scalings require separate bookkeeping. Explicit higher-order coefficient formulas, extremal-ray descriptions, and extensions to qutrits remain open.
All AI-assisted calculations, arguments, and text incorporated into the manuscript were independently checked and verified by the authors, who take full responsibility for the content of the work.
Central claim may not hold: The limiting SDP discards subleading sign constraints and accepts +S_X, although this operator is nonstoquastic for every n and its coefficient vector cannot be a limit of vectors in the exact finite-n cones. The abstract misleadingly presents a curved three-body boundary as an instance of the thermodynamic-limit characterization, although the strict-limit region is polyhedral and the curvature belongs to a finite-n continuous inner approximation. The abstract omits the essential restriction to the symmetric spin-n/2 block, which does not characterize stoquasticity or maximal violation of a general full PI Bell operator. The Q-decomposition appendix omits a factor of 3 in e_{3,G}, making its polynomial decomposition and resulting explicit coefficient formulas inconsistent with the stated matrix elements.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.