arXiv:2610.02032
Nonlocality without entanglement for multipartite quantum measurements
Satyaki Manna, Debashis Saha
Abstract
We show that a pair of two-qubit product measurements can be perfectly distinguished when accessed jointly, yet cannot be perfectly distinguished when their local components are distributed between distant parties restricted to local quantum operations and classical communication (LOCC). This establishes a measurement analogue of nonlocality without entanglement that, unlike its state-based counterpart, emerges in a remarkably simple setting. We further uncover a hierarchy of LOCC discrimination strategies: adaptive protocols, in which the probe used at one site may depend on classical information obtained from another, can strictly outperform restricted non-adaptive protocols, as demonstrated by a set of six bipartite qutrit product measurements. We also show that LOCC distinguishability of bipartite measurements can be intrinsically directional, depending on which party initiates the protocol. More generally, we construct pairs of $n$-qubit product measurements that are globally perfectly distinguishable but cannot be perfectly distinguished across any bipartition, even when all parties on either side of the bipartition are allowed arbitrary joint quantum operations. Finally, we show how quantum data hiding based on quantum-process nonlocality without entanglement can be realized using elementary optical components.
AI Summary
The paper asks whether nonlocality without entanglement can arise in discriminating distributed product measurements rather than product states. It studies single-use discrimination of demolition measurements: classical outcomes and retained probe ancillas are accessible, but post-measurement systems are not. Global strategies are compared with LOCC strategies using either fixed local probes or probes chosen adaptively from classical messages. The simplest example is the pair of two-qubit measurements $Z\otimes Z$ and $X\otimes X$. A Bell-state probe gives disjoint outcome parities, enabling perfect global discrimination, whereas local probing with classical communication cannot discriminate perfectly. A six-measurement construction on $\mathbb C^3\otimes\mathbb C^3$ separates adaptive probing from fixed-probe LOCC discrimination. For bipartite qubit projective measurements, the paper establishes equivalence of these two local strategies for perfect discrimination. A four-measurement qubit example exhibits dependence on which party probes first in the sequential protocol. For arbitrary $n\geq2$, a pair of $n$-qubit product measurements uses local bases separated by $\theta=\pi/(2n)$. An entangled parity-supported probe distinguishes them globally; the paper argues that perfect finite-round LOCC discrimination fails across every bipartition. Proofs use conditional-ancilla orthogonality, fidelity monotonicity and multiplicativity, and a spectral obstruction for blocks satisfying $m\theta<\pi/2$. An optical process-based data-hiding implementation is proposed, not demonstrated. The analysis concerns perfect single-shot discrimination, without quantifying optimal imperfect success probabilities or hiding security. Extensions to accessible post-measurement states and multiple device uses are left open.
Error found: The claimed starter-directionality theorem is false: Bob can query first using a maximally entangled probe and distinguish all four measurements by measuring his retained ancilla after Alice identifies the relevant pair. Appendix D incorrectly invokes permutation symmetry to cover all bipartitions from singleton cuts, although applying its lemma separately to the two block sizes repairs the proof.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 14 pages, 3 figures