arXiv:2610.02025
Operational transformation rates of quantum states
Giulia Mazzola, Renato Renner
Abstract
Typically, multiple copies of a quantum state are described by a tensor power of that state. However, from an operational point of view, an experimentalist cannot, in general, rule out imperfections at unknown positions or correlations between copies, so assuming independent and identically distributed (iid) copies is not justified a priori. In the following, we relax the iid assumption by considering a whole set of resource states that are fundamentally indistinguishable from a tensor power state, and in that sense look like many copies of the quantum state to the experimentalist. Using a de Finetti-type argument, we show that this operational set of states can asymptotically be represented by almost-iid states. As an application, we introduce operational analogues of asymptotic transformation rates, such as entanglement cost and distillation. This raises the question of whether these rates coincide with their iid counterparts.
AI Summary
The paper asks whether a single resource-conversion protocol can attain iid asymptotic rates when its input is unknown and potentially correlated, but passes tomography as copies of a reference state $\rho$. It defines an operational class of state sequences through tomography accuracy and confidence, requiring sample complexity polynomial in $1/\epsilon$ and $\log(1/\delta)$, and defines rates by requiring one protocol to map the entire input class into the corresponding target class. For permutation-invariant sequences, discarding $\lceil n^\alpha\rceil$ systems, for any $0<\alpha<1$, leaves a state approximable by an almost-iid state along $\rho$, with $O(n^\kappa)$ defects for some $\kappa<1$ and trace-distance error $2^{-\Omega(n^c)}$ for some $c>0$. The proof combines a tomography-localized de Finetti representation with a change-of-reference argument for almost-iid states. Under closure assumptions on free operations, this characterizes operational rates independently of the admissible tomography protocol. A blockwise construction establishes $R_{\mathcal F}(\rho\to\sigma)\leq\tilde R_{\mathcal F}(\rho\to\sigma)$; operational outputs may themselves contain defects. A converse bounds $\tilde R_{\mathcal F}$ by the ratio of regularized relative entropies of resource. For LOCC, a universal one-way decoupling protocol converts almost-iid Bell pairs into approximate iid Bell pairs at unit rate, yielding $\tilde E_D(\rho)=E_D(\rho)$. Pure-state conversion rates consequently retain their usual entropy-ratio formula. The framework assumes finite dimensions and tomography satisfying sampling consistency and noise robustness. Equality of operational and iid conversion rates remains open generally, including whether mixed-state operational entanglement cost equals standard entanglement cost.
Central claim may not hold: The abstract omits that the almost-iid characterization requires permutation symmetry, or prior symmetrization, and discarding a sublinear number of systems. The abstract's “fundamentally indistinguishable” describes only consistency with the chosen tomography criterion, although admitted states can be perfectly distinguishable from the tensor-power target by global measurements. The universal Bell-decoupling proof has a sign typo: the contribution to the lower bound on k/n is -10w_n/n, not +10w_n/n, without affecting the limiting rate.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 91 pages, 3 figures