Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2609.39780

No-go theorems for dual Hamiltonians of Non-Abelian Lattice Gauge Theories

Marco Garofalo, Tobias Hartung, Timo Jakobs, Paul Ludwig, Johann Ostmeyer, Carsten Urbach

hep-latquant-phSubmitted Sep 30, 2026• Announced Oct 1, 2026• 2 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Hamiltonian simulations of lattice gauge theories promise new insights into the inner workings of QCD. The rapid development of quantum computing hardware suggests that large scale simulations may soon become feasible. However, no efficient formulation suitable for simulations near the continuum limit is currently known for the non-Abelian case, and existing candidates typically feature long range interactions in the electric part of the Hamiltonian. We prove that such non- localities are unavoidable when the gauge configuration is reparametrised while preserving both the number of degrees of freedom and the fundamental commutation relations. We then attempt to mitigate this by introducing additional gauge links alongside additional constraints. Although this approach is successful in U(1), we prove that the corresponding construction is inconsistent for non-Abelian lattice gauge theories.

AI Summary

The paper asks whether non-Abelian Kogut–Susskind lattice gauge theories admit dual Hamiltonians with single-site magnetic terms and bounded-range electric interactions, motivated by weak-coupling simulations in plaquette-adapted bases. It examines degree-of-freedom-preserving link-to-rotor reparametrisations (“static constraints”) and an enlarged-Hilbert-space construction with additional constraints (“dynamic constraints”). For static constraints in two dimensions with open boundaries, replacing every plaquette by a rotor leaves helper links forming a spanning tree. A graph-theoretic result shows that, on a $d>1$ hypercubic lattice of extent $\ell$, some originally neighbouring vertices have tree distance $\Omega(\ell)$. The bound remains $\Omega(\ell/(K+1)^{1/d})$ with $K$ additional links under periodic boundaries. Parallel transport through the remaining links therefore introduces long operator strings. In $d\geq3$, counting shows that introducing independent rotors for every plaquette cannot be balanced by removing links while retaining connectivity. A partial conversion provides a trade-off: converting a fraction $(mn-1)/(mn)$ of plaquettes within cells gives an interaction-range bound of $mn+1$, but leaves interacting magnetic terms. For dynamic constraints, the paper recovers the local two-dimensional U(1) rotor Hamiltonian, then tests a non-Abelian analogue. Its two-link constraint $C^c=-R_1^c+L_2^c$ has commutators imposing additional conditions; for SU($N$), these force both helper links into constant wavefunctions and overconstrain the system. The dynamic obstruction applies to this particular ansatz, not all enlarged-space constructions. The discussion also describes the impossibility of eliminating non-Abelian static-constraint strings as an expectation beyond the graph-distance bounds; alternative dynamic constraints remain open.

Little sign of AI-generated textOverclaimsStrong assumptionsPossible error

Central claim may not hold: The abstract omits the single-site magnetic-term requirement needed to exclude the already-local original Hamiltonian from its canonical-reparametrization no-go claim. The static argument assumes original helper-link coordinates and therefore does not cover arbitrary canonical transformations with a single-site magnetic Hamiltonian. The spanning-tree distance bound does not prove that nonzero nonlocal electric strings necessarily survive constraints and cancellations in non-Abelian formulations. The periodic coordinate construction fails already for U(1), because all plaquettes satisfy one global relation and cannot provide the independent rotor coordinates assumed by the maximal-tree lemma. The open-boundary U(1) constraint calculation incorrectly asserts a constant-momentum nullspace and rank E-1, whereas the joint kernel is zero and the rank is E.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
14 pages

