arXiv:2609.37628
Operational theory for photonic circuits: generalizing linear optics beyond quantum theory
Ismaël Septembre, Matthias Kleinmann, Martin Plávala
Abstract
We use the analogy between the quadrature operators in quantum optics and the phase-space coordinates in a mechanical harmonic oscillator to generalise the theory of linear optics beyond quantum theory. For this, we introduce a framework for analysing photonic circuits within generalised probabilistic theories based on quadrature operators. Using this framework, we ask whether phenomena like the Hong-Ou-Mandel effect, Mach-Zehnder interferometry are specific to quantum theory or also occur across a broader class of theories. We find the latter: the vanishing photon coincidences at the output of a beam splitter also occur for classical light and for a modified version of quantised light. Similarly, for Mach-Zehnder interferometry we find that there is no qualitative difference between quantum theory and these alternative theories. Our framework can serve as a foundation to study generalised theories of complex photonic set-ups and photonic quantum computers.
AI Summary
The paper asks which features of linear-optical interference persist beyond quantum theory. It formulates photonic circuits in a phase-space generalised probabilistic framework: states are normalised, potentially negative distributions, measurements are spectral functions, and passive optical elements act through the quadrature transformations associated with unitary mode mixing. It applies this construction to Hong–Ou–Mandel (HOM) and Mach–Zehnder setups in quantum, classical, and discrete-energy “sawtooth” theories. Analytical calculations recover zero output coincidences for the quantum $|11\rangle$ input and the Mach–Zehnder signal $S(\varphi)=\cos^2\varphi$. Classical equal-energy inputs also yield zero coincidences at selected relative phases under threshold detection. Averaging over relative phase, the defined visibility approaches $100\%$ as the detection threshold approaches the input energy from below. For point-supported sawtooth inputs, $P_{\mathrm{co}}=1-|\cos\theta_{\mathrm{rel}}|$, giving visibility $2/\pi\approx64\%$. Equal-amplitude quantum coherent inputs give approximately $80\%$ under the paper’s convention $V=1-\langle P_{\mathrm{co}}\rangle$, without normalising by their approximately $40\%$ input coincidence probability. The paper also compares attainable probability pairs for coincidence measurements with and without an additional interferometer. With relative-phase control, the classical effective state space contains the quantum disk. This does not establish classical contextuality: the relevant inequality assumes an operational distinguishability condition that this classical model does not satisfy. The sawtooth visibility bound applies only to the selected states; negative phase-space states might exceed it. The calculations concern restricted circuits and measurements, leaving extensions to complex photonic circuits and computational distinctions open.
Central claim may not hold: The nonquantum coincidence zeros require qualifications: the selected sawtooth states have zeros only at particular relative phases, and classical phase-averaged coincidences approach zero only in a limiting detector-threshold regime. The claim of no qualitative difference in Mach–Zehnder interferometry is too strong: the phase-averaged sawtooth signal never vanishes, whereas the quantum two-single-photon signal has exact extinction. The coherent-state value labelled approximately 80% visibility uses an unnormalised coincidence probability despite an input coincidence probability of only approximately 40%, preventing its direct interpretation as comparable HOM suppression.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.