arXiv:2609.36542
Emergent Symmetries in Ensemble Averages
Masahito Yamazaki
Abstract
It is widely believed that there are no exact global symmetries in quantum gravity. We review recent works showing that global symmetries can nevertheless emerge after ensemble averages of theories, as encountered in holography. As a precision case study, we discuss the ensemble average of two-dimensional Narain-type conformal field theories associated with an even quadratic form of general signature, which is computed by the Siegel-Weil formula and interpreted as a sum over geometries in a three-dimensional Abelian Chern-Simons theory. Global symmetries of the bulk anyons can emerge after the average, as T-dualities relating different theories in the ensemble are "folded" into symmetries of a single theory (duality origami). We discuss the relation to the Swampland program, including the emergence of global symmetries at infinite distance. Finally, we recast strong-to-weak spontaneous symmetry breaking (SWSSB) of mixed states as an emergence of symmetries in ensemble averages; in holography, wormholes connecting the two sides of a thermofield-double construction provide its bulk realization. This motivates a new Swampland conjecture.
AI Summary
This review examines how global symmetries absent in individual theories can appear after ensemble averaging, and relates this mechanism to holography, infinite-distance limits, and strong-to-weak spontaneous symmetry breaking (SWSSB) in mixed states. It synthesizes earlier results and formulates a Swampland conjecture. The precision example is an ensemble of generalized Narain theories defined by even integral lattices of signature $(p,q)$. For $pq\neq0$ and $p+q>4$, the Siegel–Weil formula evaluates averaged theta functions as Eisenstein series. These admit a bulk interpretation as a sum over solid-torus geometries, with contributions determined by Abelian Chern–Simons theory and lens-space partition functions. Automorphisms preserving the anyon fusion and spin data leave the averaged components invariant, even when they do not preserve the unaveraged components at fixed moduli. “Duality origami” expresses the underlying change-of-variables argument: measure-preserving covariance across an ensemble becomes invariance after averaging. The mixed-state discussion interprets weak symmetry as emerging through twirling or auxiliary-field averaging. For fixed-charge thermal states, SWSSB is diagnosed by nonzero long-distance Rényi-2 correlations despite decaying ordinary charged correlations. A reviewed AdS$_3$ model realizes this through cross-circle correlators in connected BTZ geometry. The proposed conjecture requires strongly symmetric mixed states in weakly coupled Einstein gravity to exhibit SWSSB or ordinary symmetry breaking. Limitations include the incomplete bulk dual after averaging, the insufficiency of partition-function equalities to establish symmetry of all observables, and additional clustering, ensemble-equivalence, and uniform-positivity assumptions in the thermal argument. The Swampland conjecture remains unproved.
Error found: The proposed general recasting of strong-to-weak spontaneous symmetry breaking as symmetry emergence establishes restoration of weak symmetry under averaging, but does not establish the strong-symmetry setting and long-range Rényi-2 order required for SWSSB.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 22 pages, 1 figure; Based on a lecture at RIKEN iTHEMS, October 24, 2025