Related papers

Hamiltonian formulations of lattice gauge theories for quantum simulation

Indrakshi Raychowdhury

The development of quantum technology and the advent of quantum computation have renewed interest in Hamiltonian formulations of lattice gauge theories. In contrast to Euclidean Monte Carlo calculations, Hamiltonian simulation requires a direct representation of the physical Hilbert space, an efficient treatment of enforcing Gauss' law as constraints, and a formulation of real-time dynamics in terms of degrees of freedom that can be encoded on quantum or quantum-inspired classical platforms. The starting point corresponds to finding a suitable basis for Hamiltonian lattice gauge theories. The existing literature focuses on several complementary approaches: electric basis, magnetic basis, gauge-fixed, quantum-link, qubit-regularised, finite-group, and orbifold formulations. This article primarily focuses on the prepotential and loop--string--hadron formulations, where non-Abelian Gauss laws are solved locally and the dynamics is written directly in terms of gauge-invariant loop, string and hadron excitations. The discussion covers the SU(2) and SU(3) constructions in one spatial dimension, the role of residual Abelian Gauss laws, and the extension to higher dimensions through point splitting. We conclude by highlighting its direct applications: eliminating redundant gauge degrees of freedom makes exact diagonalisation and tensor network calculations feasible for studying real-time dynamics, provides insights into thermalisation properties, enables mapping of physical degrees of freedom onto analog and digital quantum hardware, and enables quantum simulation of dynamics.

International Symposium on Lattice Field Theory (LATTICE)•Jun 28, 2026•0 citations

Efficient Finite-Resource Formulation of Non-Abelian Lattice Gauge Theories beyond One Dimension

Pierpaolo Fontana, Marc Miranda-Riaza, Alessio Celi

Non-Abelian gauge theories provide the most accurate description of fundamental interactions, showing remarkable agreement with experimental data in cosmology and particle physics. Highly precise predictions can be made using standard techniques, both in the continuum and in the lattice frameworks. However, classical methods have limitations, particularly when attempting to extrapolate the continuum limit from the study of lattice gauge theories. Complementing classical computations or combining them with quantum computational methods, to improve the predictions toward the continuum limit with current quantum resources, is a formidable open challenge. In this paper, we propose a resource-efficient method to compute the running of the coupling in non-Abelian gauge theories beyond one spatial dimension. We first represent the Hamiltonian on periodic lattices in terms of loop variables and conjugate loop electric fields, exploiting the Gauss law to retain the gauge-independent ones. Then, we identify a local basis for small and large loops variationally to minimize the truncation error while computing the running of the coupling on small tori. Our method enables computations at arbitrary values of the bare coupling and lattice spacing with current quantum computers, simulators, and tensor-network calculations, in regimes otherwise inaccessible.

arXiv:2409.04441•Physical Review X•Jul 24, 2025•44 citations

Quantum simulation of non-Abelian lattice gauge theories: A variational approach to D 8 with dynamical matter

Emanuele Gaz, Pavel P. Popov, Guy Pardo +3 more

Quantum simulation of lattice gauge theories (LGTs) provides a powerful framework for understanding nonperturbative phenomena. However, to realize the hope of answering challenging physics questions on near-term devices it is crucial to develop resource-efficient formulations, in particular for non-Abelian LGTs and beyond (1+1) dimensions. In this work, we address this issue by focusing on the difficulty of simulating fermionic degrees of freedom and on mitigating the Hilbert space redundancy, i.e., the presence of exponentially many nonphysical states that do not obey gauge invariance. First, we show a procedure that removes the matter and improves the hardware-resource efficiency. We demonstrate it for the simplest non-Abelian group addressable with this procedure, D 8 , in the cases of both one and two spatial dimensions. Then, with the objective of running a variational quantum simulation on real quantum hardware, we map the D 8 LGT onto qudit systems with local interactions. We propose a variational scheme for the qudit system with a local Hamiltonian, which can be implemented on a universal qudit quantum device. Our results show the effectiveness of the matter-removing procedure, solving the redundancy problem, and reducing the amount of quantum resources. This approach can serve as a way of simulating LGTs in high spatial dimensions, with non-Abelian gauge groups, and including dynamical fermions.

arXiv:2501.17863•Physical Review Research•Jun 16, 2025•15 citations

Exploring different Formulations of non-Abelian Lattice Gauge Theories for Hamiltonian simulation

Indrakshi Raychowdhury, Zohreh Davoudi, Andrew Shaw

Hamiltonian formulation of lattice gauge theories provides the natural framework for the purpose of quantum simulation, an area of research that is growing with advances in quantum-computing algorithms and hardware. It is therefore important to identify the most accurate, while computationally economic, Hamiltonian formulation(s) of lattice gauge theories along with necessary truncation imposed on the Hilbert space of gauge bosons for any finite computing resources. We report a study toward addressing this question in the case of non-Abelian lattice gauge theories that require the imposition of non-Abelian Gauss's laws on the Hilbert space.

