Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2610.00439 · Entropy

No-signaling-in-time condition for three-flavor neutrino oscillations

Massimo Blasone, Fabrizio Illuminati, Luciano Petruzziello, Kyrylo Simonov, Luca Smaldone

hep-thhep-phquant-phSubmitted Sep 30, 2026• Announced Oct 1, 2026• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Macrorealism is a fundamental concept in quantum foundations, capturing basic features of our everyday experience. Among the main tools introduced to test violations of macrorealism are the Leggett-Garg inequalities. These inequalities provide necessary and sufficient conditions for a certain data set including the correlators measured in a number of different experimental runs (weak version of macrorealism). Leggett-Garg inequalities have proved useful for detecting violations of macrorealism in neutrino oscillation experiments. However, it is interesting to investigate a set of necessary and sufficient conditions for strong macrorealism - no-signaling-in-time and arrow-of-time conditions - in order to obtain a more complete characterization of macrorealism in the context of neutrino oscillations. In particular, here we extend previous study of the no-signaling-in-time condition to the case of three-flavor neutrino oscillations, including the CP-violating phase of the Pontecorvo-Maki-Nakagawa-Sakata matrix.

AI Summary

The paper asks how no-signaling-in-time (NSIT) tests of macrorealism extend from two-flavor to three-flavor neutrino oscillations, including the CP-violating phase $\delta$ of the PMNS matrix. It compares NSIT and arrow-of-time conditions, which characterize the strong form of macrorealism considered here, with standard and Wigner-form Leggett–Garg inequalities (LGIs). The calculation starts from a muon neutrino and uses an ideal dichotomic measurement distinguishing electron flavor from the coherent muon–tau subspace at times $0,t,2t$. Sequential projective-measurement probabilities reduce the NSIT/AoT requirements to one nontrivial equality, $\mathcal N(t)=0$, where $\mathcal N$ is the difference between the electron-detection probability at $2t$ without an intermediate measurement and its value after an unrecorded measurement at $t$. Explicit expressions are derived for this witness and the LGIs, with numerical comparisons using Gaussian wave-packet decoherence. For the parameters studied, NSIT remains violated beyond the coherence timescale, whereas standard LGIs are satisfied over most of the plotted interval; one standard inequality is violated at short times. Three-flavor mixing separates two LGI expressions that coincide in the two-flavor model. The witnesses depend on $\delta$, and the reported NSIT violation is enhanced for the nonzero-phase case examined relative to $\delta=0$. The numerical illustrations use $E=10\,\mathrm{GeV}$ and $\sigma_x=0.5\,\mathrm{GeV}^{-1}$; the wave-packet width is chosen for conceptual illustration. The treatment assumes ideal measurements. Possible discrimination between quantum-field-theoretic descriptions of neutrino mixing is left for future quantitative investigation.

Little sign of AI-generated textIncrementalStrong assumptionsPossible error

Error found: The claimed NSIT violation beyond the wave-packet coherence time lacks a consistent sequential wave-packet derivation, because intermediate flavor projection does not generally reset the spatial state needed for the paper's factorized transition probabilities. The charged-lepton flavor-resolving measurement followed by coarse-graining described operationally removes muon–tau coherence, whereas the calculated sequential probabilities retain it through an ideal dichotomic Lüders projection.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Journal reference
Entropy 28, 1086 (2026)
DOI
10.3390/e28101086
Comments
9 pages, 7 figures

Related papers

No-signaling-in-time as a condition for macrorealism: the case of neutrino oscillations

Massimo Blasone, Fabrizio Illuminati, Luciano Petruzziello +2 more

Abstract We consider two necessary and sufficient conditions for macrorealism recently appeared in the literature, known as no-signaling-in-time and arrow-of-time conditions, respectively, and study them in the context of neutrino flavor transitions, within both the plane wave description and the wave packet approach. We then compare the outcome of the above investigation with the implication of various formulations of Leggett–Garg inequalities. In particular, we show that the fulfillment of the addressed conditions for macrorealism in neutrino oscillations implies the fulfillment of the Leggett–Garg inequalities, whereas the converse is not true. Finally, in the framework of wave packet approach, we also prove that, for distances longer than the coherence length, the no-signaling-in-time condition is always violated whilst the Leggett–Garg inequalities are not.

arXiv:2211.16931•The European Physical Journal C•Aug 3, 2023•21 citations

Comparing conditions for macrorealism: Leggett-Garg inequalities versus no-signaling in time

