Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2609.38333

Collective Dynamics in Spin Chains with Constrained Dissipation: Classically Fragile but Quantum Robust

Pietro Brighi, Gianluca Frazzei, Igor Lesanovsky, Juan P. Garrahan, Alberto Biella

quant-phcond-mat.stat-mechSubmitted Sep 29, 2026• Announced Oct 1, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Collective non-equilibrium phenomena in many-body systems are strongly influenced by fluctuations, particularly in the vicinity of phase transitions, where the interplay between classical and quantum effects can alter cooperative behavior. Here, we investigate this classical-quantum competition in a kinetically constrained spin chain, the dissipative far-East model. In absence of fluctuations, the system exhibits emergent collective dynamics, resulting in phase coexistence. We find that this phenomenon is robust to quantum fluctuations, which further stabilize it, whereas classical fluctuations suppress phase coexistence at long times. We map out the steady-state phase diagram using a cluster mean-field approach and characterize the dynamics with stochastic tensor-network methods. Within the bistable phase we identify signatures of dynamical heterogeneity in both the local magnetization and the entanglement dynamics. This highlights how competing quantum fluctuations and classical kinetic constraints shape the relaxation dynamics and the phase structure of many-body systems.

AI Summary

The paper asks whether coherent quantum fluctuations and classical noise affect collective order differently in a one-dimensional kinetically constrained open system. It studies a dissipative “far-East” spin chain: three-site jump operators flip a spin to match its two right neighbours when those neighbours agree. A transverse field $\Omega$ supplies coherent dynamics; additional reverse jumps, with dimensionless strength $T$, soften the constraint. A rate imbalance $\delta$ biases the magnetization. Mean-field theory, cluster mean-field calculations with clusters up to $\ell=10$, and stochastic matrix-product-state trajectories support a bistable region at $T=0$ and weak transverse field. Mean-field theory gives $\Omega_c/\gamma=\sqrt{3/32}$ at $\delta=0$; extrapolating cluster results gives approximately $0.15$. Magnetization hysteresis and emission-rate differences characterize the two branches. Domain-wall simulations on chains including $N=192$, averaged over 500 trajectories, find ballistic interface propagation and relaxation times proportional to system size below the estimated transition, versus approximately size-independent relaxation above it. Classical Monte Carlo simulations reaching $N\sim16{,}000$ find no bistability at the tested nonzero noise strengths. Cluster calculations with both classical noise and coherent dynamics likewise indicate collapse of the bistable region. Individual quantum trajectories display heterogeneous magnetization domains and reduced entanglement at their boundaries; boundary-following entanglement grows approximately logarithmically before saturation. The stationary phase diagram relies on cluster factorization and extrapolation rather than an exact thermodynamic-limit solution. The cluster framework retains the mean-field exponent $\beta=1/2$ by construction. Trajectory large deviations and conditions under which other constrained models exhibit analogous behavior remain open directions.

Little sign of AI-generated textOverclaimsStrong assumptions

Central claim may not hold: The abstract's claim that quantum fluctuations further stabilize coexistence exceeds the reported evidence, which shows survival under weak coherent driving followed by loss of bistability as driving increases. Finite-cluster hysteresis and finite-time ballistic domain erosion provide suggestive but not decisive evidence for a genuine thermodynamic stationary bistable phase. The claim that every positive classical-noise strength destroys ferromagnetic coexistence extends beyond the reported numerical tests. At zero coherent field, both Néel configurations on an even periodic chain remain absorbing at every classical-noise strength, so the claimed unique mixed stationary state has exact exceptions.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Related papers

Dissipative quantum North-East-Center model: Steady-state phase diagram, universality and nonergodic dynamics