International Symposium on Lattice Field Theory (LATTICE)•May 16, 2022•4 citations

Search for efficient formulations for Hamiltonian simulation of non-Abelian lattice gauge theories

Zohreh Davoudi, Indrakshi Raychowdhury, Andrew Shaw

Hamiltonian formulation of lattice gauge theories (LGTs) is the most natural framework for the purpose of quantum simulation, an area of research that is growing with advances in quantum-computing algorithms and hardware. It, therefore, remains an important task to identify the most accurate, while computationally economic, Hamiltonian formulation(s) in such theories, considering the necessary truncation imposed on the Hilbert space of gauge bosons with any finite computing resources. This paper is a first step toward addressing this question in the case of non-Abelian LGTs. Such theories require the imposition of non-Abelian Gauss's laws on the Hilbert space, introducing additional computational complexity. Focusing on the case of SU(2) LGT in $1+1$ dimensions coupled to one flavor of fermionic matter, a number of different formulations of the original Kogut-Susskind framework are analyzed with regard to the dependence of the dimension of the physical Hilbert space on boundary conditions, system size, and the cutoff on the excitations of gauge bosons. The impact of such dependencies on the accuracy of the spectrum and dynamics obtained from a Hamiltonian computation is examined, and the (classical) computational-resource requirements given these considerations are studied. Besides the well-known angular-momentum formulation of the theory, the cases of purely fermionic and purely bosonic formulations (with open boundary conditions) and the loop-string-hadron formulation are analyzed, along with a brief discussion of a quantum-link-model formulation of the same theory. Clear advantages are found in working with the loop-string-hadron framework which implements non-Abelian Gauss's laws a priori using a complete set of gauge-invariant operators. It is argued that the substantially reduced cost of simulation within the loop-string-hadron formulation compared with the angular-momentum basis has implications for more efficient and robust quantum simulations of the same theory. Future studies will extend this investigation to the analysis of resource requirements for quantum simulations of non-Abelian LGT, with the goal of shedding light on the most efficient Hamiltonian formulation of gauge theories of relevance in nature.

arXiv:2009.11802•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•Oct 7, 2021•156 citations

Quantum simulations of lattice gauge theories using ultracold atoms in optical lattices

Erez Zohar, J. I. Cirac, Benni Reznik

Can high-energy physics be simulated by low-energy, non-relativistic, many-body systems such as ultracold atoms? Such ultracold atomic systems lack the type of symmetries and dynamical properties of high energy physics models: in particular, they manifest neither local gauge invariance nor Lorentz invariance, which are crucial properties of the quantum field theories which are the building blocks of the standard model of elementary particles. However, it turns out, surprisingly, that there are ways to configure an atomic system to manifest both local gauge invariance and Lorentz invariance. In particular, local gauge invariance can arise either as an effective low-energy symmetry, or as an exact symmetry, following from the conservation laws in atomic interactions. Hence, one could hope that such quantum simulators may lead to a new type of (table-top) experiments which will be used to study various QCD (quantum chromodynamics) phenomena, such as the confinement of dynamical quarks, phase transitions and other effects, which are inaccessible using the currently known computational methods. In this report, we review the Hamiltonian formulation of lattice gauge theories, and then describe our recent progress in constructing the quantum simulation of Abelian and non-Abelian lattice gauge theories in 1 + 1 and 2 + 1 dimensions using ultracold atoms in optical lattices.