J. J. Halliwell

We consider two different types of conditions which were proposed to test macrorealism in the context of a system described by a single dichotomic variable $Q$. This is the view that a macroscopic system evolving in time possesses definite properties which can be determined without disturbing the future or past state. The Leggett-Garg (LG) inequalities, the most commonly studied test, are only necessary conditions for macrorealism, but, building on earlier work J. J. Halliwell, Phys. Rev. A 93, 022123 (2016), it is shown that when the four three-time LG inequalities are augmented with a certain set of two-time inequalities also of the LG form, Fine's theorem applies and these augmented conditions are then both necessary and sufficient. A comparison is carried out with a very different set of necessary and sufficient conditions for macrorealism, namely the no-signaling in time (NSIT) conditions proposed by J. Kofler and C. Brukner, Phys. Rev. A 87, 052115 (2013) and L. Clemente and J. Kofler, Phys. Rev. A 91, 062103 (2015), which ensure that all probabilities for $Q$ at one and two times are independent of whether earlier or intermediate measurements are made in a given run, and do not require (but imply) the LG inequalities. We argue that tests based on the LG inequalities have the form of very weak classicality conditions and can be satisfied in the face of moderate interference effects, but those based on NSIT conditions have the form of much stronger coherence witness conditions, satisfied only for zero interference. The two tests differ in their implementation of noninvasive measurability and so are testing different notions of macrorealism: the augmented LG tests are indirect, entailing a combination of the results of different experiments with only compatible quantities measured in each experimental run, in close analogy with Bell tests, and are primarily tests for macrorealism per se; in contrast, the NSIT tests entail sequential measurements of incompatible quantities and are primarily tests for noninvasiveness.

arXiv:1704.01485•Physical Review A•Jul 20, 2017•44 citations

Tests of macrorealism in meson oscillation physics

Massimo Blasone, Fabrizio Illuminati, Luciano Petruzziello +2 more

Macrorealism formalizes the seemingly intuitive notion that, in contrast with the principles of quantum mechanics, a physical system can be in a definite state at any given time and moreover its dynamical evolution is independent of the measurements performed on it. In this study, we carry out a comparative analysis between three-time Leggett--Garg-type inequalities and the conditions of no-signaling-in-time and arrow-of-time for macrorealism within the context of meson oscillations. Our findings indicate that, under given initial conditions, no violations of Leggett--Garg inequalities are observed. However, no-signaling-in-time conditions are found to be violated, thereby revealing the impossibility of applying a macrorealistic description to the physics of meson oscillations.

arXiv:2402.13299•Physical Review A•Jun 10, 2024•5 citations

Revealing violations of macrorealism in flavor oscillations: Leggett-Garg inequalities and no-signaling-in-time conditions

Massimo Blasone, Fabrizio Illuminati, Luciano Petruzziello +2 more

Abstract. We briefly review recent developments in the study of the quantum nature of flavor mixing; in particular, the attention will be devoted to neutrino and neutral meson oscillations. We employ Leggett-Garg type inequalities and no-signaling-in-time conditions to probe the intrinsic quantumness of such a physical manifestation, showing how the analysis is not affected by the wave-packet spreading (for neutrinos) and the intrinsic particle instability (for mesons).

EPJ Web of Conferences•Jan 1, 2024•0 citations

Neutrino oscillations as a probe of macrorealism

Kathrine Mørch Groth, Johann Ioannou-Nikolaides, D. J. Koskinen +1 more

The correlations between successive measurements of a quantum system can violate a family of Leggett-Garg Inequalities (LGIs) that are analogous to the violation of Bell’s inequalities of measurements performed on spatially separated quantum systems. These LGIs follow from a point of view, imposing that a classical system is at all times in a definite state and that a measurement can, at least in principle, leave this state undisturbed. Violations of LGIs can be probed by neutrino flavor oscillations if the correlators of consecutive flavor measurements are approximately stationary. We discuss here several improvements of the methodology used in previous analyses based on accelerator and reactor neutrino data. We argue that the strong claims of LGI violations made in previous studies are based on an unsuitable modeling of macrorealistic systems in statistical hypothesis tests. We illustrate our improved methodology via the example of the MINOS muon-neutrino survival data, where we find revised statistical evidence for violations of LGIs at the ( 2 – 3 ) σ level, depending on macrorealistic background models.

arXiv:2504.05375•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•Nov 12, 2025•4 citations

A General Framework for Leggett--Garg Violation in Neutrino Oscillations and Matter Effects