Alberto Biella, Pietro Brighi

In this work we study the dissipative quantum North-East-Center (NEC) model: a two-dimensional spin-1/2 lattice subject to chiral, kinetically constrained dissipation and coherent quantum interactions. This model combines kinetic constraints and chirality at the dissipative level, implementing local incoherent spin flips conditioned by an asymmetric majority-vote rule. Through a cluster mean-field approach, we determine the steady-state phase diagram of the NEC model under different Hamiltonians, consistently revealing the emergence of two distinct phases, bistable and normal, across all cases considered. We further investigate the stability of the steady-state with respect to inhomogeneous fluctuations in both phases, showing the emergence of instabilities at finite wavevectors in the proximity of the phase transition. Next, we study the nonergodicity of the model in the bistable phase. We characterize the dynamics of minority islands of spins surrounded by a large background of spins pointing in the opposite direction. We show that in the bistable phase, the minority islands are always reabsorbed by the surrounding at a constant velocity, irrespectively of their size. Finally, we propose and numerically benchmark an equation of motion for the reabsorption velocity of the islands where thermal and quantum fluctuations act independently at linear order.

arXiv:2506.19011•SciPost Physics•Jan 22, 2026•0 citations

Quantum spin chain dissipative mean-field dynamics

Fabio Benatti, Federico Carollo, Roberto Floreanini B +1 more

Abstract We study the emergent dynamics resulting from the infinite volume limit of the mean-field dissipative dynamics of quantum spin chains with clustering, but not time-invariant states. We focus upon three algebras of spin operators: the commutative algebra of mean-field operators, the quasi-local algebra of microscopic, local operators and the collective algebra of fluctuation operators. In the infinite volume limit, mean-field operators behave as time-dependent, commuting scalar macroscopic averages while quasi-local operators, despite the dissipative underlying dynamics, evolve unitarily in a typical non-Markovian fashion. Instead, the algebra of collective fluctuations, which is of bosonic type with time-dependent canonical commutation relations, undergoes a time-evolution that retains the dissipative character of the underlying microscopic dynamics and exhibits non-linear features. These latter disappear by extending the time-evolution to a larger algebra where it is represented by a continuous one-parameter semigroup of completely positive maps. The corresponding generator is not of Lindblad form and displays mixed quantum-classical features, thus indicating that peculiar hybrid systems may naturally emerge at the level of quantum fluctuations in many-body quantum systems endowed with non time-invariant states.

arXiv:1807.08323•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Jun 12, 2018•36 citations

Emergent kinetic constraints, ergodicity breaking, and cooperative dynamics in noisy quantum systems

Benjamin Everest, Matteo Marcuzzi, Juan P. Garrahan +1 more

Kinetically constrained spin systems play an important role in understanding key properties of the dynamics of slowly relaxing materials, such as glasses. Recent experimental studies have revealed that manifest kinetic constraints govern the evolution of strongly interacting gases of highly excited atoms in a noisy environment. Motivated by this development we explore which types of kinetically constrained dynamics can generally emerge in quantum spin systems subject to strong noise and show how, in this framework, constraints are accompanied by conservation laws. We discuss an experimentally realizable case of a lattice gas, where the interplay between those and the geometry of the lattice leads to collective behavior and time-scale separation even at infinite temperature. This is in contrast to models of glass-forming substances which typically rely on low temperatures and the consequent suppression of thermal activation.

