Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2610.02313

How Quantum Is Bottomonium in the Quark-Gluon Plasma?

Nora Brambilla, Tom Magorsch

hep-phhep-exnucl-exnucl-thquant-phSubmitted Oct 1, 2026• Announced Oct 5, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We study how much quantum structure bottomonium retains during its evolution in the quark-gluon plasma. Within the open quantum system framework, we simulate the Lindblad equation obtained from potential nonrelativistic QCD in the quantum Brownian regime. From the resulting real-time evolution of the bottomonium density matrix, we compute the Wigner transform and study its negativity as a measure of nonclassicality and a test of a key condition underlying classical Langevin-type approximations. We find that the medium suppresses the negativity, which nevertheless approaches a finite plateau close to that of the $1\mathrm{S}$ state. The overlaps with the excited $2\mathrm{S}$ and $3\mathrm{S}$ states arise from near-canceling positive and negative phase-space contributions, driven by negative regions in the Wigner transforms of the bound-state projectors, while the $1\mathrm{S}$ overlap is insensitive to such contributions. We further show that the position-space coherence is similarly suppressed and plateaus close to the 1S value. We trace the finite residual quantum structure to conditional purification: the medium preferentially dissolves weakly bound and unbound modes with large $\langle r^2\rangle$, driving the surviving singlet $\mathrm{S}$-wave ensemble toward the $1\mathrm{S}$ state. More broadly, these results reveal that classicalization is partial and observable dependent, a feature that is relevant across applications of open quantum system methods in fundamental physics.

AI Summary

The paper asks whether bottomonium evolution in a quark–gluon plasma becomes sufficiently classical to justify Langevin-type transport, and whether residual quantum structure matters for bound-state yields. It simulates the pNRQCD Lindblad equation at next-to-leading order in $E/(\pi T)$ using approximately $2\times10^5$ quantum trajectories, Coulombic potentials, and a Bjorken medium cooling from $425$ to $190\,\mathrm{MeV}$. Density matrices are reconstructed to calculate Wigner negativity, radial position-space coherence, purity, and bound-state overlaps. For the normalized, conditional color-singlet $\ell=0$ sector—not the full ensemble—the medium suppresses negativity, which plateaus near $18\%$ after approximately $3\,\mathrm{fm}$, close to the Coulombic $1\mathrm{S}$ value of $16.6\%$. Coherence likewise approaches the $1\mathrm{S}$ value. Increasing purity and ground-state overlap support a conditional-filtering explanation: dipole transitions preferentially remove extended, weakly bound components, leaving a surviving ensemble dominated by $1\mathrm{S}$. A sign-resolved phase-space decomposition shows that $2\mathrm{S}$ and $3\mathrm{S}$ yields arise from nearly canceling contributions, predominantly involving negative regions of the measurement projectors’ Wigner functions rather than the evolving state. The $1\mathrm{S}$ overlap is largely insensitive to these terms. Thus, positive bound-state acceptance prescriptions omit contributions relevant to excited-state yields; this does not establish failure of semiclassical evolution with quantum projectors retained. Limitations include the selected conditional sector, simplified potentials and medium, omitted pre-equilibrium dynamics, and finite-volume errors, including a $13\%$ normalization deviation for the $3\mathrm{S}$ Wigner transform. A direct comparison with three-dimensional semiclassical transport including color dynamics is left open.

Little sign of AI-generated textIncrementalMissing comparisonStrong assumptions

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
11 pages, 9 figures

Related papers

Quantum simulation of bottomonium dynamics in the quark–gluon plasma via the Lindblad equation

Linyuan Wei, Jin Hu, Anping Huang +2 more

Abstract Quantum computing provides a powerful framework for simulating real-time dynamics in open quantum systems, offering key advantages for modeling heavy-quarkonium transport in high-energy nuclear collisions. In this work, we perform quantum simulations of the isotropic next-to-leading-order Lindblad equation for bottomonium in the quark-gluon plasma using a reduced spherical coordinate representation. We discretize operators and wavefunctions, map the physical state onto qubits, and execute time evolution via parameterized quantum gate operations. By extracting the Υ(1S) survival probability, we quantitatively isolate the color-octet contribution to the correlated regeneration of the bottomonium ground state, demonstrating that its overall impact is small in the final production of the bottomonium ground state Υ(1S) in the hot QCD medium at temperatures accessible at the Large Hadron Collider. Additionally, we have further optimized the quantum simulation algorithm for the Lindblad equation. The improved algorithm requires only a single ancillary qubit to realize the Lindblad evolution, thereby minimizing the circuit significantly.

