Wheeler's delayed-choice experiment demonstrates wave-particle duality of particles using different experimental configurations of a Mach-Zehnder interferometer. In a quantum version of this experiment, the wave-particle behavior of photons can be observed by controlling presence or absence of the second beam splitter. Here, we implement a delayed-choice experiment with dual selections based on entangled photons, experimentally controlling both of two beam splitters in the Mach-Zehnder interferometer, where the presence and absence of the second beam splitter are simultaneously controlled through path encoding. Our experiment reveals the wave-particle behavior of single photons under different configurations of two beam splitters. We further discuss the scenario when two beam splitters are in a quantum superposition of being present and absent, photons will be in a wave-particle quantum superposition state.
AI Summary
The paper investigates a variant of Wheeler’s delayed-choice experiment in which both the input and output beam splitters of an effective Mach–Zehnder interferometer can be selected. It combines delayed-choice state preparation using entangled photons with path-dependent operations representing the presence or absence of the output beam splitter.
Polarization-entangled photon pairs are generated by type-II SPDC. The idler polarization serves as one ancilla, while the signal’s polarization and path encode the system and a second ancilla. Measuring the idler in the computational or diagonal basis conditionally prepares the signal in a basis state or coherent superposition, representing the input-beam-splitter selection. A Sagnac interferometer applies a Hadamard or Pauli-$Z$ operation in separate paths, representing the output selection. An additional 3 m of idler fiber delays its detection by approximately 11.5 ns relative to the signal; coincidences use a 1 ns window.
Phase-dependent coincidence measurements reproduce the predicted probabilities across four effective configurations. Interference appears only when both effective beam splitters are present, with measured visibilities of 97.35% and 95.87% for the two diagonal-basis outcomes. Intermediate wave-plate settings are analyzed theoretically to discuss partial interference and proposed wave–particle superpositions, rather than experimentally demonstrated.
The stated experimental limitations include imperfect entangled-state preparation, polarization separation, wave-plate alignment, background counts, and device instability. Only two of four output paths are monitored, with normalization reconstructed from measurements across idler outcomes. The implemented controlled operation differs from the circuit model, although the reported measurement probabilities are unchanged.
Little sign of AI-generated textOverclaimsIncrementalUnclear writing
Central claim may not hold: The experiment delays idler detection but provides no mechanism or timing evidence showing that the idler measurement basis is chosen after signal detection, leaving the advertised delayed basis choice unestablished.
The second ancilla is the signal photon's path and is read out at signal detection, so the claim that both selections occur after signal detection is not supported by the implementation.
The calculated partial-interference patterns do not establish coherent superpositions of present/absent beam-splitter configurations, because conditional polarization preparation and path-resolved probabilities do not test the required configuration coherence.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
Wheeler's delayed-choice experiment demonstrates wave-particle duality of particles using different experimental configurations of a Mach-Zehnder interferometer. In a quantum version of this experiment, the wave-particle behavior of photons can be observed by controlling presence or absence of the second beam splitter. Here, we implement a delayed-choice experiment with dual selections based on entangled photons, experimentally controlling both of two beam splitters in the Mach-Zehnder interferometer, where the presence and absence of the second beam splitter are simultaneously controlled through path encoding. Our experiment reveals the wave-particle behavior of single photons under different configurations of two beam splitters. We further discuss the scenario when two beam splitters are in a quantum superposition of being present and absent, photons will be in a wave-particle quantum superposition state.
The paper investigates a variant of Wheeler’s delayed-choice experiment in which both the input and output beam splitters of an effective Mach–Zehnder interferometer can be selected. It combines delayed-choice state preparation using entangled photons with path-dependent operations representing the presence or absence of the output beam splitter.
Polarization-entangled photon pairs are generated by type-II SPDC. The idler polarization serves as one ancilla, while the signal’s polarization and path encode the system and a second ancilla. Measuring the idler in the computational or diagonal basis conditionally prepares the signal in a basis state or coherent superposition, representing the input-beam-splitter selection. A Sagnac interferometer applies a Hadamard or Pauli-Z operation in separate paths, representing the output selection. An additional 3 m of idler fiber delays its detection by approximately 11.5 ns relative to the signal; coincidences use a 1 ns window.