arXiv:1602.05839•Physical review. E•Nov 4, 2016•23 citations

Collective cluster nucleation dynamics in quantum magnets

Philip Osterholz, Fabio Bensch, Shuanghong Tang +4 more

Strongly interacting many-body systems exhibit collective properties that emerge from complex correlations among microscopic degrees of freedom. These cooperative phenomena govern the non-equilibrium response of quantum systems, with relevance ranging from condensed matter physics to quantum field theories describing fundamental aspects of our universe. Understanding such emergent dynamics from first principles remains one of the central challenges in quantum many-body physics. Here we report on the observation of collective cluster nucleation dynamics following quenches in 2D ferromagnetic quantum Ising systems implemented in an atomic Rydberg array. Our experiments reveal two distinct regimes: In the confined regime, we observe an energy-dependent cluster size, revealing large collective clusters exceeding ten spins. In contrast, the deconfined regime is characterized by kinetically constrained, avalanche-like nucleation dynamics involving the entire system. Our findings establish a new frontier for quantum simulations with Rydberg arrays, enabling controlled exploration of non-equilibrium phenomena previously out of reach. Beyond advancing experimental capabilities, they provide fundamental insights into highly correlated processes with implications that reach from quantum magnetism and glassy dynamics to cosmological models of the early universe.

cond-mat.quant-gasCross-listedarXiv:2512.04656•Dec 5, 2025•11 citations

Quantum fluctuations and correlations in open quantum Dicke models

Mario Boneberg, Igor Lesanovsky, Federico Carollo

In the vicinity of ground-state phase transitions quantum correlations can display nonanalytic behavior and critical scaling. This signature of emergent collective effects has been widely investigated within a broad range of equilibrium settings. However, under nonequilibrium conditions, as found in open quantum many-body systems, characterizing quantum correlations near phase transitions is challenging. Moreover, the impact of local and collective dissipative processes on quantum correlations is not broadly understood. Here we consider as a paradigmatic setting the superradiant phase transition of the open quantum Dicke model and characterize quantum and classical correlations across the phase diagram. We develop an approach to quantum fluctuations which allows us to show that local dissipation, which cannot be treated within the commonly employed Holstein-Primakoff approximation, rather unexpectedly leads to an enhancement of collective quantum correlations, and to the emergence of a nonequilibrium superradiant phase in which the bosonic and spin degrees of freedom of the Dicke model are entangled.

arXiv:2110.13191•Physical Review A•Jul 19, 2022•26 citations

Out-of-equilibrium evolution of kinetically constrained many-body quantum systems under purely dissipative dynamics

Beatriz Olmos, Igor Lesanovsky, Juan P. Garrahan

We explore the relaxation dynamics of quantum many-body systems that undergo purely dissipative dynamics through non-classical jump operators that can establish quantum coherence. Our goal is to shed light on the differences in the relaxation dynamics that arise in comparison to systems evolving via classical rate equations. In particular, we focus on a scenario where both quantum and classical dissipative evolution lead to a stationary state with the same values of diagonal or "classical" observables. As a basis for illustrating our ideas we use spin systems whose dynamics becomes correlated and complex due to dynamical constraints, inspired by kinetically constrained models (KCMs) of classical glasses. We show that in the quantum case the relaxation can be orders of magnitude slower than the classical one due to the presence of quantum coherences. Aspects of these idealized quantum KCMs become manifest in a strongly interacting Rydberg gas under electromagnetically induced transparency (EIT) conditions in an appropriate limit. Beyond revealing a link between this Rydberg gas and the rather abstract dissipative KCMs of quantum glassy systems, our study sheds light on the limitations of the use of classical rate equations for capturing the non-equilibrium behavior of this many-body system.