arXiv:2608.06754•Chinese Physics C•Nov 4, 2026•2 citations

Heavy quarkonium dynamics beyond the binding energy over temperature expansion

Nora Brambilla, Arthur Yi-Ting Lin, Tom Magorsch +1 more

We revisit the pNRQCD open-quantum-system description of bottomonium in a quark-gluon plasma, writing the full master equation in a spherical basis and establishing a framework for its numerical treatment. The equation does not rely on an expansion in the ratio of the binding energy over the temperature, while retaining the Born, Markov, and dilute approximations. It depends on suitable convolutions of Coulombic Green's functions with real-time chromoelectric correlators, rather than a finite set of transport coefficients. It contains jump-operator contributions that enter with both positive and negative signs, so it is not of a Lindblad type. We utilize optimal operator rotations to minimize the negative sector and define a positive-sector approximation that retains only the optimized positive terms, obtaining in this way a Lindblad equation that can be simulated efficiently with the open-source code QTraj for arbitrary chromoelectric spectral functions. We treat the discarded sector as a systematic uncertainty associated with positivity-breaking effects of the pseudo-Lindblad generator. Positivity breaking effects can be attributed to the approximations made in the derivation of the quarkonium master equation, such as the Born--Markov approximations. Using a spectral model constrained by known infrared and ultraviolet limits, we compute the in-medium width and Bjorken-evolved survival probabilities of the $Υ(1\mathrm{S},2\mathrm{S},3\mathrm{S})$. The computations show the convergence of the binding-energy-over-temperature expansion at high temperatures and provide the first large-scale quantum-trajectory simulation results for bottomonium in the low temperature regime. We can thus follow the bottomonium evolution over the full temperature range relevant in heavy-ion collisions.

hep-phCross-listedarXiv:2611.00194•Nov 3, 2026

General Lindblad equation for quarkonium evolution in a quark-gluon plasma

Aoumeur Daddi Hammou, Jean-Paul Blaizot, Pol Bernard Gossiaux +1 more

Accurate modelling and understanding of quarkonium production in ultrarelativistic heavy ion collisions requires a formalism that preserves the quantum properties of microscopic $\bar{Q}Q$ systems while treating the interaction of such pairs with the quark-gluon plasma (QGP). The open quantum system approach has recently emerged as one of the most fruitful schemes to meet such requirements. However, the quantum master equations obtained so far in this context are derived assuming a strict ordering between the QGP temperature $T$ and the $\bar{Q}Q$ energy gaps ($ΔE$) of the quarkonia bound states. This limits their predictive power since, as the QGP expands and cools down, the system traverse all regimes between the quantum Brownian motion (QBM) regime for $T\gtrsim ΔE$ to the quantum optical (QO) regime for $ΔE\gtrsim T$. In this paper, we derive and present a more general non-abelian quantum master equation of the Lindblad type, which does not suffer from these limitations and thus allows to faithfully describe the quantum evolution of the $Q\bar{Q}$ pairs during the whole QGP-evolution. We also provide some illustration of the key quantities governing this equation.

nucl-thCross-listedarXiv:2608.15347•Aug 18, 2026

Open quantum systems for quarkonia

Xiaojun Yao

I review recent applications of the open quantum system framework in the understanding of quarkonium suppression in heavy-ion collisions, which has been used as a probe of the quark–gluon plasma for decades. The derivation of the Lindblad equations for quarkonium in both the quantum Brownian motion and the quantum optical limits and their semiclassical counterparts is explained. The hierarchy of time scales assumed in the derivation is justified from the separation of energy scales in nonrelativistic effective field theories of QCD. Physical implications of the open quantum system approach are also discussed. Finally, I list some open questions for future studies.

arXiv:2102.01736•International Journal of Modern Physics A•Jul 14, 2021•93 citations

Quarkonium dynamics inside the Quark-Gluon Plasma using open quantum systems

Stéphane Delorme, Pol-Bernard Gossiaux, Thierry Gousset +1 more

\nIn recent years, a significant theoretical effort has been made towards a dynamical description of quarkonia inside the Quark-Gluon Plasma (QGP), using the open quantum systems formalism. In this framework, one can get a real-time description of a quantum system (here the quarkonium) in interaction with a thermal bath (the QGP) by integrating out the bath degrees of freedom and studying the system reduced density matrix. We investigate the real-time dynamics of a correlated heavy quark-antiquark pair inside the QGP using a quantum master equation previously derived from first QCD principles in [4]. The full equation is directly resolved in 1D to lessen computing costs and is used for the first time to gain insight on the dynamics in both a static and evolving medium following a Björken-like temperature evolution.\n

•May 17, 2021•0 citations

Quarkonium dynamics inside the Quark-Gluon Plasma using open quantum systems

Stéphane Delorme, Thierry Gousset, Roland Katz +1 more

In recent years, a significant theoretical effort has been made towards a dynamical description of quarkonia inside the Quark-Gluon Plasma (QGP), using the open quantum systems formalism. In this framework, one can get a real-time description of a quantum system (here the quarkonium) in interaction with a thermal bath (the QGP) by integrating out the bath degrees of freedom and studying the system reduced density matrix. We investigate the real-time dynamics of a correlated heavy quark-antiquark pair inside the QGP using a quantum master equation previously derived from first QCD principles in [4]. The full equation is directly resolved in 1D to lessen computing costs and is used for the first time to gain insight on the dynamics in both a static and evolving medium following a Björken-like temperature evolution.

