arXiv:2609.36497
Evanescent-wave Johnson Noise from Superconductors
Hruday Mallubhotla, Gustav Romare, Ilya Esterlis, Maxim Vavilov, Robert Joynt, Alex Levchenko
Abstract
We compute the evanescent-wave Johnson noise (EWJN) in the vacuum half-space above a superconductor, and the resulting relaxation time ($T_1$) of spin and charge qubits placed at nanometer distances from the surface. The electromagnetic response is described by a single microscopic transverse current-response kernel $Q(q, ω)$ for a BCS superconductor. This is computed for varying densities of both non-magnetic impurities and magnetic impurities, for arbitrary frequency and temperature and for wave vectors $q \ll k_F$ (the Fermi wavevector). When combined with the fluctuation-dissipation theorem and the nonlocal surface impedances of the half-space, this yields the magnetic and electric field noise at any distance $z \gg k_F^{-1}$ from the surface, from which we obtain $T_1$. Just below $T_c$ the magnetic noise is enhanced relative to the normal state by the coherence (Hebel-Slichter-type) peak of the dissipative conductivity and drops exponentially at lower temperatures; the electric noise shows no coherence peak. The theory predicts that there is a zero-temperature noise floor induced by magnetic impurities. In the gapless regime produced by pair breaking, the finite subgap density of states $ν(0)$ yields a temperature-independent noise spectral density and a relaxation rate bounded by $T_1^{-1}(T)\le[ν(0)/ν_F]^{2}\,T_{1,N}^{-1}(T)$ for $T\ll T_c$, with equality in the extreme nonlocal regime. Here $ν(0)$ and $ν_F$ are the superconducting and normal-state densities of states at the Fermi energy, and $T_{1,N}(T)$ is the relaxation time the same electrode would produce in its normal state at the same temperature.
AI Summary
The paper asks how superconductivity, nonlocal electrodynamics, and disorder determine evanescent-wave Johnson noise and the relaxation of qubits nanometers above a bulk superconducting surface. It computes the transverse current-response kernel of an isotropic $s$-wave BCS superconductor with nonmagnetic disorder and magnetic impurities treated by a self-consistent Shiba $T$-matrix. Combining this kernel with specular-boundary surface impedances and fluctuation–dissipation relations gives magnetic noise and spin-qubit $T_1$. Analytical limits and numerical comparisons recover established normal-metal, London, Pippard, and Mattis–Bardeen responses. For representative niobium parameters at 2.88 GHz, magnetic noise exhibits a coherence peak just below $T_c$: at heights of 3–10 nm it can reach approximately twice the normal-state value. At lower temperatures, gapped superconductivity suppresses relaxation exponentially; the reported $T_1$ enhancement at 10 nm reaches approximately $4\times10^5$ at $0.1T_c$. Gapless superconductivity induced by magnetic impurities instead produces residual dissipation proportional to $[\nu(0)/\nu_F]^2$. The paper states the low-temperature bound $T_1^{-1}\leq[\nu(0)/\nu_F]^2T_{1,N}^{-1}$, with equality approached in the extreme nonlocal regime. Electric noise has no coherence peak within the longitudinal-response approximation used. The calculation assumes equilibrium, a half-space, specular reflection, and wavevectors $q\ll k_F$. Thin films require modified reflection coefficients. The longitudinal superconducting response is approximate outside the local dirty limit. Disorder-induced density-of-states tails, nonequilibrium quasiparticles, dephasing, and spatial noise correlations are excluded; other relaxation mechanisms can dominate once superconducting EWJN is strongly suppressed.
Central claim may not hold: The abstract's low-temperature DOS-squared relaxation-rate bound fails at fixed nonzero frequency near the onset of gaplessness, where finite-frequency absorption can remain positive while ν(0) approaches zero. The abstract overstates the electric-noise calculation's microscopic completeness: it requires a separate longitudinal response that the paper only approximates. The stated normal-state check omits the magnetic contribution 2/[τs(1+γ)] to the scattering rate unless magnetic impurities are also removed or the lifetime is redefined. Equation z4law overestimates its screened magnetic-noise prefactor by a factor of eight because its displayed integral is evaluated incorrectly.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 17 pages, 9 figures