A central topic in economics and finance is the valuation of strategic games and bets, of investments providing uncertain future cashflows, and of other asset-like structures and contracts. Often, such valuation involves a probabilistic model, random variables, and computing expectation values of complex payoffs. Extending beyond this classical framework, a scenario emerges where assets are non-commuting operators and the inherent uncertainty is described by quantum states. In this work, we combine such notions of quantum finance with a graph-theoretic framework and ideas from contextuality. We discuss exclusive quantum assets and introduce scenarios when holding such assets can provide advantages over holding classical assets. In particular, we consider a "quantum market" based on nonlocal games such as the CHSH game and demonstrate that this setting can function as a market with well-defined financial structures. We provide upper bounds on the fair prices of the quantum assets based on graph-theoretic quantities like the independence number and the Lovász theta number. Our insights into markets of non-commuting assets help to elucidate what a financial system in a world filled with quantum technology could look like.
AI Summary
The paper asks how to value hypothetical financial claims whose payouts are determined by quantum measurements, focusing on exclusivity constraints and nonlocal games rather than computational speedups for classical finance. Classical assets are random variables; quantum assets are Hermitian operators with expected payoff $\operatorname{Tr}(\rho A)$. Exclusivity means disjoint classical supports or $A_iA_j=0$ quantum mechanically.
For nonnegative portfolio weights $w$, it proves that classical assets bounded above by one have expected portfolio value at most the weighted independence number $\alpha(G,w)$, while quantum assets satisfying $0\preceq A_i\preceq I$ are bounded by the weighted Lovász number $\vartheta(G,w)$. Saturating constructions are given. The classical proof identifies independent sets of simultaneously nonzero assets; the quantum proof constructs a feasible Gram matrix for the theta semidefinite program. The pentagon illustrates the separation $2$ versus $\sqrt{5}$.
A concrete market uses repeated CHSH games, a trusted exchange, and consumable bundles of winning-event claims. For $\rho(\eta)=(1-\eta)|\Phi^+\rangle\langle\Phi^+|+\eta I/4$, the prescribed quantum strategy wins with probability $(1-\eta)(2+\sqrt{2})/4+\eta/2$, exceeding $3/4$ when $\eta<1-1/\sqrt{2}$. Binomial inventory calculations determine the expected number of quantum-enabled rounds. Traders’ noise estimates then determine reservation prices through expected settlement, with disagreement producing distinct bid and ask valuations.
The model assumes an honest exchange, stationary independent state preparations, known input probabilities, nonnegative holdings, and zero discounting. Information-acquisition costs, estimation uncertainty, changing market conditions, other games, and cryptographic enforcement without a trusted exchange are left for future work.
Little sign of AI-generated textOverclaimsIncrementalUnclear noveltyStrong assumptions
Central claim may not hold: The exchange selects quantum versus classical play using bundle availability for the joint input (x,y), which can produce an effective nonlocal strategy with winning probability 0.963388 in a one-round example, invalidating the general market mechanism's claimed CHSH locality.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
A central topic in economics and finance is the valuation of strategic games and bets, of investments providing uncertain future cashflows, and of other asset-like structures and contracts. Often, such valuation involves a probabilistic model, random variables, and computing expectation values of complex payoffs. Extending beyond this classical framework, a scenario emerges where assets are non-commuting operators and the inherent uncertainty is described by quantum states. In this work, we combine such notions of quantum finance with a graph-theoretic framework and ideas from contextuality. We discuss exclusive quantum assets and introduce scenarios when holding such assets can provide advantages over holding classical assets. In particular, we consider a "quantum market" based on nonlocal games such as the CHSH game and demonstrate that this setting can function as a market with well-defined financial structures. We provide upper bounds on the fair prices of the quantum assets based on graph-theoretic quantities like the independence number and the Lovász theta number. Our insights into markets of non-commuting assets help to elucidate what a financial system in a world filled with quantum technology could look like.
The paper asks how to value hypothetical financial claims whose payouts are determined by quantum measurements, focusing on exclusivity constraints and nonlocal games rather than computational speedups for classical finance. Classical assets are random variables; quantum assets are Hermitian operators with expected payoff Tr(ρA). Exclusivity means disjoint classical supports or AiAj=0 quantum mechanically.