arXiv:1406.5485•Physical Review E•Oct 31, 2014•38 citations
Collective non-equilibrium phenomena in many-body systems are strongly influenced by fluctuations, particularly in the vicinity of phase transitions, where the interplay between classical and quantum effects can alter cooperative behavior. Here, we investigate this classical-quantum competition in a kinetically constrained spin chain, the dissipative far-East model. In absence of fluctuations, the system exhibits emergent collective dynamics, resulting in phase coexistence. We find that this phenomenon is robust to quantum fluctuations, which further stabilize it, whereas classical fluctuations suppress phase coexistence at long times. We map out the steady-state phase diagram using a cluster mean-field approach and characterize the dynamics with stochastic tensor-network methods. Within the bistable phase we identify signatures of dynamical heterogeneity in both the local magnetization and the entanglement dynamics. This highlights how competing quantum fluctuations and classical kinetic constraints shape the relaxation dynamics and the phase structure of many-body systems.
The paper asks whether coherent quantum fluctuations and classical noise affect collective order differently in a one-dimensional kinetically constrained open system. It studies a dissipative “far-East” spin chain: three-site jump operators flip a spin to match its two right neighbours when those neighbours agree. A transverse field Ω\OmegaΩ supplies coherent dynamics; additional reverse jumps, with dimensionless strength TTT, soften the constraint. A rate imbalance δ\deltaδ biases the magnetization.
Mean-field theory, cluster mean-field calculations with clusters up to ℓ=10\ell=10ℓ=10, and stochastic matrix-product-state trajectories support a bistable region at T=0T=0T=0 and weak transverse field. Mean-field theory gives Ωc/γ=3/32\Omega_c/\gamma=\sqrt{3/32}Ωc​/γ=3/32​ at δ=0\delta=0δ=0; extrapolating cluster results gives approximately 0.150.150.15. Magnetization hysteresis and emission-rate differences characterize the two branches. Domain-wall simulations on chains including N=192N=192N=192, averaged over 500 trajectories, find ballistic interface propagation and relaxation times proportional to system size below the estimated transition, versus approximately size-independent relaxation above it.
Classical Monte Carlo simulations reaching N∼16,000N\sim16{,}000N∼16,000 find no bistability at the tested nonzero noise strengths. Cluster calculations with both classical noise and coherent dynamics likewise indicate collapse of the bistable region. Individual quantum trajectories display heterogeneous magnetization domains and reduced entanglement at their boundaries; boundary-following entanglement grows approximately logarithmically before saturation.
The stationary phase diagram relies on cluster factorization and extrapolation rather than an exact thermodynamic-limit solution. The cluster framework retains the mean-field exponent β=1/2\beta=1/2β=1/2 by construction. Trajectory large deviations and conditions under which other constrained models exhibit analogous behavior remain open directions.
In this work we study the dissipative quantum North-East-Center (NEC) model: a two-dimensional spin-1/2 lattice subject to chiral, kinetically constrained dissipation and coherent quantum interactions. This model combines kinetic constraints and chirality at the dissipative level, implementing local incoherent spin flips conditioned by an asymmetric majority-vote rule. Through a cluster mean-field approach, we determine the steady-state phase diagram of the NEC model under different Hamiltonians, consistently revealing the emergence of two distinct phases, bistable and normal, across all cases considered. We further investigate the stability of the steady-state with respect to inhomogeneous fluctuations in both phases, showing the emergence of instabilities at finite wavevectors in the proximity of the phase transition. Next, we study the nonergodicity of the model in the bistable phase. We characterize the dynamics of minority islands of spins surrounded by a large background of spins pointing in the opposite direction. We show that in the bistable phase, the minority islands are always reabsorbed by the surrounding at a constant velocity, irrespectively of their size. Finally, we propose and numerically benchmark an equation of motion for the reabsorption velocity of the islands where thermal and quantum fluctuations act independently at linear order.
Abstract We study the emergent dynamics resulting from the infinite volume limit of the mean-field dissipative dynamics of quantum spin chains with clustering, but not time-invariant states. We focus upon three algebras of spin operators: the commutative algebra of mean-field operators, the quasi-local algebra of microscopic, local operators and the collective algebra of fluctuation operators. In the infinite volume limit, mean-field operators behave as time-dependent, commuting scalar macroscopic averages while quasi-local operators, despite the dissipative underlying dynamics, evolve unitarily in a typical non-Markovian fashion. Instead, the algebra of collective fluctuations, which is of bosonic type with time-dependent canonical commutation relations, undergoes a time-evolution that retains the dissipative character of the underlying microscopic dynamics and exhibits non-linear features. These latter disappear by extending the time-evolution to a larger algebra where it is represented by a continuous one-parameter semigroup of completely positive maps. The corresponding generator is not of Lindblad form and displays mixed quantum-classical features, thus indicating that peculiar hybrid systems may naturally emerge at the level of quantum fluctuations in many-body quantum systems endowed with non time-invariant states.
