arXiv:2610.01462
Unbounded separation between definite and indefinite causal order in finite-dimensional quantum metrology
Yanglin Hu, Zi-Shen Li, Giulio Chiribella, Yuxiang Yang
Abstract
Indefinite causal order is known to offer enhancements in quantum metrology, notably including an unbounded advantage in the measurement of a geometric phase of a harmonic oscillator. This advantage, however, is specific to the infinite dimensional setting, and its finite dimensional analogue remains elusive, with recent findings suggesting that advantages in finite dimensions may be fundamentally limited to bounded constant factors. Here we show that, in fact, arbitrarily large advantages arise for finite dimensional systems in the finite sample regime. Specifically, we establish an unbounded separation between definite and indefinite causal order in the estimation of a geometric phase associated to two sets of $N$ displacements generated by discrete position and momentum operators on a $d$-dimensional quantum system: for any given constant $R$, there exist values of $N$ and $d=Ω(N^2)$ such that a strategy with indefinite order uses an initial probe with $R$ times less energy than the probe required by every strategy with definite order achieving the same mean squared error, whenever the number of measurement shots $ν$ is bounded as $ν=\mathcal{O}(\exp(πd/16)/\mathrm{poly}(d))$. In other words, indefinite order offers an energy saving that grows arbitrarily large with the parameters of the problem. To prove this result, we establish an approximate Weyl relation for discrete Gaussian wavepackets, which is of independent technical interest.
AI Summary
Can indefinite causal order provide an arbitrarily large metrological advantage using finite-dimensional probes? This paper studies estimation of the symplectic product $\bar\omega$ of two average phase-space displacements, given two sets of $N$ unknown displacement oracles on a $d$-dimensional system. The resource compared is initial probe energy, measured by $H=X^2+P^2$. A quantum switch superposes the two orders of the displacement sets, approximately encoding $N^2\bar\omega$ on a control qubit. With a discrete Gaussian probe of energy $E_{\mathrm{ICO}}\simeq1$, the protocol achieves $\mathrm{MSE}=O(1/(\nu N^4))$. This requires $d=\Omega(N^2)$ and holds within a finite-sample window $\nu=O(e^{\pi d/16}/\mathrm{poly}(d))$, with sufficient shots for phase unwrapping. For definite-order protocols using the same fixed order in every shot, a lower bound $\mathrm{MSE}=\Omega(1/(\nu E_{\mathrm{DCO}}N^2))$ implies an initial-energy ratio growing as $\Omega(N^2)$ at matched precision, even with unrestricted later energy injection. The construction establishes a state-dependent approximate Weyl relation for discrete Gaussian wavepackets, with error $O(\mathrm{poly}(d)e^{-\pi d/16})$ while trajectories remain away from phase-space boundaries. Ramsey measurements and tunable oracle attenuation provide estimation and phase unwrapping; the definite-order bound uses side information and quantum Fisher information for the first oracle. The separation is across growing finite-dimensional instances, not unbounded at fixed dimension. Boundary errors limit the stated precision window, and the switched protocol reaches intermediate energies $O(N^2)$, so the result is not a total-energy saving. Suggested spin implementations additionally require control of curvature errors.
Central claim may not hold: The abstract claims an advantage over every definite-causal-order strategy, but the proof excludes classically varying orders between shots, which can bypass the low-initial-energy first-oracle bottleneck using unrestricted intermediate energy injection. The global quantum-switch MSE guarantee requires sufficiently many shots for phase unwrapping, a condition absent from the abstract's window specified only by an upper bound. For arbitrary displacement vectors, the stated sufficient bulk dimension has a leading coefficient four times too small because all 2N displacements can contribute to each coordinate.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 47 pages, 3 figures