M. M. Ettefaghi, H. Hajipour

The Leggett--Garg inequality (LGI) constrains temporal correlations under the assumptions of macrorealism and noninvasive measurability. We study the four-time quantity \(K_4\) for two-flavor neutrino oscillations using a pseudo-density matrix (PDM) under static conditions, instead of non-invasive measurement. With this approach, it becomes possible to examine a Horodecki-type criterion for the temporal Pauli-correlation tensor. The Horodecki criterion had been proven for CHSH inequality (R. Horodecki et al. Phys. Lett. \textbf{A200}, 340), For any unitary qubit evolution, the corresponding scalar is \(M_R=2\). Although, this result characterizes the correlation tensor and the optimized temporal construction, it does not imply that a fixed flavor observable violates the LGI at every neutrino energy or baseline. We therefore evaluate \(K_4\) explicitly for flavor measurements in matter of constant density. The numerical examples illustrate how matter effects modify the temporal correlations, with a pronounced matter--vacuum separation near the MSW resonance for the chosen parameters and generally smaller differences in the selected off-resonance cases. This finding motivates further investigation of matter-induced temporal correlations in atmospheric neutrinos and their potential relevance to future studies with long-baseline and atmospheric-neutrino experiments, including DUNE and Hyper-Kamiokande.

quant-pharXiv:2610.34832•Oct 27, 2026•0 citations
Macrorealism is a fundamental concept in quantum foundations, capturing basic features of our everyday experience. Among the main tools introduced to test violations of macrorealism are the Leggett-Garg inequalities. These inequalities provide necessary and sufficient conditions for a certain data set including the correlators measured in a number of different experimental runs (weak version of macrorealism). Leggett-Garg inequalities have proved useful for detecting violations of macrorealism in neutrino oscillation experiments. However, it is interesting to investigate a set of necessary and sufficient conditions for strong macrorealism - no-signaling-in-time and arrow-of-time conditions - in order to obtain a more complete characterization of macrorealism in the context of neutrino oscillations. In particular, here we extend previous study of the no-signaling-in-time condition to the case of three-flavor neutrino oscillations, including the CP-violating phase of the Pontecorvo-Maki-Nakagawa-Sakata matrix.
The paper asks how no-signaling-in-time (NSIT) tests of macrorealism extend from two-flavor to three-flavor neutrino oscillations, including the CP-violating phase δ\deltaδ of the PMNS matrix. It compares NSIT and arrow-of-time conditions, which characterize the strong form of macrorealism considered here, with standard and Wigner-form Leggett–Garg inequalities (LGIs).
The calculation starts from a muon neutrino and uses an ideal dichotomic measurement distinguishing electron flavor from the coherent muon–tau subspace at times 0,t,2t0,t,2t0,t,2t. Sequential projective-measurement probabilities reduce the NSIT/AoT requirements to one nontrivial equality, N(t)=0\mathcal N(t)=0N(t)=0, where N\mathcal NN is the difference between the electron-detection probability at 2t2t2t without an intermediate measurement and its value after an unrecorded measurement at ttt. Explicit expressions are derived for this witness and the LGIs, with numerical comparisons using Gaussian wave-packet decoherence.
For the parameters studied, NSIT remains violated beyond the coherence timescale, whereas standard LGIs are satisfied over most of the plotted interval; one standard inequality is violated at short times. Three-flavor mixing separates two LGI expressions that coincide in the two-flavor model. The witnesses depend on δ\deltaδ, and the reported NSIT violation is enhanced for the nonzero-phase case examined relative to δ=0\delta=0δ=0.
The numerical illustrations use E=10 GeVE=10\,\mathrm{GeV}E=10GeV and σx=0.5 GeV−1\sigma_x=0.5\,\mathrm{GeV}^{-1}σx​=0.5GeV−1; the wave-packet width is chosen for conceptual illustration. The treatment assumes ideal measurements. Possible discrimination between quantum-field-theoretic descriptions of neutrino mixing is left for future quantitative investigation.
Abstract We consider two necessary and sufficient conditions for macrorealism recently appeared in the literature, known as no-signaling-in-time and arrow-of-time conditions, respectively, and study them in the context of neutrino flavor transitions, within both the plane wave description and the wave packet approach. We then compare the outcome of the above investigation with the implication of various formulations of Leggett–Garg inequalities. In particular, we show that the fulfillment of the addressed conditions for macrorealism in neutrino oscillations implies the fulfillment of the Leggett–Garg inequalities, whereas the converse is not true. Finally, in the framework of wave packet approach, we also prove that, for distances longer than the coherence length, the no-signaling-in-time condition is always violated whilst the Leggett–Garg inequalities are not.
