Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2609.38724

Ergotropy from energetic coherence and the third law of thermodynamics

O. S. Yáñez-Soria, G. Guarnieri, B. Çakmak, R. Román-Ancheyta

quant-phcond-mat.stat-mechSubmitted Sep 30, 2026• Announced Oct 1, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We study the ergotropy and the thermodynamic potentials of a qubit battery charged by repeated interactions with clusters of thermal ancillas, qubits or oscillators, through a composite system-bath coupling that generates steady-state coherence in the energy basis. A single parameter encoding the bath quantum statistics yields the coherence and ergotropy in closed form for any cluster size. For large clusters, the ergotropy becomes independent of the bath statistics and, at optimal couplings, reaches a universal fraction of the equilibrium internal energy of the qubit at the bath temperature. Since the charged state has no population inversion, all extractable work comes from coherence. The ergotropy is flat at low temperatures. We trace this plateau to the third law, and show that the ergotropy is proportional to the equilibrium enthalpy of the qubit, whose slope vanishes with the heat capacity. For a battery composed of multiple qubits, the coherence grows exponentially with the number of qubits while the ergotropy grows linearly, both remaining a nearly constant fraction of their respective maxima. The charged state is a non-equilibrium steady state with finite entropy at zero temperature, sustained by the work of switching the collisional interaction on and off. The cost is nonzero whenever the parallel coupling is nonzero, and, unlike the ergotropy, it depends on the bath statistics.

AI Summary

The paper asks how much work can be stored as energy-basis coherence in a qubit coupled to thermal ancillas, and how its temperature dependence and maintenance cost relate to thermodynamics. It studies a repeated-interaction model with clusters of $N$ thermal qubits or oscillators and a composite coupling containing longitudinal and excitation-exchange terms. A collision-limit Lindblad equation yields analytical steady-state Bloch vectors, coherence and ergotropy for arbitrary $N$, treating both ancilla types through one statistical parameter. In the large-cluster limit, the stored ergotropy becomes independent of ancilla statistics. Optimizing the coupling ratio gives $2f_1^2=(1+\sqrt{2})f_2^2$ and $\mathcal W^*(T)=\frac{\hbar\omega}{2}(\sqrt{2}-1)\tanh[\hbar\omega/(2k_BT)]$. At zero temperature this is approximately $0.207\hbar\omega$; the state has purity $3/4$ and no population inversion, so its ergotropy is entirely coherent. The ergotropy optimum differs from the coherence optimum. The low-temperature plateau follows from proportionality to the equilibrium qubit energy, whose derivative is the vanishing heat capacity. This proportionality is specific to the large-cluster limit; finite-$N$ plateaus follow directly from exponentially small thermal derivatives. The nonequilibrium state retains entropy $0.416k_B$ at zero temperature, giving its free-energy difference a finite negative slope. Explicit switching-work calculations show that maintaining the state consumes power, with bath-statistics dependence persisting at large $N$. The analysis assumes resonance and the Markovian collision limit. Collective multi-qubit batteries are examined numerically only up to seven qubits at zero temperature: ergotropy grows approximately linearly, near $0.3\hbar\omega$ per qubit, whereas unnormalized $l_1$ coherence grows exponentially.

No sign of AI-generated textIncrementalStrong assumptionsPossible error

Error found: The abstract leaves unqualified an ergotropy–equilibrium-enthalpy proportionality that holds in the large-cluster limit but not generally for finite oscillator clusters. The multi-qubit scaling calculation does not specify an initial state or total-spin sector, although the collective dynamics has multiple stationary states with different coherence and ergotropy. The claimed high-temperature coincidence of free-energy difference and ergotropy is incorrect at leading order: their ratio approaches approximately 1.104 rather than one.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
12 pages, 8 figures