Kinetically constrained spin systems play an important role in understanding key properties of the dynamics of slowly relaxing materials, such as glasses. Recent experimental studies have revealed that manifest kinetic constraints govern the evolution of strongly interacting gases of highly excited atoms in a noisy environment. Motivated by this development we explore which types of kinetically constrained dynamics can generally emerge in quantum spin systems subject to strong noise and show how, in this framework, constraints are accompanied by conservation laws. We discuss an experimentally realizable case of a lattice gas, where the interplay between those and the geometry of the lattice leads to collective behavior and time-scale separation even at infinite temperature. This is in contrast to models of glass-forming substances which typically rely on low temperatures and the consequent suppression of thermal activation.
Strongly interacting many-body systems exhibit collective properties that emerge from complex correlations among microscopic degrees of freedom. These cooperative phenomena govern the non-equilibrium response of quantum systems, with relevance ranging from condensed matter physics to quantum field theories describing fundamental aspects of our universe. Understanding such emergent dynamics from first principles remains one of the central challenges in quantum many-body physics. Here we report on the observation of collective cluster nucleation dynamics following quenches in 2D ferromagnetic quantum Ising systems implemented in an atomic Rydberg array. Our experiments reveal two distinct regimes: In the confined regime, we observe an energy-dependent cluster size, revealing large collective clusters exceeding ten spins. In contrast, the deconfined regime is characterized by kinetically constrained, avalanche-like nucleation dynamics involving the entire system. Our findings establish a new frontier for quantum simulations with Rydberg arrays, enabling controlled exploration of non-equilibrium phenomena previously out of reach. Beyond advancing experimental capabilities, they provide fundamental insights into highly correlated processes with implications that reach from quantum magnetism and glassy dynamics to cosmological models of the early universe.
In the vicinity of ground-state phase transitions quantum correlations can display nonanalytic behavior and critical scaling. This signature of emergent collective effects has been widely investigated within a broad range of equilibrium settings. However, under nonequilibrium conditions, as found in open quantum many-body systems, characterizing quantum correlations near phase transitions is challenging. Moreover, the impact of local and collective dissipative processes on quantum correlations is not broadly understood. Here we consider as a paradigmatic setting the superradiant phase transition of the open quantum Dicke model and characterize quantum and classical correlations across the phase diagram. We develop an approach to quantum fluctuations which allows us to show that local dissipation, which cannot be treated within the commonly employed Holstein-Primakoff approximation, rather unexpectedly leads to an enhancement of collective quantum correlations, and to the emergence of a nonequilibrium superradiant phase in which the bosonic and spin degrees of freedom of the Dicke model are entangled.
We explore the relaxation dynamics of quantum many-body systems that undergo purely dissipative dynamics through non-classical jump operators that can establish quantum coherence. Our goal is to shed light on the differences in the relaxation dynamics that arise in comparison to systems evolving via classical rate equations. In particular, we focus on a scenario where both quantum and classical dissipative evolution lead to a stationary state with the same values of diagonal or "classical" observables. As a basis for illustrating our ideas we use spin systems whose dynamics becomes correlated and complex due to dynamical constraints, inspired by kinetically constrained models (KCMs) of classical glasses. We show that in the quantum case the relaxation can be orders of magnitude slower than the classical one due to the presence of quantum coherences. Aspects of these idealized quantum KCMs become manifest in a strongly interacting Rydberg gas under electromagnetically induced transparency (EIT) conditions in an appropriate limit. Beyond revealing a link between this Rydberg gas and the rather abstract dissipative KCMs of quantum glassy systems, our study sheds light on the limitations of the use of classical rate equations for capturing the non-equilibrium behavior of this many-body system.