arXiv:2610.01523
Inherent Turbulence Immunity of Vector Vortex Beams in Free Space Quantum Key Distribution
Behnam Talari, Rouhollah Karimzadeh
Abstract
Orbital angular momentum (OAM) multiplexing provides an infinite-dimensional discrete Hilbert space ideally suited for high-capacity free-space quantum key distribution (QKD). Nevertheless, pure scalar spatial modes carrying topological charge ($|\ell| \ge 1$) undergo severe decoherence when transmitted through terrestrial atmospheric turbulence. Turbulent refractive-index eddies split high-order vortex singularities, induce catastrophic intermodal crosstalk across adjacent topological channels, and rapidly drive the quantum bit error rate (QBER) well above the unconditional 11% security threshold associated with individual cloning attacks. Here, we demonstrate that hybrid polarization-OAM entangled states, known as vector vortex beams (VVBs), provide intrinsic, hardware-free immunity against turbulent perturbations. Because the optical anisotropy of terrestrial air is exceedingly small ($Δn < 10^{-9}$), refractive-index fluctuations couple symmetrically to orthogonal circular polarization modes as an identical common-mode scalar phase screen that cancels in the relative polarization-phase degree of freedom. By numerically propagating modal fields through modified power-spectral phase screens over turbulence strengths ranging from $D/r_0 = 0$ to $3.0$, we show that the VVB encoding protocol suppresses the asymptotic QBER from 42.0% to 4.8%, yielding an error-suppression factor of approximately 11.6 without requiring active adaptive optics or deformable mirrors.
AI Summary
The paper investigates whether hybrid polarization–orbital-angular-momentum encoding can reduce turbulence-induced errors in free-space QKD without adaptive optics. It considers vector vortex states $\bigl(|R\rangle|+\ell\rangle+e^{i\alpha}|L\rangle|-\ell\rangle\bigr)/\sqrt{2}$. Modeling atmospheric turbulence as an identical scalar phase screen on both polarization components, it derives cancellation of that phase in their pointwise relative phase and consequently in local normalized Stokes parameters. The study is numerical, with a proposed transceiver architecture rather than a reported QKD experiment. Modified-spectrum random phase screens are generated on a $256\times256$ grid over a $6\,\mathrm{mm}$ aperture, spanning turbulence strengths $D/r_0=0$–$3$. Scalar-mode survival is assigned an exponential decay model, while vector-state survival is taken to remain near unity with a hardware-dependent floor; QBER is calculated as $(1-P)/2$. Reported results include scalar QBER approaching $50\%$, versus approximately $4.8\%$ for vector encoding, and vector-state fidelity above $90\%$. The text also reports a vector QBER below $5.8\%$ at $D/r_0=3$, despite describing a turbulence-independent $4.8\%$ floor elsewhere. These values are compared with an asserted $11\%$ security threshold; no protocol-specific security analysis is presented. The stated residual-error sources are SLM pixelation and phase quantization, crystal-induced astigmatism and walk-off, and finite-aperture/modal-overlap effects. The protection argument assumes polarization-independent scalar turbulence and establishes local phase cancellation, which is then used to motivate the claimed modal-survival and QKD performance.
Central claim may not hold: Common-phase cancellation preserves local polarization immediately at a phase screen, but the paper's VVB full-state fidelity under that screen equals the scalar-mode fidelity, invalidating the inference of inherently protected modal transmission. The paper assumes near-unity VVB survival and converts it into QBER without specifying receiver projections, a complete QKD encoding, or an error model that justifies the conversion. The claimed approximately 11.6-fold error suppression disagrees with both 42.0%/4.8% = 8.75 and 40.3%/4.8% ≈ 8.40. At D/r0 = 1.2 and ℓ = 2, the scalar survival model predicts approximately 0.194 and 40.3% QBER, whereas the stated approximately 0.11 target-mode histogram probability implies 44.5% using the paper's QBER formula.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 9 figures