Related papers

Ergotropy from coherences in an open quantum system

Barış Çakmak

We show that it is possible to have nonzero ergotropy in the steady states of an open quantum system consisting of qubits that are collectively coupled to a thermal bath at a finite temperature. The dynamics of our model leads the qubits into a steady state that has coherences in the energy eigenbasis when the system consists of more than a single qubit. We observe that even though the system does not have inverted populations, it is possible to extract work from the coherences and we analytically show that in the high-temperature limit, ergotropy per unit energy is equal to the l_{1} norm of coherence for the two-qubit case. Further, we analyze the scaling of coherence and ergotropy as a function of the number of qubits in the system for different initial states. Our results demonstrate that one can design a quantum battery that is charged by a dissipative thermal bath in the weak-coupling regime.

arXiv:2005.08489•Physical review. E•Oct 9, 2020•101 citations

Ergotropy of nonequilibrium steady states beyond the full secular approximation

Xing-Xing Hu, Hui-Yu Yang, Kun Zhang +1 more

Understanding the generation and activation of ergotropy, the maximum work extractable by cyclic unitary operations, is central to quantum battery research. Positive-temperature thermal states are passive, whereas nonequilibrium environments can sustain nonpassive steady states with nonzero ergotropy. However, the full secular approximation commonly used in Lindblad descriptions can suppress steady-state coherence and obscure its contribution to ergotropy. Using a Bloch-Redfield master equation beyond the full secular approximation, we investigate the ergotropy of the nonequilibrium steady state (NESS) of two exchange-coupled qubits connected to independent thermal reservoirs. The NESS ergotropy of two qubits with the same frequency is entirely coherent and grows quadratically with temperature bias near equilibrium. In contrast, detuned qubits can exhibit incoherent ergotropy. We derive an exact analytical criterion for its activation and show that activation requires the hotter reservoir to be coupled to the qubit with the higher bare frequency. Comparing NESSs obtained with and without full secularization reveals quantitative and qualitative differences in ergotropy that reflect changes in both its coherent and incoherent contributions. The results clarify the mechanisms of NESS ergotropy activation and demonstrate the importance of retaining steady-state coherence beyond the full secular approximation when characterizing stationary work resources.

quant-pharXiv:2610.24561•Oct 20, 2026•0 citations

Ergotropy Activation and Coherence in Dissipatively Charged Quantum Batteries

Hui-Yu Yang, Kang-Yuan Chen, Kun Zhang +2 more

Quantum batteries can exploit quantum resources to enhance energy storage and work extraction, and recent experimental progress has brought their implementation closer to reality. In realistic settings, however, environmental dissipation is unavoidable, making dissipative charging a physically relevant operating regime. Here we investigate ergotropy in dissipatively charged quantum batteries, focusing on interaction-induced work extraction. For two coupled two-level systems (TLSs), we derive exact analytical expressions for the total, coherent, and incoherent ergotropy in both resonant and detuned configurations. We show that, in the resonant case, ergotropy is activated only above a critical coupling associated with an interaction-induced energy-level crossing, whereas detuning enables ergotropy already in the weak-coupling regime. Moreover, quantum coherence, although necessary for coherent work extraction, is not by itself sufficient to guarantee nonzero coherent ergotropy. In the strong-coupling regime, the resonant setup reaches the maximum ergotropy at a finite coupling strength, whereas the detuned setup approaches the same limit only asymptotically. Extending the analysis to a periodic XX spin chain of $N$ TLSs, we analytically derive the finite-temperature coupling threshold for ergotropy activation and show that it scales as $1/N$ in the large-$N$ limit. These results identify frequency detuning, interaction strength, and system size as key control parameters for ergotropy generation in open quantum batteries.