For nonnegative portfolio weights w, it proves that classical assets bounded above by one have expected portfolio value at most the weighted independence number α(G,w), while quantum assets satisfying 0⪯Ai⪯I are bounded by the weighted Lovász number ϑ(G,w). Saturating constructions are given. The classical proof identifies independent sets of simultaneously nonzero assets; the quantum proof constructs a feasible Gram matrix for the theta semidefinite program. The pentagon illustrates the separation 2 versus 5.
A concrete market uses repeated CHSH games, a trusted exchange, and consumable bundles of winning-event claims. For ρ(η)=(1−η)∣Φ+⟩⟨Φ+∣+ηI/4, the prescribed quantum strategy wins with probability (1−η)(2+2)/4+η/2, exceeding 3/4 when η<1−1/2. Binomial inventory calculations determine the expected number of quantum-enabled rounds. Traders’ noise estimates then determine reservation prices through expected settlement, with disagreement producing distinct bid and ask valuations.
The model assumes an honest exchange, stationary independent state preparations, known input probabilities, nonnegative holdings, and zero discounting. Information-acquisition costs, estimation uncertainty, changing market conditions, other games, and cryptographic enforcement without a trusted exchange are left for future work.
We develop a quantum-style formalism for economic valuation in which the value of a good is represented by a wavefunction over price space. The observed price is associated with measurement of a price operator, while uncertainty in valuation is represented by the width of the valuation distribution. The state evolves according to a Schr\"odinger-type equation containing a valuation potential, a price-inertia term, and, for an open market, a non-Hermitian source/sink term. The purpose of the formalism is not to claim that financial markets are microscopic quantum systems. Rather, quantum mechanics provides a compact mathematical language for situations in which valuation is uncertain, sequential operations need not be interchangeable, and cyclic trading can reveal discrepancies that are invisible when each transaction is considered in isolation. We derive the canonical price--momentum commutator, the moment hierarchy, Ehrenfest equations, and a price--velocity uncertainty relation. We then introduce a lattice of mutually interacting assets through a neighbor-tension potential. The resulting model supports propagating valuation disturbances and provides a simple mathematical description of herding and synchronization. The principal new construction concerns arbitrage. Rather than identifying arbitrage directly with a geometric phase, we represent individual trading operations by operators. When two trading operations commute, their order is immaterial. When they do not commute, a round trip constructed from their group commutator fails to close in valuation space. This nonclosure is a natural mathematical signature of path dependence. An economically observable arbitrage opportunity arises when the resulting cycle transformation produces a positive net payoff after transaction costs. The formalism therefore connects four ideas: valuation uncertainty, neighbor interaction, noncommuting trading operations, and cyclic arbitrage. A harmonic valuation well provides a solvable benchmark, while a three-asset trading loop provides the simplest setting in which the distinction between ordinary price differences and genuinely noncommutative cycle effects becomes visible.
A derivative is a financial asset whose future payoff is a function of underlying assets. Pricing a financial derivative involves setting up a market model, finding a martingale ("fair game") probability measure for the model from the existing asset prices, and using that probability measure to price the derivative. When the number of underlying assets and/or the number of market outcomes in the model is large, pricing can be computationally demanding. In this work, we first formulate the pricing problem in a linear algebra setting, including the realistic setting of incomplete markets where derivatives do not have a unique price. We show that the problem can be solved with a variety of quantum techniques such as quantum linear programming and the quantum linear systems algorithm. While in previous works the martingale measure is assumed to be given, here it is extracted from market variables akin to bootstrapping, a common practice among financial institutions. We discuss the quantum zero-sum game algorithm and the quantum simplex algorithm as viable subroutines. For quantum linear systems solvers, we formalize a new market assumption milder than market completeness, which allows the potential for large speedups. Towards prototype use cases, we conduct numerical experiments motivated by the Black-Scholes-Merton model.
We develop a comprehensive theoretical framework for quantum-enhanced risk modeling in financial systems, establishing mathematical foundations for representing and computing risk factors using quantum states and operations. The theory begins by formulating portfolio risk as quantum observables, where correlations between assets are naturally encoded in entangled quantum states, enabling exponentially compact representations of high-dimensional covariance structures. We derive theoretical bounds on the accuracy of quantum risk estimates and prove convergence theorems for quantum algorithms that compute value-at-risk, conditional value-atrisk, and higher-moment risk measures. Our framework incorporates counterdiabatic evolution techniques to navigate complex risk landscapes efficiently, establishing conditions under which quantum annealing approaches converge to optimal portfolio configurations with provable performance guarantees. We analyze the computational complexity of quantum versus classical risk calculation, identifying scenarios where quantum advantage emerges based on portfolio size, correlation structure complexity, and required solution precision. The theory extends to dynamic risk assessment under changing market conditions, proving that quantum algorithms can adapt to evolving risk profiles with polynomial overhead. We establish fundamental limits on quantum speedups for risk computation and identify problem structures that maximize quantum advantage. This theoretical foundation bridges quantum computing and quantitative finance, offering rigorous principles for designing quantum algorithms that address computational bottlenecks in modern risk management.
