arXiv:2609.38724
Ergotropy from energetic coherence and the third law of thermodynamics
O. S. Yáñez-Soria, G. Guarnieri, B. Çakmak, R. Román-Ancheyta
Abstract
We study the ergotropy and the thermodynamic potentials of a qubit battery charged by repeated interactions with clusters of thermal ancillas, qubits or oscillators, through a composite system-bath coupling that generates steady-state coherence in the energy basis. A single parameter encoding the bath quantum statistics yields the coherence and ergotropy in closed form for any cluster size. For large clusters, the ergotropy becomes independent of the bath statistics and, at optimal couplings, reaches a universal fraction of the equilibrium internal energy of the qubit at the bath temperature. Since the charged state has no population inversion, all extractable work comes from coherence. The ergotropy is flat at low temperatures. We trace this plateau to the third law, and show that the ergotropy is proportional to the equilibrium enthalpy of the qubit, whose slope vanishes with the heat capacity. For a battery composed of multiple qubits, the coherence grows exponentially with the number of qubits while the ergotropy grows linearly, both remaining a nearly constant fraction of their respective maxima. The charged state is a non-equilibrium steady state with finite entropy at zero temperature, sustained by the work of switching the collisional interaction on and off. The cost is nonzero whenever the parallel coupling is nonzero, and, unlike the ergotropy, it depends on the bath statistics.
AI Summary
The paper asks how much work can be stored as energy-basis coherence in a qubit coupled to thermal ancillas, and how its temperature dependence and maintenance cost relate to thermodynamics. It studies a repeated-interaction model with clusters of $N$ thermal qubits or oscillators and a composite coupling containing longitudinal and excitation-exchange terms. A collision-limit Lindblad equation yields analytical steady-state Bloch vectors, coherence and ergotropy for arbitrary $N$, treating both ancilla types through one statistical parameter. In the large-cluster limit, the stored ergotropy becomes independent of ancilla statistics. Optimizing the coupling ratio gives $2f_1^2=(1+\sqrt{2})f_2^2$ and $\mathcal W^*(T)=\frac{\hbar\omega}{2}(\sqrt{2}-1)\tanh[\hbar\omega/(2k_BT)]$. At zero temperature this is approximately $0.207\hbar\omega$; the state has purity $3/4$ and no population inversion, so its ergotropy is entirely coherent. The ergotropy optimum differs from the coherence optimum. The low-temperature plateau follows from proportionality to the equilibrium qubit energy, whose derivative is the vanishing heat capacity. This proportionality is specific to the large-cluster limit; finite-$N$ plateaus follow directly from exponentially small thermal derivatives. The nonequilibrium state retains entropy $0.416k_B$ at zero temperature, giving its free-energy difference a finite negative slope. Explicit switching-work calculations show that maintaining the state consumes power, with bath-statistics dependence persisting at large $N$. The analysis assumes resonance and the Markovian collision limit. Collective multi-qubit batteries are examined numerically only up to seven qubits at zero temperature: ergotropy grows approximately linearly, near $0.3\hbar\omega$ per qubit, whereas unnormalized $l_1$ coherence grows exponentially.
Error found: The abstract leaves unqualified an ergotropy–equilibrium-enthalpy proportionality that holds in the large-cluster limit but not generally for finite oscillator clusters. The multi-qubit scaling calculation does not specify an initial state or total-spin sector, although the collective dynamics has multiple stationary states with different coherence and ergotropy. The claimed high-temperature coincidence of free-energy difference and ergotropy is incorrect at leading order: their ratio approaches approximately 1.104 rather than one.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 12 pages, 8 figures