quant-pharXiv:2611.05010•Physical Review A•Nov 4, 2026•0 citations

Energetic channels in finite many-body quantum charging

Dara Murphy, George Mihailescu, Anne Matthies +2 more

We examine how a finite many-body system can function as an effective charger for a single-qubit quantum battery, using the Lipkin-Meshkov-Glick model as a paradigmatic setting. As our figure of merit, we consider the battery ergotropy while explicitly resolving the energetic flows across the composite system. In the absence of intra-charger interactions, we show that the generation of non-zero ergotropy is controlled by the competition between collective coupling and spectral mismatch. We further demonstrate that even passive positive-temperature charger states can generate finite battery ergotropy, provided the charger is sufficiently large and sufficiently hot. Intra-charger interactions restructure the charger spectrum and qualitatively modify the available energetic pathways. While they can enhance the amount of energy accessible for charging, they can simultaneously divert energy into internal many-body and battery-charger interaction channels, producing an energetic impedance to direct charger-to-battery transfer. Consequently, battery ergotropy alone is insufficient to characterize an effective many-body charger: the useful work generated and its energetic provenance must be assessed together.

quant-pharXiv:2610.22034•Oct 16, 2026•0 citations

Charging a quantum battery from the Bloch sphere

C. A. Downing, M. S. Ukhtary

We reconsider the quantum energetics and quantum thermodynamics of the charging process of a simple, two-component quantum battery model made up of a charger qubit and a single--cell battery qubit. We allow for the initial quantum state of the charger to lie anywhere on the surface of the Bloch sphere, and find the generalized analytical expressions describing the stored energy, ergotropy and capacity of the battery, all of which depend upon the initial Bloch sphere polar angle in a manner evocative of the quantum area theorem. The origin of the ergotropy produced, as well as the genesis of the battery capacity, can be readily traced back to the quantum coherences and population inversions generated (and the balance between these two mechanisms is contingent upon the starting Bloch polar angle). Importantly, the ergotropic charging power and its associated optimal charging time display notable deviations from standard results which disregard thermodynamic considerations. Our theoretical groundwork may be useful for guiding forthcoming experiments in quantum energy science based upon coupled two-level systems.

quant-pharXiv:2601.10844•Annalen der Physik•Jan 19, 2026•3 citations

Work extraction from coupled qubits in equilibrium and nonequilibrium thermal reservoirs

Maryam Hadipour, Soroush Haseli

This study investigates the thermodynamic behavior of a two-qubit quantum system, where each qubit is coupled to an independent thermal reservoir, either bosonic or fermionic. Using a master equation approach, we analyze both steady-state and time-dependent ergotropy to understand how different reservoir statistics affect work extraction. In bosonic environments, ergotropy consistently declines with increasing temperature due to thermal noise. In contrast, fermionic reservoirs exhibit more complex behavior, with ergotropy enhanced by particle transport under non-equilibrium conditions. Our results reveal a threshold-like sensitivity to the chemical potential configuration, leading to qualitatively distinct regimes of energy storage performance. Time-resolved analyses show that the system's approach to steady state varies depending on the type of reservoir and the coupling strength between qubits. These insights highlight how carefully engineered reservoir properties and non-equilibrium driving can be leveraged to optimize quantum battery performance.

