arXiv:2609.36874
Closing a single-copy gap to the Holevo bound with two-copy measurements
Changhao Li
Abstract
The Holevo Cramér-Rao bound sets the asymptotically attainable precision of quantum multiparameter estimation, but its attainability with finite quantum state copies remains unresolved in general. While a gap between the single-copy optimum and the Holevo bound persists at any finite copy number for two-parameter estimation models, the higher-parameter case has remained open. Here we disprove universal finite-copy gap persistence beyond two parameters by constructing a three-parameter rank-two model whose Holevo bound is unattainable with one copy but attained exactly with two. We further prove finite-copy persistence for full-rank models with any number of parameters. We then experimentally implement the two-copy collective measurement for the constructed model using superconducting qubits. We observe a two-copy estimation error below the single-copy and separate-measurement bounds determined from state tomography. By introducing controlled depolarization, we show that this precision advantage persists over a finite noise range. Our results connect the attainability of ultimate quantum precision to the structure of the multiparameter estimation model and the resources available for collective measurements.
AI Summary
Can a collective measurement on finitely many copies attain the Holevo bound when every single-copy measurement falls strictly short? Two-parameter models obey gap persistence; this paper constructs a three-parameter counterexample and proves persistence for full-rank models with any number of parameters. The counterexample is a rank-two unitary model in dimension four, with identity weighting. Its normalized locally unbiased estimation costs satisfy $C_1=(3+2\sqrt{2})/8> C_H=C_2=5/8$. The Holevo value follows from an operator-block inequality and explicit optimizing estimators; the single-copy optimum follows from conditional pure-qubit estimation and the Gill–Massar inequality. An explicit two-copy projective measurement has commuting estimator observables and attains $5/8$. The single-copy Nagaoka–Hayashi bound also equals $C_1$, so its gap to Holevo closes at two copies. A separate full-rank persistence theorem uses Naimark dilation and equality conditions to show that finite-copy attainment would imply single-copy attainment. A superconducting-qubit implementation represents auxiliary sectors by classical flags and measures two transmons collectively. The measured normalized cost is $0.709(9)$, versus a tomography-derived single-copy lower bound of $0.741(7)$ and a separate-measurement bound of $0.778(8)$. It remains above the ideal Holevo value $0.625$. Any nonzero depolarization makes the model full rank and prevents exact finite-copy attainment, although the ideal fixed two-copy measurement retains an advantage up to depolarizing strength approximately $0.198$. Experimental comparisons depend on reconstruction assumptions. The construction is local and model-specific; rank deficiency and first-order support motion are necessary, but are not shown sufficient, and a classification of models permitting closure remains open.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 24 pages, 3 figures