Quantum computers have the potential to provide an advantage for financial pricing problems by the use of quantum estimation. In a broader context, it is reasonable to ask about situations where the market and the assets traded on the market themselves have quantum properties. In this work, we consider a financial setting where instead of by classical probabilities the market is described by a pure quantum state or, more generally, a quantum density operator. This setting naturally leads to a new asset class, which we call quantum assets. Under the assumption that such assets have a price and can be traded, we develop an extended definition of arbitrage to quantify gains without the corresponding risk. Our main result is a quantum version of the first fundamental theorem of asset pricing. If and only if there is no arbitrage, there exists a risk-free density operator under which all assets are martingales. This density operator is used for the pricing of quantum derivatives. To prove the theorem, we study the density operator version of the Radon-Nikodym measure change. We provide examples to illustrate the theory.
Abstract Finance stands as the most quantitatively advanced branch of the social sciences, yet it is also the most humbling. The mean-variance efficient frontier, the CAPM, arbitrage pricing relations, the Black–Scholes–Merton option formula and the efficient market hypothesis possess unparalleled formal elegance, yet they suffered a broad empirical refutation in the global financial crisis of 2008. Standard models understate tail risk, misinterpret the comovement of assets that are supposed to diversify risk, and presuppose liquidity and rationality — two features that vanish precisely when they are most needed. Behavioural finance has documented an extensive catalogue of cognitive biases, yet it remains a patchwork of isolated effects without a unified calculus of probability. This monograph is the first systematic work to establish quantum finance. It argues that the mathematical formalism of quantum mechanics supplies this missing unified structure: financial states are state vectors in Hilbert space; beliefs and valuations coexist as superposed amplitudes; trading and information disclosure act as measurements that collapse states in accordance with the Born rule; assets and markets are entangled with one another; and path interference generates fat tails and herding, which are inadmissible under classical additive probability. The book comprises six parts and thirty chapters in total. Part I lays the philosophical and formal foundations. Starting from the paradigm crisis, it proceeds through quantum probability and quantum stochastic processes to construct the analytical framework built on three core pillars of quantum finance. Part II develops quantum asset pricing, covering the quantum CAPM, quantum APT, quantum option pricing and the term structure of interest rates. Part III advances quantum risk management, including quantum risk measures, Value-at-Risk (VaR) and expected shortfall, stress testing, credit risk and phase transitions in systemic risk. Part IV addresses quantum portfolios and asset allocation, ranging from the quantum meanvariance frontier, strategic and tactical asset allocation, to factor investing and hedge fund strategies. Part V turns to market microstructure and behavioural finance, examining quantum order flows, marketmaker liquidity, quantum prospect theory and market sentiment. Part VI looks ahead to frontier avenues: quantum computational optimization, quantum machine learning, blockchains, postquantum cryptography and quantuminformed financial regulation. This book rigorously recovers the classical CAPM, efficient market hypothesis and Gaussian risk models as special cases under decoherence limits. It is intended for graduate students and faculty in finance and financial engineering, as well as researchers and practitioners working on asset pricing, risk management, portfolio allocation and financial regulation.
Portfolio optimization under conditions of risk and market uncertainty remains a foundational challenge in financial economics and investment management. Classical optimization frameworks, including mean–variance models and stochastic programming approaches, often struggle with high-dimensional asset universes, nonlinear correlations, and dynamic market regimes. This paper examines quantum computing approaches to portfolio optimization under risk and market uncertainty, focusing on hybrid quantum–classical algorithms designed to enhance combinatorial optimization and probabilistic modeling. By integrating quantum annealing, variational quantum circuits, and quantum-enhanced sampling techniques with classical financial analytics, the study evaluates their potential to improve computational efficiency and scenario sensitivity. The analysis considers both theoretical advantages and practical limitations within the Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum (NISQ) era. The findings suggest that quantum-assisted optimization may complement traditional portfolio models by expanding feasible solution spaces and improving robustness under uncertainty, thereby contributing to more adaptive and resilient investment strategies.