arXiv:2610.01880
Symmetry considerations in chirality-induced spin selectivity
Dmitry Budker, Angela Wittmann
Abstract
The chirality-induced spin selectivity (CISS) effect, the coupling between structural chirality and electron spin polarization, has been experimentally observed across many diverse systems. However, despite extensive theoretical effort, a unified mechanistic understanding remains elusive. In this perspective, we demonstrate how some of the basic properties of the fascinating effects of CISS can be understood based on straightforward symmetry considerations commonly employed in fundamental particle physics. In particular, we show that CISS does not violate any fundamental symmetries including parity and time-reversal. By anchoring CISS within the universal language of symmetry, we offer a robust conceptual foundation for interpreting experiments and guiding future theoretical and experimental designs.
AI Summary
This perspective asks how chirality-induced spin selectivity (CISS) can be reconciled with parity and time-reversal symmetry, distinguishing current-driven “dynamic” CISS from “quasi-static” effects at chiral molecule–magnetic material interfaces. It analyzes transformation properties of rotationally invariant combinations of chirality, spin, current, electric dipole moment, and magnetization, rather than developing a microscopic transport model. For dynamic CISS, the proposed invariant is $\chi\,\mathbf{s}\cdot\mathbf{J}$, where chirality $\chi$ is parity-odd and time-reversal-even. This combination is even under both transformations and encodes reversal of spin polarization upon reversal of current or molecular handedness. For quasi-static CISS, an interface-induced electric dipole permits the parity-even combination $\chi\,\mathbf{d}\cdot\mathbf{m}$, which is time-reversal-odd. The discussion invokes dissipation to accommodate this apparent time asymmetry, using Ohm’s law as an analogy and introducing a schematic factor $i$ to represent time-reversal sign change. The resulting expression, $i\chi\,\mathbf{d}\cdot\mathbf{m}$, is presented as consistent with fundamental time-reversal invariance. The central conclusion is that these CISS correlations need not imply fundamental parity or time-reversal violation. The treatment is qualitative: it supplies symmetry classifications and parameter-reversal expectations, but no numerical predictions, experimental measurements, or microscopic mechanism. It explicitly does not predict effect magnitudes, and notes the absence of consensus on a quantitative measure of chirality. The dissipation argument is schematic rather than an explicit dynamical derivation.
Central claim may not hold: The quasi-static CISS discussion invokes dissipation without specifying a nonequilibrium process or demonstrating microscopic reversibility of its dynamics. The allowed scalar χ(s·J) establishes symmetry compatibility, not a spin-polarization response or a complete account of dynamic CISS phenomenology. Multiplying the T-odd correlation χ(d·m) by a schematic i does not establish a physically allowed dissipative response and therefore does not demonstrate time-reversal compatibility for quasi-static CISS.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.