arXiv:2406.09580•Scientific Reports•Aug 28, 2025•4 citations
We study the ergotropy and the thermodynamic potentials of a qubit battery charged by repeated interactions with clusters of thermal ancillas, qubits or oscillators, through a composite system-bath coupling that generates steady-state coherence in the energy basis. A single parameter encoding the bath quantum statistics yields the coherence and ergotropy in closed form for any cluster size. For large clusters, the ergotropy becomes independent of the bath statistics and, at optimal couplings, reaches a universal fraction of the equilibrium internal energy of the qubit at the bath temperature. Since the charged state has no population inversion, all extractable work comes from coherence. The ergotropy is flat at low temperatures. We trace this plateau to the third law, and show that the ergotropy is proportional to the equilibrium enthalpy of the qubit, whose slope vanishes with the heat capacity. For a battery composed of multiple qubits, the coherence grows exponentially with the number of qubits while the ergotropy grows linearly, both remaining a nearly constant fraction of their respective maxima. The charged state is a non-equilibrium steady state with finite entropy at zero temperature, sustained by the work of switching the collisional interaction on and off. The cost is nonzero whenever the parallel coupling is nonzero, and, unlike the ergotropy, it depends on the bath statistics.
The paper asks how much work can be stored as energy-basis coherence in a qubit coupled to thermal ancillas, and how its temperature dependence and maintenance cost relate to thermodynamics. It studies a repeated-interaction model with clusters of NNN thermal qubits or oscillators and a composite coupling containing longitudinal and excitation-exchange terms. A collision-limit Lindblad equation yields analytical steady-state Bloch vectors, coherence and ergotropy for arbitrary NNN, treating both ancilla types through one statistical parameter.
In the large-cluster limit, the stored ergotropy becomes independent of ancilla statistics. Optimizing the coupling ratio gives 2f12=(1+2)f222f_1^2=(1+\sqrt{2})f_2^22f12​=(1+2​)f22​ and W∗(T)=ℏω2(2−1)tanh⁡[ℏω/(2kBT)]\mathcal W^*(T)=\frac{\hbar\omega}{2}(\sqrt{2}-1)\tanh[\hbar\omega/(2k_BT)]W∗(T)=2ℏω​(2​−1)tanh[ℏω/(2kB​T)]. At zero temperature this is approximately 0.207ℏω0.207\hbar\omega0.207ℏω; the state has purity 3/43/43/4 and no population inversion, so its ergotropy is entirely coherent. The ergotropy optimum differs from the coherence optimum.
The low-temperature plateau follows from proportionality to the equilibrium qubit energy, whose derivative is the vanishing heat capacity. This proportionality is specific to the large-cluster limit; finite-NNN plateaus follow directly from exponentially small thermal derivatives. The nonequilibrium state retains entropy 0.416kB0.416k_B0.416kB​ at zero temperature, giving its free-energy difference a finite negative slope. Explicit switching-work calculations show that maintaining the state consumes power, with bath-statistics dependence persisting at large NNN.
The analysis assumes resonance and the Markovian collision limit. Collective multi-qubit batteries are examined numerically only up to seven qubits at zero temperature: ergotropy grows approximately linearly, near 0.3ℏω0.3\hbar\omega0.3ℏω per qubit, whereas unnormalized l1l_1l1​ coherence grows exponentially.
We show that it is possible to have nonzero ergotropy in the steady states of an open quantum system consisting of qubits that are collectively coupled to a thermal bath at a finite temperature. The dynamics of our model leads the qubits into a steady state that has coherences in the energy eigenbasis when the system consists of more than a single qubit. We observe that even though the system does not have inverted populations, it is possible to extract work from the coherences and we analytically show that in the high-temperature limit, ergotropy per unit energy is equal to the l_{1} norm of coherence for the two-qubit case. Further, we analyze the scaling of coherence and ergotropy as a function of the number of qubits in the system for different initial states. Our results demonstrate that one can design a quantum battery that is charged by a dissipative thermal bath in the weak-coupling regime.
Understanding the generation and activation of ergotropy, the maximum work extractable by cyclic unitary operations, is central to quantum battery research. Positive-temperature thermal states are passive, whereas nonequilibrium environments can sustain nonpassive steady states with nonzero ergotropy. However, the full secular approximation commonly used in Lindblad descriptions can suppress steady-state coherence and obscure its contribution to ergotropy. Using a Bloch-Redfield master equation beyond the full secular approximation, we investigate the ergotropy of the nonequilibrium steady state (NESS) of two exchange-coupled qubits connected to independent thermal reservoirs. The NESS ergotropy of two qubits with the same frequency is entirely coherent and grows quadratically with temperature bias near equilibrium. In contrast, detuned qubits can exhibit incoherent ergotropy. We derive an exact analytical criterion for its activation and show that activation requires the hotter reservoir to be coupled to the qubit with the higher bare frequency. Comparing NESSs obtained with and without full secularization reveals quantitative and qualitative differences in ergotropy that reflect changes in both its coherent and incoherent contributions. The results clarify the mechanisms of NESS ergotropy activation and demonstrate the importance of retaining steady-state coherence beyond the full secular approximation when characterizing stationary work resources.