EPJ Web of Conferences•Jan 1, 2022•2 citations
We study how much quantum structure bottomonium retains during its evolution in the quark-gluon plasma. Within the open quantum system framework, we simulate the Lindblad equation obtained from potential nonrelativistic QCD in the quantum Brownian regime. From the resulting real-time evolution of the bottomonium density matrix, we compute the Wigner transform and study its negativity as a measure of nonclassicality and a test of a key condition underlying classical Langevin-type approximations. We find that the medium suppresses the negativity, which nevertheless approaches a finite plateau close to that of the 1S1\mathrm{S}1S state. The overlaps with the excited 2S2\mathrm{S}2S and 3S3\mathrm{S}3S states arise from near-canceling positive and negative phase-space contributions, driven by negative regions in the Wigner transforms of the bound-state projectors, while the 1S1\mathrm{S}1S overlap is insensitive to such contributions. We further show that the position-space coherence is similarly suppressed and plateaus close to the 1S value. We trace the finite residual quantum structure to conditional purification: the medium preferentially dissolves weakly bound and unbound modes with large ⟨r2⟩\langle r^2\rangle⟨r2⟩, driving the surviving singlet S\mathrm{S}S-wave ensemble toward the 1S1\mathrm{S}1S state. More broadly, these results reveal that classicalization is partial and observable dependent, a feature that is relevant across applications of open quantum system methods in fundamental physics.
The paper asks whether bottomonium evolution in a quark–gluon plasma becomes sufficiently classical to justify Langevin-type transport, and whether residual quantum structure matters for bound-state yields. It simulates the pNRQCD Lindblad equation at next-to-leading order in E/(πT)E/(\pi T)E/(πT) using approximately 2×1052\times10^52×105 quantum trajectories, Coulombic potentials, and a Bjorken medium cooling from 425425425 to 190 MeV190\,\mathrm{MeV}190MeV. Density matrices are reconstructed to calculate Wigner negativity, radial position-space coherence, purity, and bound-state overlaps.
For the normalized, conditional color-singlet ℓ=0\ell=0ℓ=0 sector—not the full ensemble—the medium suppresses negativity, which plateaus near 18%18\%18% after approximately 3 fm3\,\mathrm{fm}3fm, close to the Coulombic 1S1\mathrm{S}1S value of 16.6%16.6\%16.6%. Coherence likewise approaches the 1S1\mathrm{S}1S value. Increasing purity and ground-state overlap support a conditional-filtering explanation: dipole transitions preferentially remove extended, weakly bound components, leaving a surviving ensemble dominated by 1S1\mathrm{S}1S.
A sign-resolved phase-space decomposition shows that 2S2\mathrm{S}2S and 3S3\mathrm{S}3S yields arise from nearly canceling contributions, predominantly involving negative regions of the measurement projectors’ Wigner functions rather than the evolving state. The 1S1\mathrm{S}1S overlap is largely insensitive to these terms. Thus, positive bound-state acceptance prescriptions omit contributions relevant to excited-state yields; this does not establish failure of semiclassical evolution with quantum projectors retained.
Limitations include the selected conditional sector, simplified potentials and medium, omitted pre-equilibrium dynamics, and finite-volume errors, including a 13%13\%13% normalization deviation for the 3S3\mathrm{S}3S Wigner transform. A direct comparison with three-dimensional semiclassical transport including color dynamics is left open.
Abstract Quantum computing provides a powerful framework for simulating real-time dynamics in open quantum systems, offering key advantages for modeling heavy-quarkonium transport in high-energy nuclear collisions. In this work, we perform quantum simulations of the isotropic next-to-leading-order Lindblad equation for bottomonium in the quark-gluon plasma using a reduced spherical coordinate representation. We discretize operators and wavefunctions, map the physical state onto qubits, and execute time evolution via parameterized quantum gate operations. By extracting the Υ(1S) survival probability, we quantitatively isolate the color-octet contribution to the correlated regeneration of the bottomonium ground state, demonstrating that its overall impact is small in the final production of the bottomonium ground state Υ(1S) in the hot QCD medium at temperatures accessible at the Large Hadron Collider. Additionally, we have further optimized the quantum simulation algorithm for the Lindblad equation. The improved algorithm requires only a single ancillary qubit to realize the Lindblad evolution, thereby minimizing the circuit significantly.
