arXiv:2609.37822
Measuring the spin of a spin-1/2 and getting a result of 7
Joseph McGowan, Nicholas Mantella, Noah Baker, Aephraim M. Steinberg
Abstract
The weak value of an operator is the average result of measuring that operator on a quantum system given specified initial and final states. The overlap between these states appears in the denominator of the weak value, and thus if that overlap is small, the weak value can be arbitrarily large. In 1988, Albert, Aharonov, and Vaidman proposed a weak Stern-Gerlach experiment which would be able to measure a so-called anomalous weak value, a measurement result which lies out- side of the eigenvalue spectrum of the operator being measured. Though anomalous weak values have been measured in numerous optical systems, here we present the first such realization of this experiment as originally proposed. By placing a Bose-Einstein condensate of 87Rb in a magnetic gradient and performing an unlikely postselection, we measure an effective magnification of a weak magnetic momentum kick (~ 8 $μ$m/s) by a factor of 14. We also demonstrate that increasing the momentum kick decreases the "weakness" of the measurement and reduces the amplification.
AI Summary
The paper addresses whether anomalous weak values can be observed in an atomic implementation of the weak Stern–Gerlach experiment, using continuous atomic motion as the pointer rather than an optical analogue. It reports weak-value amplification in a $^{87}\mathrm{Rb}$ Bose–Einstein condensate containing approximately $5$–$10\times10^3$ atoms. An equal superposition of the hyperfine states $|2,0\rangle$ and $|1,0\rangle$ acts as an effective spin-$1/2$. A magnetic-field gradient produces opposite momentum kicks through the second-order Zeeman effect. Microwave rotations implement nearly orthogonal postselection, and evolution for one-quarter period in a harmonic waveguide maps momentum onto position. Imaging both postselection outputs and subtracting their fitted centers suppresses common-mode motion; each setting averages 60 image pairs. For a condensate with a $31\,\mu\mathrm{m}$ Thomas–Fermi radius and a single-component velocity kick of $4.4(5)\,\mu\mathrm{m/s}$, the largest measured separation is reported as $14(6)$ times that kick, or $7(3)$ times the unamplified two-component separation. The shift reverses sign and passes through zero near orthogonal postselection, rather than diverging. Increasing the kick to $9.2(8)\,\mu\mathrm{m/s}$ reduces amplification and broadens the departure from the weak-value approximation, consistent with finite-strength calculations. The main limitations are low postselection probability, unreliable profile fitting at low density, and camera noise; fits outside a prescribed spatial range are excluded. Gaussian predictions only approximately describe the Thomas–Fermi cloud. Reducing cloud size also reduced atom number enough to prevent testing the predicted amplification increase. Metrological applications are proposed, but no sensitivity advantage is demonstrated.
Error found: The abstract pairs an approximately 8 μm/s kick with amplification by 14, whereas the Results supports amplification by 7(3) relative to the 8.8 μm/s unpostselected separation, or by 14(6) relative to the 4.4 μm/s single-component kick. The Results confuses the weak values of σz and Sz/ℏ: a conditional shift of approximately 14δp corresponds to approximately 14 for σz and approximately 7 for Sz/ℏ. The theoretical identification of the postselected pointer shift with a joint expectation omits division by the postselection probability. The printed Gaussian conditional-mean formula is too small by a factor of two, and the printed maximum-shift formula has a negative radicand for nonzero real coupling.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 6 pages, 3 figures