arXiv:2609.38836
Joint measurability of coplanar POVMs
Taro Yoshino, Koichi Tojo, Kei Hagihara, Akinori Tanaka, Takuki Tomita
Abstract
An unbiased qubit positive operator-valued measure (POVM) can be uniquely expressed in terms of the Bloch vector. We prove that for POVMs with coplanar Bloch vectors, they are jointly measurable if and only if the perimeter of the convex closure of Bloch vectors is less than or equal to 4. Moreover, as a corollary, we give an affirmative answer to the conjecture suggested by [Andrejic-Kunjwal 2020] on the existence of a joint device for POVMs whose Bloch vectors lie on the same circle.
AI Summary
The paper addresses joint measurability of arbitrary finite families of unbiased binary qubit POVMs whose Bloch vectors lie in a common plane through the origin. For $E_i(\varepsilon)=\tfrac12(I+\varepsilon a_i\cdot\sigma)$, it proves that the family is jointly measurable if and only if the centrally symmetric polygon $\operatorname{conv}\{\pm a_1,\ldots,\pm a_n\}$ has perimeter at most $4$. This recovers the two-measurement criterion $\|a+b\|+\|a-b\|\leq2$. For equal-length vectors $a_i=\eta(\cos\alpha_{i-1},\sin\alpha_{i-1},0)$ with $0=\alpha_0<\cdots<\alpha_{n-1}<\pi$, the criterion becomes $\eta\leq[\sum_{i=1}^{n-1}\sin((\alpha_i-\alpha_{i-1})/2)+\cos(\alpha_{n-1}/2)]^{-1}$. This establishes the previously open necessity direction of the Andrejic–Kunjwal circle conjecture; its sufficiency direction was already known. The paper also notes that another conjecture follows from this resolution. The proof first expresses compatibility, including for noncoplanar vectors, as $L\leq1$, where $L$ minimizes a sum of Euclidean norms over antisymmetric vector assignments satisfying the marginal constraints. It shows that $L$ depends only on the symmetric convex hull. In the planar case, polygon-edge vectors supply an explicit primal optimizer, while normalized edges supply a dual certificate. An alternating-sum inequality for ordered unit vectors on a semicircle establishes dual feasibility, giving $L$ equal to one-quarter of the perimeter. The explicit geometric characterization is restricted to unbiased binary qubit measurements with coplanar Bloch vectors; biased, higher-dimensional, and general noncoplanar measurements are not characterized by the perimeter theorem.
Central claim may not hold: The abstract's unsigned-convex-hull criterion is false: the incompatible measurements with Bloch vectors (1,0), (0,1), and (0,0) have unsigned-hull perimeter 2+sqrt(2)<4, whereas the body's theorem correctly uses the symmetrized hull. The alternating-unit-vector induction defines its intermediate vector y with the opposite sign from that required by both the induction hypothesis and the subsequent identity, repairable by reversing its coefficients. The support set J is defined over 1 through n instead of 1 through N in the optimality lemma and Section 3, contradicting the paper's own example with a nonzero eighth column when n=4.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.