arXiv:2610.01549
Molecular Dynamics with Nuclear Effects on Quantum Computers
Lukas Haßfurth, Juliane Heitkämper, Elias Walter, Birger Horstmann
Abstract
Nuclear quantum effects are critical for describing proton transfer and hydrogen bonding, but their incorporation into quantum chemistry calculations is often computationally prohibitive on classical hardware. A promising alternative are quantum computers due to their linear scaling in the space requirements with system size. We introduce a novel hybrid quantum-classical algorithm for ab-initio molecular dynamics that incorporates nuclear quantum effects via the nuclear-electronic orbital method. The proposed algorithm evaluates ground state energies and forces on the quantum computer using a variational quantum eigensolver, while the molecular geometries are updated classically. We validate our approach through simulations of $\text{H}_2$, $\text{H}_2\text{O}$ and the Zundel ion $\text{H}_5\text{O}_2^+$, comparing the simulated vibrational spectra with experimental data. Upon inclusion of nuclear quantum effects, the proton shuttling movement in the Zundel ion becomes effectively barrierless, and errors in the simulated frequencies improve significantly. Employing compact hardware-efficient ansatz circuits we achieve results comparable to the more accurate UCCSD ansatzes, which hints towards the feasibility of executing our algorithm on near-term quantum devices.
AI Summary
The paper asks how to incorporate nuclear quantum effects into quantum-computer-assisted ab-initio molecular dynamics. It combines the nuclear-electronic orbital (NEO) framework, which treats selected nuclei and electrons in second quantization, with VQE ground-state preparation and force evaluation at each timestep. Geometries and nuclear basis centers are propagated classically using velocity Verlet. The implementation includes active-space embedding, orbital tracking across geometries, and analytical force operators. Validation uses noiseless statevector simulations of $\mathrm{H}_2$, water, and the Zundel ion $\mathrm{H}_5\mathrm{O}_2^+$, with 1-ps trajectories, 121-as timesteps, and approximately $33\,\mathrm{cm}^{-1}$ spectral resolution. For water, NEO-UCCSD gives vibrational-frequency errors of $-0.9\%$, $-1.0\%$, and $-1.9\%$, compared with purely electronic errors of $6.8\%$, $5.3\%$, and $2.8\%$. For hydrogen, NEO instead shifts the error from $+4.6\%$ to $-5.0\%$. In constrained Zundel proton-transfer scans, NEO changes a double-well effective potential into a single well. Including nuclear $p_z$ orbitals enables mode coupling and a spectral doublet near the experimental $930$ and $1062\,\mathrm{cm}^{-1}$ peaks. A reduced 17-excitation NEOUCCSD circuit gives peak deviations below $40\,\mathrm{cm}^{-1}$ from exact active-space dynamics. The semiclassical propagation assumes localized, quasi-distinguishable nuclei whose mean positions track basis centers; larger nuclear bases can violate this assumption and underestimate frequencies. Results depend strongly on active-space and nuclear-basis choices. Hardware-efficient circuits reproduce simpler-system frequencies less consistently and fail to reproduce the Zundel spectrum. No noisy-hardware execution or quantum advantage is demonstrated.
Error found: The abstract's hardware-efficient-versus-UCCSD comparison needs qualification because the hardware-efficient ansatzes fail on the Zundel ion's spectral structure and nonlinear mode coupling. The nuclear dynamics relies on localized, sufficiently pinned nuclear densities and does not demonstrate systematic nuclear-basis convergence. The stated 50 meV initial excitation conflicts with the amplitude appendix's 5 meV upper bound, leaving an unresolved discrepancy relevant to anharmonic frequencies. The displayed analytical-gradient operator omits the Hamiltonian's two-body prefactors of 1/2, although the later embedded-force expression includes them. The embedding appendix reverses the exchange signs in its symmetrization correction, contradicting both its starting force expression and its final generalized Fock matrix.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 21 pages, 14 figures