We consider two different types of conditions which were proposed to test macrorealism in the context of a system described by a single dichotomic variable QQQ. This is the view that a macroscopic system evolving in time possesses definite properties which can be determined without disturbing the future or past state. The Leggett-Garg (LG) inequalities, the most commonly studied test, are only necessary conditions for macrorealism, but, building on earlier work J. J. Halliwell, Phys. Rev. A 93, 022123 (2016), it is shown that when the four three-time LG inequalities are augmented with a certain set of two-time inequalities also of the LG form, Fine's theorem applies and these augmented conditions are then both necessary and sufficient. A comparison is carried out with a very different set of necessary and sufficient conditions for macrorealism, namely the no-signaling in time (NSIT) conditions proposed by J. Kofler and C. Brukner, Phys. Rev. A 87, 052115 (2013) and L. Clemente and J. Kofler, Phys. Rev. A 91, 062103 (2015), which ensure that all probabilities for QQQ at one and two times are independent of whether earlier or intermediate measurements are made in a given run, and do not require (but imply) the LG inequalities. We argue that tests based on the LG inequalities have the form of very weak classicality conditions and can be satisfied in the face of moderate interference effects, but those based on NSIT conditions have the form of much stronger coherence witness conditions, satisfied only for zero interference. The two tests differ in their implementation of noninvasive measurability and so are testing different notions of macrorealism: the augmented LG tests are indirect, entailing a combination of the results of different experiments with only compatible quantities measured in each experimental run, in close analogy with Bell tests, and are primarily tests for macrorealism per se; in contrast, the NSIT tests entail sequential measurements of incompatible quantities and are primarily tests for noninvasiveness.
Macrorealism formalizes the seemingly intuitive notion that, in contrast with the principles of quantum mechanics, a physical system can be in a definite state at any given time and moreover its dynamical evolution is independent of the measurements performed on it. In this study, we carry out a comparative analysis between three-time Leggett--Garg-type inequalities and the conditions of no-signaling-in-time and arrow-of-time for macrorealism within the context of meson oscillations. Our findings indicate that, under given initial conditions, no violations of Leggett--Garg inequalities are observed. However, no-signaling-in-time conditions are found to be violated, thereby revealing the impossibility of applying a macrorealistic description to the physics of meson oscillations.
The correlations between successive measurements of a quantum system can violate a family of Leggett-Garg Inequalities (LGIs) that are analogous to the violation of Bell’s inequalities of measurements performed on spatially separated quantum systems. These LGIs follow from a point of view, imposing that a classical system is at all times in a definite state and that a measurement can, at least in principle, leave this state undisturbed. Violations of LGIs can be probed by neutrino flavor oscillations if the correlators of consecutive flavor measurements are approximately stationary. We discuss here several improvements of the methodology used in previous analyses based on accelerator and reactor neutrino data. We argue that the strong claims of LGI violations made in previous studies are based on an unsuitable modeling of macrorealistic systems in statistical hypothesis tests. We illustrate our improved methodology via the example of the MINOS muon-neutrino survival data, where we find revised statistical evidence for violations of LGIs at the ( 2 – 3 ) σ level, depending on macrorealistic background models.
The Leggett--Garg inequality (LGI) constrains temporal correlations under the assumptions of macrorealism and noninvasive measurability. We study the four-time quantity K4K_4K4​ for two-flavor neutrino oscillations using a pseudo-density matrix (PDM) under static conditions, instead of non-invasive measurement. With this approach, it becomes possible to examine a Horodecki-type criterion for the temporal Pauli-correlation tensor. The Horodecki criterion had been proven for CHSH inequality (R. Horodecki et al. Phys. Lett. \textbf{A200}, 340), For any unitary qubit evolution, the corresponding scalar is MR=2M_R=2MR​=2. Although, this result characterizes the correlation tensor and the optimized temporal construction, it does not imply that a fixed flavor observable violates the LGI at every neutrino energy or baseline. We therefore evaluate K4K_4K4​ explicitly for flavor measurements in matter of constant density. The numerical examples illustrate how matter effects modify the temporal correlations, with a pronounced matter--vacuum separation near the MSW resonance for the chosen parameters and generally smaller differences in the selected off-resonance cases. This finding motivates further investigation of matter-induced temporal correlations in atmospheric neutrinos and their potential relevance to future studies with long-baseline and atmospheric-neutrino experiments, including DUNE and Hyper-Kamiokande.