arXiv:1503.02312•Reports on Progress in Physics•Dec 18, 2015•543 citations
Hamiltonian simulations of lattice gauge theories promise new insights into the inner workings of QCD. The rapid development of quantum computing hardware suggests that large scale simulations may soon become feasible. However, no efficient formulation suitable for simulations near the continuum limit is currently known for the non-Abelian case, and existing candidates typically feature long range interactions in the electric part of the Hamiltonian. We prove that such non- localities are unavoidable when the gauge configuration is reparametrised while preserving both the number of degrees of freedom and the fundamental commutation relations. We then attempt to mitigate this by introducing additional gauge links alongside additional constraints. Although this approach is successful in U(1), we prove that the corresponding construction is inconsistent for non-Abelian lattice gauge theories.
The paper asks whether non-Abelian Kogut–Susskind lattice gauge theories admit dual Hamiltonians with single-site magnetic terms and bounded-range electric interactions, motivated by weak-coupling simulations in plaquette-adapted bases. It examines degree-of-freedom-preserving link-to-rotor reparametrisations (“static constraints”) and an enlarged-Hilbert-space construction with additional constraints (“dynamic constraints”).
For static constraints in two dimensions with open boundaries, replacing every plaquette by a rotor leaves helper links forming a spanning tree. A graph-theoretic result shows that, on a d>1d>1d>1 hypercubic lattice of extent ℓ\ellℓ, some originally neighbouring vertices have tree distance Ω(ℓ)\Omega(\ell)Ω(ℓ). The bound remains Ω(ℓ/(K+1)1/d)\Omega(\ell/(K+1)^{1/d})Ω(ℓ/(K+1)1/d) with KKK additional links under periodic boundaries. Parallel transport through the remaining links therefore introduces long operator strings. In d≥3d\geq3d≥3, counting shows that introducing independent rotors for every plaquette cannot be balanced by removing links while retaining connectivity. A partial conversion provides a trade-off: converting a fraction (mn−1)/(mn)(mn-1)/(mn)(mn−1)/(mn) of plaquettes within cells gives an interaction-range bound of mn+1mn+1mn+1, but leaves interacting magnetic terms.
For dynamic constraints, the paper recovers the local two-dimensional U(1) rotor Hamiltonian, then tests a non-Abelian analogue. Its two-link constraint Cc=−R1c+L2cC^c=-R_1^c+L_2^cCc=−R1c​+L2c​ has commutators imposing additional conditions; for SU(NNN), these force both helper links into constant wavefunctions and overconstrain the system.
The dynamic obstruction applies to this particular ansatz, not all enlarged-space constructions. The discussion also describes the impossibility of eliminating non-Abelian static-constraint strings as an expectation beyond the graph-distance bounds; alternative dynamic constraints remain open.
The development of quantum technology and the advent of quantum computation have renewed interest in Hamiltonian formulations of lattice gauge theories. In contrast to Euclidean Monte Carlo calculations, Hamiltonian simulation requires a direct representation of the physical Hilbert space, an efficient treatment of enforcing Gauss' law as constraints, and a formulation of real-time dynamics in terms of degrees of freedom that can be encoded on quantum or quantum-inspired classical platforms. The starting point corresponds to finding a suitable basis for Hamiltonian lattice gauge theories. The existing literature focuses on several complementary approaches: electric basis, magnetic basis, gauge-fixed, quantum-link, qubit-regularised, finite-group, and orbifold formulations. This article primarily focuses on the prepotential and loop--string--hadron formulations, where non-Abelian Gauss laws are solved locally and the dynamics is written directly in terms of gauge-invariant loop, string and hadron excitations. The discussion covers the SU(2) and SU(3) constructions in one spatial dimension, the role of residual Abelian Gauss laws, and the extension to higher dimensions through point splitting. We conclude by highlighting its direct applications: eliminating redundant gauge degrees of freedom makes exact diagonalisation and tensor network calculations feasible for studying real-time dynamics, provides insights into thermalisation properties, enables mapping of physical degrees of freedom onto analog and digital quantum hardware, and enables quantum simulation of dynamics.
Non-Abelian gauge theories provide the most accurate description of fundamental interactions, showing remarkable agreement with experimental data in cosmology and particle physics. Highly precise predictions can be made using standard techniques, both in the continuum and in the lattice frameworks. However, classical methods have limitations, particularly when attempting to extrapolate the continuum limit from the study of lattice gauge theories. Complementing classical computations or combining them with quantum computational methods, to improve the predictions toward the continuum limit with current quantum resources, is a formidable open challenge. In this paper, we propose a resource-efficient method to compute the running of the coupling in non-Abelian gauge theories beyond one spatial dimension. We first represent the Hamiltonian on periodic lattices in terms of loop variables and conjugate loop electric fields, exploiting the Gauss law to retain the gauge-independent ones. Then, we identify a local basis for small and large loops variationally to minimize the truncation error while computing the running of the coupling on small tori. Our method enables computations at arbitrary values of the bare coupling and lattice spacing with current quantum computers, simulators, and tensor-network calculations, in regimes otherwise inaccessible.
