arXiv:2609.37965
Strong-to-Weak Spontaneous Symmetry Breaking of Dephased Fermions
Abhijat Sarma
Abstract
Strong-to-weak spontaneous symmetry breaking (SWSSB) is a novel phase transition in mixed states associated with the loss of global charge information. In this work we study fermions with $U(1)$ symmetry under infinite density dephasing and derive the SWSSB properties of the resulting mixed states. Our central observation is that at infinite dephasing every Renyi correlator is exactly the spin-spin correlator of a compact XY model, whose Boltzmann weight is the squared full-counting-statistics generating function of a classical ensemble built from the parent state. For the Renyi-2 correlator it is the full counting statistics of the parent state itself. We complement the infinite dephasing mapping with a novel diagrammatic expansion for the Renyi-1 correlator, applicable to any diagonal mixed state, which computes the couplings of the Renyi-1 XY model. We also study a replica field theory for even Renyi index quantities, applicable at finite dephasing. Our analysis indicates that fully dephased metals display long-range SWSSB in $d\geq 2$, as confirmed numerically and experimentally in $d=2$, and quasi-long-range SWSSB in $d=1$. For insulating parent states both an SWSSB and a trivial phase are possible at infinite dephasing depending on UV details. Long-range SWSSB in $d\geq 3$, or quasi-long-range SWSSB in $d=2$, survives above a nonuniversal, Renyi-index-dependent threshold and is lost when the parent state is deep in the insulating phase, with the exception of quantum Hall insulators which generically have quasi-long-range SWSSB. For even Renyi indices we also determine the stability of the SWSSB phase away from infinite dephasing and derive the universality class of the SWSSB transition.
AI Summary
The paper asks when density dephasing of a number-conserving fermionic ground state produces strong-to-weak spontaneous symmetry breaking (SWSSB), detected by nonlinear density-matrix correlators despite the absence of ordinary coherence. It treats metallic, trivial insulating, and quantum Hall parent states, distinguishing the phase-stable Rényi-1/fidelity diagnostics from higher-Rényi probes. At infinite dephasing, every Rényi-$\alpha$ correlator maps exactly to a compact XY-model correlator with weight $|\Psi_\alpha[\theta]|^2$, where $\Psi_\alpha$ generates full counting statistics of the ensemble proportional to $p^{\alpha/2}$. For $\alpha=2$, this is the parent distribution itself. A diagrammatic expansion addresses Rényi-1 correlators, while infrared power counting and vortex arguments yield long-range SWSSB for metals in $d\geq2$ and algebraic correlations in one dimension. Trivial insulators can be ordered or disordered depending on microscopic details; in two dimensions, algebraic Rényi-1 order requires $\eta<1/4$, with necessary bounds $\sqrt{\det\bar g}>1/(2\pi)$ and $\delta E<\pi\sqrt{\det\mathcal K}$, involving the structure-factor coefficient, gap, and kinetic-energy tensor. Quantum Hall states evade the vortex threshold through confinement. For even Rényi indices, finite-dephasing analysis predicts stability of long-range order, but algebraic order survives only for $\eta>4$. A doubled-state field theory gives metallic transitions upper critical dimension $d_c=2$ and insulating transitions XY/BKT descriptions. The expansions lack a lattice-scale small parameter: plateaus and thresholds remain nonuniversal, nonperturbative changes of infrared behavior are not rigorously excluded, and several Rényi-1 extensions are conjectural.
Central claim may not hold: The discrete integration-by-parts identity is false for the stated hard-core distributions: a two-site equal mixture gives ⟨p[n+h]/p[n]⟩=1/2 rather than 1. The resulting nonzero mean score invalidates the stated score-moment and projection formulas, leaving the advertised general Rényi-1 diagrammatic technique and its derived stiffness bounds unestablished. The general conclusion of long-range Rényi-1 SWSSB in dephased metals is stronger than the supplied justification, which combines an uncontrolled infrared argument with the defective expansion.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 18 pages