Quantum batteries can exploit quantum resources to enhance energy storage and work extraction, and recent experimental progress has brought their implementation closer to reality. In realistic settings, however, environmental dissipation is unavoidable, making dissipative charging a physically relevant operating regime. Here we investigate ergotropy in dissipatively charged quantum batteries, focusing on interaction-induced work extraction. For two coupled two-level systems (TLSs), we derive exact analytical expressions for the total, coherent, and incoherent ergotropy in both resonant and detuned configurations. We show that, in the resonant case, ergotropy is activated only above a critical coupling associated with an interaction-induced energy-level crossing, whereas detuning enables ergotropy already in the weak-coupling regime. Moreover, quantum coherence, although necessary for coherent work extraction, is not by itself sufficient to guarantee nonzero coherent ergotropy. In the strong-coupling regime, the resonant setup reaches the maximum ergotropy at a finite coupling strength, whereas the detuned setup approaches the same limit only asymptotically. Extending the analysis to a periodic XX spin chain of NNN TLSs, we analytically derive the finite-temperature coupling threshold for ergotropy activation and show that it scales as 1/N1/N1/N in the large-NNN limit. These results identify frequency detuning, interaction strength, and system size as key control parameters for ergotropy generation in open quantum batteries.
We examine how a finite many-body system can function as an effective charger for a single-qubit quantum battery, using the Lipkin-Meshkov-Glick model as a paradigmatic setting. As our figure of merit, we consider the battery ergotropy while explicitly resolving the energetic flows across the composite system. In the absence of intra-charger interactions, we show that the generation of non-zero ergotropy is controlled by the competition between collective coupling and spectral mismatch. We further demonstrate that even passive positive-temperature charger states can generate finite battery ergotropy, provided the charger is sufficiently large and sufficiently hot. Intra-charger interactions restructure the charger spectrum and qualitatively modify the available energetic pathways. While they can enhance the amount of energy accessible for charging, they can simultaneously divert energy into internal many-body and battery-charger interaction channels, producing an energetic impedance to direct charger-to-battery transfer. Consequently, battery ergotropy alone is insufficient to characterize an effective many-body charger: the useful work generated and its energetic provenance must be assessed together.
We reconsider the quantum energetics and quantum thermodynamics of the charging process of a simple, two-component quantum battery model made up of a charger qubit and a single--cell battery qubit. We allow for the initial quantum state of the charger to lie anywhere on the surface of the Bloch sphere, and find the generalized analytical expressions describing the stored energy, ergotropy and capacity of the battery, all of which depend upon the initial Bloch sphere polar angle in a manner evocative of the quantum area theorem. The origin of the ergotropy produced, as well as the genesis of the battery capacity, can be readily traced back to the quantum coherences and population inversions generated (and the balance between these two mechanisms is contingent upon the starting Bloch polar angle). Importantly, the ergotropic charging power and its associated optimal charging time display notable deviations from standard results which disregard thermodynamic considerations. Our theoretical groundwork may be useful for guiding forthcoming experiments in quantum energy science based upon coupled two-level systems.
This study investigates the thermodynamic behavior of a two-qubit quantum system, where each qubit is coupled to an independent thermal reservoir, either bosonic or fermionic. Using a master equation approach, we analyze both steady-state and time-dependent ergotropy to understand how different reservoir statistics affect work extraction. In bosonic environments, ergotropy consistently declines with increasing temperature due to thermal noise. In contrast, fermionic reservoirs exhibit more complex behavior, with ergotropy enhanced by particle transport under non-equilibrium conditions. Our results reveal a threshold-like sensitivity to the chemical potential configuration, leading to qualitatively distinct regimes of energy storage performance. Time-resolved analyses show that the system's approach to steady state varies depending on the type of reservoir and the coupling strength between qubits. These insights highlight how carefully engineered reservoir properties and non-equilibrium driving can be leveraged to optimize quantum battery performance.