We revisit the pNRQCD open-quantum-system description of bottomonium in a quark-gluon plasma, writing the full master equation in a spherical basis and establishing a framework for its numerical treatment. The equation does not rely on an expansion in the ratio of the binding energy over the temperature, while retaining the Born, Markov, and dilute approximations. It depends on suitable convolutions of Coulombic Green's functions with real-time chromoelectric correlators, rather than a finite set of transport coefficients. It contains jump-operator contributions that enter with both positive and negative signs, so it is not of a Lindblad type. We utilize optimal operator rotations to minimize the negative sector and define a positive-sector approximation that retains only the optimized positive terms, obtaining in this way a Lindblad equation that can be simulated efficiently with the open-source code QTraj for arbitrary chromoelectric spectral functions. We treat the discarded sector as a systematic uncertainty associated with positivity-breaking effects of the pseudo-Lindblad generator. Positivity breaking effects can be attributed to the approximations made in the derivation of the quarkonium master equation, such as the Born--Markov approximations. Using a spectral model constrained by known infrared and ultraviolet limits, we compute the in-medium width and Bjorken-evolved survival probabilities of the Υ(1S,2S,3S)Υ(1\mathrm{S},2\mathrm{S},3\mathrm{S})Υ(1S,2S,3S). The computations show the convergence of the binding-energy-over-temperature expansion at high temperatures and provide the first large-scale quantum-trajectory simulation results for bottomonium in the low temperature regime. We can thus follow the bottomonium evolution over the full temperature range relevant in heavy-ion collisions.
Accurate modelling and understanding of quarkonium production in ultrarelativistic heavy ion collisions requires a formalism that preserves the quantum properties of microscopic QˉQ\bar{Q}QQˉ​Q systems while treating the interaction of such pairs with the quark-gluon plasma (QGP). The open quantum system approach has recently emerged as one of the most fruitful schemes to meet such requirements. However, the quantum master equations obtained so far in this context are derived assuming a strict ordering between the QGP temperature TTT and the QˉQ\bar{Q}QQˉ​Q energy gaps (ΔEΔEΔE) of the quarkonia bound states. This limits their predictive power since, as the QGP expands and cools down, the system traverse all regimes between the quantum Brownian motion (QBM) regime for T≳ΔET\gtrsim ΔET≳ΔE to the quantum optical (QO) regime for ΔE≳TΔE\gtrsim TΔE≳T. In this paper, we derive and present a more general non-abelian quantum master equation of the Lindblad type, which does not suffer from these limitations and thus allows to faithfully describe the quantum evolution of the QQˉQ\bar{Q}QQˉ​ pairs during the whole QGP-evolution. We also provide some illustration of the key quantities governing this equation.
I review recent applications of the open quantum system framework in the understanding of quarkonium suppression in heavy-ion collisions, which has been used as a probe of the quark–gluon plasma for decades. The derivation of the Lindblad equations for quarkonium in both the quantum Brownian motion and the quantum optical limits and their semiclassical counterparts is explained. The hierarchy of time scales assumed in the derivation is justified from the separation of energy scales in nonrelativistic effective field theories of QCD. Physical implications of the open quantum system approach are also discussed. Finally, I list some open questions for future studies.
\nIn recent years, a significant theoretical effort has been made towards a dynamical description of quarkonia inside the Quark-Gluon Plasma (QGP), using the open quantum systems formalism. In this framework, one can get a real-time description of a quantum system (here the quarkonium) in interaction with a thermal bath (the QGP) by integrating out the bath degrees of freedom and studying the system reduced density matrix. We investigate the real-time dynamics of a correlated heavy quark-antiquark pair inside the QGP using a quantum master equation previously derived from first QCD principles in [4]. The full equation is directly resolved in 1D to lessen computing costs and is used for the first time to gain insight on the dynamics in both a static and evolving medium following a Björken-like temperature evolution.\n
In recent years, a significant theoretical effort has been made towards a dynamical description of quarkonia inside the Quark-Gluon Plasma (QGP), using the open quantum systems formalism. In this framework, one can get a real-time description of a quantum system (here the quarkonium) in interaction with a thermal bath (the QGP) by integrating out the bath degrees of freedom and studying the system reduced density matrix. We investigate the real-time dynamics of a correlated heavy quark-antiquark pair inside the QGP using a quantum master equation previously derived from first QCD principles in [4]. The full equation is directly resolved in 1D to lessen computing costs and is used for the first time to gain insight on the dynamics in both a static and evolving medium following a Björken-like temperature evolution.