arXiv:2610.00739
How Superradiance Survives Molecular Noise inside Virus Capsids
Tianran Li, Irina Tsvetkova, Matthew Brauser, Amala Raj, Philip Shushkov, Bogdan Dragnea
Abstract
Excited organic dyes chemically bound to an icosahedral virus shell can spontaneously synchronize and emit a superradiant burst of light. The mechanism that allows it to occur at room temperature, despite collisional dephasing and inhomogeneous broadening, is not understood. Few other known low-dimensional condensed matter systems exhibit room-temperature superradiance (SR). In the fluctuation-prone environment of molecular-based systems, electron--vibrational coupling has been proposed to play a central role. Here, we addressed experimentally the existence of underdamped virus capsid phonon-like modes and theoretically their involvement in the transition from uncorrelated to cooperative emission. We find that SR-active dye-labeled capsids exhibit underdamped low-frequency oscillations that modulate the dye excited-state response, and modeling shows how such capsid motion can promote the collective polarization required for superradiant emission.
AI Summary
The paper asks how cooperative emission can persist at room temperature in aqueous suspensions of virus capsids densely labeled with organic dyes. Building on previously observed superradiant bursts from Oregon Green–labeled brome mosaic virus, it tests whether collective capsid vibrations provide a dynamical contribution beyond emitter density and static symmetry. Ultrafast transient-absorption measurements on capsids carrying approximately 300 dyes reveal reproducible oscillatory modulation near $0.9$–$1.0\,\mathrm{cm}^{-1}$, absent in free-dye and weakly labeled controls. As an independent mechanical probe, protein shells assembled around 20-nm gold nanoparticles introduce a component near $1.3\,\mathrm{cm}^{-1}$ alongside the gold-core breathing mode at $5.1\,\mathrm{cm}^{-1}$. Coupled-oscillator and elastic models support interpreting these signals as underdamped, capsid-associated acoustic-like motion. A minimal open-system simulation couples 10 two-level emitters, collective radiative decay, independent stochastic transition-energy fluctuations, and one self-consistently driven classical vibrational coordinate. Noise suppresses the delayed cooperative burst. In the tested cases, common transition-energy modulation and static emitter coupling do not restore it; vibrational modulation of emitter–emitter coupling does. A two-emitter analysis attributes protection to an increased bright–dark energy splitting that reduces disorder-induced mixing. The model also produces trailing emission oscillations, compared with a secondary experimental feature near 55 ps. The measurements do not uniquely identify a normal mode or resolve the proposed soft-mode manifold. Gold-core particles differ geometrically from native capsids. The 10-emitter model is intended to identify a possible mechanism rather than reproduce the full dye ensemble; its radiative rate and vibrational frequency are adjusted to experimental timing.
Central claim may not hold: The superradiance model's stated parameters drive its dimensionless oscillator toward an initial displaced equilibrium near −2857, permitting interaction changes around 286 THz without reconciling that amplitude with the 0.035 nm fluctuation used to estimate the modulation coefficient. The static-coupling control is much weaker than the interactions permitted by the driven model, so the comparison does not isolate dynamic modulation as the reason cooperative emission recovers. The printed Langevin force covariance divides by k_B T instead of multiplying by it and omits the white-noise time delta, although the manuscript does not establish whether this error affected the calculations.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.