arXiv:2609.37318
A magnetic-field insensitive gate set for trapped-ion nuclear spin qubits
Jonathan Paul Home, Jeremy Flannery, Matteo Mazzanti, Jan Apolin, Shreyans Jain
Abstract
We outline a complete set of operations for manipulating nuclear spin qubits of trapped-ions stored in high magnetic fields such as required for Penning trapping, where the nuclear and electron spins are largely decoupled due to the dominance of the external field Hamiltonian. The reduced nuclear magnetic moment results in insensitivity to external magnetic fields compared to the use of an electron spin, but also makes the nuclear spin hard to manipulate on fast timescales. To maintain speed, we propose a two-qubit phase gate technique which utilizes the electron spin, but for which the qubit remains protected from magnetic fields through retaining the nuclear encoding. This method works for magnetic-field insensitive qubits at lower fields as well as for both microwave and laser field gradients.
AI Summary
The paper addresses how to entangle nuclear-spin qubits in high-field trapped-ion systems without sacrificing their reduced magnetic-field sensitivity or accepting the slow spin–motion coupling of nuclear transitions. The setting is Penning traps at several tesla, where electron and nuclear spins are approximately decoupled. An analytical treatment of hyperfine mixing estimates transition sensitivities and microwave matrix elements. For $^9\mathrm{Be}^+$ and $^{43}\mathrm{Ca}^+$ at $3$–$6\,\mathrm{T}$, nuclear-transition drive strengths are approximately $0.006$–$0.026$ of electron-spin transition strengths. The main proposal combines a low-frequency, electron-spin-dependent magnetic-field gradient with four microwave tones: two near each of two nuclear-state-resolved electron-spin transitions. A $\pi/2$ offset between the modulation phases reverses the effective force between nuclear states. A rotating-frame and Bessel-function expansion yields a geometric phase-gate Hamiltonian acting on the nuclear encoding, with the same effective coupling and duration as the corresponding electron-spin gate. For low-frequency magnetic noise, equal modulation indices make the leading electron-spin noise contribution common to both logical states, leaving residual nuclear sensitivity. The effective coupling is $\Omega_gJ_2(\beta)$, maximized at approximately $0.486\Omega_g$ for $\beta=3.05$. An alternative setting, $\beta=3.83$, suppresses the leading off-resonant leakage term at reduced coupling. The results are analytical proposals rather than experimental demonstrations or quantified fidelity predictions. Stated practical issues include microwave-power requirements, matching the two modulation indices, off-resonant electron-spin leakage, and unwanted force terms requiring additional dynamical decoupling. Single-qubit nuclear rotations remain slower than electron-spin rotations.
Central claim may not hold: The four-tone derivation projects onto bare electron-down states after a dressing transformation whose initial value is generally nonidentity, so it does not establish the claimed bare nuclear gate without additional preparation and termination conditions. Operating at the maximum of J_2 protects the force amplitude but not magnetic-noise cancellation against differential microwave-amplitude errors, and the quoted value of J_0 near beta=3.83 has the wrong sign. The claimed low-field extension is not established by an explicit encoding and verification of the assumptions used in the high-field derivation. For the paper's two-level Hamiltonian, the perturbative eigenstate admixture is g/(2 Delta), so its eigenvectors and leading nuclear-transition matrix elements contain a factor-of-two error.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 9 pages, 3 figures