Phase-dependent coincidence measurements reproduce the predicted probabilities across four effective configurations. Interference appears only when both effective beam splitters are present, with measured visibilities of 97.35% and 95.87% for the two diagonal-basis outcomes. Intermediate wave-plate settings are analyzed theoretically to discuss partial interference and proposed wave–particle superpositions, rather than experimentally demonstrated.
The stated experimental limitations include imperfect entangled-state preparation, polarization separation, wave-plate alignment, background counts, and device instability. Only two of four output paths are monitored, with normalization reconstructed from measurements across idler outcomes. The implemented controlled operation differs from the circuit model, although the reported measurement probabilities are unchanged.
A quantum system can behave as a wave or as a particle, depending on the experimental arrangement. When, for example, measuring a photon using a Mach-Zehnder interferometer, the photon acts as a wave if the second beam splitter is inserted, but as a particle if this beam splitter is omitted. The decision of whether or not to insert this beam splitter can be made after the photon has entered the interferometer, as in Wheeler's famous delayed-choice thought experiment. In recent quantum versions of this experiment, this decision is controlled by a quantum ancilla, while the beam splitter is itself still a classical object. Here, we propose and realize a variant of the quantum delayed-choice experiment. We configure a superconducting quantum circuit as a Ramsey interferometer, where the element that acts as the first beam splitter can be put in a quantum superposition of its active and inactive states, as verified by the negative values of its Wigner function. We show that this enables the wave and particle aspects of the system to be observed with a single setup, without involving an ancilla that is not itself a part of the interferometer. We also study the transition of this quantum beam splitter from a quantum to a classical object due to decoherence, as observed by monitoring the interferometer output.
Light's wave-particle duality is at the heart of quantum mechanics and can be well illustrated by Wheeler's delayed-choice experiment: The choice of inserting or removing the second classical (quantum) beam splitter in a Mach-Zehnder interferometer determines the classical (quantum) wave-particle behavior of a photon. In this paper, we report our experiment on directly observing simultaneous wave and particle behavior in a narrowband single-photon wave packet by classically inserting or removing the second beam splitter when part of the wave packet passes through it. Our experiment demonstrates that the produced wave-particle state can be utilized in encoding quantum information.
Wave-particle duality constitutes one of the most intriguing features in quantum physics. A well-known gedanken experiment that provides evidence for this is Wheeler's delayed-choice experiment based on a Mach-Zehnder interferometer [J. A. Wheeler, in Mathematical Foundations of Quantum Theory, edited by A. R. Marlow (Academic, New York, 1978), pp. 9--48; in Quantum Theory and Measurement, edited by J. A. Wheeler and W. H. Zurek (Princeton University Press, Princeton, 1984), pp. 182--213]. Many different versions of delayed-choice experiments have been conducted with both classical and quantum detecting devices. Recently, it was proposed that the delayed-choice experiment could be devised from the perspective of a device-independent prepare-and-measure scenario [R. Chaves et al., Causal Modeling the Delayed-Choice Experiment, Phys. Rev. Lett. 120, 190401 (2018)]. In our work, we experimentally realize this modified version with a deterministic single-photon source and examine the wave-particle objective in a causal-modeled scheme without the assistance of entanglement, which is achieved by violating the dimension-witness inequalities. Our experiment also provides an intriguing perspective and exhibits the benefits of studying quantum theory from the casual model point of view.