Quantum simulation of lattice gauge theories (LGTs) provides a powerful framework for understanding nonperturbative phenomena. However, to realize the hope of answering challenging physics questions on near-term devices it is crucial to develop resource-efficient formulations, in particular for non-Abelian LGTs and beyond (1+1) dimensions. In this work, we address this issue by focusing on the difficulty of simulating fermionic degrees of freedom and on mitigating the Hilbert space redundancy, i.e., the presence of exponentially many nonphysical states that do not obey gauge invariance. First, we show a procedure that removes the matter and improves the hardware-resource efficiency. We demonstrate it for the simplest non-Abelian group addressable with this procedure, D 8 , in the cases of both one and two spatial dimensions. Then, with the objective of running a variational quantum simulation on real quantum hardware, we map the D 8 LGT onto qudit systems with local interactions. We propose a variational scheme for the qudit system with a local Hamiltonian, which can be implemented on a universal qudit quantum device. Our results show the effectiveness of the matter-removing procedure, solving the redundancy problem, and reducing the amount of quantum resources. This approach can serve as a way of simulating LGTs in high spatial dimensions, with non-Abelian gauge groups, and including dynamical fermions.
Hamiltonian formulation of lattice gauge theories provides the natural framework for the purpose of quantum simulation, an area of research that is growing with advances in quantum-computing algorithms and hardware. It is therefore important to identify the most accurate, while computationally economic, Hamiltonian formulation(s) of lattice gauge theories along with necessary truncation imposed on the Hilbert space of gauge bosons for any finite computing resources. We report a study toward addressing this question in the case of non-Abelian lattice gauge theories that require the imposition of non-Abelian Gauss's laws on the Hilbert space.
Hamiltonian formulation of lattice gauge theories (LGTs) is the most natural framework for the purpose of quantum simulation, an area of research that is growing with advances in quantum-computing algorithms and hardware. It, therefore, remains an important task to identify the most accurate, while computationally economic, Hamiltonian formulation(s) in such theories, considering the necessary truncation imposed on the Hilbert space of gauge bosons with any finite computing resources. This paper is a first step toward addressing this question in the case of non-Abelian LGTs. Such theories require the imposition of non-Abelian Gauss's laws on the Hilbert space, introducing additional computational complexity. Focusing on the case of SU(2) LGT in 1+11+11+1 dimensions coupled to one flavor of fermionic matter, a number of different formulations of the original Kogut-Susskind framework are analyzed with regard to the dependence of the dimension of the physical Hilbert space on boundary conditions, system size, and the cutoff on the excitations of gauge bosons. The impact of such dependencies on the accuracy of the spectrum and dynamics obtained from a Hamiltonian computation is examined, and the (classical) computational-resource requirements given these considerations are studied. Besides the well-known angular-momentum formulation of the theory, the cases of purely fermionic and purely bosonic formulations (with open boundary conditions) and the loop-string-hadron formulation are analyzed, along with a brief discussion of a quantum-link-model formulation of the same theory. Clear advantages are found in working with the loop-string-hadron framework which implements non-Abelian Gauss's laws a priori using a complete set of gauge-invariant operators. It is argued that the substantially reduced cost of simulation within the loop-string-hadron formulation compared with the angular-momentum basis has implications for more efficient and robust quantum simulations of the same theory. Future studies will extend this investigation to the analysis of resource requirements for quantum simulations of non-Abelian LGT, with the goal of shedding light on the most efficient Hamiltonian formulation of gauge theories of relevance in nature.
Can high-energy physics be simulated by low-energy, non-relativistic, many-body systems such as ultracold atoms? Such ultracold atomic systems lack the type of symmetries and dynamical properties of high energy physics models: in particular, they manifest neither local gauge invariance nor Lorentz invariance, which are crucial properties of the quantum field theories which are the building blocks of the standard model of elementary particles. However, it turns out, surprisingly, that there are ways to configure an atomic system to manifest both local gauge invariance and Lorentz invariance. In particular, local gauge invariance can arise either as an effective low-energy symmetry, or as an exact symmetry, following from the conservation laws in atomic interactions. Hence, one could hope that such quantum simulators may lead to a new type of (table-top) experiments which will be used to study various QCD (quantum chromodynamics) phenomena, such as the confinement of dynamical quarks, phase transitions and other effects, which are inaccessible using the currently known computational methods. In this report, we review the Hamiltonian formulation of lattice gauge theories, and then describe our recent progress in constructing the quantum simulation of Abelian and non-Abelian lattice gauge theories in 1 + 1 and 2 + 1 dimensions using ultracold atoms in optical lattices.