Bohr's complementarity notion is at the heart of quantum physics. It suggests that quantum systems are observed as waves or particles depending on the type of measurement, i.e., the experimental arrangement, they are subjected to. For instance, sending single photons to an open or closed Mach-Zehnder interferometer (MZI) leads to the observation of particle or wave behaviours, respectively. In 1984, Wheeler proposed a "Gedanken" delayed-choice experiment in which the interferometer configuration is chosen at will by the experimentalist only after the photon has already passed the input beam-splitter (BS_in) of the device. This experiment was realized using a single photon source and showed that Bohr's complementarity notion was still obeyed.It was recently proposed to take Wheeler's experiment one step further by employing an output "quantum beam-splitter" (QBS), i.e.,preparing BS_out in a coherent superposition of being absent and present. This allows choosing the type of measurement, i.e., wave or particle, only after having determined the state of the QBS, which can be (in principle) infinitely delayed.We realized such an experiment by exploiting the resource of entanglement, in this case pairs of polarization entangled photons. The behaviour of one of the paired photons, called the test photon, is analysed using a MZI having a QBS at its output. This QBS is enabled by entanglement and made of a polarization dependent beam-splitter. The other photon, called the corroborative photon, allows determining the state of the QBS, and consequently, which test photon behaviour (wave, particle, or both) is observed.By manipulating the corroborative photon polarization state, we demonstrate a continuous morphing of the test photon from wave to particle behaviour. This refutes simple models of single photons behaving exclusively as waves or particles. The state of the QBS is determined via the measurement of the corroborative photon only after the test photon has already been detected. The space-like separation between the two measurements invalidates local-hidden variable models associated with pre-existing information about the measurement outcomes. In other words, when the test photon is detected, no information is available about the type of measurement it underwent. These results still perfectly obey Bohr's complementarity notion and its extension.
Bohr's complementarity notion is at the heart of quantum physics, and suggests that in a quantum experiment, the observed phenomena are inherently linked to the type of measurement that is performed. For example, sending single photons to an open or closed Mach-Zehnder interferometer leads to the observation of particle or wave behaviours. In 1984, Wheeler proposed a 'Gedanken' experiment in which the experimentalist chooses the interferometer configuration, at will, only after the photon has already passed the input beam-splitter (BSin) of the device. This experiment was realized using a diamond-based single photon source, and it was shown that Bohr's complementarity notion was still obeyed, as expected. It was recently proposed theoretically to take Wheeler's experiment one step further by employing a 'quantum beam-splitter' (QBS) at the interferometer output. In this case, the output beam-splitter (BSout) is placed in a coherent superposition of being absent and present, which also allows to further delay the choice of the measurement type. The type of measurement is determined only after having measured the state of the QBS, which can be (in principle) infinitely delayed. We demonstrate the realization of such an experiment by exploiting entanglement. In particular, we take advantage of pairs of polarization entangled photons. The behaviour of one of the paired photons, called the test photon, is analysed by sending it to a Mach-Zehnder interferometer having an entanglement-enabled QBS at its output. This device is made of a polarization dependent beam-splitter followed by polarization state erasers. The other photon, called the corroborative photon, allows determining the actual state of the QBS, and consequently, which test photon behaviour (wave, particle, or both) is measured. By manipulating the corroborative photon, we demonstrate a continuous morphing from wave to particle behaviour, which refutes too simple views of single photons behaving exclusively as waves or particles. The measurements on the test photon and the interferometer configuration are performed in a strictly delayed manner. The state of the QBS is measured only after the test photon already left the interferometer, and is detected, which means that it is destroyed before the type of measurement it under- goes is determined. We find that even in this configuration, Bohr's complementarity notion, and its extension, are perfectly obeyed. The space-like separation between the measurements invalidates local-hidden variable models associated with pre-existing information about the measurement out- comes. In other words, when the test photon is detected, no information is available about the type of measurement that was performed. This assertion is confirmed by the violation of the Bell's inequalities with more than 10 standard deviations. The presence of entanglement shows furthermore that genuine quantum behaviour for the test photons has been observed. As a conclusion, we have demonstrated the experimental realization of the quantum version of Wheeler's experiment. Trying to explain our observations in classical terms causes severe contradictions, but the results are in perfect agreement with quantum physics, in which the measurement timing order does not matter. The beauty in such experiments is that space and time do not seem to play any role.